Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

College saving advice?

who's talking here?

Zionist NightOwl 1
KWPlanner 1
"AmysAngels" 1
PeauxBoy 1
jtcitrus 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

jtcitrus --- 17 years ago -

Hey, I'm going to be a father soon, and like most of us, I'm doing financial stuff. So as I understand it: it's better to fully fund a Roth IRA before you put anything into a 529 savings plan, because you can take money out penalty free for education expenses after 5 years. 

jtcitrus --- 17 years ago -

So, does that sound accurate? Any Advice? 

PeauxBoy --- 17 years ago -

As I understand it, you can withdraw as much as you want penalty free to fund education expenses. However, you can only pull out the amount contributed tax free. Let's say you contribute $20,000 and the account grows another $10,000 through appreciation of the underlying shares. You can withdraw the $20K and pay no taxes, but the remaining $10K will be taxed. Hope that helps and I invite anyone to add to or correct anything that I may have written. 

Zionist NightOwl --- 17 years ago -

Yes, basically, but it depends on the individual's circumstances. I'm not a financial adviser, but my understanding is that Roth contributions can be withdrawn w/o penalty or taxes, but the earnings portion is only tax-free after age 59½ and after 5 yrs. Earnings that come out before age 59½ are taxable even when used for college expenses, although no penalty is incurred. I think the biggest disadvantage of Roth IRA's for education expenses is that the annual distribution (contributions + earnings) is counted toward income when determining the parents' contributions for financial aid eligibility. The 529 plan distributions don't. So if you're intending to apply for financial aid at all, (and just about everyone needs to these days), the Roth IRA distribution can cost a lot in missed financial aid. Here are a couple of good articles, along with a chart I found, summarizing college funding vehicles: 529 beats Roth IRA for college savings Extreme College Funding Chart (actually a link from the above article): College Funding Vehicle Comparison I'm going to be a father soon Congratulations! 

jtcitrus --- 17 years ago -

Congratulations Thanks Zionist! 

"AmysAngels" --- 17 years ago -

Hey, I'm going to be a father soon, and like most of us, I'm doing financial stuff. Congratulations!! So as I understand it: it's better to fully fund a Roth IRA before you put anything into a 529 savings plan, because you can take money out penalty free for education expenses after 5 years. JDB on here is my financial guru. He has both of my girls set up on a college savings plan and it comes out of our bank account every month, like a bill! He has always given great advice and we have always followed it. (If my girls don't have any money for college after all this, I hope JDB can pay their way.) LOL 

KWPlanner --- 17 years ago -

I would typically recommend using 529 plans for college savings. For one thing, the contribution limits for 529s are much higher, and anyone can contribute to it. Not sure if this is applicable to you or not, jtcitrus, but there are also income limitations in place which may make you ineligible to make Roth contributions; there are no income constraints for 529 plans. Obviously there are numerous other factors that should be considered when determining the best way to save and how much to save for funding a college education. And with the hundreds of 529 plans out there, it would behoove you at least consult a financial advisor such as myself or jdb. I have a writeup I did last year on the various college savings options available. If you would like a copy of it just shoot me a PM with your email and I'll be more than happy to send it to you. It focuses primarily on 529 plans, with five state plans I recommmend to clients, but also discusses grants, loans, and other savings vehicles one can use for college savings. By the way, jtcitrus, congrats on the upcoming fatherhood! Don't blink....they'll be out of college before you realize it. lol 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground