Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Are Hospital-Rental Breastpumps REALLY Better than the Medela Pump in Style?

who's talking here?

My3LilJuels 4
~grandma again~ 2
planemom 2
leslie 2
likenmori 1
OhCheesecake! 1
I ♥ My Thông 5
chunksNbones 2
3monkeysmomma 1
mommato3 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

I ♥ My Thông --- 18 years ago -

I need to figure out if the hospital grade rental pump is better than the Medela pump in style one. If you've rented before, please let me know! :) Thanks!! 

~grandma again~ --- 18 years ago -

I bet if you talked to Suzanne at Merry-Go-Round, she can give you the very best advice on that. 

OhCheesecake! --- 18 years ago -

I will give you an emphatic YES!!!!!!! 

mommato3 --- 18 years ago -

Yes they are. Again, I will say it. I am a perinatal nurse and from personal experience...I had the pump in style (it was a gift). The hospital grade medela symphony is a cadillac and the pump in style is a taurus. I am very appreciative of my gift and did use the heck out of it, but when I could, I used a pump on my unit. It mimics a baby. A baby empties the breast better than a pump, but for going back to work, if you have not invested in one or not have a love one who has purchased one for you, rent one :) 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

I never tried the hospital pumps. I was satisfied with the Medela. I used it for three of my kids, almost three years total. I was able to feed and pump at the same time or I could double pump if needed. But I has enough milk to feed an army so that may be why it was easy for me. 

leslie --- 18 years ago -

Definately the hospital grade ones are better!! I used the Medela Symphony and the pump in style and the Symphony was 10 times better 

leslie --- 18 years ago -

Definately the hospital grade ones are better!! I used the Medela Symphony and the pump in style and the Symphony was 10 times better 

3monkeysmomma --- 18 years ago -

I've used both. Rented the symphony after problems bfing 1st two kids. I think unless you have bfing issues you would be happy with the pump in style. I turned the symphony back in after 2 or three months and was fine with the pump in style after that. Consider your usage. Will you only be pumping? Have you had problems in the past? If you will be pumping occassionally to beef up your supply or store extra, then the pump in style should be ok. good luck! 

My3LilJuels --- 18 years ago -

the hospital grade pumps are much better -- the moters are more consistant, faster and stronger. They are rated to use without wearing out for about 50,000 hours, whereas the pump in style is designed for about 150 hours of use. Hospital pumps are treated as medical equipment, and the PIS is regulated by the FDA at the same level as your husband's electric razer. Most moms will produce more milk over time with the Symphony. 

~grandma again~ --- 18 years ago -

There ya go! I knew she could tell you everything you wanted to know about those things. She is an expert in that field, for sure. 

I ♥ My Thông --- 18 years ago -

Thank you SO much to all of you. Does anyone know if the medela symphony is available for purchase??? 

chunksNbones --- 18 years ago -

How's the baby Docswife? 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

Try here. 

I ♥ My Thông --- 18 years ago -

How's the baby Docswife? I'm just beside myself with worry. I had an appointment for her to see the doctor yesterday and she ended up taking some liquids from a new bottle (Avent) (also tried a new formula) so I thought I solved the problem. I canceled the appointment then by last night, same problem. Doc couldn't get me in today so we will be going out at 9:45 in the morning. I SHOULD have taken her in yesterday, but when she took a good amount in the new bottle, I thought maybe she didn't like the other ways I had tried to give it to her. Anyway, lesson learned. My middle son has a red throat, so I am guessing something is brewing in both of them. 

chunksNbones --- 18 years ago -

awww...well I hope they both get better soon! 

likenmori --- 18 years ago -

you can rent them from merry go round. I did that for a few months while my dd was in the hospital. 

My3LilJuels --- 18 years ago -

Most people rent - as the retail cost is about $1650 new. You will sometimes see them on eBay for about $1200, but you need to make sure you are buying from an actual Medela Dealer or Medela will not honor the warranty. We get requests to ship them all over so if you want to try one and there isn't a rental station near you (and if you won't be back in our area soon), we can ship it to you. 

I ♥ My Thông --- 18 years ago -

We get requests to ship them all over so if you want to try one and there isn't a rental station near you (and if you won't be back in our area soon), we can ship it to you. What do you charge per month? Also, does my pump in style tubing work with it so I don't have to buy an accessory kit? If it won't work, how much is it for the start up tubing kit? You're awesome. Thank you so much. I was stressing about renting one here, as I am not going to be here another month, but it was still half the cost to rent per week, so if I'm here more than another week, it would have been best to rent the whole month, etc. blah.. long story short, I was confused on what to do! You're awesome for offering to ship it. I look forward to the details on it!! 

My3LilJuels --- 18 years ago -

Sorry I'm just getting back to you -- swim team had me wiped out yesterday. Anyway, we charge actual shipping cost to ship (about $30 - $35). Our monthly rental is $65/month (rates go down the longer you rent for). You will need new tubes and the Symphony connector if you don't have them already. Tubes are about $5 each and the connector kit is $20. Hope that helps. I'll be at the store today from 1-5 if you want to call me. 

I ♥ My Thông --- 18 years ago -

Im coming home next week so I will plan to come by and rent it. Do you have it in stock to rent? Will this help to increase my supply and not just maintain it? 

My3LilJuels --- 18 years ago -

Yes, we have them available. As to increasing your supply, yes, it should help. I noticed a old post where you said you were bleeding while pumping with your PIS, so please bring your PIS parts with you so that we can make sure you are using the correct size shield. Just give us a call when you get back and I'll setup an appointment time for you. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground