Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Americans Who've Used Canada's Health-Care System Respond to Current Big-Lie Media Campaign

who's talking here?

marthas attic 17
freshhell 1
whatchamacallit 1
smartypants 6
randyjet 8
Sandyr9111 2
NoNameNoLastName 5
Cicero 11
lean 9
Spartacus 1
ghostpost 3
david 3
justforfun 1
~sassy~ 24
ExLady In Blue 2
rEVOLution 8
Unichic™ 64
OH SNAP! 32
Nightstorm 3
Wilstar77 1
Possum 2
Shana 1
Agent of Change 3
POTUS 1
Hiro Protagonist 14
clockwatcher. 28
TakeTheGlovesOff 2
JetMan 1
jtcitrus 12
JohnLynch 40
Polly Ester 1
NewNanna 1
zombie slayer 3
BigTuna 2
sadiesmom 1
theirsalways 1
goatlady 40
Jean 1
*momof5* 16
Darrell 14
-Ray 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
NoNameNoLastName --- 17 years ago -

Bill Mann Bill Mann – Sun Jun 14, 5:24 pm ET The scare ads and op-ed pieces featuring Canadians telling us American how terrible their government health-care systems have arrived - predictably. There's another, factual view - by those of us Americans who've lived in Canada and used their system. My wife and I did for years, and we've been incensed by the lies we've heard back here in the U.S. about Canada's supposedly broken system. It's not broken - and what's more, Canadians like and fiercely defend it. Example: Our son was born at Montreal's Royal Victoria Hospital. My wife got excellent care. The total bill for three days in a semi-private room? $21. My friend Art Finley is a West Virginia native who lives in Vancouver. "I'm 82, and in excellent health," he told me this week. "It costs me all of $57 a month for health care, and it's excellent. I'm so tired of all the lies and b.s. I hear about the system up here in the U.S. media." Finley, a well-known TV and radio host for years in San Francisco, adds, "I now have 20/20 vision thanks to Canadian eye doctors. And I haven't had to wait for my surgeries, either." A Canadian-born doctor wrote a hit piece for Wingnut Central (the Wall Street Journal op-ed page) this week David Gratzer claimed: "Everyone in Canada is covered by a single payer -- the government. But Canadians wait for practically any procedure or diagnostic test or specialist consultation in the public system." Vancouverite Finley: "That's sheer b.s." I heard Gratzer say the same thing on Seattle radio station KIRO this week. Trouble is, it's nonsense. We were always seen promptly by our doctors in Montreal, many of whom spoke both French and English. Today, we live within sight of the Canadian border in Washington state, and still spend lots of time in Canada. Five years ago, while we were on vacation in lovely Nova Scotia, the Canadian government released a long-awaited major report from a federal commission studying the Canadian single-payer system. We were listening to CBC Radio the day the big study came out. The study's conclusion: While the system had flaws, none was so serious it couldn't be fixed. Then the CBC opened the lines to callers across Canada. Here it comes, I thought. The usual talk-show torrent of complaints and anger about the report's findings. I wish Americans could have heard this revealing show. For the next two hours, scores of Canadians called from across that vast country, from Newfoundland to British Columbia. Not one said he or she would change the system. Every single one defended it vigorously. The Greatest Canadian Ever Further proof: Not long ago, the CBC asked Canadians to nominate and then vote for The Greatest Canadian in history. Thousands responded. The winner? Not Wayne Gretzky, as I expected (although the hockey great DID make the Top 10). Not even Alexander Graham Bell, another finalist. The greatest Canadian ever? Tommy Douglas. Who? Tommy Douglas was a Canadian politician - and the father of Canadian universal health care.  

Sandyr9111 --- 17 years ago -

Like to see a ton of interviews done live with the people from other countries and Canada to see how they feel about it. Our healthcare costs are ridiculous but i dont wanna die wtg for a damn appt either. As it is it take a month unless ur child is dying to get into TCH for a specialist. And i have private insurance. 

david --- 17 years ago -

My argument still stands if the healthcare is great why do they come to the u.s for care, please answer that for me. 

sadiesmom --- 17 years ago -

I have friends in Canada and just their personal experiences is enought to scare you. The husband, in his 70's, had to wait 6 months for a hip replacement. Dr told him if somone on the list died, he might be able to move up. The woman, in her 60's, waited almost 2 years for both knees to be replaced. Their daughter, waited months for a MRI opening when they thought she had stomach cancer. Not everyone ends up getting treated. They weigh your age and health against the costs related to treating you. If it costs too much, you're just out of luck. 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

I have friends in Canada and they come here for treatment. They hate hate hate the Canadian insurance. 

ExLady In Blue --- 17 years ago -

I know many Canadians, too, and they aren't bragging about the system. The most you will get out of them is that as long as you just need something minor, you will be okay, but if you need bypass surgery, cancer treatment, something so simple as an MRI, you'd better plan to sit back and wait, and pray, pray, pray that you get treatment before it's too late. 

rEVOLution --- 17 years ago -

My argument still stands if the healthcare is great why do they come to the u.s for care, please answer that for me. I don't think there are any facts to support what people "think" of their health care system. I assume people go to other countries to get certain procedures done that they either can't get in their home country or can't afford in their home country. People from the US travel the world to get procedures done that they can't get done or can't afford here. If their systems were so bad then why would our government be meeting with them to get ideas on how to run their proposed system. Also if you want to find out who has the best health care you might start by looking at the mortality rates in each country. In those countries where the people are living the longest might have the best health care. That might be a flawed way of looking at it but it was a just a thought I had. I could be wrong. 

Wilstar77 --- 17 years ago -

People say Suddenlink Internet sucks. I on the other hand have never had any problems. 

rEVOLution --- 17 years ago -

The only problem I have with government run health care is that I think there is way too much corruption, greed, and pure evil within the government. I don't want the same people who allowed and committed the atrocities that our government does to other countries being in charge of my health care. They drop a bomb on the wrong location killing hundreds of innocent women and children, not once but on several occasions. I don't want these folks anywhere near my families health. I know there is corruption in the our current health care system but I think we would be better off holding those people accountable for their actions, having them replaced and starting fresh with some folks who posses more compassion and less greed. Not allowing our government to give more handouts to illegals at our expense all in the name of "it's better for everybody." 

NoNameNoLastName --- 17 years ago -

at I think there is way too much corruption, greed, and pure evil within the government. I don't want the same people who allowed and committed the atrocities that our government does to other countries being in charge of my health care. And Obama is offering it as an OPTION. If you don't like it, keep your plan. It's as simple as that. I know there is corruption in the our current health care system but I think we would be better off holding those people accountable for their actions, having them replaced and starting fresh with some folks who posses more compassion and less greed. And who will replace them? Bottom line, private health insurance companies have one objective - maximize profits, like any other corporation. This is achieved in two ways - charging as much as possible, and reducing costs (=denying coverage) as much as possible. They all have the same common objective, and they all use the same tactics. Can you blame them? To break this circle you need to do something different. 

david --- 17 years ago -

Nnnln is obama promising that employer sponsored healthcare isnt/will not go away. My fear is that employers will see this as a way of saving $$ where everyone is forced to go to uhc. 

Jean --- 17 years ago -

As it is it take a month unless ur child is dying to get into TCH for a specialist. And i have private insurance. How lucky you are to have only waited a month. I just booked an appt with my daughter at TX Childrens last week the earliest we can get in is Nov. You usually wait 5 months at least for a allergist/immunologist/neurologist appt. That is what we have been seeing. 

Spartacus --- 17 years ago -

To break this circle you need to do something different. Most people like the care that their doctors give them, but are very frustrated with their insurance companies. The whole system is broke. It's good that someone finally has the guts to do something about it. 

lean --- 17 years ago -

I am hoping and praying that Obama sticks to his guns and does something about our healthcare. I never really thought about it until I lost my job and had to start looking for it. And...for all those horror stories you see them roll out about other countries's government health care...there are the same amount of horror stories right here in the US. 

lean --- 17 years ago -

and Yes...there is private health insurance...you do have to list everything medically you have had happen to you in the last 10 years..yes...10 years....and God help you if you take more then 2 maintenance meds...my husband was rejected because he takes bp and cholesteraul...and he was taking something topically...more then 2 and wham you are out. Guess it is better to not takes meds and have a heart attack or stroke 

NoNameNoLastName --- 17 years ago -

Nnnln is obama promising that employer sponsored healthcare isnt/will not go away. My fear is that employers will see this as a way of saving $$ where everyone is forced to go to uhc. If people start to move away from the insurance companies, they will have to get their act together in terms of better coverage, lower costs, and improved services. They will not simply say "oh, well, tough $#!^, let's just go out of business." And if the government plan is crappy as some of you think it will be, companies will continue to offer private insurance as a way to attract talent. This is a big decision factor for many people when they are considering a new job - unless you won the lottery. 

POTUS --- 17 years ago -

Relying on the Government for Health Care = Trusting the Government with your Life. Do you? 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

As it is it take a month unless ur child is dying to get into TCH for a specialist. And i have private insurance. ditto! 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

We git wut we pay for...so if the Government's sellin', I ain't buyin'! 

lean --- 17 years ago -

Relying on the Government for Health Care = Trusting the Government with your Life. Do you? what is your solution then? My husband and I have this disagreement also..he doesnt want the govt involved in health care decisions..fine...then what is your suggestion? There has to be a better way then there is now. And if you think the govt is corrupt..take a good hard look at the insurance companies and pharmaceutical companies. Dont mean to come out fighting but this has hit a nerve with me..esp when I had to pay 100's of dollars for a "next level" antibiotic for my daughter. I had the money...but you know what? I can understand the desperation parents must feel when they are put in a corner having to decide whether to eat or get the medicine...or the elderly who stop taking their pills because they hit the donut hole in the Medicare and they cant afford anymore until next year. I will now get off my soapbox LOL Oh..one more thing..LOL...I still have to wait 3 months to get into see a specialist...and I have private insurance. 

Unichic™ --- 17 years ago -

My argument still stands if the healthcare is great why do they come to the u.s for care, please answer that for me. Who?? Our medical advances and drug research often surpass the US. For instance, I was on beta-blockers and took a drug called betapace (sotalol). It had less of the side-effects of inderal and propranonal. When i moved here to go to college, y'll didn't have it for about 5 more years later. 

Unichic™ --- 17 years ago -

Our healthcare costs are ridiculous but i dont wanna die wtg for a damn appt either. The systemis not perfect, but neither is the US by far. Don't be fooled. The only time I had issues with the CAN healthcare was when I lived in a small town the size of maybe half of cleveland, tx. Maybe even smaller. We were 1.5hrs outside the city of Toronto and we were on a waiting list for a general physician because there weren't any in the small town. We were requested to go to the Town's hospital for care; however, the next town over had opening s and we got in there. It was a 25-30 minute drive. Don't you all drive that when you live out in BFE??? In Toronto, I had absolutely no problems with wait times with doctors. In fact, no longer than any wait in the ER that I have had here - TRUTH! 

david --- 17 years ago -

Uni so your claiming no one comes to the u.s for medical treatment, are you really making that argument? 

lean --- 17 years ago -

My mom is from Europe and I have lived over there and it is amazing to me how you hear about all the horror stories about those poor Canadians/Europeans who are dropping like flies because they cant get medical care...and when you are over there they are looking at us like we are fricken idiots because we are all stressed out about losing healthcare coverage or paying out the nose for it. Oh...and by the way...we ALL are already paying for the uninsured people..one way or another. Its time this all came out from under the rug and on the table and dealt with. I need to burn my soapbox LOL 

lean --- 17 years ago -

Uni so your claiming no one comes to the u.s for medical treatment, are you really making that argument? I believe alot of people do come here for medical care...they also go to Paris...and London...you dont hear about those too much over here. 

lean --- 17 years ago -

As I tell my husband...in no way do I believe this will be the end of Cigna/Aetna/BCBS...but it sure will give them a run for their money wont it? They whine about how they wont be able to compete....I dont believe it for a second. 

Sandyr9111 --- 17 years ago -

My big thing is like RX that here costs $3K a month but u can get it from India for $130 a month? The same exact medication. Somethings very freaking wrong with that. 

lean --- 17 years ago -

My big thing is like RX that here costs $3K a month but u can get it from India for $130 a month? The same exact medication. Somethings very freaking wrong with that. BINGO!! or why is it that the hospital bill for my procedure was $3k but they accepted $130 from the insurance company? Where the heck is that coming from?? Or when I get the bill from the lab...they charge one thing but due to the special discount they offer my insurance company it is 80% less. Great..I am happy for it but are you telling me if I didnt have insurance I should pay the full amt?? 

Unichic™ --- 17 years ago -

Uni so your claiming no one comes to the u.s for medical treatment, are you really making that argument? Not as many as YOU probably think. Listen, when you are dying from some terminal illness and you have the money, you'll travel to other places for so-called "new" advances. Same thing here. Look at Farah Fawcett and several other celebs. She travelled to Germany for so-called "innovative" care. 

Unichic™ --- 17 years ago -

My big thing is like RX that here costs $3K a month but u can get it from India for $130 a month? The same exact medication. I Totally AGREE!!!! I sometimes order overseas. Oh and in case anyone wants my overseas connection (I had someone PM me asking), it's www.medicapharma.com. I have also used another one for renova cream and i think I paid $20/ tube instead of $85 or whatever the heck it was. Mine was made in france or packaged there at least. 

lean --- 17 years ago -

Dont get me wrong...I think the quality of care in the US is great...but there are horror stories over here..just like there are over there. There has to be some middle ground where there can be a safety net to catch you. I personally think there is a huge weight on people's shoulders regarding this issue...staying in a job you dont like because you have a family member who is sick...deathly afraid of losing your job because that means goodbye health insurance. And..nobody seems to talk about the burden of providing health insurance to employees...especially for smaller companies. If you think about it...you have a company with 100 employees...the full premium cost to the insurance company is lets say $600 ...if the company pays 60% of that they have a monthly bill of 36k...yes they get to write that off but it is still money out the door in the meantime. **and if my math is wrong pls feel free to correct me LOL 

Unichic™ --- 17 years ago -

Dont get me wrong...I think the quality of care in the US is great...but there are horror stories over here..just like there are over there. Yes, yes and yes! I am not putting down the US healthcare, but please don't put down the Canadian healthcare either. We are just as intelligent and advanced as the US, hands down. The two "systems" have issues. I wish we could do sliding scale insurance. Kind of a compromise between the two? 

Polly Ester --- 17 years ago -

Here it the deal for me. Every single one of us knows people with no insurance. The numbers are getting higher. Some are poor, some are unemployed, and a whole bunch of them don't have their priorities on straight. They get free. subsidized, or reduced fee medical care. Who is paying for that?? Why are our insurance premiums so high? Yeah, some of it is unregulated and greedy drug companies. But I would say most of it is because we are paying for everyone's medical care that isn't insured. To be honest, I'm bitter about it. I can barely make ends meet and a work a couple of jobs, but I pay insurance. I've never been sick and I'm under 30..but my rates through one of my employers is still a huge percentage of my paycheck. I think it would be fairer to see across the board medical care. 

lean --- 17 years ago -

Polly...I couldnt agree more. 

-Ray --- 17 years ago -

It is NOT about ANYBODY's healthcare, it IS all about power and the ability to control the masses...these 'people' don't give a rats a ss whether you live or die....if you are over 65 they really want you to die... this just crossed the line from dumb idea to fascism. "Democrats in the House and Senate are crafting legislation that would REQUIRE all Americans to have health insurance, prohibit insurers from refusing to cover pre-existing conditions and place other restrictions on the industry. " http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601087&sid=aqLNecbH0dcg In other words, material benefit or workability should not be the only criteria for judging an idea. The cost to freedom should be considered first and foremost. If the government can make me rich at the price of some liberty, I damn better be allowed to reject that trade. Alas, we still have the 2d Amendment. 

Unichic™ --- 17 years ago -

It is NOT about ANYBODY's healthcare, it IS all about power and the ability to control the masses...these 'people' don't give a rats a ss whether you live or die....if you are over 65 they really want you to die... this just crossed the line from dumb idea to fascism. I don't see this at all Ray. In fact, if you look at statistics, Canadians (with socialized healthcare) live healthier and longer than Americans - FACT! Why do you think that is? I know why, because Canadians have the ability to go to the doctor when something arises insteading of waiting because they can't afford the bill or the ungodly deductibles. My family has to pay nearly a $3000 deductible on top of our $600+/month for for family insurance. THAT is highway robbery. I have health issues that require labwork several times per year and I forgo it because I don't want to pay the ridiculous deductible. Something is NOT bloody right with that. So you tell me what is wonderful about the American healthcare system. Would you? I paid this amount even two years ago when our family income was under $40K. All our hard earned money was going to insurance to protect us, but I couldn't even afford haircuts for the family - I cut our hair. I had to shop the Good Will and 2nd hand places and sell crap on ebay and the KYS just to get by. I couldn't even send my kid to preschool and yet I made too much to qualify for subsidized preschool. Tell ME that is not frickin' ridiculous and if it's not, then I'll be a rats azz. The only people I see b!tchin' and moaning about this are the people who are comfortable or well-to-do getting pissy. What about those that work their azzes off and can't afford healthcare in the end? The people who make too much, but not enough to pay for health insurance and therefore don't qualify for govt help with healthcare. 

clockwatcher. --- 17 years ago -

My husband's bosses are Canadian as well as coworkers as well as those working in the Toronto office...They have stated that would choose American health care (at this point) well over the socialized medicine in Canada. They use the waiting list to ration health care. The elderly and feeble will never make the list. Another issue is priority of medicine. Canadian health care view cataract surgery as elective surgery!! That's crazy!!! 

JohnLynch --- 17 years ago -

Wait times for surgery, medical treatments at all-time high: report by staff writer, October 15, 2007 CBC News (Canada) The average wait time for a Canadian awaiting surgery or other medical treatment is now 18.3 weeks, a new high, according to a report released Monday. That's an increase of 97 per cent over 14 years, the report says. "Canadians wait longer than Americans, Germans, and Swedes for cardiac care, although not as long as New Zealanders or the British," it reads. "Economists attempting to quantify the cost of this waiting time have estimated it to amount to $1,100 to $5,600 annually per patient." The report, the 17th annual edition of Waiting Your Turn: Hospital Waiting Lists in Canada, is published by the Fraser Institute, an independent Canadian research organization. 

freshhell --- 17 years ago -

The US is just about dead last in health care for the civilized world. I pay around $2000 a month for individual health insurance plus copays. Since I have no income, this is a big hardship for me. Luckily I don't have cancer or heart disease or diabetes. Yet. I know that if I do, my insurance will find some obscure reason to cancel my coverage. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

polly ditto!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 

page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

politics


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground