Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Teachers and Political Opinions

who's talking here?

CMGs 2
JDB2 1
sunshine1881 2
planemom 1
maverick 1
rose8304 4
NoNameNoLastName 2
BeadQueen 1
momof5 1
Wilstar77 1
*maryc 1
clockwatcher. 1
iheartboxers 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

rose8304 --- 17 years ago -

I know that teachers are people and they have opinions, but do you think they should share them in their classes? I am in college and my professor sent us two emails today. In one, he referenced the Houston Chronicle like this "...the Houston Comical or some such liberal rag (my opinion)..." and then in the second email he said "...happy holidays (formerly known as Christmas before the libs took over education)..." I'm not saying I'm offended or anything. I don't really care what his opinion is and I don't think it actually affects my grade or class participation as it is an online class. I was just wondering what people's opinions on the subject might be. 

rose8304 --- 17 years ago -

I'd like to hear everyone's opinion, but I'd especially to hear from teachers, so if you are one, please say so. Thanks! 

sunshine1881 --- 17 years ago -

I think college is a lot different than public high schools, etc. One of the huge benefits of college is the free exchange of ideas between people of differing cultural and political views, so I really don't have a problem with it at that level. We're all adults at that stage of life. 

clockwatcher. --- 17 years ago -

No opinions, to me, are appropriate within any classroom setting...The money I spend for my child's education should be for educational content and not a teacher's personal opinions regarding politics, social issues, etc. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 17 years ago -

Intelligent opinion, opening up a discussion - yes. Rambling like Rush Limbaugh without any coherence - no. 

rose8304 --- 17 years ago -

Intelligent opinion, opening up a discussion - yes. Rambling like Rush Limbaugh without any coherence - no. Maybe that's why it struck me the way it did. If it had been an inperson class and he'd asked our opinions and opened a discussion, that would be one thing. This wasn't like that. Some people had emailed him asking questions about an assignment. The first email was telling us we had to use the Wall Street Journal (its an economics class) not a "liberal rag". 

NoNameNoLastName --- 17 years ago -

WSJ has a very well defined position. If you study ethical norms, you will see they are completely on the side of freedom and efficiency in all their editorials. I had to study them ad nauseam in a business law course I just completed. A couple of hints to do an objective analysis - start by identifying the point the article is trying to defend, and the reasons presented to support it. Then look for missing information and ambiguity (mostly in the form of adjectives), and start questioning the article from there. You may or may not agree with the article, but regardless, you should always do it consciously. 

BeadQueen --- 17 years ago -

I'm a teacher. I think we have to be very careful in expressing our personal opinions in class. When teaching government we would teach the difference between conservatives and liberals and the differences between political parties. That usually provided some interesting discussions. The important thing I always tried to teach was that opinions needed to be based on something. One of the things that middle school students had a hard time with is debate. When they found out that they have to be able to argue either side of an issue, they were confused. They found it very hard to support an idea that they didn't "believe in." 

JDB2 --- 17 years ago -

Intelligent opinion, opening up a discussion - yes. Rambling like Rush Limbaugh without any coherence - no. interesting view...especially since the overwhelming majority of academia have a view point sustantially different than Rush's....I guess that is ok though, right? 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

In college, no I don't have a problem with it. Unless it was related to a classroom assignment I find it odd the professor e-mailed you but as far as expressing his opinion, not a problem. 

CMGs --- 17 years ago -

well, the statement says "rambling like Rush", not rambling right wing garbage like Rush. I've heard lots of rambling liberal talk show hosts that ramble and make absolutely no sense either. 

momof5 --- 17 years ago -

I think it's a little over the top. We all have opinions, but in a place of business, you need to be professional. I think he crossed the line. Also, if some of his students are liberal, that might hinder their opinion of him and possibly affect how they do in the class knowing how he feels about their political views. I don't know, maybe I'm overthinking it, but I think there's a place and a time for things like that, and it's not in an email from a professor to one of his students. 

CMGs --- 17 years ago -

And to answer your question Rose, I agree with momof5. It was a poor place to insert his own views. 

sunshine1881 --- 17 years ago -

I only see a problem with it if it influenced his grading. College is supposed to be more like the "real world" and you have to deal with varying opinions and the people who express them in "real life" so why not in college. In my government class I intentionally tried to figure out my professor's political view throughout the class. When I got my final paper back, he gave me a great note that he didn't agree with my stance at all, but it was a fine piece of academic work and well supported. I got and A, and that was the ultimate victory for me. 

Wilstar77 --- 17 years ago -

I agree. College should be an exchange of ideas. High school is a different story because you are dealing with kids who are not adults. 

rose8304 --- 17 years ago -

I don't know, maybe I'm overthinking it, but I think there's a place and a time for things like that, and it's not in an email from a professor to one of his students. I don't know if this makes a difference, but it was an email to all of his students. I find it odd the professor e-mailed you but as far as expressing his opinion, not a problem. It's an online class, so email is how we communicate. I agree. College should be an exchange of ideas. High school is a different story because you are dealing with kids who are not adults. I agree for the most part, but this wasn't a discussion. He was clarifying what sources we could use for an essay we have to write by telling us we must use the Wall Street Journal (which he'd said in the actual assignment and I didn't question that because it's an economics class and he's the teacher) and couldn't use anything like the "Houston Comical or any other liberal rag". I just found that to be very unnecessary. It doesn't explain the assignment or clarify anything. In fact, the way he said it actually made me lose a little respect for him. Not that there was much there. He hasn't proven to be a great teacher so far. I'm glad I only have to take his class for three weeks. I don't think I could stand him for a whole semester. 

iheartboxers --- 17 years ago -

If I say I want a sheet of blue construction paper, everyone wants a sheet of blue construction paper. If I say I want a cheeseburger for lunch, lunch choices around the room will suddenly change to cheeseburger. So for the really BIG opinions, I keep 'em to myself. But that's with small children... 

maverick --- 17 years ago -

Teachers should stay focused on the subject matter. Their political opinions are not needed. As far as Rush goes he is usually correct in his analysis but he does tend to ramble. I quit listening because he always beats every subject to death. 

*maryc --- 17 years ago -

I have a friend that is an English Professor. She always tells me it is improper for them to give a political opinion. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground