Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

5th Grade Math Question

who's talking here?

cmi 2
Zionist NightOwl 2
I Kissed Frogs 8
Astro King 1
Lorralei 3
tysmom 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

I Kissed Frogs --- 18 years ago -

Can someone tell me the reason for this type of math question? I think I am trying to make it mean more than it does... Lila rolls a number cube two times. The first time she gets a 3. List all the possible outcomes of Lila's two rolls. (The teacher added to pretend they were cubes of 6) My ds claims he is supposed to write 2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12 which are all the possible sums the next roll could be. My question is why? Is it just a reasoning skill exercise? 

I Kissed Frogs --- 18 years ago -

Or did my ds misunderstand and have a totally wrong answer/ understanding of the question. 

tysmom --- 18 years ago -

did they give an example?? 

Lorralei --- 18 years ago -

it's called statistics and probability. Translate "number cube" to dice. 1,2,3,4,5,6. If dice 1 is 1 and dice 2 is 1, then the sum is 2. If dice 1 is 1 and dice 2 is 2, then the sum is 3. On and on until you cover all the numbers. 

I Kissed Frogs --- 18 years ago -

No example given on the worksheet and he doesn't have his math book for me to look at for possible explanation. 

I Kissed Frogs --- 18 years ago -

Thanks! So his answer is correct that it could be no less than 2 and no higher than 12. It just seemed a strange question but it is a TAKS prep question and they always throw in extra info (like the sum of the 1st row) to see if they can confuse you. 

Lorralei --- 18 years ago -

Yep, his answer is right. It's a "building block" to the career as a professional gambler in Vegas... lol. I love stats and probability. 

Astro King --- 18 years ago -

IKF, I'm actually a fifth grade math teacher myself. Lorralei is right - this is a probability question. The reasoning for this type of problem is two parts. First, the kids need to know that the word probability means chance. In the lower grades they use the word "chance." Now they must know the upper-level term, probability. Second, the state wants to see how deep they can think. It's also a part logic question where they have to figure it out. Hang in there - we teachers love to see parental involvement and support! 

Lorralei --- 18 years ago -

At one time I aspired to be a high school statistics teacher. When kids get into college so many of them HATE statistics. They try to call it "math". It's logic... you use math, but it's logic. I would have loved to teach kids to where they enjoyed it. I had an awesome prof in college for stats. Of course, he liked me because I already knew (and loved) stats. 

cmi --- 18 years ago -

If you get a 3 the first time, how can it possibly add up to anything higher than 9 after the second roll?I read the problem to say that one number cube is rolled 2 times. One of the rolls is definitely 3 and the second could be 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, or 6. So, the sums could be 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, or 9. 

I Kissed Frogs --- 18 years ago -

I can't stand math. I was very good at it until Algebra and then it didn't make sense and I kept trying to make it make sense instead of just learning the rules and following them. It didn't help that my Algebra I teacher would respond to the whole class that my question was the most stupid thing she had ever heard and would not justify it with an answer or to explain the process in a different way. I failed and had to go to summer school and that teacher basically passed you if you just showed up. The next year I got the same teacher for Algebra II and failed my first grading semester. My mom requested that I be moved to another teacher but the only option was honors alegra. I went into and that teacher took the time to ask how I was looking at it and finally told me "I have been a teacher for 25 years and never questioned how to do this. You way of looking at it makes so much sense and I am questioning all I know." She then told me to stop trying to make it make sense and just learn the rules which I did and started making A's. But the experience makes me think I am looking at all math problems from a weird angle and even had some of my ds' teachers tell me I approach it nontypically and he does too. It has always been okay until DIVISION! He is struggling with it and I don't know how to tell him because I approach it way different than his teacher. I need a stand in mom, lol. 

tysmom --- 18 years ago -

I always have my students list the outcomes. 

I Kissed Frogs --- 18 years ago -

Good point CMI. I was thinking she rolled 2 dice twice. Let me go pull his paper from his backpack and see if I didn't read it wrong. I kept wanting to put that 3 in there when I first read it and he is the one that told me they always try to trick you with extra info and that was a sentence he was to ignore. 

cmi --- 18 years ago -

If the teacher told me that, I would be the one arguing. The problem says she rolled a 3 the first time....without that info, yes the others are possible. But, since that info is given, the others are no longer possibilities. But, knowing how some teachers are, she probably has her own idea of what she wants the problem to mean. LOL 

I Kissed Frogs --- 18 years ago -

I think you are correct CMI after rereading it. My son said it was 2 dice but it only says the one cube (dice). 

Zionist NightOwl --- 18 years ago -

They do give you extra information some times, but this sentence is not extraneous info. you can ignore. It is part of the problem. CMI is right. She rolls a cube twice. The first one is a 3. That leaves her outcomes 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, and 9. 

I Kissed Frogs --- 18 years ago -

I swear I had a brain before I became a stay at home mom. I handled multimillion dollar projects and now I can't do 5th grade homework... Thanks ladies. 

Zionist NightOwl --- 18 years ago -

lol. You're still a very smart lady. It's just been a few years since we did 5th grade work, right? That's my story, and I'm sticking with it. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground