Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

The Right Age to Spank?

who's talking here?

outermaga 2
GCan 20
Denise C 1
Fiona 3
Fallon 14
QueenCassie 1
sunshine1881 14
likeke27 2
Sarah75 25
cowboyswife 7
My2Texans 2
gumbeauxgirl 2
Mygirl01 1
Mabbers 6
Momsterof2 2
HsMommy 7
christina 7
RX8LVR 1
ExLady In Blue 3
Unichic™ 4
PutOnYourBigGirlPanties 20
ladybughomeschool 2
PHSMOMOF2 12
Nickie 6
♥kerry♥ 3
MomofTwins* 3
Niki 1
BarbWire 9
jamie 57

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

jamie --- 17 years ago -

Someone on here just said that I should spank my 13 mth old for pouring out GOLDFISH CRACKERS and stomping on them. I feel that is too young to spank. I do lightly slap her had if she is trying to reach for something hot...etc. But I mostly do timeout with her What is your opinion? 

cowboyswife --- 17 years ago -

I really was not paying attention to her age. Get a life... 

jamie --- 17 years ago -

I am asking for advice...sooner or later she will be old enough. 

Fallon --- 17 years ago -

You can pop a bottom without killing a child. 

cowboyswife --- 17 years ago -

exactly Fallon. 

PHSMOMOF2 --- 17 years ago -

You can pop her little bottom or her thighs when she does something wrong. 

QueenCassie --- 17 years ago -

Spanking doesn't mean you have to beat them. You can pop them on the fanny enough to get their attention without actually hurting them. When they are old enough to be defiant, disrespectful,throw fits,etc- they are old enough to be disciplined. jmo 

Mygirl01 --- 17 years ago -

Not that I want to be jumped on for my opinion, but spanking is not the way to disipline a child for most normal childhood offenses. On rare occassions, you may have to resort to it, but I wouldn't hit my child for such a minor offense. 

Sarah75 --- 17 years ago -

I am asking for advice...sooner or later she will be old enough. i thought you had an older child? what worked for you/him? discipline techniques are not cross the board for every child/parent. what works for one may not work for another. 

jamie --- 17 years ago -

Sarah75 my older child was constantly getting into trouble as a toddler, but I think I started spanking him about 2 years old. She is typically a great baby...except when she doesnt get her nap 

PHSMOMOF2 --- 17 years ago -

You have to set guidelines.. even at one they will test you. You should not allow her to have total control and let her walk all over you. She has to know you are the parent. What you may think is cute now, it will not be cute in a few years then in hindsight you will look back and be like damn I should of stopped that so pick your poison. 

Mabbers --- 17 years ago -

Everyone around here laughs at my spanks unless in devil mode. So yeah, a spanking can mean a gazillions different points on the Richter scale. A 13-mo is probably not needing more than micro...hardly felt at all. Devil mode can rise to epic proportions. 

jamie --- 17 years ago -

I feel that it was a minor offense, because she typically doesnt do stuff like that...she did get a timeout. I gave her a minute and a half. 

GCan --- 17 years ago -

That's an individual decision and often is determined by the way you were brought up, your parenting style, etc. Some people flat out do not believe in spanking regardless of the infraction. For me, it depends on the age and severity. When my kids were toddlers and touched something they weren't suppose to, I'd slap their hands. If they threw a temper tantrum, I'd pop a bottom. They're under 10 right now and will be spanked for willful disobedience. I don't think I'd spank at 13 months for messing with the goldfish. She's probably thinking of it more as a game rather than making things tough on mom. 

Fiona --- 17 years ago -

A firm no and a swat on the fanny aka big padded diaper wouldn't hurt. At 13 months she has to start learning that you mean business. Trust me correct it while they are young I have a 11 yr old you can visit my house and see what laxed parenting gets you. (I went through the whole I don't want to spank stage and it didn't work out) Yeah crunching goldfish is a minor offense but if you start now she will know what behavior is expected and you will probably spank less in the long run. 

Nickie --- 17 years ago -

my dd is 14 months old and i pop her on her bottom or her thighs when she does something she's not supposed to. no way would she comprehend that i'm sticking her in "time out". she would prob think that's just a game i'm playing with her. 

outermaga --- 17 years ago -

By 13 months I was giving my dd a swat on the bottom. They do have a diaper on so it isn't like you are going to hurt her.. you just do it hard enough to get a point across. 

Denise C --- 17 years ago -

Not that I want to be jumped on for my opinion, but spanking is not the way to disipline a child for most normal childhood offenses. On rare occassions, you may have to resort to it, but I wouldn't hit my child for such a minor offense. I agree 100%. She learned something new. She was experimenting. Learning new sounds and feelings. I would not have spanked mine for this nor have I ever spanked for minor things. They are 8 and 11 and have maybe been spanked twice. Both for deliberately disobeying. Out of control? No. Undisciplined? No. They are great kids and well behaved. Teachers to neighbors to friends parents ALWAYS tell me how good they are and shocked when I tell them they do act up sometimes. 

Sarah75 --- 17 years ago -

By 13 months I was giving my dd a swat on the bottom. They do have a diaper on so it isn't like you are going to hurt her.. you just do it hard enough to get a point across. i was also, but i didn't have a 13 month old that was wearing 3 month clothes. (sorry, i still can't get over how tiny she is!!!!) 

PHSMOMOF2 --- 17 years ago -

Wow 3month old clothes, damn girl are you feeding that child? Sh@t my son was weighing at least 25 pounds at that age. I made sure he ate real food by then, he was healthy and ate ice cream, mash potatoes, spaghetti, rice, bananas, oatmeal, corn meal, nuggets , french fries. 

Sarah75 --- 17 years ago -

Wow 3month old clothes, damn girl are you feeding that child? Sh@t my son was weighing at least 25 pounds at that age. that's what i was thinking. i commented that my boys were about in 2t by that age....they were active, healthy, and growing ;) 

BarbWire --- 17 years ago -

I never hit any of my children and they all turned out fine. I spoke to them about their actions and explained right from wrong. Children are meant to be loved not physically abused. Yes, raising a hand to them in any fashion is abusive. 

Mabbers --- 17 years ago -

So I'm assuming it's your job to visit every thread and put a few people down Miss Barbed Wire? Your name sounds a little rough around the edges. Cute juxtaposition. 

sunshine1881 --- 17 years ago -

I never hit any of my children and they all turned out fine. I spoke to them about their actions and explained right from wrong. Children are meant to be loved not physically abused. Yes, raising a hand to them in any fashion is abusive. You're blessed then that you didn't have a hellion. My first was great, and I very seldom had to get on to him at all. My DD is a different story. You give that child and inch, and she'll take a mile. I assure you, she is FAR from abused, but she does get her bottom swatted after all else has failed. 

Sarah75 --- 17 years ago -

Children are meant to be loved not physically abused. Yes, raising a hand to them in any fashion is abusive. after the other thread, i'm thinking that i may try duct tape and WD40. does that count? (i'm gonna have to put some thought into how to utilize the WD40 though ;)). 

Fiona --- 17 years ago -

I never hit any of my children and they all turned out fine. I spoke to them about their actions and explained right from wrong. Children are meant to be loved not physically abused. Yes, raising a hand to them in any fashion is abusive. that shiz is to funny...LOL thanks I needed that now wake up your dreaming physically abused for spanking them 

sunshine1881 --- 17 years ago -

Redneck Daycare Pictures, Images and Photos 

GCan --- 17 years ago -

I never hit any of my children and they all turned out fine. And I was spanked as a child and turned out fine as well. 

Nickie --- 17 years ago -

I never hit any of my children and they all turned out fine. I spoke to them about their actions and explained right from wrong. Children are meant to be loved not physically abused. Yes, raising a hand to them in any fashion is abusive. wow. you took spanking to discipline and totally ran with it, dressed it up and called it abuse. get your facts straight. 

PutOnYourBigGirlPanties --- 17 years ago -

 

Nickie --- 17 years ago -

And I was spanked as a child and turned out fine as well. me too. i learned my lesson. 

Sarah75 --- 17 years ago -

LOL SunShine1881! i wouldn't have messed up my paint, but at least the duck ended up duct taped also ;P 

outermaga --- 17 years ago -

Spare the rod, spoil the child. Sometimes a kid needs a pop on the butt.. sometimes a good talking to will do the job. That is JMO. 

Momsterof2 --- 17 years ago -

It think it depends on the kid, DD is 9 and spanking as never worked with her you could beat her and it would just make her mad taking things and privlages away works for her now my DS (8) all you have to do is pop his butt and he is in line at 13 months a swat on the behind can be just the trick to get their attention as they dont understand the concept of taking things away 

likeke27 --- 17 years ago -

Sometimes a kid needs a pop on the butt.. sometimes a good talking to will do the job. That is JMO. ditto 

BarbWire --- 17 years ago -

So I'm assuming it's your job to visit every thread and put a few people down Miss Barbed Wire? I just stated my opinion that I do not agree with hitting a child for any reason. Guilty conscience? LOL You're the one making personal attacks with " Your name sounds a little rough around the edges. Cute juxtaposition." I was talking generally. 

jamie --- 17 years ago -

17 lbs and 27 inches tall. She eats formula & table foods-what we eat our Gerber Graduates. I can say this... she will only take a 4 oz bottle. I try to give her 8 oz bottles at nap & bed time....but she only drinks 1/2. I am only 4'11''. When I was like 18 mths old I was in a pagaent with girls a foot taller than me (0-18mths age group). I was a runt too. I've only put her in one pageant at 2 weeks...I didnt want her to grow up to be vain. How do I add...a pic on here? 

Sarah75 --- 17 years ago -

i will post this here, even though i posted it on the other thread....... i was just thinking....is it a medical/birth issue that she is only wearing 3 month clothes at 13 months? if so, i would think twice about how you would discipline her. jmo. 

jamie --- 17 years ago -

At this rate I think I should keep her on the formula until she is 2....or doesnt like the taste. 

likeke27 --- 17 years ago -

How do I add...a pic on here? please don't!!! it's disgusting and you will make some pedophile extremely happy 

page 1 2 3 4 5 6
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...

advice


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground