Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

My 3rd graders spelling words...

who's talking here?

planemom 1
ambergris 1
qpc 1
Deltadawn 1
goots1 1
*Jenn* 1
justcat 5

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

justcat --- 17 years ago -

Ok.So around Christmas, my third grader (and his class) were given a spelling aptitude test. Apparently he did well.. They were placed into groups, depending on their skill. There are 5 , between two classes in his group. Now.I am not complaining. Not really…This is what we wanted from public school, for him to be challenged. And to a degree he is.. But I just wonder if this is not hurting him more than it is helping him. I say this because. A) he is not really memorizing the words, other than the definitions he has to do for homework during the week. The words are really to complex for him to retain their meaning. B) being that he wont have the opportunity to use the words, I am not sure he will retain the spelling of them either. Now, they use a good system, because they are root or base words, and then derivatives..So, that helps them learn to spell them. Anyway.. Your thoughts on if this is helping him or not ?? Last weeks words, and he made a 100.. (crat) plutocrat, democrat, technocrat, autocrat, (cracy) autocracy, aristocracy, bureaucracy, democracy, plutocracy (arch) matriarch, oligarch, anarchist, monarch, hierarchical. (archy) anarchy, patriarchy, oligarchy, hierarchy, matriarchy, This week. in no random order, they are not sorted yet lol Polysyllabic, equitable, polysemous, equatorial, polymath, equanimity, polygon, omnidirectional, (which word perfect says should be two words ??) Macroscopic, magnification , macroeconomics, polyglot, magnificent, magnitude, equation, omnivore, omniscient, polytechnic, equilateral, equivalent, omnipotent. 

ambergris --- 17 years ago -

. B) being that he wont have the opportunity to use the words, I am not sure he will retain the spelling of them either. I think I'd agree. I've probably only needed to spell about 5 of those words in the last 20 years. I would rather they learn (in 3rd grade) words that they are actually using and that will be in the books they are using. It is good they are challenging him but is this really the only way to challenge them? 

*Jenn* --- 17 years ago -

wow my dd is in 3rd grade and does not have those kind of spelling words. 

justcat --- 17 years ago -

I know..He has made at least a 98 or above on all the tests,which include writing the meaning of the root word... But I went back and tested him on a couple of the words from past weeks..and he was not perfect on them...makes me wonder.. 

justcat --- 17 years ago -

No..my 4th grader niece,does not have words that hard :) 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

If he can already spell well then these words will help him exercise his brain. Would you rather have him have spelling tests on words that he can spell or words like this that will challenge him? He may not use many of the them until later in life but think how much easier his classes will be because he has already been exposed to so many words. 

goots1 --- 17 years ago -

Sounds to me like your son is lucky that he has a teacher that challenges her or his students. This is a good thing IMO. 

justcat --- 17 years ago -

To the above to posts..Those are my exact thoughts.At least,when we first started the program...And it has blown me away,that for the most part,it has been very easy for him.I was pretty surprised however,when upon review,he does not seem to be retaining what he is learning,and hoping that it is not a lesson in futility,at my childs expense... And,I wonder where he will end up next year..From what I see..the fourth grade is not doing this...Maybe they will next year.. I really needed to talk with his teacher more,but it just kind of happened..and we were not even aware of it or why at first..I am interested in knowing if this is something they came up with (I dont know if all the 3rd grade is involved) or if its something that is their regular curriculum.. Again..I am thrilled that he is being challenged..Just pondering the long term effects.. My child is no genius...He is a great reader,and over all good student..But..is not in GT..(scored 2 points 2 low). I am not stressing over this in anyway...Just keeping an eye on my boy lol 

Deltadawn --- 17 years ago -

These words are good brain exercises, he will need reinforcement of some sort in order to retain the knowledge gained. Word games, discussions on history and current events with family trying to add those words to the family vocabulary instead of just his, would help him. It would be a shame for him to just lose all this newly obtained knowledge. 

justcat --- 17 years ago -

Good idea Delta..I am going to save the tests,and review over the summer..And I guess go look for a book,or just come up with words on my own for the summer.. 

qpc --- 17 years ago -

cathou1....your third grader is at Timbers, right? My daughter has the same words. I wish my oldest (in 5th grade) had gone through the same program. She breezes through spelling tests, and these words probably wouldn't even challenge her, but I like that fact that it is teaching rules for spelling...some of the rules are even a little obscure. If my oldest dd had gone through it, it would have helped her with the spelling B when she gets weird words :) 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground