Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

1600 year old bible put online. Not the same as yours. Interesting.

who's talking here?

Carla 1
Fallon 2
Fancy 1
planemom 3
JDaddy 1
Going off air 3
ShookUpRamen 6
Mabbers 5
Cicero 2
Angela 1
Donkey Hodie 2
Unichic™ 2
~Songbird~ 1
OH SNAP! 14
ladybughomeschool 1
Laurabeth 1
POTUS 1
zapper007 2
believer 9
anti-antichange 1
*maryc 1
evolved 1
TeaLeaves 2
JeffSpicoli 1
burbchick 1
goatlady 1
*momof5* 12
-Ray 1
MxMike. 1
Magical 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

OH SNAP! --- 17 years ago -

Apparently there are actually two books included that aren't in today's bible, and also some notes and corrections were made. Interesting article. Would love to hear some thoughts on it: Link LONDON, England (CNN) -- The world's oldest known Christian Bible goes online Monday -- but the 1,600-year-old text doesn't match the one you'll find in churches today. Discovered in a monastery in the Sinai desert in Egypt more than 160 years ago, the handwritten Codex Sinaiticus includes two books that are not part of the official New Testament and at least seven books that are not in the Old Testament. The New Testament books are in a different order, and include numerous handwritten corrections -- some made as much as 800 years after the texts were written, according to scholars who worked on the project of putting the Bible online. The changes range from the alteration of a single letter to the insertion of whole sentences. And some familiar -- very important -- passages are missing, including verses dealing with the resurrection of Jesus, they said. Juan Garces, the British Library project curator, said it should be no surprise that the ancient text is not quite the same as the modern one, since the Bible has developed and changed over the years. "The Bible as an inspirational text has a history," he told CNN. "There are certainly theological questions linked to this," he said. "Everybody should be encouraged to investigate for themselves." That is part of the reason for putting the Bible online, said Garces, who is both a Biblical scholar and a computer scientist. "Scholars will want to look very closely at it, and some of the Web site functionality is specifically for them -- the ability to search the text, the ability to highlight a word, the degree of detail is particularly interesting for scholars interested in the text," he said. Don't Miss * Codex Sinaiticus project But, he added, "It's for everyone, really a wide audience, because of curiosity, because they appreciate the value of it." By the middle of the fourth century, when the Codex Sinaiticus was written, there was wide but not complete agreement on which books should be considered authoritative for Christian communities, according to the Web site where the Codex is posted. The Bible comes from the Monastery of St. Catherine in the Sinai desert, where a scholar named Constantine Tischendorf recognized its significance in 1844 -- and promptly took part of it, Garces explained. "Constantine Tischendorf was in search for ancient manuscripts, so he appreciated the age and value of it," Garces said. He took a handful of pages to Germany to publish them, then returned in 1853 and in 1859 for more. On that last trip, he took 694 pages, which ended up in St. Petersburg, Russia. The Soviet government decided to sell them in 1933 -- to raise money to buy tractors and other agricultural equipment. The British government bought the pages for £100,000, raising half the money from the public. Garces called that event one of the first fundraising campaigns in British history. Film footage from the time shows crowds of people turning out to see the manuscript, which was considered a national treasure, he said. Though the Bible has been reassembled online, in the real world it remains scattered. Most of it is in London. Eighty-six pages are held at the University Library in Leipzig, Germany, parts of 12 pages are held at the National Library of Russia in St. Petersburg, and 24 pages and 40 fragments remain at St. Catherine's Monastery, recovered by the monks from the northern wall of the structure in June 1975. The manuscript contains the Christian Bible in Greek, including the oldest complete copy of the New Testament. (A copy held at the Vatican dates from about the same period.) Older copies of individual portions of the Christian Bible exist, but not as part of a complete text. The Codex also includes much of the Old Testament that was adopted by early Greek-speaking Christians. That portion includes books not found in the Hebrew Bible and regarded in the Protestant tradition as apocryphal, such as 2 Esdras, Tobit, Judith, 1 & 4 Maccabees, Wisdom and Sirach. The New Testament portion includes the Epistle of Barnabas and The Shepherd of Hermas. As it survives today, Codex Sinaiticus comprises just over 400 large leaves of parchment -- prepared animal skin -- each of which measures 15 inches by 13.6 inches (380 mm by 345 mm).  

Donkey Hodie --- 17 years ago -

Juan Garces, the British Library project curator, said it should be no surprise that the ancient text is not quite the same as the modern one, since the Bible has developed and changed over the years. Wait, what? 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

Though the Bible has been reassembled online, in the real world it remains scattered. and there's the loophole for people to say, "it isn't accurate, we have no way to know what's been doctored"...etc etc etc. 

OH SNAP! --- 17 years ago -

Never mind him. He has obviously been deceived by Satan. The bible hasn't changed. EVER. *sticks fingers in ears* LALALALALALALALALAALALALAALA!!!! 

-Ray --- 17 years ago -

What a great post. I bookmarked this one....... Thanks Kid! 

ShookUpRamen --- 17 years ago -

The Codex Sinaiticus is one of the most important documents in Christian history. Its remarkable agreement with the later manuscripts verifies that the Bible was reliably transmitted. It does contain some variation from the manuscript that was used to translate the King James Bible. These variations do not alter any major doctrines, but they have caused a backlash among KJV-only advocates who maintain the inerrancy of the KJV in its English form, as well as its superiority to all other English translations. The KJV-only crowd is a little, well, misguided. For the rest of us, the Sinaiticus ranks up there with the Codex Vaticanus and the Dead Sea Scrolls as the great documents demonstrating reliable transmission. 

Angela --- 17 years ago -

When you go to this "Codex Sinaiticus project" and you try to read these new books it gives you trouble. I am trying to pull up this book they called Barnabas that they are saying comes after Revelations. It will not give it to me. Nothing. Wonder if anyone else was able to. 

Fallon --- 17 years ago -

I never read the KJV, but I am Catholic. Our Bible has more books in it that the KJV. So I don't see what the big deal? 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

The KJV-only crowd is a little, well, misguided LOL... 

ShookUpRamen --- 17 years ago -

The KJV is the same as every other translation, only it was written 400 years earlier, and therefore the language is archaic. Its differences stem from the fact that is was based on a later manuscript, the textus receptus (TR). After earlier manuscripts such as the CS were found, it was noticed that minor differences existed between the CS and the TR. For example, the 2nd half of Mark 16, the encounter with Jesus and the woman caught in adultery (John 8), and an extra Trinitarian formulation (I John) are found in the TR, and hence in the KJV. These verses are not included, or are included with footnotes, in most modern translations, since these translations are based on the earlier manuscripts. None of these omissions affect any major doctrine. The Catholic Bible includes the "extra" apocryphal books. These books are not included in Protestant Bibles because protestants believe that the Bible has authority over the church, rather than vice versa. Since the Jews of Jesus' day did not recognize the Apocrypha as scripture, the church had no authority to add it later. There are other reasons why the Apocrypha is not included, but I'm trying to be brief. 

OH SNAP! --- 17 years ago -

I never read the KJV, but I am Catholic. Our Bible has more books in it that the KJV. It does? I never knew that. I thought all of the bibles were the same as far as the books, only that there were different translations. 

Fallon --- 17 years ago -

No. There are many different ones out there. So I guess I just can't see that a big deal. More like a duh, no crap sherlock moment. 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

The Catholic Bible includes the "extra" apocryphal books. These books are not included in Protestant Bibles because protestants believe that the Bible has authority over the church, rather than vice versa. Since the Jews of Jesus' day did not recognize the Apocrypha as scripture, the church had no authority to add it later. interesting. I was always under the impression that the Catholic bible was the original text, as far as, all books included, and when Luther broke away from the church, he edited it. 

TeaLeaves --- 17 years ago -

Any idea how much something that old would sell for. I have an over 100 yo family bible that I'd sell if the money was right. 

MxMike. --- 17 years ago -

The bible hasn't changed. EVER. That is the funniest little bit of denial I have ever seen!! LOL the bible has changed drastically over the centuries to suit different agendas of kings and popes throughout history. 

ladybughomeschool --- 17 years ago -

There have always been different versions of the Bible. The Bible is a guidebook to be read and interpreted prayfully under the guidance of God. Without a relationship with God, the Bible is just another book. 

Laurabeth --- 17 years ago -

Without a relationship with God, the Bible is just another book. BINGO! 

OH SNAP! --- 17 years ago -

I thought the bible was supposed to be the living word of God. And how does this gibe with the people who believe everything in the bible is literal? 

*maryc --- 17 years ago -

Fallon, is it the book of Wisdom that the Catholic bible has.....don't remember and haven't had one in a while. 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

When the church chose which books to include in the official Bible they used several rules. Among them are: 1. Does New Tesatment attest to the authority of scripture? 2. Do extra-Biblical Jewish writers affirm it? 3. Is the book consistant with the rest of God's revelations? 4. Was it written by a prophet or divine authority? The apopcrypha books have caused controversy for a long time. One reason they weren't included in the Protestant Bible is the author couldn't be verified. Some scholars feel a few were included in the Catholic Bible because they conveyed important lessons. If remember correctly there are over 20 apocrapha books. Some of them would be much closer to a Frank Perretti book than a book of the Bible. 

Fancy --- 17 years ago -

There was a program on the Discovery Channel regarding these "other" bibles. Quite intersting. 

POTUS --- 17 years ago -

The New Testament books are in a different order, and include numerous handwritten corrections -- I like how the word of God has to be corrected from time to time... 

~Songbird~ --- 17 years ago -

very interesting post. thank you for sharing. 

believer --- 17 years ago -

Here is an article for you to consider: The Accuracy of the Biblical Records Does the Bible contain errors? The question often arises when discussing the biblical records, "How can a document that has been copied over and over possibly be reliable?Everyone knows there are tons of errors in it." While it is true that the documents have been copied many times, we often have misconceptions about how they were transmitted. All ancient documents were copied by hand before the advent of the printing press in the 16th century. Great care was exercised in reproducing these manuscripts. We often assume that one copy was made and then another from that and another from that and so on, each replacing the copy it was reproduced from. This is not how manuscripts copying worked. Copyists were usually working from one or two very old documents. They would make many copies of their source copy, all the while preserving their source and comparing the copies they have made. Josephus tells how the Jews copied the Old Testament: "We have given practical proof of our reverence for our own Scriptures. For although such long ages have now passed, no one has ventured either to add, or to remove, or to alter a syllable; and it is an instinct with every Jew, from the day of his birth, to regard them as the decrees of God, to abide by them, and, if need be, cheerfully to die for them" (Against Apion, Book I, sec., 8, p. 158) Josephus made no exaggeration. The Jewish copyists knew exactly how many letters were in every line of every book and how many times each word occurred in each book. This enabled them to check for errors (Shelly, Prepare to Answer,p. 133). The Jews believed that adding any mistake to the Scriptures would be punishable by Hell - unlike the modern secretary who has many letters to type and must work hard to keep his job, and consequently feels that mistakes are inevitable. Great care is exercised with scriptures when someone holds a conviction such as this. But even with the great amount of care exercised in copying, errors have crept into the manuscripts. No one questions that spelling errors, misplaced letters, and word omissions have occurred. What is not true is that these errors have gradually built up over time so that our copies look nothing like the originals. This view was commonly held until recently. In 1947 the accuracy of these documents was confirmed by the Dead Sea Scrolls. These scrolls were found in caves in the desert near the Dead Sea by a shepherd boy. Before the discovery of these scrolls, the earliest Old Testament manuscripts we had were from about 980 A.D. The manuscripts discovered in the caves dated from 250 B.C. to shortly after the time of Christ. In careful comparison of the manuscripts it was confirmed that the copies we had were almost precisely the same as those which date over 1000 years earlier. No other historical literature has been so carefully preserved and historically confirmed. When we come to the New Testament we see a similar phenomenon. There are over 5,000 Greek New Testament manuscripts in existence. This is by far more than any other historical documents, which usually have maybe a dozen copies from very late dates. The New Testament manuscripts are many and old and they are spread over a wide geographical area. What this enables the New Testament historian to do is collect manuscripts from Jerusalem and Egypt and Syria and other places and compare them for variations. And variations do exist, but as with the Old Testament they are relatively few and rarely important to the meaning of the text. What these manuscripts demonstrate is that different families of texts existed very early that were copied from the original or good copies of the original. This allows us to trace the manuscripts back to the source as one would follow the branches of a tree to get to the trunk. Aside from the manuscripts themselves, virtually the entire New Testament could be reproduced from citations contained in the works of the early church fathers. There are some thirty-two thousand citations in the writings of the Fathers prior to the Council of Nicea (Moreland, Scaling the Secular City, p. 136). 

anti-antichange --- 17 years ago -

The New Testament books are in a different order, and include numerous handwritten corrections -- some made as much as 800 years after the texts were written i'm surprised christians still aren't making 'corrections' till they get it exactly to their liking. you know, a little nip and tuck here and there. 

believer --- 17 years ago -

The New Testament books are in a different order, and include numerous handwritten corrections -- some made as much as 800 years after the texts were written That statement doesn't tell us anything. What kind of corrections? Spelling errors? Misplaced letters? 

ShookUpRamen --- 17 years ago -

i'm surprised christians still aren't making 'corrections' till they get it exactly to their liking. you know, a little nip and tuck here and there. The reasons why this doesn't occur have been ably and reasonably presented, such that even the most novice critic can understand them. 

Cicero --- 17 years ago -

Here is an article for you to consider: What does that prove? The OP's original post reported missing books from the Bible. It is well known that entire books were purposely omitted from the Bible. Hardly appropriate behavior when dealing with the word of God, eh? 

ShookUpRamen --- 17 years ago -

It is well known that entire books were purposely omitted from the Bible. Statements like this make me question whether apologetics even has a place in the discussions of this age. But upon reflection, I understand that there is still a minority of people who actually care about logic and proof, and the possibility of absolute truths. For those who do not, all I can do is invite you to examine my life, and that by doing so you would know that I am not trying to "pull a fast one" on anyone. 

Cicero --- 17 years ago -

Statements like this make me question whether apologetics even has a place in the discussions of this age. But upon reflection, I understand that there is still a minority of people who actually care about logic and proof, and the possibility of absolute truths. For those who do not, all I can do is invite you to examine my life, and that by doing so you would know that I am not trying to "pull a fast one" on anyone. Wait, What? 

JeffSpicoli --- 17 years ago -

logic and proof That's what's missing in all this "bible is the word of god." LMAO. 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

ShookUpRamen...wth are you talking about? 

Carla --- 17 years ago -

interesting. I was always under the impression that the Catholic bible was the original text, as far as, all books included, and when Luther broke away from the church, he edited it. No, the Hebrew Bible (the Old Testament) predates the Catholic Church. Most of the Apocryphal books that are included in the Catholic Bible were written during the 400 years of silence, from the end of Malachi to the time of Christ. Martin Luther didn't "edit" the Bible. His break with the Catholic Church came about after he began to study the Scriptures more indepth for the lectures he was giving and when he was translating the Bible into German. The 95 Theses that he nailed to the door of the Castle Church in Wittenberg listed the areas where he believe the stance of the RCC was in error according to the Bible. Specifically, that salvation is by God's grace and through faith alone, that it cannot be bought or earned. He was particularly emphatic that the church's sale of indulgences was corrupt. Luther's challenge of the RCC, along with the publication of the Gutenberg Bible 60 years earlier which made the Scriptures more widely available to the common man, was the catalyst for the Reformation. More people were able to read what the Bible actually said for themselves rather than just listening to what the church told them it did. As ShookUpRamen said, God is the authority, not a particular church. 

ShookUpRamen --- 17 years ago -

As ShookUpRamen said, God is the authority, not a particular church. Although I do believe that, I don't believe I said it. My point was not to be critical of Catholics, but rather to explain how they arrived at a different canon. 

ShookUpRamen --- 17 years ago -

ShookUpRamen...wth are you talking about? mom, to keep it short, there are literaly 10's of thousands of copies and portions of ancient manuscripts of the bible that have been found, dating all the way back to the 3rd century. Even if those manuscripts were not available, we would still have the writings of the early church fathers, in which 90% of the NT was quoted. On top of this, the OT manuscript evidence found at Qumran (DSS) removed any reasonable doubt about the transmission of the OT. Bottom line: You may not like what the Bible says, and you may not think it is inspired, but it HAS been reliably transmitted. Only someone with an ax to grind, or someone deliberately antagonistic, or perhaps someone with an outdated and fragile view of inerrancy broken by modern scholarship could argue that the texts were not reliably transmitted. Look this up for yourself. Heck, even go and read Bart Ehrman's Misquoting Jesus. 

Unichic™ --- 17 years ago -

I thought the bible was supposed to be the living word of God. And how does this gibe with the people who believe everything in the bible is literal? Oh boy lol! 

Unichic™ --- 17 years ago -

The question often arises when discussing the biblical records, "How can a document that has been copied over and over possibly be reliable?Everyone knows there are tons of errors in it." While it is true that the documents have been copied many times, we often have misconceptions about how they were transmitted. All ancient documents were copied by hand before the advent of the printing press in the 16th century. Great care was exercised in reproducing these manuscripts. We often assume that one copy was made and then another from that and another from that and so on, each replacing the copy it was reproduced from. This is not how manuscripts copying worked. Copyists were usually working from one or two very old documents. They would make many copies of their source copy, all the while preserving their source and comparing the copies they have made. Ever play telephone as a kid???? One kid starts the circle and says a couple of sentences. By the time it gets to the 12th person, the whole thing has changed. 

OH SNAP! --- 17 years ago -

Well, my logic is this: Even assuming that every translation has gone directly back to the original manuscripts and has not been a translation from one translation to another, if the bible is the ONLY authority we have to go on when it comes to what God's will is, isn't it a little disconcerting that no one could even agree at the time the bible was being pieced together which books to include and which books not to include? Is it not especially disconcerting to someone whose view is that the ONLY way to heaven is through Jesus Christ, that some accounts of his life and the things he said have been edited or omitted entirely? Does that mean that some books of the bible may have been more inspired by God than others? And, if so, who decides which ones? Wait, that was the Church. Sooo...I think there was some agreement the bible is just a book. Why on Earth would it be a book we consider to be so accurate that we would kill and/or die for what's in it? Especially when the average person has never even read it cover to cover, much less researched the missing chapters. 

JDaddy --- 17 years ago -

Studying the history of the Bible has been one of the most enlightening events of my life. There are no new revelations with this Codex. The Bible is unique among all other texts. Study the Dead Sea Scrolls to see how little the Bible has changed over time. Realize that over 90 percent of the New Testament can be recreated just by looking at quotations in other ancient texts. It hasn't changed. Errors do occur - look at the "wicked Bible" KJV version in the 16th century but scripture interprets scripture and what we have today is simply awesome. 

OH SNAP! --- 17 years ago -

The Bible is unique among all other texts. Well, to be fair, it did borrow a little from time to time. This is one example:  

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground