Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Was Jesus the only child bore to Mary? And did she have "relations" with Joseph?

who's talking here?

Julmummy 1
RRay 1
BrookleighPhotography 1
Syrah1214 4
Angela 9
Flopsy Bunny Boutique 1
justforfun 1
JUNIPER 1
Catgirl Loves Animal_Control 6
KwdFoodie 1
Ogre1 1
AGME98 1
bucko 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Syrah1214 --- 17 years ago -

Thanks to anyone who knows. 

bucko --- 17 years ago -

dont know, what does the bible say? 

Angela --- 17 years ago -

No he had brothers and sisters that followed. 

Syrah1214 --- 17 years ago -

really? I always thought Mary was pure from start to finish and although married to Joseph, I was always under the impression that he never had relations with her because her womb was the one who held Jesus. 

Catgirl Loves Animal_Control --- 17 years ago -

Joseph had other children from his 1st wife than after Jesus him and Mary (his 2nd wife) had more children. 

BrookleighPhotography --- 17 years ago -

I thought he only had one brother. 

bucko --- 17 years ago -

I was always under the impression that he never had relations with her so you think just because she carried Jesus Joseph never had sex with Mary? please 

Angela --- 17 years ago -

Sorry. That is not the case. You can look it up if you like. On separate occasions the Bible states that his mother and brothers were waiting for him. 

Catgirl Loves Animal_Control --- 17 years ago -

You can look it up if you like. On separate occasions the Bible states that his mother and brothers were waiting for him. He also had sisters. 

KwdFoodie --- 17 years ago -

So Mary wasn't a virgin. Shocking. 

Angela --- 17 years ago -

Mary was Joseph's first wife. 

bucko --- 17 years ago -

And Mary wasn't a virgin. how do you know that? 

Angela --- 17 years ago -

No he had brothers and sisters that followed. I said that earlier. Also one of his brothers name was James. I remember that for sure. 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

Did Mary give birth to other children after Jesus was born? The Bible is very specific in saying that Mary, the mother of Jesus, did have other children after Jesus was born. The Bible says that Jesus was her FIRSTBORN and Joseph did not know her intimately UNTIL she gave birth to Jesus. The Bible does not say that she remained a virgin, nor does the Bible say that Jesus was her only child. This teaching that suggests that Mary remained a virgin is antibiblical. Mary did not remain a virgin. This is for certain. For a woman to remain a virgin while being married to her husband would be considered a sin by God's standards. God created marriage. The two become one flesh and the bed is undefiled in marriage. Mary and Joseph were married in every sense of the word. Joseph took Mary to be his wife, not a roommate. Had she remained a virgin her entire married life, this would have been very dysfunctional. It would have displeased her husband and the Lord. 

RRay --- 17 years ago -

and the point is what? 

Syrah1214 --- 17 years ago -

Are Catholic teachings different? 

Angela --- 17 years ago -

yep Catholics believe that she was a virgin until she dies. But in the Bible it says that "Joseph did not know her until after Jesus was born" Mat 1:25 

Syrah1214 --- 17 years ago -

and the point is what? To me? I was just wondering. I don't know... 

Catgirl Loves Animal_Control --- 17 years ago -

Mary was Joseph's first wife. Mary was very young when she married the much older man Joseph. Jesus has older siblins - must have been from Joseph do to a previous marriage. 

Angela --- 17 years ago -

There is no scriptural record of Joseph being a widower. However both Eastern Orthodox tradition as well as the Eastern Catholic tradition tell us that he was. Depending on what you believe, which I believe what the Bible tells me. 

Flopsy Bunny Boutique --- 17 years ago -

Is not this the carpenter, the son of Mary, the brother of James, and Joses, and of Juda, and Simon? and are not his sisters here with us? Mark 6:3 

Catgirl Loves Animal_Control --- 17 years ago -

Did Mary, Joseph’s wife and the mother of Jesus, ever give birth to other children? The question of whether or not Mary gave birth to other children besides Jesus is one that has been debated throughout the history of the church. Passages in which the other children of Mary are mentioned are Matthew 12:46-50; 13:55; Mark 6:3 (mentioning sisters as well as four brothers); Luke 8:19-20; John 2:12; 7:3-10; and Acts 1:14. Several interpretations of these passages were given by early church leaders. Epiphanius believed they refer to the sons of Joseph by a previous marriage. Jerome said they are cousins. Helvidius believed that they are the sons of Joseph and Mary (young half-brothers of Jesus). There are several reasons to prefer Helvidius’s view. In the first place, it is the simplest and most natural interpretation of the text. If Mary was so much younger than Joseph that he had a large number of children by an earlier marriage while refraining from a normal marital relationship with her, why would children from an earlier marriage be mentioned repeatedly in close connection with Mary without any indication that they were step-brothers and sisters? It seems most likely that Luke’s reference to Jesus as Mary’s “firstborn” (Luke 2:7) and the statement in Matthew 1:24-25 (“Joseph arose from his sleep, and did as the angel of the Lord commanded him, and took her as his wife, and kept her a virgin until she gave birth to a Son; and he called His name Jesus”) implies that she and Joseph had a large natural family following the Savior’s birth. This, after all, would be the normal and honorable pattern within Jewish culture. The view that the brothers and sisters (Greek: adelphos, adelphe) mentioned in these passages are actual brothers and sisters confirms Paul’s references to James as “the Lord’s brother” in Galatians 1:19 and to “The Lord’s brothers” in 1 Corinthians 9:5. If they were cousins rather than brothers, Paul would have used the Greek word for “cousins” (anepsioi; see Colossians 4:10). In light of these factors, those who would depart from the simplest and most natural meaning of the text carry the burden of proof. In our view, the reverence for celibacy and the exaltation of Mary that occurred within the early church is more likely an explanation for Epiphanius’s and Jerome’s interpretations than genuine historical fact. 

Angela --- 17 years ago -

Thank you for proving me correct catgirl 

Catgirl Loves Animal_Control --- 17 years ago -

We learn as we go. 

Angela --- 17 years ago -

I grew up in the church. It comes second nature. I am glad to see that you are giving it another chance. If you ever need anything please let me know. I will be there. 

Julmummy --- 17 years ago -

I was always under the impression that he never had relations with her because her womb was the one who held Jesus. Wouldn't that make Joseph a saint then? 

Angela --- 17 years ago -

Wouldn't that make Joseph a saint then If you look into Catholic teachings they do call him St. Joseph. 

Catgirl Loves Animal_Control --- 17 years ago -

I grew up in the church. It comes second nature. I am glad to see that you are giving it another chance. If you ever need anything please let me know. I will be there. TY, Im trying here. I always have more questions than answers, tho..lol. 

AGME98 --- 17 years ago -

Catgirl: I hope I can shed some light on the question of Jesus having brothers or not. The actual dispute is not whether or not Jesus had brothers (stepbrothers), but whether Mary was a perpetual Virgin. Jesus did not have brothers (see links below). The "... October 2002 Biblical Archaeology Review (BAR) announced that a first century stone ossuary had been discovered that is believed to have held the bones of St. James, the brother of Jesus, also known as "James the Just." The ossuary carries an inscription that says, in Aramaic, "James son of Joseph, brother of Jesus." “Some non-Catholics were quick to tout the box as evidence against the perpetual virginity of Mary, however this does not follow. The ossuary identifies its James as the son of Joseph and the brother of Jesus, it does not identify him as the son-much less the biological son-of Mary. The only point that Catholic doctrine has defined regarding the "brethren of the Lord" is that they are not biological children of Mary. What relationship they did have with her is a matter of speculation. They may have been Jesus' adoptive brothers, stepbrothers through Joseph, or-according to one popular theory-cousins. As has often been pointed out, Aramaic had no word for "cousin," so the word for brother was used in its place. This inscription is in Aramaic, and so there would be little surprise if it were being used in that way. In fact, that's what you'd expect. While the inscription does not establish the brethren of the Lord as biological children of Mary, it does have an impact on which theory may best explain the relationship of the brethren to Jesus. If James "the brother of the Lord" were Jesus' cousin then it would be unlikely for him also to have a father named Joseph. This would diminish the probability of the cousin theory in favor of the idea that this James was a stepbrother or an adoptive brother of Jesus. The stepbrother hypothesis is, in fact, the earliest one on record. It is endorsed by a document known as the Protoevangelium of James, which dates to the year 120, within sixty years of James' death (A.D. 62). According to the Protoevangelium, Joseph was an elderly widower at the time he was betrothed to Mary. He already had a family and thus was willing to become the guardian of a virgin consecrated to God. The stepbrother hypothesis was the most common explanation of the brethren of the Lord until St. Jerome popularized the cousin hypothesis just before the year 400. The stepbrother hypothesis is also supported by the fact that Joseph apparently was significantly older than Mary, as he appears to have died before our Lord's public ministry began. Hope this helps. One thing to keep in mind, the cousin theory is just that....theory. However, be careful when talking about the choice of words in the Bible when you reference the choice of words in Greek. The original text of the Bible was not written in Greek, it was written in Aramaic. It was translated into Greek much later. 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

Chris Rock in Dogma said it best.. do you think some guy is going to stay with some chick who don't put out???? 

JUNIPER --- 17 years ago -

do you think some guy is going to stay with some chick who don't put out???? If she is rich, of course. They are known as gigilos. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground