Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Could anybody tell me what an eight year old's punishment should be?

who's talking here?

coach'sgirl 1
amb07 2
RotorHead 1
chunksNbones 1
Raia's Mommy 1
captureit11 2
Rednose 1
bidingmytime 1
Lucykarragen777 4
pollyanna 1
UmSeriously 3
Meme2my5 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Lucykarragen777 --- 18 years ago -

What would it be? spanking, grounding, what? If an eight year old pushed his/her little sister down stairs on purpose? What would you do? 

amb07 --- 18 years ago -

From the top of the stairs? 

UmSeriously --- 18 years ago -

Whoa. That's major. In this scenario, I'd wear their little bottom out then go from there. Grounding, chores, writing sentences, etc... The only times I believe in corporal punishment are when the child is in danger of hurting themself or hurting someone else. 

Lucykarragen777 --- 18 years ago -

Thats nice. 

amb07 --- 18 years ago -

No mental/psychological problems? 

Lucykarragen777 --- 18 years ago -

Writing sentences? I never thought of that. 

captureit11 --- 18 years ago -

ah "write sentences" i used to do that ALL the time..i hate it! but i learned 

captureit11 --- 18 years ago -

we used to write "i will not back talk mom and dad" one time we had to write them 1,000 times! SUCKED!! 500 times was the least. 

Lucykarragen777 --- 18 years ago -

Woa. 

UmSeriously --- 18 years ago -

So did this happen to you, or is it just a hypothetical situation? 

Meme2my5 --- 18 years ago -

sit with her at the table and ask her why she would do this,sometimes it comes from anger at the other child and sometimes it is from jealousy. try to find out which it is and deal with it from that point of view. 

Rednose --- 18 years ago -

The best punishment for my 8 year old is no TV for a week of two. When he got that punishment, he asked me if he could have a spanking instead and that is when I knew I had got him where it hurt the most. When he complained about the no TV. I would have him tell me why he wasn't allowed to watch TV and trust me, he as been better since. 

RotorHead --- 18 years ago -

Lucky,is it your child? Are you satisfied the way your parents handled you even though they didn't have an Internet message board to come to for advice? I apologize if they contacted Ann Landers for advice. 

UmSeriously --- 18 years ago -

I read Ann Landers religiously when I was a little kid. lol 

chunksNbones --- 18 years ago -

if I had done something like that at 8 years old, I'd have gotten some serious spankings... And seriously I read advice columns all the time when I was a kid too! Still love em!haha 

coach'sgirl --- 18 years ago -

The only times I believe in corporal punishment are when the child is in danger of hurting themself or hurting someone else. If my son did that...my first response would be to beat the daylights out of him because I would be so scared and upset...then go from there...there would be more!! I do like the sentence thing though...my son would HATE that!! 

Raia's Mommy --- 18 years ago -

lucy did you push your sister down the stairs? 

bidingmytime --- 18 years ago -

the idea of parenting is trying to get the kid to understand what they did and how it was wrong. I'm not against a corporal punishment, but if you've used that often (I'm talking a swift swat on the butt) at all, then it's effectiveness wears quickly. There is a reason that he felt he wanted to do that. Even if it was impulsiveness. It would be wise to watch them both when they don't know you are watching and see what's going on in their relationship. Take the child out of the environment (out of the house) somewhere not familial and show him some type of example of what he did. Like point out a situation similiar and ask him what he thinks of that....then try to relate what he is witnessing to what he did. 

pollyanna --- 18 years ago -

If you decide to do the sentences...I would recommend using positive language to form the sentence, such as "I will treat my sister kindly...etc. Children tend to ignore the "not" in the sentence, so if it was "I will not be mean to my sister" you are actually reinforcing the opposite. Just a suggestion. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground