Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

HELP- disciplining a 3 yr old...

who's talking here?

FishinKim 3
*emily 1
Mabbers 5
AIL 1
Aiemzee 1
Tootsieboo 1
chunksNbones 3
3monkeysmomma 1
Diamom 2
angelbebe77 2
Unichic™ 3
ladybughomeschool 2
*Fancy* 1
*maryc 3
JohnLynch 2
Stella111 1
goatlady 1
YO♥Momma 2
Justin Case 1
Puppydoglover 1
luv2massage 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

angelbebe77 --- 17 years ago -

My 3 yr old is driving me nuts and I need help. First we get reports from daycare saying how good and polite he is. At home, he becomes the devil. He is very selfish, which I completely understand. He has a brand new sister, which means the dynamics of our family has changed, and acting out is natural at his age and under these circumstances… I understand that. The problem is I am afraid of how he is acting now and what he will be like as an older child, teen and beyond and I don’t know how to put a stop to it now before it gets out of control… We had an incident and I told my 3 yr old to go to time out and yelled “NO!” and he ran away from me. Of course this was while I was nursing my dd. So I got up and grabbed his arm to put him in time out and he went limp. One kid stuck to my boob and the other acting like a boob. So I swatted his butt and he laughed at me. HE LAUGHED AT ME!! After my head spun a la Linda Blair style, I went to pop him in the mouth and he flung his head down and I ended up poking his eye. I felt so bad but I was still upset, so I apologized for poking his eye and then put him into time-out anyway. The spitting has not happened again yet, although when he doesn’t get his way he thinks about spitting b/c his tongue will start to pop out of his mouth, but then he puts it back in. So maybe I solved that problem by poking his eye… we’ll see. When I ask him to hand me something, he’ll throw it on the grown next to me, but won’t hand it to me. Everything I’ve been asking him to do or not to do, he does the opposite. For instance, we were sitting on the bed w/ his sister and he was being really good. I even commented on how good he was acting. Then he stood up. I told him, “Please don’t jump on the bed when your sister is on it.” He jumped over her and landed on the pile of pillows. DH grabbed him and put him into time out. I’m just exhausted over the whole thing… time out is getting very regular and seems almost meaningless at this point. Any seasoned mom’s or dad’s have ANY tips besides poking the kid in the eye every time he becomes defiant????  

goatlady --- 17 years ago -

LMAO!!!! I remember those days so well. He's just looking for attention and acting out because he isn't the main focus right now. Try to involve him in the care of the baby as much as you can...eg. bringing you a diaper, blanket etc. When you are nursing, set up something fun for him to do at the same time like playdough or building blocks or read him a story while you nurse. Our oldest was the same when his sister arrived...he spent a lot of time sitting on his bed (our version of time out). It will pass in time and hopefully when it does he will still have both eyes! We also bought our son a baby doll so he had his own baby to care for....my dad had a fit, but it helped. 

Diamom --- 17 years ago -

When you have a nursing baby, sometimes you have to pick your battles. Also, at 3 he is old enough for tv & toys to be taken away. Remind him in advance what will happen if he does 'x' behavior and FOLLOW THRU. That is the best thing you can do. My 3 year old had it rough when I was nursing my last b/c he could not get instant gratificationon what he was needing. I tried to make some snacks accessible just in case. If he was bad while I was nursing, I would ignore the behavior and AFTER always sit him down and talk to him and take away a privelege. That worked. 

Diamom --- 17 years ago -

Oh, it can help to have a special DVD or toy he can play with with you are nursing and only then. 

*emily --- 17 years ago -

BE CONSISTENT with the time outs. Keep them short and completely ignore him while he is in time out. Also, keep praising him like you said you were. IMO, its a lot about the age. My youngest is the same. If I gave her a swat on the booty she would stare at me and spank herself again. Like "whatcha gonna do now momma?" SOOOOOO pissed me off. For us, with her, time outs work better, and I have made a concious effort to only react to bad behavior with discipline. Calmly. When I react with anger or frustration the situation is always worse. 

YO♥Momma --- 17 years ago -

I'll let you know when I find the secret LOL Mine is 4 and The BIGGEST TOOT OF THEM ALL! My 6 old an angel! 

*maryc --- 17 years ago -

I would do everything in my power to let him know he is just as loved and just as important to you as he was before the new baby arrived. I know it is tough with a new baby to take care of, but find some alone time with him to just sit on the floor and play with him. He's angry and jealous and really doesn't know how to handle the feelings........this, too, shall pass! 

FishinKim --- 17 years ago -

I understand you're frustrated...but popping a 3 y.o. in the mouth isn't going to teach him anything. I have a 3 1/2 y.o. that is determined to put me in my grave. She's an angel at school, everyone loves her, etc. We've brought her up the same way we did our other 2 sweet children. But this kid just has a stubborn streak. I have never had to deal with the limp child syndrome or the screaming bloody murder child until now. I apologize to all the parents I used to bad mouth for not being able to handle their kids. But the thing is...I always win the battle when it comes to "You will do what I ask or tell you to do simply because I am the parent". Be tough, be consistent and follow through. I know some will say to punish after you're done nursing because he might see it as distracting you from the baby, but he needs to be punished/redirected IMMEDIATELY for his behavior...not when she has finished on both sides. And like someone said, he is old enough know to feel the pain of having things taken away. Time outs are a must here. Good luck and stay strong! 

chunksNbones --- 17 years ago -

i have a 3 yr old and a 2 1/2montg old.i just figured out that me losing my temper does nothimg but make it a lot harder to get stuff done. i dont ask or say please, its more like "pickup your toys now" dont negotiate. my boy hasnt really acted differently towards the baby, but i was very worried. we dont use him as a lil helper unless he wants to and never compare them (see your brother is taking a nap, why arent you?) good luck, 3 yr olds are pains 

chunksNbones --- 17 years ago -

i have a 3 yr old and a 2 1/2montg old.i just figured out that me losing my temper does nothimg but make it a lot harder to get stuff done. i dont ask or say please, its more like "pickup your toys now" dont negotiate. my boy hasnt really acted differently towards the baby, but i was very worried. we dont use him as a lil helper unless he wants to and never compare them (see your brother is taking a nap, why arent you?) good luck, 3 yr olds are pains 

YO♥Momma --- 17 years ago -

I have never had to deal with the limp child syndrome or the screaming bloody murder child until now. I apologize to all the parents I used to bad mouth for not being able to handle their kids. Its so comforting to know I am not the only one out there... You look at my book collection its how to change your child in five day, how to deal with a strong willed child, the list goes on.... One good thing is I KNOW SHE WILL NEVER GET PUSHED OVER IN LIFE. My oldest who is an angel on the other hand is too sweet to be a leader she does seem to get pushed over...:( 

Unichic™ --- 17 years ago -

I think this is pretty normal behavior for a 3 year old with a baby sibling. Just be consistent with the time outs, it will get better. My son was almost 21 months when my DD was born. I remember the defiant behavior and my exhaustion dealing with it lol. Hang in there :). 

angelbebe77 --- 17 years ago -

I understand you're frustrated...but popping a 3 y.o. in the mouth isn't going to teach him anything. I do know this but was at my wits end.. I jumped ahead of myself and forgot to write that he stuck his tongue out & spit at me and then I popped him. Thanks everyone... It's just so hard b/c I was always the "good" kid. When I did something wrong to make my mom say my full name I would cry. My friends were the ones who would laugh at their mom when they would get spanked. I would NEVER do that. But YO Momma, I do get pushed over in life. So like your daughter, I don't think that my son will ever be pushed over. 

Unichic™ --- 17 years ago -

Its so comforting to know I am not the only one out there... You look at my book collection its how to change your child in five day, how to deal with a strong willed child, the list goes on.... One good thing is I KNOW SHE WILL NEVER GET PUSHED OVER IN LIFE. My oldest who is an angel on the other hand is too sweet to be a leader she does seem to get pushed over...:( I don't know if this reflects on who they become as older children/adults etc... My 7 year old DD is/was so stubborn. Temper tantrums lasted an hour. I had to walk away from that kid in public many times with looks or horror from passerbys. That kid, to this day, basically fights everything from food to clothing etc.... In school she is mild and meek and sweet. Perfect set-up for getting picked on. I see it coming very soon. I hope she pulls out those kahunas if it does happen or she will get her 42 lbs stomped on. 

Unichic™ --- 17 years ago -

I do know this but was at my wits end.. I jumped ahead of myself and forgot to write that he stuck his tongue out & spit at me and then I popped him. You did the best you knew at that moment. We have all made parental mistakes - that's life. Don't beat yourself up. I am sure you are exhausted and overwhelmed. 

FishinKim --- 17 years ago -

I do know this but was at my wits end.. I jumped ahead of myself and forgot to write that he stuck his tongue out & spit at me and then I popped him. Like I said...I really understand your frustration. When I did something wrong to make my mom say my full name I would cry. This was me...never got a spanking. All they had to do was ask if I wanted one and I would break out in hives, lol. 

Stella111 --- 17 years ago -

Try putting him in his room after counting to three. Stand at the door and hold it closed while talking to him. Tell him when you are quiet I will start your time out. After he is quiet for 3 minutes it is over. I did this with my 3 year old and it didn't take long for his behavior to stop on the count of 3. 

ladybughomeschool --- 17 years ago -

You know this is coming from the new baby trauma. I know this sounds a little weird but it worked for me. Get your son his own "baby" to care for while you are caring for your baby. You can get him a doll, diapers, and a bottle. It kind of works like play therapy. If he can be responsible for something then his focus is not on the attention he is losing from you. He probably feels like a fifth wheel. I completely believe in spanking so everyone please do not lecture me. In my opinion, spanking should be used as a last resort because it tend to lose its effectiveness. The time out needs to be in his room with toys removed. It is useless to pitch a fit without an audience, so do not give him one. 

Mabbers --- 17 years ago -

It is useless to pitch a fit without an audience, so do not give him one. Bingo. 

chunksNbones --- 17 years ago -

my kid will laugh when I spank him too. He sees me getting so frustrated and laughs. Pisses me off. He's actually taken my hand and started spanking himself and laughing and laughing. It was NOT funny. GRRRR. So now (and I'm serious it's only been like a week or two) I'm not losing my temper or letting it escalate to that. Seems to be working so far... 

luv2massage --- 17 years ago -

Ok. My middle child was the definition of the strong-willed child. He would hold his breath until he passed out. For him, splashing him in the face with some water is what got his attention. It took 2 times. If he started in I would just ask if I needed to get water, and he would settle right down. Each child is different, so you just have to keep trying until you find the right combination. 

luv2massage --- 17 years ago -

In the ultimate reaping what you sow, my son is now a detention officer at the harris county jail. He gets to deal with "problem children" all day! 

AIL --- 17 years ago -

We are in a pretty similar situation with an almost 4 year old and an 11 week old (nursing also). Luckily our oldest has been pretty good since the baby was born. However we have had a few issues where time out didn't work. Taking favorite toys or movies away seems to be a punishment she does not like! I only had to do it once and now just threatening to do it is effective. I also make sure we really talk about problems and hug afterward. Maybe you could offer rewards after so long and make sure he knows how proud you are of his progress. 

Puppydoglover --- 17 years ago -

OH WOW! First of all, I don't have children - have never been blessed to have them. KUDO's to you mom's for sticking it out and not killing your kids. I don't mean that literally. You need more than one day a year for mother's day it seems to me. Yikes! That's tough work you're doing. It sounds tough to me anyways! :) Hang in there! 

*maryc --- 17 years ago -

Strong willed children are always a challenge, but they grow up to be the nicest adults! 

JohnLynch --- 17 years ago -

DH grabbed him and put him into time out. I’m just exhausted over the whole thing… time out is getting very regular and seems almost meaningless at this point. Time out doesn't work. 

*maryc --- 17 years ago -

Time out DOES work. My grandson hated it, but it worked! 

Mabbers --- 17 years ago -

It worked for middle ds but not for oldest. Sometimes it works for Insano. 

3monkeysmomma --- 17 years ago -

Tough times! My just turned 3 y/o is alot like your ds, but she doesn't have a little sibling, thank goodness! Forget the terrible twos - I think it is the terrible threes! Time out absolutely works - both she and my ds HATE it and usually straighten up when I threaten it. 

JohnLynch --- 17 years ago -

Time out DOES work. If so then what does "time out is getting very regular and seems almost meaningless at this point" mean to you? 

ladybughomeschool --- 17 years ago -

Time out doesn't work. It depends on the kid and how time out is done. It is the only thing available to me in Children's Ministry and it does work quite well for some children. It works with my dd as a first option. Sometimes she pushes the envelope too far and gets a spanking but she is learning to accept the time out even though she hates it. 

Mabbers --- 17 years ago -

Sometimes ya just have to get medieval on their a$$es too. :) 

FishinKim --- 17 years ago -

If so then what does "time out is getting very regular and seems almost meaningless at this point" mean to you? That the kid is too old for time out and you need to move on to other things or you have a freakishly expressive little kid. 

Justin Case --- 17 years ago -

It works with my dd as a first option. Time out can work as an option, but not as the only option. Didn't our God say something like "If you spare the rod, you will spoil the child"? 

Mabbers --- 17 years ago -

In my experience, nothing works as the only option. LOL. That's what keeps us on our toes over here. 

Tootsieboo --- 17 years ago -

My advise is to stop the behavior asap and don't ignore it. Spankings do not hurt a strong willed child. They will actually help. My kids will point out bad behaving kids and say "mom they need a spankin". One other piece of advise to all young moms/dads. Please do not ignore your kids bad behavior when in public. It is so dang annoying when parents let their kids scream and cry and just ignore them. I know you get used to it at home but in public people really don't want to hear it. This may sound harsh but try going out for a nice dinner, movie, or just shopping only to hear a kid scream and cry. Not fun. 

*Fancy* --- 17 years ago -

Man, I would go bonkers with a kid like those here. Both of mine were really pleasant, one still is, the other is not, but is grown. I don't spank because I have a temper, but do believe that spankings work, especially with strong willed kids like these. I was one of those strong willed kids, and still am. ;0) 

Aiemzee --- 17 years ago -

I don't mean to hijack the thread but I have a question- what age do you start time outs? My daughter is 20 mos old and defiant as ever. She has been throwing tantrums all of a sudden for no apparent reason and wants her way nonstop. She hadn't been like this before and I'm trying to keep her in line because 'I run things, not her.' When I taught high schoolers I never had this problem. I was able to stay calm, keep classroom discipline in order, and not yell. I have no experience with a low-verbal little girl who seems to be starting her terrible twos early. I can see the stubburn attitude and lack of reaction already and I'm worried that I too will have the same issues as you when she's 2 and 3.. Any advice? I've been switching from calm discipline to yelling and swatting lately and it has made zero difference. 

Mabbers --- 17 years ago -

I honestly think you have to be consistent and quick. Letting stuff slide because you're frustrated is a button they love to push. As stated earlier, they HATE it if you're not "into" their tantrum, and I refuse to acknowledge it. I go down my list of disciplines until something works for that particular instance. It's these kinds of kids that make mommies step up to the plate every damn day. It's exhausting, but I'm bigger, I'm louder, I'm meaner and I'm the boss. I get this attitude of, "I brought you in this world and I can certainly take you out." LOL. Unfortunately, it's a long haul and they won't give up...ever. Oldest was like that, and he's about to turn 19. And now Insano is exactly the same way. It's overwhelming, but daggumit, I will NOT tolerate the little alpha male runt and that's all there is to it. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice
children
help


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground