Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Gardasil vaccine on Good Morning America!

who's talking here?

marthas attic 1
Sweetie Pie 1
aggiegirl 2
planemom 3
Sandyr9111 3
♥be as you are♥ 1
Rachel 4
★ † 12 Stones † ★ 2
~Shannon~ 1
momof5 2
doodlelab 1
bidingmytime 1
Ashlei 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Rachel --- 18 years ago -

Discussing whether it could cause more harm than good....not on yet. I am VERY interested as to the nature of this segment. 

Sandyr9111 --- 18 years ago -

If my sattelite wasnt out id record it. I refuse to give it to mine just yet. I dont think they did enough testing on it. And now they have the meningitis vax they r pushing too.....ive never even heard of it. 

Rachel --- 18 years ago -

Researchers Question If HPV Vaccine Is Worth the Risk Gardasil's High Cost and Effectiveness Come Under Fire By SHARYN ALFONSI Aug. 20, 2008 — Sonya Sheehan's daughters are the picture of health, and she wants to keep it that way. As a nurse, Sheehan had her older daughter inoculated with Gardasil, the human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccine. She plans to give the shot to her 6-year-old in a few years, to protect her against cervical cancer. Most medical organizations have strongly advocated using the HPV vaccine for girls 11 and 12 years old. Merck, the maker of the vaccine, launched a massive and carefully targeted marketing campaign, where young women stand before the camera and declare with confidence, "I could be one less," woman to die of cervical cancer. The commercials have caught the attention of parents, and in just two years, more than 8 million young women have been given a Gardasil shot. Dr. Nathan Litman, Director of Inpatient Pediatrics at Montefiore Medical Center in New York, considers Gardasil a medical breakthrough. "This vaccine should be able to prevent about 70 percent of cervical cancer," he said. But, an editorial to be published in the New England Journal of Medicine on Thursday outlined some serious concerns about the vaccine. First, Gardasil's long-term effectiveness is unclear. Because cervical cancer takes years to develop, critics say the current information is insufficient to determine whether Gardasil works. "The overall effect of the vaccines on cervical cancer remains unknown," Dr. Carolyn J. Haug, the Journal of Norwegian Medical Association's editor, wrote in the New England Journal editorial. "The real impact of HPV vaccination on cervical cancer will not be observable for decades." Gardasil is also expensive, costing about $400 to $1,000 for the necessary three doses of the vaccine. Studies have not proven how long the immunity will last and whether or not additional shots will be needed, which would raise the cost even higher. And it's not a slam dunk. The vaccine only protects against some of the viruses that cause cervical cancer, so women still need regular pap screenings. And some doctors said that a traditional pap screen may be more effective. These remaining questions have prompted some doctors to ask if it's worth it for girls to get vaccinated in the first place. "Most of the information people have right now leads them to believe that if they're vaccinated with Gardasil, they're protected for life, and that's just not true," said Dr. Diane Harper of Dartmouth College. There is also the issue of side effects. FDA records reveal that, since Gardasil's approval, nearly 9,000 girls had "bad health events" after receiving their shots. These included 78 reported outbreaks of genital warts, 18 deaths and six cases of Guillain Barre Syndrome, which can result in paralysis. It is unknown whether there are unseen side effects, like decreasing the body's ability to fight off other strains of the HPV virus. Merck maintains that the vaccine is perfectly safe and effective. "These reports are from conditions that have occurred following the vaccination," said Dr. Rick Haup, executive director of Merck research labs. "They do not necessarily mean they are causally related." But, "with so many essential questions still unanswered, there is good reason to be cautious," Haug wrote. Virginia is set to require all young girls to get vaccinated before entering middle school this fall, and dozens of other states are considering whether to make the Gardasil shot mandatory for young women. These lingering questions are sure to inject a new shot of concern into the debate 

marthas attic (Mod) --- 18 years ago -

we did the meningitis vac, but when we were going to do the Gardasil they were out and we just had not got around to going back to get it. Kinda glad now as I want to wait and see what everyone says about it. 

Sandyr9111 --- 18 years ago -

There is also the issue of side effects. FDA records reveal that, since Gardasil's approval, nearly 9,000 girls had "bad health events" after receiving their shots. These included 78 reported outbreaks of genital warts, 18 deaths and six cases of Guillain Barre Syndrome, which can result in paralysis. It is unknown whether there are unseen side effects, like decreasing the body's ability to fight off other strains of the HPV virus. THIS is my problem....its like they almost had no clue what side affects would occur! DEATH? Paralysis? Not for my kid. 

bidingmytime --- 18 years ago -

I come from a medical family and feel that vaccines are important, but like you Sandy9111, no way am I comfortable with even the smallest of these percentages of side effects. I'll wait too. 

Rachel --- 18 years ago -

There was a meningitis outbreak a few years ago...it was serious so I don't mind that vaccine. I have always thought it was too early to "require" the Gardisil vaccine and have declined it every time it was offered. Thankfully I have a wonderful pediatrician who is cool with my decision. 

Sandyr9111 --- 18 years ago -

Ive got a medical background as well but this just has bothered me from the beginning when they started talking about making it "mandatory"! 

doodlelab --- 18 years ago -

There is also the issue of side effects. FDA records reveal that, since Gardasil's approval, nearly 9,000 girls had "bad health events" after receiving their shots. These included 78 reported outbreaks of genital warts, 18 deaths I'm confused. Isn't the vaccine suppose to stop a girl from getting infected with the HPV virus, which causes genital warts? 

aggiegirl --- 18 years ago -

I have had all 3 shots. I got them when they came out and I am still alive with no warts, not paralyzed and not dead. I have many friends who have also had the vaccines and they are all ok too! 

Ashlei --- 18 years ago -

i got the meningitis vac and have had 2/3 doses of the gardisil vac.. 

Rachel --- 18 years ago -

I am thankful that I have time to wait before my daughter needs it... 

Sweetie Pie --- 18 years ago -

Women who have certain strains of HPV are more likely to develop cervical cancer. I'm an RN (Women's Health/peds) and am waiting a little longer on it for our 13 year old. Our pedi agreed its best to wait and get more long term studies. 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

I'm glad I have a couple of years before I feel the need for this vaccine for my girls. Hopefully, by then some of the controversy will be put to rest. 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

I'm confused. Isn't the vaccine suppose to stop a girl from getting infected with the HPV virus, which causes genital warts? Doctors don't usually screen before giving the shots. They may have already been infected. 

~Shannon~ --- 18 years ago -

Our pedi agreed its best to wait and get more long term studies. I would wait too. I looked at shot requirements for the school and it was one of the requirements. Edited to say recommended not required. 

aggiegirl --- 18 years ago -

There will always be controversy over stuff like this. Not everyone is going to agree. You just have to way the odds for yourself and not be swayed by everyone else. 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

I looked at shot requirements for the school and it was one of the requirements. Humble ISD web site shows it's recommended but not required. 

♥be as you are♥ --- 18 years ago -

There will always be controversy over stuff like this. I agree. There are risks with everything. What about tthe required immunizations that are "linked" to Autism? It's a personal choice for your famiy, and just do what your comfortable with... 

momof5 --- 18 years ago -

HPV is a tricky virus. There are numerous strains, you can be infected with more than one, and a condom does NOT protect you from getting it. I'm going to wait another year or so for my daughter, but I do think the vaccine is a good thing if they can work the bugs out of it. 

★ † 12 Stones † ★ --- 18 years ago -

again why we do not vaccinate. every time they come out with the amazing new vaccine everyone runs out to get it half the people die or have ill side effects. it is never worth the risk 

★ † 12 Stones † ★ --- 18 years ago -

i know parents that will not give their kids decongestants because of the huge recall they did -back winter time-- and the reason they recalled is because parents were over dosing their children--simple don't overdose-- but the child had a terrible runny nose and congestion. but they run out and get them EVERY vaccine known to man so they won't catch something that well frankly they may never catch!!! this makes absolutely no sense to me! 

momof5 --- 18 years ago -

every time they come out with the amazing new vaccine everyone runs out to get it half the people die or have ill side effects. and in just two years, more than 8 million young women have been given a Gardasil shot. FDA records reveal that, since Gardasil's approval, nearly 9,000 girls had "bad health events" after receiving their shots 8 million received, 9000 with side effects and of those only 78 reported outbreaks of genital warts, 18 deaths and six cases of Guillain Barre Syndrome, which can result in paralysis. That's a drop in the bucket really. Not to downplay it, but really, this isn't a large amount given the larger number of 8 million. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground