Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Great article about OBAMA,by M.E. newspaper.

who's talking here?

Empty Nest 1
smartypants 9
Justwatching72 1
mamajulie 2
haroldoftherocks 1
Forecaster 18
bidingmytime 32
Nightstorm 7
AllenVanAllen 2
Texian 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

bidingmytime --- 18 years ago -

By Mark Levine, Middle East historian Submitted to Al Jazeera newspaper As soon as Barack Obama rose to the top of the field of Democratic presidential contenders, he developed a "Muslim problem" based on false accusations that he is, or once was, a Muslim. There is little doubt that these accusations will be raised again, however unfairly, when Obama squares off against John McCain, the Republican presidential candidate, in November's election. But if we were to assume that Obama overcomes this and other obstacles to win his historic bid for the White House, a far more serious Muslim problem awaits "President" Obama: A majority of the world's 1.4 billion Muslims have an utter lack of trust in the US. Senator Obama's experience of living in a Muslim country (Indonesia, where he attended school during his childhood), along with his relative youthfulness and message of hope, have the potential to heal this rift, however. He has the merits which can energise young Muslims in the same way he has inspired millions of young Americans. Comprehensive changes required But this potential will not easily be realised, partially because of the ill-advised policies of the Bush administration and their impact on the Muslim world. Most of the Generations X, Y Muslims I know, from Morocco to Pakistan, will not be swayed by Obama's lofty rhetoric unless it is backed by comprehensive changes in US foreign policy. Indeed, the young and educated citizens of the Muslim majority world are more politically sophisticated and historically knowledgeable of Washington's foreign policy than their generational cohorts in the US. They feel deeply and negatively impacted by these policies as they try to find coherence and stability in the increasingly chaotic post-9/11 landscape. Islamic demographics How can Obama reach Islam's most crucial demographic - the young and passionate? Muslim youth are not one homogeneous entity but comprise a remarkable diversity. From the Saudi teenagers who listen to Britney Spears to those who are swayed by the farewell messages of female suicide bombers; the Egyptian metalheads who spend Friday afternoons at the mosque and Friday evenings playing Black Metal; and the graduate students in Islamabad whose Talibanesque appearance is belied by their study of Hebrew and the latest theories of comparative religion. While it is heartening to hear Obama tell young people around the world "You matter to us. Your future is our future. And our moment is now," it is not at all clear that his presidency would seize that moment to implement a mutual drive across the Muslim world. In the US today merely to advocate talking with our adversaries is considered radical. But the students, activists, religious figures and artists who are struggling against the robust authoritarianism that dominates the Muslim world want action. What Obama must do The senator from Illinois must stop offering political, economic and military support to repressive governments who torture political prisoners, discourage economic and political reform, and censor Facebook, YouTube and other key nodes of the emerging Muslim public and cultural spheres. He must push to get US forces out of Iraq, now. And, perhaps more importantly, Obama must hold all the countries of the Middle East - including Israel - to one standard. Would a President Obama satisfy any of these demands? Not likely. Obama locates the root of the region's woes solely inside it, "emanating from the perverse and hateful ideologies of radical Islam". He is unwilling to even question the role and impact of US Middle East policy in analysing the region's problems. He will not offer even mild criticism of Israel while wholeheartedly endorsing Tel Aviv's refusal to consider granting Palestinian sovereignty over any part of East Jerusalem, which forecloses any possibility for peace. It becomes difficult to see how such views would enable the kind of "aggressive diplomatic effort" across the region the senator calls for. Talking to Iran Will Obama sit for talks with the Iranian leadership if he becomes president? [EPA] Moreover, Obama's much debated willingness to talk to Iran is undercut by his support for implementing confrontational policies. For example, he supported designating the Revolutionary Guards as a terrorist organisation and pushing for increased sanctions against the Islamic Republic -before even sitting down with its leadership. Most importantly, Obama hedges his pledge to remove US forces from Iraq, refusing to commit to a full withdrawal of US troops while calling for a large expansion of the ranks of the active duty military. This suggests that as president, Obama would continue and even increase US military engagements in the region, against the wishes of the vast majority of its inhabitants. Luckily, a burgeoning coalition of people across the Middle East - in particular, the younger generation - are not waiting for "President" Obama, or anyone else, to save them. American activist youths A growing activist community, religious and secular together, is challenging the sclerotic politics of their governments and the resistance identities of Islamist extremism - in cyberspace, in the emerging media sphere, and when possible on the streets - with a positive, peace, justice and development oriented Islam. But this is not the "moderate" Islam preferred by American policy-makers. Rather, it is based on a radical critique of the status quo - of US global economic and military supremacy as much as of the self-inflicted problems of their societies. If an Obama administration is unwilling or unable to break free of the geopolitical and economic priorities that have long determined US Middle East policy, it will be up to the young Americans who helped elect him to join their counterparts across the Muslim world in demanding that their leaders finally walk the talk of peace, democracy and equitable development. If they do, an Obama White House could preside over the birth of a new and more positive relationship between the US and the Muslim world.  

bidingmytime --- 18 years ago -

It is the youth that will mobilize this country!! Diplomacy is the ONLY way to ensure our safety. We need to CHANGE our policy with the whole M.E. region. 

Forecaster --- 18 years ago -

I would love to know how the Muslim countries wish us to revitalize our foreign policies? What part of our policies do they wish us to change? I predict the Muslim countries say they don't like our foreign policies when in reality they don't like our presence in the Middle East. If you were to ask a Pakistani citizen what policy they would liked change by the US government I'm willing to put money that they'd complain of our presence and not a single policy. 

bidingmytime --- 18 years ago -

Well, I know that it is a long article, but it is really worth the read. As you know, my family is partly Arab so this is a topic that is important to us, particularly because the U.S. has been extremely pro-Israel for decades. And that is not bad, except that the tension between the countries and Israel is serious and needs to be handled with care and diplomacy. 

bidingmytime --- 18 years ago -

As I read further in your post, I actually think that you are wrong on that where you think that Pakistani's couldn't tell you what policy they would like changed. Everyone in the Middle East would say that the relationship between Israel and the U.S. is not balanced or fair in relation to the Arab countries. Do not, please, hear me as sounding anti-Israel. Nor do I ever want to be accused of negating the seriousness of the suicide bombings. They are sick and wrong. But, the history of the region is volitile to say the least. And the way the U.S. has addressed the issues has been horrible. 

Forecaster --- 18 years ago -

And that is not bad, except that the tension between the countries and Israel is serious and needs to be handled with care and Maybe you would care to shed some light on the correct ways to do this as I'm not sure how it's possible. The Middle East wants Israel back for itself and we have a duty to protect Israel. I don't see it possible to please both and Israel has always backed our proposals to the UN even when every other country was against us. If we turn our back on our only true ally then we've lost the battle all together. 

bidingmytime --- 18 years ago -

First, you are not correct that the M.E. wants all of Israel for themselves. Not at all. The radical, fanatics may say this, but the rest of the rational part of the M.E. do not. They want specific parts of Israel which Israel had agreed upon and then renigged. They want a certain small part of Jerusalem which has been part of their heritage long before the Jews came to Israel. Also, why do we have a duty to protect Israel? I don't think we need to turn our back on Israel at all. Not at all. Do you know that many many more people in Israel agree that their government ought to give land to Palestine. They do. Many many Israelis donate time and money and even activism to help the Palestinian crisis going on over there. 

Forecaster --- 18 years ago -

Everyone in the Middle East would say that the relationship between Israel and the U.S. is not balanced or fair in relation to the Arab countries. The reality is though that Israel is our ally and most Middle Eastern countries are not and don't care to be an ally of the US. I don't consider you to sound anti Israel. I do believe most of our youth don't understand the need to protect Israel as they may not understand the history surrounding our support. 

Forecaster --- 18 years ago -

Also, why do we have a duty to protect Israel? Maybe because we are responsible for many of the jews being placed there. Those other countries have tried to over take that country many times and failed. I consider that divine intervention. The United States of America, the super power that stands for fair and just promised many years ago to take care of Israel and our country is based on back bone, character and pride therefore we must continue with our promise. 

bidingmytime --- 18 years ago -

I understand your point. However, with respect, the people that "claimed" Israel, took the land with force and cruelty. It wasn't the right way to handle it. But, I'm not going to argue that point, for sure. What I want to say is that now, in 2008, there are 1.3 million people living behind a barbed wire fence with only ONE opening The living conditions are terrible, beyond inhumane in fact. This is barbaric and unacceptable. 

bidingmytime --- 18 years ago -

If it is divine intervention, then you think that we should just allow that whole population to die away...just ignore their human needs and let them die?? Even many many organizations in Israel proper do not believe that anymore. 

Forecaster --- 18 years ago -

1.3 million people living behind a barbed wire fence with only ONE opening I understand what you are saying but what I'm saying is that we made a promise to Israel and we made no such promise to anyone else. Why is it our job to improve the lives of those people? I don't mean that to sound anti Palestinian either but we are stuck in the middle of this horrific situation and being a God fearing man myself I will always side with Israel and pray my government does as well. There is a reason we have always been the super power and always maintained the status. 

bidingmytime --- 18 years ago -

There can be a peaceful solution. There can be. It would take diplomacy on our part. The Arab world needs to see that we are fair, not just biased. 

bidingmytime --- 18 years ago -

I hear you, and I am grateful for this peaceful conversation. Thank you. I don't believe that to endorse the proper care of the Palestinian people would be going against Israel. And even if it is an ally, if they do something wrong, very wrong, than we should be able to say, "hey, we don't exactly agree with that..." you know? 

Forecaster --- 18 years ago -

There can be a peaceful solution. I don't see it as possible if we stay true to ourselves and not sell this country short. 

Forecaster --- 18 years ago -

I don't believe that to endorse the proper care of the Palestinian people would be going against Israel. We support Israel and Russia ultimately supports Palestine so in essence they're not being denied. I enjoy pleasant debate as I learn from it. 

bidingmytime --- 18 years ago -

I might probaby need to stop talking about this soon, because I am personally involved in this. My sister is a U.S. diplomat working in the West Bank on the right of return for Palestinian refugees. There are many many horrific stories I could share, but one in particular, that I want to share. There are check points that the hundreds of people in the West Bank must go through if they are "fortunate enough" to have employement or attend school, or they need medical care, in Israel proper. The check points are of course guarded by armed IDF officers. One day when my sister was waiting in line to get through the check point a woman with her husband was in labor and needed to cross. It was very obvious that she was in labor. But, the guards would not let her pass. For some reason they hadn't opened the "terminal" they call it yet, and they wouldn't open it early for her. My sister said that the woman had to go behind a large rock and deliver her baby on the dirt ground, with no woman or nurse or doctor to attend her. Her husband who could also not attend her was flailing his arms and crying out to the officers to beg them to help him let her get through. They would not. Eventually, my sister said, that an ambulance came from the Israeli side and some other Palestinian people carried her over to the waiting med personnel. This is the year 2008. This is treatment by a country that WE support and the whole world sees this and many many other scenarios like it and judge accordingly. Another incident is the Rachel Corrie story, if you want to google that. I will only tell you that this woman tried to block the demolition of a Palestinian home that the Israeli government was going to bulldoze. She stood right in front of the bulldozer. And it ran her over! If I talk too much more about this, I will start to cry. I know what you or many others would say. What about the hundreds of people killed in Israel by suicide bombers, or the rockets that are shot over. There is no excuse for the fanatical Arab violence. NON whatsoever. But, if you cage a person and treat them like animals, how does one expect them to behave? 

bidingmytime --- 18 years ago -

Forecaster, I thank you for allowing me this intellectual exchange. I thought that the article was good because it was written by a person who understands the Middle Eastern point of view and I was curious what they were thinking about our upcoming election. Just so you know, I am not anti-Israel. In fact, I am gratified to know that millions of young Israelis are working to support some kind of peaceful solution and that is good. 

haroldoftherocks --- 18 years ago -

 

bidingmytime --- 18 years ago -

OKkkk, but what did you think about the article?? 

AllenVanAllen --- 18 years ago -

Thanks bmt and Forecaster for that that thoughtful and enlightening dialog. 

bidingmytime --- 18 years ago -

Ohhh, thanks for saying that! I was wondering if you and T were up and had seen this thread. How are you tonite? 

smartypants --- 18 years ago -

I don't know if I have all my facts straight, but I'm pretty sure Yasir Arafat made demands vis a vis the Left Bank and Gaza Strip lands which he wanted for the creation of a Palestinian State. When those very lands were offered, he turned the offer down. (was it 1967?) Arafat and Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon were equally inept at reaching a solution for the Palestinians. Arafat's ideology was bland and his vision for Palestine mostly non existant...he strikes me as someone who was fond of being thought of as a revolutionary, but there isn't much substance to the title. Possession of Jerusalem will always be contested as it contains sites holy to 3 religions; therefore there will be no agreement unless they agree to share. 

smartypants --- 18 years ago -

The Arab world, except for assassinated President Gamal Nasser, doesn't seem very forthcoming with suggestions for solutions. Mostly we hear rhetoric about Israel being a "stinking corpse", or nothing, which is just as bad. This is their region of the world. IMO they should be more proactive in solving the problem. And if they did, whoever is our next President, would not play a major role, but a minor one. 

Forecaster --- 18 years ago -

I don't know if I have all my facts straight, but I'm pretty sure Yasir Arafat made demands vis a vis the Left Bank and Gaza Strip lands which he wanted for the creation of a Palestinian State. When those very lands were offered, he turned the offer down. (was it 1967?) Arafat and Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon were equally inept at reaching a solution for the Palestinians. Arafat's ideology was bland and his vision for Palestine mostly non existant...he strikes me as someone who was fond of being thought of as a revolutionary, but there isn't much substance to the title. Possession of Jerusalem will always be contested as it contains sites holy to 3 religions; therefore there will be no agreement unless they agree to share. I remember this as well. Arafat was indeed offered the land but there was no meeting of the minds between the two. History has shown that both of the countries prefer fighting to peace. 

AllenVanAllen --- 18 years ago -

We are doing well, tonight bmt. Thank you for asking! All is quite on the homefront! Hello to smarty and anyone else who happens to see this post! I know there has to be a way for peace in the middle-east. I have hope this one day will come to pass. 

Nightstorm --- 18 years ago -

Possession of Jerusalem will always be contested as it contains sites holy to 3 religions; therefore there will be no agreement unless they agree to share. What a concept. Simple yet impossible. How do you all feel about Hamas since they've been elected into power? 

smartypants --- 18 years ago -

Hello AllenVanAllen and family :) 

Nightstorm --- 18 years ago -

History has shown that both of the countries prefer fighting to peace. Because compromise is not part of either's vocabulary. I hold them equally responsible for the mess they're in. 

bidingmytime --- 18 years ago -

You are all right that Arafat and Sharon did negotiate, but both men, more so ARafat did not hold up their end of the bargain. First, the negotian was for much more than the land that they now have, and it was agreed upon, but then both sides were not faithful to their agreement. My personal opinion of Yassar Arafat is that he was a corrupt, terrorist, and did not do right by his people. Interesting that you ask me about Hamas. My answer could probably bring some turmoil, but here it goes. Hamas is the only power that historically has listened and stood b their word. However, obviously they have used fanatical and sometimes terroristic tactics that are wholly unacceptable. The Palestinian people listen to Hamas, and they even respect the police authority of Hamas, so if that is a power that can be used to work with them, why not use it. I don't think that it will mean we are bowing to a terrorist organization. Did you see in the news today, Mandela was finally taken off the terrorist watch list that we have had here in the U.S.?? Nelson Mandela! He was on the terrorist list because of his radical approach to opposition of Apartheid. Does Hamas have along way to come, of course, but if they are the power to work with and Israel is willing, then whatever works. 

bidingmytime --- 18 years ago -

I can see how most would hold them equally responsible. But, knowing the history as well as I do, I'm sorry, but I hold Israel and the U.S. even more responsible. The Arab people were there FIRST. Period. The way in which Israel was just given to the Jewish people was done very very poorly. Thankfully, the youth of Israel is seeing that the fanatical Zionist movement is more counterproductive to peace in the region. 

bidingmytime --- 18 years ago -

One important factor to remember is that the ARab people are tribal. They did not even have land deeds or paperwork to show who owned what land when the Jewish Zionists came to claim Israel. So, being more intellectual, and proactive, they "took" land from Arab families who had no recourse. I guess it is the "survival of the fittest modality" but still and all, it has turned into a blood bath because of it. And make no mistake, this war in the Middle East between Israel and Palestine is not at all about religion. It is about land. The Arabs were promised a certain land boundary and it was Never given. In fact, settlements were built right in the area that the Arabs were promised. Soooo, it just invited turbulence.... 

smartypants --- 18 years ago -

Hamas may be an organization that could go either way...peaceful diplomacy or terrorist aggression. They remind me of the IRA. I haven't seen much about them in the news lately, (but my attention has been focused on the presidential race), so if they can demonstrate peaceful intentions and restraint for awhile, that would open doors for diplomacy...always a good thing. 

bidingmytime --- 18 years ago -

Anyway, it is my fervant prayer that a new administration would be able to mediate some very positive dialog that would encourage and support more compromise and change in that region. If we had a President that really seemed to understand and want to help in that region. You know, knew the difference between Shiite and Sunni (Bush didn't even know the differences before invading Iraq), I really believe that we would be seen differently in the eyes of even the fanatical terrorists who hate us. The alternative is just too scary, and I don't think we have enough Homeland Security or weapons to deter the evil that could visit us from the al Queda's of the world. 

bidingmytime --- 18 years ago -

I think your analogy of Hamas and the IRA is right on. There is no excuse whatsoever for the terror and violence. However, we have seen in history that sometimes these tactics end up bringing change. Look at Ireland now. AMAZING, huh? 

smartypants --- 18 years ago -

I hold Israel and the U.S. even more responsible. The Arab people were there FIRST. Period. The way in which Israel was just given to the Jewish people was done very very poorly It was done poorly. The settlement of America was done poorly, if you look at it from the perspective of the American Indians. I feel for those Arabs who lost land that belonged to their families for generations, those who died needlessly. I also feel for the Jewish diaspora who faced generations of bigotry persecution and masacre merely because of their ethnicity. So now we have two groups on roughly the same patch of earth who have experienced unfairness. There is no one group who is going to entirely vacate. Looking back merely opens bitter wounds and resolves nothing. They BOTH must put away past mistakes and start again. 

Nightstorm --- 18 years ago -

Glad to see you guys are open-minded as am I regarding Hamas. I agree about Arrafat but I was no fan of Sharon either. Btw, I also have a bleeding heart for the Native Americans. 

Forecaster --- 18 years ago -

And make no mistake, this war in the Middle East between Israel and Palestine is not at all about religion. It is about land. The Arabs were promised a certain land boundary and it was Never given. For arguments sake let's say it was given to the Palestinians. I don't believe for one minute all the conflict would subside. Obama should understand his slip of support for the Palestinians is not looked favorably by the majority of the US. 

Forecaster --- 18 years ago -

Do any of you deny the holocaust? The jews have been persecuted and I see it as they are now being persecuted. They are the chosen people by God himself. Jesus died for their sins asking God for forgiveness for them. 

bidingmytime --- 18 years ago -

His slip of support for the Palestinians??? I don't like that. Anyone who has EVER seen the way these people have to live, better darn well have some compassion for them. Truly. The state of Israel is never going to be given to the Palestinians and they do not expect that. But, they do expect that the land boundaries for desginated in 1967 should be granted. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground