Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Income Tax – what would you rather pay?

who's talking here?

randyjet 2
daveyjones 2
CommonSense 4
OH SNAP! 5
Allimama 3
GTV3 1
razumikhin 1
RCSKI 1
JetMan 13

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Income Tax – what would you rather pay?

What would you rather pay: Our current progressive income tax which ‘Spreads the Wealth’ -or- A flat tax of 18-20% with no exemptions to ‘Keep it Fair’

Progressive Tax Vote
 
 28.3% (13)
Flat Tax Vote
 
 71.7% (33)
JetMan --- 18 years ago -

What would you rather pay: Our current progressive income tax which ‘Spreads the Wealth’ -or- A flat tax of 18-20% with no exemptions to ‘Keep it Fair’  

Allimama --- 18 years ago -

I liked the notion of raising the sales tax so that you only spend on what you are consuming, regardless of your wealth. My dh said that it would never work, but I don't remember why. 

OH SNAP! --- 18 years ago -

No tax except for sales tax. Ray's posted a very good piece about it a couple of times. Makes a ton of sense to me. 

daveyjones --- 18 years ago -

Definitely the flat tax. 

Allimama --- 18 years ago -

So KK, have you heard what the downside is to the sales tax? I can't remember what the dh said about it. 

OH SNAP! --- 18 years ago -

So KK, have you heard what the downside is to the sales tax? I can't remember what the dh said about it. Hrm...haven't heard a downside. 

Allimama --- 18 years ago -

It sounds wonderful to me as well. I'll ask him about it tomorrow. We had a whole discussion about why it wouldn't work back when Huckabee was running, but I simply can't remember his reasons. 

daveyjones --- 18 years ago -

I don't know of a reason either. Everybody will be paying "their fair share" of taxes...prostitutes, drug dealers, republicans!!! Everyone! (lol!!!) 

OH SNAP! --- 18 years ago -

Yep, and they'll be paying based on what they actually consume which seems very fair. 

CommonSense --- 18 years ago -

So KK, have you heard what the downside is to the sales tax? I can't remember what the dh said about it. It places a higher burden on the middle and lower taxes. The wealthy don't typically spend all their money (the obvious exception being 80's rock stars spending it on women's clothes), but the middle and lower classes do. My suggestion: -A low national sales tax + a progressive tax on earnings over a certain amount (I'd peg it around $150k). -Raise the limits on 401k contributions and for the State of Texas: -NO state property taxes, put in a low income tax instead. It's MY property, why do I have to "lease" it from the State? 

OH SNAP! --- 18 years ago -

Well, the lower and middle classes would still come out ok because they wouldn't be paying income tax on top of sales tax. If they needed to scale back, they'd have the choice to do so. Also, if I remember correctly, everyone would get a large portion of it back. 

CommonSense --- 18 years ago -

Well, the lower and middle classes would still come out ok because they wouldn't be paying income tax on top of sales tax. The sales tax would be higher. No matter what the government would need the same revenue, but with a sales tax the burden falls on the consumer. The lower and middle classes spend a much bigger portion of their income than do the wealthy. 

OH SNAP! --- 18 years ago -

But the amount they'd get back is a much higher percentage of their income than for the wealthy, too. 

CommonSense --- 18 years ago -

But the amount they'd get back is a much higher percentage of their income than for the wealthy, too. I think under such a system consumer spending would go down. Since the cost is higher people would buy less, although that might be offset by the returns they'd get later. I'd be doomed, I always lose receipts when I need them. 

JetMan --- 18 years ago -

Looks like we want to 'Keep it Fair'. 

razumikhin --- 18 years ago -

One concern with a universal sales tax is that it would disproportionately effect those on a fixed income (i.e. retirees) whose income doesn't tend to increase w/ inflation. Typically this is handled today by the tax code by indexing exemptions and tax tables to inflation. How do you do this with sales tax w/o creating an equally complex system? 

GTV3 --- 18 years ago -

The sales tax would be higher. No matter what the government would need the same revenue, but with a sales tax the burden falls on the consumer. The lower and middle classes spend a much bigger portion of their income than do the wealthy. Under the Value Added Tax (VAT) or sales tax plan, things that you do not pay sales tax on remain sales tax free. So if you are truly poor and are spending money on rent and food, you pay no tax. But if you buy non-essentials like soda, beer, a Mercedes Benz, you pay. 

randyjet --- 18 years ago -

No matter what the government would need the same revenue, but with a sales tax the burden falls on the consumer. The proposed rate for a VAT tax is starting at 23%. The effect will be to exempt the wealthy from most taxes, and only the ordinary American will pay taxes. If you think that things are expensive now, just wait and get that one. Another fun feature is that it will be based on the sales price, so that when gasoline goes up, so does the amount of the VAT tax. Right now the Federal gas tax is FIXED. With a VAT it rises along with the prices. The wealthy will basically pay NO tax at all. They have options that the rest of us do not have. They can and do incorporate and will simply have their corporations by all their things for them, and thus they will be exempt from the tax completely. Also, they will simply buy their cars, boats, aircraft off shore to escape the tax. Only dumb Republicans could possibly think of such a thing. They truly believe that only the ordinary Americans should pay taxes and that the wealthy should live off the rest of us. 

JetMan --- 18 years ago -

It's nice to see that 76% of you want to steer clear of socialism. 

JetMan --- 18 years ago -

76.9% and rising! 

JetMan --- 18 years ago -

77.8% -- WOW! 

JetMan --- 18 years ago -

It's fallen back to 75%. 

JetMan --- 18 years ago -

Back up -- 77.4% !!! 

JetMan --- 18 years ago -

Down to 75%. 

JetMan --- 18 years ago -

Fallen to 73.5%. 

CommonSense --- 18 years ago -

It's nice to see that 76% of you want to steer clear of socialism. It's not-so-nice to see some of you rely on McCain/Palin for a definition of socialism. Get a dictionary. 

JetMan --- 18 years ago -

Obviously 73% are willing to open up their pocketbooks in a big way to combat socialism. 

JetMan --- 18 years ago -

75% 

RCSKI --- 18 years ago -

I WOULD RATHER THE FAIR TAX. 

JetMan --- 18 years ago -

Back up to 76.2% 

randyjet --- 18 years ago -

I WOULD RATHER THE It should be called the UNFAIR TAX since it will let the wealthy basically pay NO taxes at all. The only people who WILL be taxed are US, ordinary Americans who will NOT be able to dodge the VAT tax. The tax rate will START at 23% of the sales price of most items. This will really hit all of us pretty hard by increasing the price of all goods that we need by that amount. It will be even worse when you look at gas prices. Think that gas was expensive recently? Just add 23% MORE to the price on top of what you spent. Remember, as the price goes up, so does the amount of the tax. Just look at the crooks who support this. One of the worst is former Republican Rep. Tauzin who engineered the Medicare drug plan giveaway to the phamacuetical companies. After he gave them billions of dollars, he retired from Congress to act as their prime lobbyist. Any person who thinks this is fair is retarded. 

JetMan --- 18 years ago -

Dropping, now down to 72.1%. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

politics


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground