Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Rebel Flag

who's talking here?

freshhell 3
randyjet 5
Mabbers 3
♥Connie♥ 2
greengirl 2
~sassy~ 10
Dark_Side 1
CoralReef 3
momof5 10
wildflower 1
MxMike 5
txmomx5 1
Agent of Change 1
Allimama 4
Big Ben 6
♥kerry♥ 2
N.S. Sherlock 1
Shenanigans 5
Megan 1
Kemical_Ali 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Megan --- 17 years ago -

What is everyone's thoughts on it? I'm curious to know 

Mabbers --- 17 years ago -

Redneck. LOL. 

Allimama --- 17 years ago -

Definitely tied to slavery. Stop flying it. 

Dark_Side --- 17 years ago -

Offensive for it's racist association. 

momof5 --- 17 years ago -

It represents a really ugly time in our history, why anyone is proud of that, is beyond me. 

wildflower --- 17 years ago -

Historical and it maybe a little redneck but it should still be able to fly. 

freshhell --- 17 years ago -

My sons were born and raised in Texas. They will have nothing to do with any person or business that displays the rebel flag. I am less observant, but I do find it offensive. 

Allimama --- 17 years ago -

I think that it represents the idea that man can own man--which is absolutely evil. I've never understood the arguments that it does not--but perhaps someone could illuminate me. 

♥kerry♥ --- 17 years ago -

redneck and racist...whether that is what someone intended or not, that is what I think when I see it. 

Shenanigans --- 17 years ago -

I think you're all off but I'm not gonna tell you how to interpret symbols. My mother's side of the family is from Mississippi. None of them ever owned slaves or condoned slavery. The flag to them represents a southern pride type patriotism. They are proud of southern heritage, traditions, grit and beliefs that come with being from the south. I would love to see the reaction one would get from my mom/uncles/grandparents etc to say the only thing the south has ever represented was slavery. To say that is a slap in their face (b/c once again they never owned slaves) and an insult to their upbringing. Edited to add: They are not redneck, do not attend white capped meetings or drive trucks with huge tires and lots of tacky stickers. Unfortunately the flag has been used by that stereotype to the point it is now a joke. 

freshhell --- 17 years ago -

It doesn't matter if you were not from a family that was wealthy enough to own slaves. If they were willing to kill for the privilege, I don't think that's anything to be proud of. The Rebel flag has nothing to do with pride. It has to do with arrogance. 

momof5 --- 17 years ago -

The flag to them represents a southern pride type patriotism. They are proud of southern heritage, traditions, grit and beliefs that come with being from the south. I'm not southern, so I can't relate to those sentiments. The civil war was mainly about abolishing slavery, the rebel flag represented those that wanted to KEEP slavery intact. How can anyone feel "pride" in that? 

Shenanigans --- 17 years ago -

The Rebel flag has nothing to do with pride. It has to do with arrogance. Are you from the south? Also the Civil War was about more that slavery. 

Shenanigans --- 17 years ago -

I'm not southern, so I can't relate to those sentiments. That's a good attitude to have about it. Don't judge unless you TRULY understand the other side. 

momof5 --- 17 years ago -

Also the Civil War was about more that slavery. slavery was the main focus. Those that fought, fought knowing they were protecting their RIGHT to OWN SLAVES. Waving that rebel flag is an outward expression that you believe they were right. 

greengirl --- 17 years ago -

Redneck. LOL. Definitely tied to slavery. Stop flying it. Offensive for it's racist association. It represents a really ugly time in our history, why anyone is proud of that, is beyond me. I think that it represents the idea that man can own man--which is absolutely evil. I've never understood the arguments that it does not-- redneck and racist...whether that is what someone intended or not, that is what I think when I see it. Yep, to all the above.  

Allimama --- 17 years ago -

My family is also from Mississippi. I was raised in the South as well. However, the rebel flag represented the secession of the south from the union over the right to own slaves--I'm not sure what other symbol it could represent. 

♥kerry♥ --- 17 years ago -

I'm from the South, but it doesn't instill any pride in me. Like I said in my post above, if I see it on the back of a truck or in a yard..I think "redneck racist"..I'm not saying that is true since I don't know what stranger's attitudes are, it is just my perception of them. That is what the poster asked--what do we think about it. That is my honest answer regarding my opinion of it. 

greengirl --- 17 years ago -

I'm from the South, but it doesn't instill any pride in me. ...if I see it on the back of a truck or in a yard..I think redneck racist..I'm not saying that is true since I don't know what strangers think, it is just my perception of them. again, "yep", same here. :) 

CoralReef --- 17 years ago -

I'm from the South, but it doesn't instill any pride in me. I'm from Florida, and every Southerner knows it is a racist redneck symbol. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

Being from the south, the "deep" south, I was taught this flag stands for Southern Pride, however, like the following cut and paste says, over time that has changed. My mil is the daughter of an Alabama cotton Farmer, she is a member of the UDC and the DAR. A kinder, gentler woman does not exist. There is not a racist bone in this woman's body but she holds this flag near and dear to her heart. It's meaning for her is pride in her heritage and her roots. There were actually four so-called Confederate flags. The familiar one was the battle flag of the Confederate army, the other three simply represented the Confederacy at different points in time. Its original purpose was to identify the Confederacy because they wanted to secede from the Union. Although slavery was a major issue during the Civil War, the South fought for their right to secede from the Union, "they weren't fighting to keep the slaves". They wanted to keep the slaves because they had a major impact on the production of cotton. A lot of people think the Confederate flag is racist because a lot of hate groups have used it as their flag but its original purpose was simply the flag of the Confederacy. But, like many other things in history, its meaning has changed over time. The south uses it as a symbol of pride. 

Mabbers --- 17 years ago -

I've never been anything other than Southern, and it does NOT carry a positive connotation. 

Shenanigans --- 17 years ago -

I've never been anything other than Southern, and it does NOT carry a positive connotation. That's fine. I'm just stating how I feel about it. Don't have one on the back of my car, but I don't write people off as racist if they do. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

and it does NOT carry a positive connotation. Not for you, nor for me, for that matter, as I too have come to see it as something negative but not everyone does, and not everyone who see's it as something good is racist. ;D 

momof5 --- 17 years ago -

Although slavery was a major issue during the Civil War, the South fought for their right to secede from the Union, "they weren't fighting to keep the slaves". They wanted to keep the slaves because they had a major impact on the production of cotton. These two sentences contradict each other completely. They didn't NEED to keep slaves, they could have hired workers like we do today. Again, the MAIN FOCUS of the civil war was the protection of THEIR RIGHT to own slaves. No amount of "southern pride" spin, can change that. Owning another human being is vile, regardless of the race of that person. And that flag represents JUST THAT. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

Like I said in my post above, if I see it on the back of a truck or in a yard..I think "redneck racist".. Here too 

♥Connie♥ --- 17 years ago -

Hmmm - I've never understood the big hoopla over the Rebel Flag. To me - as far as I understood it and remember from grade school history classes - the Rebel Flag was supposed to represent the South. You know as in the North versus South Civil War? Other than that I think it has gotten a bad rap as being representative of slavery since the Civil War was about more than just slavery. Here's what I was taught about the Rebel Flag: The first official flag of the confederacy was the Stars and Bars, and was reported to the provisional congress of the C.S. by the flag committee on March 4,1861. It appears to have not had a recorded vote. It was written into the journal of the congress. It is said to have been designed by Nicola Marschall, a Prussian Artist and to have been inspired by the Austrian flag. It appears in many variations with stars ranging from 7 to 15 stars. 11 states that seceded from the Union, 2 (Kentucky and Missouri that had confederate and union governments), 1 (Maryland) that attempted to secede but whose legislature was disbanded by federal officials and was unable to join the confederacy, even though it furnished more troops to the cause then at least one member of that country and 1 slave state (Delaware) that remained loyal to the union. 

Mabbers --- 17 years ago -

I don't write people off as racist if they do. I don't either. But I can't seem to dismiss the eye-rolling when I DO see one. LOL. 

Shenanigans --- 17 years ago -

good post connie 

N.S. Sherlock --- 17 years ago -

I too am from the "deep south". I have great Southern pride..after all, we have the best food, lol. I have some hillbilly relatives that proudly have it plastered all over their trucks and flying off their porch...and yes, they are redneck racists. They know full well what it represents, even though they deny it. I can not imagine that anyone that did not hold those sentiments would display it knowing that it represents those views to so many. 

CoralReef --- 17 years ago -

There were actually four so-called Confederate flags. From there on down, copied and pasted from yahoo answers. Nice going Sassy. You might consider giving credit to the original author. http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20090217161258AAGCwbj 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

Owning another human being is vile, Absolutely true regardless of the race of that person. And that flag represents JUST THAT. Not for everyone. My mil is angry that it's meaning has become what it has, because initially it was anything BUT. And so for her, she see's it as something entirely unrelated to slavery. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

Copied and pasted from yahoo answers. Nice going Sassy. Sorry you have a problem with my research style. Would you have rather I went to the library? 

CoralReef --- 17 years ago -

Sorry you have a problem with my research style. Dishonesty, i.e., stealing other people's work, is a problem. 

momof5 --- 17 years ago -

My mil is angry that it's meaning has become what it has, because initially it was anything BUT. And so for her, she see's it as something entirely unrelated to slavery. I can somewhat understand that in older generations. They were raised in a whole different world and mentality when it comes to things like the rebel flag. HOWEVER... Those proudly displaying them now are much younger...anyone 50 years old and younger, knows EXACTLY what it "represents" in this day and age. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

To me - as far as I understood it and remember from grade school history classes - the Rebel Flag was supposed to represent the South. You know as in the North versus South Civil War? Other than that I think it has gotten a bad rap as being representative of slavery since the Civil War was about more than just slavery. Anyone who believes otherswise needs a history lesson. I happen to think of red neck racist when I see it displayed BUT I also am aware that for some, this flag DOES NOT hold racist sentiments for them, and to say it must is just stupid. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

Dishonesty, i.e., stealing other people's work, is a problem. Pay attention! I said it was A CUT AND PASTE. Now go look up the defination of stupidity.... 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

Historical and it maybe a little redneck but it should still be able to fly. I am more in agreement with this. It is way past the events of that time. I would have been against it just after the war, and would have SHOT any person showing it. The fact is that it is part of our history, and I have no problem now with flying it over battlefields, Confederate buildings, and the like. I can care less what somebody chooses to fly on their own turf, though, I would not patronize their business since it is meant as a racist statement. Other than as something like Six Flags of which one is the Confederate Flag. I don't think it is appropriate for it to be flown over state government buildings unless it has a direct and continuing connection to the Confederarcy. The museum of the Confederacy in VA should certainly fly it for example. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

I can somewhat understand that in older generations. They were raised in a whole different world and mentality when it comes to things like the rebel flag. And I agree, as I too have come to see it as a racist thing. But for my mil, in her late 70's, it's very much a banner of pride for her. 

Allimama --- 17 years ago -

Omg, get off your high horse coral reef. She looked it up to make sure that she got it right, she didn't turn it in as a term paper. If we're really going to start claiming plagiarism on here, then every talking point of the libs would be in question. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground