Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Ladies and gentlemen, I present to you the Straw Man argument

who's talking here?

Fancy 1
CyberSage 1
AuthorMan 2
Vedette 1
justforfun 1
~sassy~ 1
brian* 1
OH SNAP! 2
Squareduck 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

OH SNAP! --- 17 years ago -

Not to insult anyone's intelligence as I'm sure many of you are already familiar with the straw man argument, but since I see it being used over and over and over on KU, I thought it's worth enlightening some of the repeat offenders. From this point on, everything will be cut and pasted from wiki. ;) A straw man argument is an informal fallacy based on misrepresentation of an opponent's position.[1] To "set up a straw man," one describes a position that superficially resembles an opponent's actual view, yet is easier to refute. Then, one attributes that position to the opponent. For example, someone might deliberately overstate the opponent's position.[1] While a straw man argument may work as a rhetorical technique—and succeed in persuading people—it carries little or no real evidential weight, since the opponent's actual argument has not been refuted.[2] The term is derived from the practice in ages past of using human-shaped straw dummies in combat training. In such training, a scarecrow is made in the image of the enemy, sometimes dressed in an enemy uniform or decorated in some way to vaguely resemble them. A trainee then attacks the dummy with a weapon such as a sword, club, bow or musket. Such a target is, naturally, immobile and does not fight back, and is therefore not a realistic test of skill compared to a live and armed opponent. It is occasionally called a straw dog fallacy, scarecrow argument, or wooden dummy argument.[citation needed] In the UK, it is sometimes called Aunt Sally, with reference to a traditional fairground game. Reasoning Carefully presenting and refuting a weakened form of an opponent's argument is not always itself a fallacy. It can refocus the scope of an argument or be a legitimate step of a proof by exhaustion. In contrast the straw man fallacy occurs in the following pattern: 1. Person A has position X. 2. Person B ignores X and instead presents position Y. Y is a distorted version of X and can be set up in several ways, including: 1. Presenting a misrepresentation of the opponent's position and then refuting it, thus giving the appearance that the opponent's actual position has been refuted.[1] 2. Quoting an opponent's words out of context — i.e., choosing quotations that are not representative of the opponent's actual intentions (see contextomy and quote mining).[2] 3. Presenting someone who defends a position poorly as the defender and then refuting that person's arguments, thus giving the appearance that every upholder of that position, and thus the position itself, has been defeated.[1] 4. Inventing a fictitious persona with actions or beliefs that are criticized, such that the person represents a group of whom the speaker is critical. 5. Oversimplifying an opponent's argument, then attacking the simplified version. 3. Person B attacks position Y. 4. Person B draws a conclusion that X is false/incorrect/flawed. This sort of "reasoning" is fallacious because attacking a distorted version of a position simply does not constitute an attack on the position itself. Example Alpha: Nude bathing is healthy and nude beaches should be permitted here. Bravo: No. That kind of free sex threatens the morality of society. Bravo has misrepresented Alpha's position as a call for sexual promiscuity. Debating around a Straw Man Strictly speaking there are three ways to deflect a straw man setup. 1. Using the terms of the straw man, and refuting the theory itself. (Beach debate: "Free sex does not threaten morality. Think about all those people who wouldn't get born if sex wasn't free. Doing that would be immoral.") (Note: The above retort uses a strawman fallacy itself. The disputant has not claimed that sex in general should be restricted, only the type of sex that they regard as immorally "free". That is implicitly sexual activity motivated by lust not for procreation. There is also a presumption here that birth control is inherently immoral.) 2. Clarifying the original theory ("I said evolution should be taught, not that I believe in the big bang.") This may involve explicitly pointing out the straw man. 3. Questioning the disputation ("Why could it not have been made in 6 24-hour days?") 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

Wiki is factual. 

OH SNAP! --- 17 years ago -

Ummm...you didn't read any of that did you? lol What are you trying to say? That it's a myth? That it doesn't happen on KU? What? 

CyberSage --- 17 years ago -

I always knew TKK supported free sex. 

Vedette --- 17 years ago -

I totally prefer free sex to the kind you have to pay for. Much safer. ;) 

brian* --- 17 years ago -

Straw Man has become the most common political rebuttal form there is. It's hard to watch political debates anymore because of it. I like when issues are debated point/ counterpoint but apparently this straw man theory has taken hold and seems to work. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

Nice copy and paste KK....You do that almost as well as I do. :) 

AuthorMan --- 17 years ago -

I totally prefer free sex to the kind you have to pay for. Much safer. ;) I was always taught that one would appreciate something more if one had to work for it. :-) 

AuthorMan --- 17 years ago -

Straw Man has become the most common political rebuttal form there is. I really liked his performance in the 'Wizard of Oz'. 

Squareduck --- 17 years ago -

Wiki sucks! Any educated person would not use Wiki as a source. 

Fancy --- 17 years ago -

Wiki sucks! Any educated person would not use Wiki as a source. Maybe KK submit that definition herself and just wanted to bring attention to it. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground