Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

OK.. KU Car Guys.. or gals... Chevy. vs. Toyota vs. Nissan

who's talking here?

Melanie 1
stampin' gal 2
bobbi 1
Fallon 2
mamadog53 1
Sandyr9111 1
maverick 1
funmom 1
Clown Vomit 2
R.E.B. 2
Bliz 1
Scottie's Hottie 1
Lillabeth 1
Melissa 1
Yosamitesa 1
Ogre1 1
genxer 1
racefan 1
Quicksilver Messenger Service 2
Puppydoglover 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Puppydoglover --- 17 years ago -

If you were going to buy a truck from either of these, which one would you choose and why? I am having a difficult time making a decision on 3 choices but they're all different makes so not sure which is better. I've checked KBB.com for the values, etc. but not sure what else to go by. The gas mileages are not vastly different. The exact trucks I am trying to choose amongst are: Nissan Frontier Access Cab (Nismo) Chevy Silverado 1500 - Z71 4wd (ext cab) Toyota Tacoma Pre-runner - King cab 4d These are all 2006 models. Any info/insight you can offer is greatly appreciated.  

Bliz --- 17 years ago -

I have test driven all of these and others back in 2006 when I wanted to buy a new truck. Here is my humble opinion: 1) Frontier--much smaller interior than the others...back seat is almost unusable for adult passengers. Wheelbase is smaller than others so it will ride a bit rougher. That being said, its more like a sports car because of the Nismo options. I do like the looks of the 4 door frontier even if its not big enough for a family vehicle. 2) The Chevy ext cab is the most useful of the extended (not crew cab) models. Do you want 4wd? Its more expensive to fix when it breaks and most people do not need it. The other 2 trucks on your list do not have 4wd. In 2wd, I would be willing to bet that the gas mileage is as good or better than the other 2 models (no I am not kidding--I used to own a 6cylinder Tundra and a Chevy V-8 gets the same or better mileage under many circumstances. 3) Tacoma--even the 6cyl drives like a race car with about 250 HP. The king cab is a lot smaller than the chevy full-size ext cab you also mentioned. I selected the Tundra access cab (extended) when I was looking because it was a little sturdier in the frame than the taco, and the financing deal at that time made the difference. When I was looking, everyone was offering "employee pricing", but no deals in financing except for Toyota. It was a decent truck, but more expensive than a similarly equipped Chevy or Ford (if financing options were equivalent or paying cash). Of the models you mention, I would select the Chevy Ext cab because it is a true full-size pickup, with a marginally useful back seat while the Nismo and Taco will barely hold a suitcase. It also gets decent mileage (for a truck), and is the smoothest riding of the trucks you mention (if you get 2WD). If you actually need a durable truck for towing or heavy hauling, get the Chevy or better yet, a Ford F series. Good luck! 

racefan --- 17 years ago -

look into the dodge quad cab; for what you will pay for the Z71 ext cab, you can get a 4cab with a hemi 4x4 pkg. and you will be happy with all the room. if your choices have to be narroed down to those three, then stick with the chevy. 

Puppydoglover --- 17 years ago -

Thanks a lot for the info!! I am leaning towards the Chevy, but hubby just loves his Japanese cars. I grew up with Ford and Chevy so I love American muscle. :) I hope to get more opinions from everyone on here. Excellent reviews by the way. You picked up some really good points that I had not considered and helped confirm some of my reasons for which to choose. :) 

genxer --- 17 years ago -

we have a 2007 tacoma and LOVE it. Can't say enough good about it. 

Fallon --- 17 years ago -

Since the government intervention with Chevy I would not ever consider a vehicle from them. EIther of the other 2 are going to be great trucks. 

Sandyr9111 --- 17 years ago -

Go to msnautos.com and read the reviews and peoples comments....i did that when i was buying a couple of years ago...they talk about problems they have had with those models and such. 

Quicksilver Messenger Service --- 17 years ago -

If you were going to buy a truck from either of these, which one would you choose and why? I am having a difficult time making a decision on 3 choices but they're all different makes so not sure which is better. I've checked KBB.com for the values, etc. but not sure what else to go by. The gas mileages are not vastly different. The exact trucks I am trying to choose amongst are: Nissan Frontier Access Cab (Nismo) Chevy Silverado 1500 - Z71 4wd (ext cab) Toyota Tacoma Pre-runner - King cab 4d These are all 2006 models. Any info/insight you can offer is greatly appreciated. None of the above...go look at Honda Ridgelines.... 

R.E.B. --- 17 years ago -

Ford F150 

Clown Vomit --- 17 years ago -

Tacoma. Ford sucks. 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

I grew up with Ford and Chevy so I love American muscle Then you're better off buying the Toyota Tundra. They're actually made here. I'm with R.E.B. the only truck out there is the F-150 

R.E.B. --- 17 years ago -

Ford sucks. Hmmmm. So that is why they don't need bailouts with our tax money? 

Quicksilver Messenger Service --- 17 years ago -

Ford sucks. Gerald? 

Melissa --- 17 years ago -

I am a Ford girl, but I bought my sister's Toyota SUV several years ago because I needed a vehicle. I'll tell you what, that dang Toyota has been a Godsend. It is a 1999 and has 172k miles now, and it still runs great. Other than routine maintenance and replacing the parts that are made to wear out, we have had no problems with it. If I had to choose between the three you mentioned, I would go with the Toyota just because of my positive experience with mine lasting FOREVER. 

stampin' gal --- 17 years ago -

but hubby just loves his Japanese cars. i'm with your hubby on this one. i won't buy an american car. had one once......piece of crap. won't ever do it again. but, i don't know anything about those trucks (i'm not a truck kinda gal, lol). good luck with your choice! :) 

Clown Vomit --- 17 years ago -

Gerald? Harrison. 

Melanie --- 17 years ago -

a Ford F series. Yup. We have an F250. Chevy, no way. 

Yosamitesa --- 17 years ago -

The Toyota will have the best resell value. If that matters... If it is interior space you want, then go with the Chevy. If not important, the Toyota may be the better bet. 

bobbi --- 17 years ago -

I would never own an American car again after owning several Japanese cars......Honda, Acura and Toyota. They are the best made cars.....last forever, you don't get the squeaks and rattles that you get with American made cars. 

Scottie's Hottie --- 17 years ago -

I am all about American made cars but I just don't think that they hold up the way the foreign cars do. I have been shopping for used cars and I can tell you that the resale on Toyota, Nissan, and Honda's is crazy!! Even with well over a 100K these cars hold their value. They are just really well made vehicles. 

Puppydoglover --- 17 years ago -

man, the decision is getting harder, not easier. keep the opinions coming.. :) 

Lillabeth --- 17 years ago -

Sorry, but you couldn't pay me to buy a Chevy, Toyota, Dodge, or a Nissan. With a husband that is a mechanic and owns his own shop I know which cars have the most problems. We've always had Fords, until the stopped making mini vans and I had to buy a Honda. That stupid van has had more problems that all of our Fords. Go with what you really want just look into repairs/cost before you buy. Good Luck!! 

stampin' gal --- 17 years ago -

With a husband that is a mechanic and owns his own shop I know which cars have the most problems. We've always had Fords, until the stopped making mini vans and I had to buy a Honda. That stupid van has had more problems that all of our Fords. see, that is the exact opposite of us. i had a ford crapstar and that piece of $h!t left me stranded more places than i can remember. we sold it the last time it broke down in the middle of northpark at rush hour when the transmission COMPLETELY DIED. nothing but trouble with that hunk of junk. that was the FIRST and LAST ford i will EVER own. even if you gave me one for free, i wouldn't drive it.....i'd sell it, lol. after the crapstar, we bought a honda odyssey......best car ever. had it for 5 years, not one problem. like i said before.....good luck in your search. there will be LOTS of varying opinions on this one. best of luck to ya :) 

Fallon --- 17 years ago -

My Ford Bronco has over 248K miles, it is a 1996. Every thing on it is still original, except the radiator. I have someone every week or so offer to buy it from me. No way I would sell. That thing is a tank. Our next vehicle will be the F150. And they do hold up their resale value very well. Would rather get the F250, but that would be over kill for a commuter car:) 

maverick --- 17 years ago -

American trucks Ford, Chevy and Dodge still beat the Japanese hands down. Cars on the other hand are a different story. I have a Chevy Avalanche and love it, so does everyone I know who owns one. For a straight up truck - I would go Ford f150 - best selling vehicle for how many years in a row?? 

funmom --- 17 years ago -

i have had nissan's for over 10 years i love them.. they never i mean never give me any trouble my last one lasted to over 300,000 miles i am already at a 130,000 on mine now.. not that i dont like other makes/models but i really love my nissan 

mamadog53 --- 17 years ago -

DH owns a 72 Chevy pickup with probably close to 300K miles on it. We're not sure because the odometer was messed up for awhile. My Chevy Suburban has ove 200K miles on it. The only time I ever drove anything else it was a 74 Datsun B210 hatchback. That had to have been the worst car ever made. It went through several transmissions and clutches in the few years that I owned it. I returned to my senses and went back to Chevys. They last forever. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground