Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Parents - Help! Need toughts on an eleven year old having her own cell phone!

who's talking here?

Melanie 1
whatchamacallit 1
Denise C 1
la guerita 1
planemom 1
Sandyr9111 1
ambergris 1
movedagain 2
Cajunmom 1
9829LuvLuv9829 1
random 1
Mabbers 2
Rachel 1
Tootsieboo 1
recycled teenager 1
~sassy~ 1
Diamom 1
txmomx5 1
Melissa 1
believer 1
RCSKI 1
jtcitrus 1
Tammy 4
zombie slayer 2
goatlady 1
*momof5* 1
a2jblessed 1
-Ray 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Tammy --- 17 years ago -

Would like some "fellow parent thoughts" on this one. My DD will be 11 come August. She is an all around great kid (thought she can be a little sassy at times, lol). She is on the honor role, has great conduct at school, and is more responsible then most of her peers. Here is the situation: she is wanting her own cell phone. I always thought when she turned 16 that would be a good time to get her one. Do you think an 11 year old should have her own cell phone? We do not want her to grow up too fast and I realize she is more mature then most kids her age. When she is at a friends house or girls scouts it would be a lot easier to get a hold of her. If DH and I did this she would have strict limits on using the phone. She also told us she would pay for her own phone and said she would pay the 10. a month for the extra line by selling her earrings. I don't mind paying the 10. but I would be more inclined to get her one of the free phones if we even did this. If there are any parents out there that would like to share their views on this I would love to hear them! In fact, I'm begging for some opinions, lol 

movedagain --- 17 years ago -

My dd has a phone, she is 11, she has it because I work. I have her text me when she rides to school and when she gets home. She has now figured out texting and it has helped with some of her friends and such. She has the free phone--so do I, they work fine. If she is responsible, and you want to pay for it, why not? We have RULES about the phone--no phone during dinner, or after 8pm, and she does not have picture messages on her phone (LOTS OF REASONS for this!!! ) If she loses it, she pays for it! She also has to text me or she is in trouble. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

In the pure sense, it's silly. However, for safety's sake, I think it might make sense. 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

Make sure she understands the responsibility involved with having a phone. Anything she texts can be used against her by her "friends". I say this because a friends daughter was extremely embarrassed when one of her "friends" showed everybody a text regarding her thoughts on a cute boy. 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

In fact, I'm begging for some opinions, lol no need to beg...there's never a shortage of opinions on KU. I wish we could harness THAT energy for electricity and we'd never pay a high bill again! ok, as far as cell phones go for a child that age, it's completely up to you. We got one for our oldest, who is now 13, last year. The reason she got it was her school bus had 2 car accidents and I couldn't get ahold of her...then there was a bomb scare at the school...so, after that, she got a phone so she could call us if there was ever an emergency. She very rarely uses it, she's not a big phone person to begin with. So, for us, it's not a big deal. I've seen other kids that cannot be off the phone and they're constantly texting. It's very annoying for everyone around them. I guess it just depends on the need and the kid. hope that helps :) 

Mabbers --- 17 years ago -

We do a to-go phone for my 11yo. In fact, he and I share it just because I'm always here. LOL. But he's been asking for a plan which includes unlimited texting and we've put the kybosh on that one. 

Cajunmom --- 17 years ago -

I personally think it's ridiculous for an 11 year old to have a cell phone. 

la guerita --- 17 years ago -

In the pure sense, it's silly. However, for safety's sake, I think it might make sense. i actually agree with sassy ;) 

Tammy --- 17 years ago -

Thanks for the thoughts and opinions. Another question: From time to time would you look at what texts she sends and receives for "safety sake"? JMABS - A pay as you go is a greeat idea but it would be a lot cheaper to add her to our plan. It would only be $10. 

9829LuvLuv9829 --- 17 years ago -

I think that it is up to you.... my son has had a cell phone from a very early age (9). He is and has always been responsible. My daughter is 12 and just got one for Christmas. She loses it all the time; half the time she doesn't know where it is at. Defeats the purpose of her having it if I can never reach her! we started witha pay as you go for her and it wasn't worth it. Get a free phone! Chances are she will lose it or it could get stolen. that is when it gets expensive. 

recycled teenager --- 17 years ago -

Don't they have them with parental controls, so there could be only certain phone numbers called and no texting? I think that is what my grandson has 

Mabbers --- 17 years ago -

JMABS - A pay as you go is a greeat idea but it would be a lot cheaper to add her to our plan. It would only be $10. Well that's a no-brainer. LOL. 

Diamom --- 17 years ago -

I have a 9 yr old and I have been thinking of getting one that I can give when she goes places for safety sakes (sometimes easier to go in the potty and call mom than ask the host for help). I was thinking of not calling her phone but the emergency phone. 

goatlady --- 17 years ago -

We gave my 11 yo my old one when I got a new one...she was already sitting on the phone with her 2 BFF's! We could never get calls! We have a family plan. 

whatchamacallit --- 17 years ago -

My 11 year old got his first phone when he was 9. It was a pay as you go plan. He had it for a month and then lost it, for over a year! Then I got him another phone when he was 11. He did great keeping up with it until he jumped into the pool with it in his pocket! Right now, he has no phone. The only reason I will get him another phone is for my piece of mind, being able to call and check on him and know what he is up to. 

txmomx5 --- 17 years ago -

My daughter is 10 and she has one. It helps her stay in touch with her friends in the town we just moved from and it allows me to keep up with her if she's away from me. We havent had any issues, our family plan has unltd texting and free nights and wkends, she knows if she messes up the phone is mine and she would rather walk the line than give it up. I have an extra phone in my plan that no one is really using right now because it was hubby's and he uses work cell for everything, sooo I'm thinking of giving that to my son to use (he's almost 9) for the same reasons. He can keep up with his friends where we used to live and I can always contact him. Quite a few of their friends have either their own phones or phones that they have unrestricted access to, so really its not that big of a deal. Same thing as having a land-line just for the kids. 

-Ray --- 17 years ago -

NO. Eleven year olds dont need em. I won this battle till my daughter was 14. After that......I was toast. 

Tammy --- 17 years ago -

NO. Eleven year olds dont need em. I won this battle till my daughter was 14. After that......I was toast. Well at least you made it till she was 14, lol Thanks everyone for the great advice I totally appreciate hearing everyones views. 

Tootsieboo --- 17 years ago -

We give get our kids their first cell phone before starting 6th grade. It in case of emergencys at school. Like lockdowns or after school practice. 

Sandyr9111 --- 17 years ago -

I got mine a freebie at 10. She will be 13 in October and I think she has used 150 minutes in 3 years and 30 texts. She is a phone user really either. I did just get her an upgrade seen as how she kept up with the other one all these years. She is responsible and knows what she can and cant do with her phone. 

Melissa --- 17 years ago -

We plan on providing our son with a cell phone by then. So many wireless companies have great parental controls for the phones and you should be able to adequately control who, when, and how much with regard to the calls. I would say that for safety's sake, it is a good idea. 

a2jblessed --- 17 years ago -

ONLY if the child needs it. I bought one for my daughter that was 11 awesome kid BUT once she got the phone WOW what a differance texts, picture text, etc. She would erase everything no telling what was being sent. Not only that but she would use it in the middle of the night and stay on it. Just be careful. I took it away and now shes been doing fine. But everyone has differant ideas 

Melanie --- 17 years ago -

I personally think it's ridiculous for an 11 year old to have a cell phone. I agree. Probably not the answer you want. 

random --- 17 years ago -

No. they shouldn't have them at school during class. ours will get one eventually, but it will be set to only us! 

zombie slayer --- 17 years ago -

mine has had one since he was 10. i can monitor all texts and calls online. i recommend unlimited text if you give a tween a cell phone. 

believer --- 17 years ago -

I know some families that have watched their child's grades suffer because of giving them unlimited text 

Denise C --- 17 years ago -

My 8 and 11 year old both have cell phones. Don't see a problem with it. 

zombie slayer --- 17 years ago -

I know some families that have watched their child's grades suffer because of giving them unlimited text oh man. glad that is not the case with my son. school first, then social time. 

jtcitrus --- 17 years ago -

no 

Tammy --- 17 years ago -

Wow! Thanks for everyone's thoughts and suggestions, I truly do appreciate it. I think we will go ahead and get her one but she will have limits on calling. We already have unlimted family texting so we are ok there, lol But she will have to do have her homework first but with her I don't think that will be a problem. She's the type to do her homeowrk as soon as she gets home from school to get it out of the way. Like I mentioned she's a good kid except for being a bit sassy every now and then and is responsible. I never even have to tell her to clean her room. She's the type to make her bed every morning before she leaves her room. Thanks again KU! 

Rachel --- 17 years ago -

My kids did not get a phone until they NEEDED one. I don't see why an 11 yo would need a cell phone unless they are in a bunch of extracurricular activities. 

movedagain --- 17 years ago -

Rachel, my 11 yr old rode to school alone this year and home alone, it is 1.8 miles. She had to text me when she arrived and when she got home. It is worth every penny of a cell phone bill to know she was safe. She rode on the greenbelt alone.... 

RCSKI --- 17 years ago -

It's not necessary and a complete waste of money. However, if you are get the kind that only has 3 numbers in it (IE-yours, her dad, and 911). We did not give our kids cell phones until they started driving. 

ambergris --- 17 years ago -

I am so gonna need to make sure DD doesn't see this thread. She is in high school and still does not have a cell phone. Anytime she has ever needed to reach me she has used a school phone since every teacher has one in their class. I don't anticipate that she will get one for a few more years. When she starts driving I'll give in and get one but until then there is no shortage of phones or friends cell phones for her to use. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground