Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Whats you view?

who's talking here?

marthas attic 1
BrookleighPhotography 2
Queen Aeval 1
txdaddy 6
2girlygirls 5
RX8LVR 1
~harpo~ 4
chunksNbones 6
Fin and Feather 1
freni32 1
~sassy~ 1
Shutterman 1
Lord Cheezus 1
Campbellskid :^) 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Whats you view?

Do you agree that someone should be allowed to join the service and fight for our country, before they can leaglly buy a beer in the country they would be fighting for?

Agree Vote
 
 39.2% (20)
Disagree Vote
 
 60.8% (31)
~harpo~ --- 18 years ago -

Do you agree that someone should be allowed to join the service and fight for our country, before they can leaglly buy a beer in the country they would be fighting for? 

BrookleighPhotography --- 18 years ago -

Yes JMO but i feel they have no relivence. 

chunksNbones --- 18 years ago -

I think that if someone is volunteering to lay his/her life on the line for our country, we should at least allow them a beer..... 

~harpo~ --- 18 years ago -

I think that if someone is volunteering to lay his/her life on the line for our country, we should at least allow them a beer..... Ditto! 

chunksNbones --- 18 years ago -

The other option would be to raise the enlistment age up to 21, but nobody would join then.. 

2girlygirls --- 18 years ago -

I don't think there is a black and white answer. Some 18 years have the good sense to drink responsibly, but most don't. Any 18 year old could benefit from a few years in the military. 

chunksNbones --- 18 years ago -

Any 18 year old could benefit from a few years in the military. But, wouldn't it be wrong to expect that 18 year old to be killed before having his/her first legal drink? 

2girlygirls --- 18 years ago -

Do you seriously believe that an 18 year old hasn't already had his/her first drink? As for the getting killed part, the odds of them getting in an alcohol related accident is far more likely. 

BrookleighPhotography --- 18 years ago -

Do you seriously believe that an 18 year old hasn't already had his/her first drink? As for the getting killed part, the odds of them getting in an alcohol related accident is far more likely. Sorry momof1 you know i luvh you BUT DITTOOOO! LOL. come on 21 ain't stoppin them from drinkin, DH joined the marines at 18! 

Queen Aeval --- 18 years ago -

They let me drink on the base when I was in, joined at 17. I doubt they do anymore... I think that if the guys and girls are old enough to be trusted with a semi-automatic weapon, they ought to be able to have a dang beer. 

chunksNbones --- 18 years ago -

Do you seriously believe that an 18 year old hasn't already had his/her first drink? As for the getting killed part, the odds of them getting in an alcohol related accident is far more likely. No, I'm not stupid. I know that most 18 year olds have had their first drink. I'm talking about their first LEGAL drink. And yes, an alcohol related accident is more likely to occur. But what I don't think is right is to allow an 18 year old to have a GUN and lay his/her life on the line for YOU and ME (which I would consider to be a huge sacrifice) and NOT allow him/her to have a drink in their own country legally. Now, does an 18 year old drink responsibly? Probably not, but an 18 year old who's in the military is a little different than a frat boy right? 

txdaddy --- 18 years ago -

the military requires that you follow the laws of the country/state you are stationed in...so if they go to germany...drink away. momof1...there is no expectation of getting killed. there is a higher possibility, but not an expectation 

txdaddy --- 18 years ago -

is a little different than a frat boy right? lol...yes, the 18 in the military can drink more...lol 

2girlygirls --- 18 years ago -

the military requires that you follow the laws of the country/state you are stationed in...so if they go to germany...drink away. momof1...there is no expectation of getting killed. there is a higher possibility, but not an expectation Couldn't have said it better and my hands are full of baby so I'm typing with 1 hand 

chunksNbones --- 18 years ago -

Like I said earlier, what about raising the enlistment age up to 21 then? 

marthas attic (Mod) --- 18 years ago -

Like I said earlier, what about raising the enlistment age up to 21 then? I think a large part of those who join are right out of high school and if you raise the age to 21, you are going to go way down on enlistment. JMO 

txdaddy --- 18 years ago -

Like I said earlier, what about raising the enlistment age up to 21 then? wow...you really do not want us to have a military do you? 

2girlygirls --- 18 years ago -

They make the choice to join knowing what the drinking laws are so I guess I don't really get your point? 

chunksNbones --- 18 years ago -

wow...you really do not want us to have a military do you? hehe, that's not it at all actually :) You say potato I say I'm right, whatever! lol! let's just agree to disagree ok? I gotta go eat lunch before my kid wakes up 

txdaddy --- 18 years ago -

They make the choice to join knowing what the drinking laws are so I guess I don't really get your point? yep 

~harpo~ --- 18 years ago -

They make the choice to join knowing what the drinking laws are so I guess I don't really get your point? That would be the point they can amke to choice to serve our counrty, but not to have a beer? 

txdaddy --- 18 years ago -

You say potato I say I'm right, whatever! lol! let's just agree to disagree ok? I gotta go eat lunch before my kid wakes up not sure what we are disagreeing about. the facts are that if you upped the enlistment age to 21, there would be less of a pool to recruit from therefore our military would shrink...and i would say drastically. remember what happened last time our military was reduced by drastic numbers? 

2girlygirls --- 18 years ago -

If it mattered that much to them then I guess they shouldn't join. 

txdaddy --- 18 years ago -

That would be the point they can amke to choice to serve our counrty, but not to have a beer? but it is known ahead of time. not sure what the problem is here to be honest. 

~harpo~ --- 18 years ago -

not sure what the problem is here to be honest. No problem, just asking for others views. 

~sassy~ --- 18 years ago -

On this issue I am completely torn. On one hand I believe if you are expected to fight for our country - and upon turning 18 can be "forced" to fight for this country....then it seems only fair that you ought legally be allowed to buy a beer once turning 18. After all, are you legal at 18 or not? I'm surprised someone hasn't challenged the legality of a state imposing this law at the Supreme Court level. That a minor can legally kill her unborn offspring yet someone of legal age can not buy a beer seems odd to me. I understand WHY we don't want 18 year-old's drinking but is it right? 

Campbellskid :^) --- 18 years ago -

I may be misunderstanding, but if my child joined, I would rather he be sober and able to think if he got in a sticky situation. If it's more about the age, I tip my hat to anyone joining, because they have everyone's family and friends' safety in mind. I would be more proud of one of my kids joining at 17 or 18, than becoming a drunk and acting stupid at 21. I apoligize if I took the question wrong! 

freni32 --- 18 years ago -

im sorry but buying beer...and fighting for our country...I see no relation...like comparing apples to oranges.... Rules are Rules...especially for someone going into the military...they think they should be special because they are in the military...so lets have a 17 year old be able to buy beer... they have the age limit of 21 for a reason... I have been in the military when I was 18...and looking back...no...wait till your 21...I dont feel like I should have been treated anyway differently...yes what I was doing was a good cause...but grow up...rules are rules and they need to be followed... just my thoughts :} 

Fin and Feather --- 18 years ago -

rules are rules and they need to be followed... ditto 

Shutterman --- 18 years ago -

I think 18 year olds should spend a mandatory year in the service after graduation so they could fully understand what defending this country is about. And so they could get their $h!t together for the real world. 

Lord Cheezus --- 18 years ago -

On this issue I am completely torn. On one hand I believe if you are expected to fight for our country - and upon turning 18 can be "forced" to fight for this country....then it seems only fair that you ought legally be allowed to buy a beer once turning 18. After all, are you legal at 18 or not? I'm surprised someone hasn't challenged the legality of a state imposing this law at the Supreme Court level. Most states raised their drinking ages under pressure from the Federal government, in order to keep their federal Highway funding. Some states also have clauses in their laws that allow underage active-duty military personnel to legally drink; I agree with that provision. I think 18 year olds should spend a mandatory year in the service after graduation so they could fully understand what defending this country is about. It works great for Israel and many other countries; the problem here is that the left would whine about civil rights. They fail to understand that many things they perceive as "rights" are actually "privileges", and that privilege comes with certain responsibilities. 

RX8LVR --- 18 years ago -

Yes JMO but i feel they have no relivence. Ditto. Unless there is a draft, joining the service is voluntary... If the men/women joining don't want to join until they are old enough to drink, legally, then they should wait to join the service until they are of legal drinking age... FYI - I don't think most soldiers have trouble getting a beer no matter what the age. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground