Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Question for Christians

who's talking here?

freshhell 1
eterry2 1
bbjones 1
Zionist NightOwl 4
KingTruth 2
Angela 1
Astro King 1
KwdFoodie 3
momof5 10
junkyard dog 5
onestepforward 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

momof5 --- 18 years ago -

On the Obama thread, some people were saying the Islam God is the same as the Christian God, and others strongly disagreed mostly based on the statement the they don't recognize Jesus as the son of God. So, does that mean that Jews worship a different God as well? They don't recognize Jesus as the savior either...I just wanted to clear up any confusion. 

onestepforward --- 18 years ago -

I don't think that you will be able to clear up the confusion since this is a question of faith ;) Many people do believe/have faith that all 3 are connected via Abraham. 

momof5 --- 18 years ago -

I just thought it was an interesting question since so many were against the idea that Islam and Christianity would share the same God. You would think they would feel the same way about Jews, but that was never mentioned, so I thought I would ask here. 

Zionist NightOwl --- 18 years ago -

does that mean that Jews worship a different God as well? NO, Jews and Christians worship the same God, YHVH. They share the same Scriptures up until the Brit HaDasha (New Testament), which chronicles Jesus' life and the lives of his earliest followers. Christians believe that Jesus was the Messiah spoken of in the Jewish writings, although most Jews believe that Jesus was not the prophesied Messiah. others strongly disagreed mostly based on the statement that they don't recognize Jesus as the son of God That is not the reason why many believers think that Allah and YWVH are not one and the same. It is because they believe that Allah was worshiped as a pagan deity well before Abraham was even born. One cannot worship a polytheistic, pagan god and then say that that is who Abraham was really worshipping as the monotheistic deity. I admit that I know very little about Islam. I have no idea whether the following text is true or not; perhaps someone who is Muslim can refute or affirm it. But this is one of the texts I found just by a quick google on whether Allah and Yahweh are one and the same: Is Allah The Same God As The God Of The Bible?, M. J. Afshari, p 6, 8-9 "That Islam was conceived in idolatry is shown by the fact that many rituals performed in the name of Allah were connected with the pagan worship that existed before Islam. And today, millions of Moslems pray towards Mecca, where the famous revered black stone is located. 1.Before Islam Allah was reported to be know as: the supreme of a pantheon of gods; the name of a god whom the Arabs worshipped; the chief god of the pantheon; Ali-ilah; the god; the supreme; the all-powerful; all-knowing; and totally unknowable; the predeterminer of everyone’s life destiny; chief of the gods; the special deity of the Quraish; having three daughters: Al Uzzah (Venus), Manah (Destiny), and Alat; having the idol temple at Mecca under his name (House of Allah).; the mate of Alat, the goddess of fate. 2.Because the Ka’aba, the sacred shrine which contains the Black Stone, in Mecca was used for pagan idol worship before Islam and even called the House of Allah at that time. 3.Because the rituals involved with the Islamic Pilgrimage are either identical or very close to the pre-Islamic pagan idol worship at Mecca. 4. Because of other Arabian history which points to heathen worship of the sun, moon, and the stars, as well as other gods, of which I believe Allah was in some way connected to. This then would prove to us that Allah is not the same as the true God of the Bible whom we worship, because God never changes." (Is Allah The Same God As The God Of The Bible?, M. J. Afshari, p 6, 8-9) http://www.bible.ca/islam/library/islam-quotes-afshari.htm 

onestepforward --- 18 years ago -

I see your point about Jews. Good question. 

momof5 --- 18 years ago -

Okay, Nightowl, I hope the people that posted in the Obama thread read what you wrote since their argument was that it could not be the same God because Islam didn't believe Jesus was the son of God. Thanks for your answer. : ) 

Zionist NightOwl --- 18 years ago -

This article I just found gets into the argument from more of a (Southern Baptist) theological perspective: Are God & Allah the same?  

momof5 --- 18 years ago -

that article is basically saying the same thing, that they don't believe Jesus is the son of God, therefore they can't believe in the same God. So, that being said, Jews feeling the same way, they cannot believe in the same God. How can you have it apply to one but not the other? This is what the article boils down too...direct quote from it... Today, similar debate has revolved around the two largest faiths in the world, Islam and Christianity, and whether the god of the Koran is the God of the Bible. Simply put, the god of Muhammad is not the Father of Jesus. The subject in its essence is not a linguistic issue, but a theological matter with eternal ramifications. To say that since Allah is Arabic for God and YHWH is Hebrew for God, Christians and Muslims worship the same God is beyond naïve ?- it is blasphemous. 

Angela --- 18 years ago -

Jews feeling the same way, they cannot believe in the same God. How can you have it apply to one but not the other? Jews do believe in the same God that Christians do. They just do not believe that Jesus was the Messiah. They believe he was a prophet. Same God. Same Old Testament. 

Zionist NightOwl --- 18 years ago -

But the Jewish and the Christian religions are identical with the exception of Jesus' role. We use the same Tanakh (Old Testament: Torah, Prophets, and Wisdom books). 

momof5 --- 18 years ago -

So because they use the Koran, that makes them not believe in the same God, not because of Jesus, but because they use a different book. Okay, well, again, I hope the Christians that sited that they aren't the same because they don't believe Jesus is the son of God will realize that Jews don't believe that either, but that's okay because they use the same book. 

momof5 --- 18 years ago -

I'm just trying to understand the logic...that's all. Thanks for the answers, I really do appreciate it. 

eterry2 --- 18 years ago -

I'm just trying to understand the logic Religion often defies logic 

Zionist NightOwl --- 18 years ago -

I have to go. But I wish I could continue this very interesting dialogue. Thank you, momof5, for starting it. I guess what I'm saying is that the Jewish and Christian religions are the same--same sacred texts, same everything. The earliest believers in Jesus were Jewish men and women who believed that Jesus was their Messiah. They existed in the synagogues for many years alongside the Jewish non-believers, until the political differences between them caused a split and the believers had to leave and form their own Messianic Congregations. (As a derogatory term, they were labeled "Christians" by the nonbelievers.) That is a very interesting time, historically, which I have studied and which I'd like to share but I have to run. Islam's history is very different. I found another article that I found interesting. Again, I apologize that I have to rely on Google, because I don't know much about Islam. But I'll post this last article in the hope that it sheds some light on why I think Allah is a completely different deity: Allah - the Moon God 

momof5 --- 18 years ago -

Thank you NightOwl, for all of your info and viewpoints. I just had to ask when I was reading that other thread, it really threw me for a loop! Have a good day! Thanks again. : ) 

bbjones --- 18 years ago -

Jews do believe in the same God that Christians do. Technically Jews and Christians have the same God, but the Jews turned the laws that God gave them into a religion. In other words, they worship the law more than they worship God. They believe that the law saves them and not God. They do not believe in a triune God. They do not believe that God became flesh and died for their sins in order to give them salvation. So, in reality, the Jewish concept of God is not the same as the Christian concept. Sadly, many people who say they have put their faith in Jesus Christ do the same thing as the Jews and turn religious. They think that their efforts in keeping the old laws will make them acceptable to God. God dying in the flesh and our belief and recognition of that sacrifice is what makes us acceptable to God. 

freshhell --- 18 years ago -

Jews, Christians, and Moslems all believe in basically the same god. There is so much overlap. All 3 are basically patriarchal. The man is the boss. That is all I need to know. Thank you very much. Freshy has left the synagogue. 

KwdFoodie --- 18 years ago -

Who says god is a HE. She isn't! 

junkyard dog --- 18 years ago -

Jews, Christians, and Moslems all believe in basically the same god. Nope. Not the case. Looks like you didn't read the previous posts. 

KwdFoodie --- 18 years ago -

So, in reality, the Jewish concept of God is not the same as the Christian concept. According to you. 

junkyard dog --- 18 years ago -

Who says god is a HE. She isn't! God does. He is the Father. Don't know of any she that is a father. 

Astro King --- 18 years ago -

momof5, I'm late to join in, but hey, I would like to help answer your original question if that is okay. First of all, thank you for thinking about religion in the first place. So many people in today's society don't give it a minute of their time. You've done much more, so thank you. Now to what you're after. Islam rejects the Trinity (the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit) that is integral to Christianity. Muslims believe that Jesus was a great man and prophet but that He was not God incarnate. Muslims believe that Christians believe in three gods, which is not correct. We believe in one God in which there are three parts - Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. Islam also denies that Jesus was crucified. Now that said, no matter what you think of Muslims, we as Christians are called to love one another. Respect is key - no, we're not supposed to reject our own Christian beliefs and promote Islam. Far from it. We just need to treat our Muslim friends as human beings, deserving fair and equal treatment. That's the best way to show them God's love. 

KingTruth --- 18 years ago -

So, in reality, the Jewish concept of God is not the same as the Christian concept. According to you. I decree that the truth is...it would be according to the difference of what the Jews believe and the Christians believe. If it was the same, then there wouldn't be two different names for the beliefs. 

momof5 --- 18 years ago -

Islam rejects the Trinity (the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit) that is integral to Christianity. Yes, but Jews reject that idea too, so how can you say they believe in the same God, based on that answer, they would not. 

momof5 --- 18 years ago -

I can understand if you say, that based on their belief of the Koran, they would not not believe in the same God. But if your only basis of saying they don't is that they dont' believe in the trinity, then, neither do the Jews, therefore, you wouldn't be worshipping the same God. That was my original question. 

junkyard dog --- 18 years ago -

According to you. This has been a really civil thread. Why is it necessary to interject those types of comments? Why don't you add something pertinent to the discussion instead? 

momof5 --- 18 years ago -

they would not not believe in the same God. only one "not" should be there...sorry. lol. 

KwdFoodie --- 18 years ago -

This has been a really civil thread. Why is it necessary to interject those types of comments? Why don't you add something pertinent to the discussion instead? It was according to him, IOWs how he interprets it. And furthermore, what a coincidence, but you sound just like Jonezie. 

junkyard dog --- 18 years ago -

It was according to him, IOWs how he interprets it. And furthermore, what a coincidence, but you sound just like Jonezie. There you go with accusations again. How could I sound like anyone on a forum? Do you have some kind of super duper computer that I have never heard of that relays my voice and other people's voices to you? Now, let's get back to the topic. I don't think that anyone has to interpret the difference between the Jewish beliefs and the Christian beliefs. I believe that it is pretty obvious. 

KingTruth --- 18 years ago -

And furthermore, what a coincidence, but you sound just like Jonezie. I decree that the truth is...Bill Cosby uses the term Jonezie...what a coincidence...does that mean you sound like Bill and therefore are the same person? 

junkyard dog --- 18 years ago -

I decree that the truth is...Bill Cosby uses the term Jonezie...what a coincidence...does that mean you sound like Bill and therefore are the same person? lol Exactly 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground