Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Homeschool vs Public school

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 3
Sweetie Pie 1
JerseyGirl 1
cmi 3
Fancy 1
planemom 1
lLackCreativity 3
amb07 1
qpc 3
4nTX 1
Tyrus 1
ditsterz 6
BaylorMom 5
ladybeachbum 4
m•t•v 2
Homeschool mom 2
addipie 1
KingTruth 1
Itty Bitty Prints 1
Sue 1
village_mom 1
Cherish You 2
pamperedpaws 1
momof5 7
MomTimesFive 1
lovetoteach 2
UmSeriously 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

momof5 --- 18 years ago -

Here in Kingwood we have an excellent public school system. I was just curious why so many people still choose to do homeschooling. I understand it if the schools are bad or you child has a learning disability of some type. Otherwise, I'm not sure why someone would opt to teach them at home. 

ditsterz --- 18 years ago -

1.some people feel that public schools arent good enough. 2. some people are extremely religious and want to incorporate religion in every subject their child learns. 3.some people want to completely shelter their child from outside influences. 

UmSeriously --- 18 years ago -

A lot of homeschoolers think public school doesn't give the children enough room to express their individuality. They see them as forcing conformity down their children's throats and trying to force them into the same mold as everyone else. A lot of it can also be for religious reasons as well. 

addipie --- 18 years ago -

I do not home school but have a friend that does... ONE of her main reasons has to do with things going on in schools (violence)-she feels the kids are safer with her. I know this is not her only reason but she really feels stongly about this part 

momof5 --- 18 years ago -

I just wonder also, if they protect their kids from the world now, and they expect them to go to college, how prepared will they be? The only authority for education they've had is their own parent! The influences at college are far greater and temptations to do "bad" things stronger, how will they handle that never having to deal with their peers on a daily basis? 

cmi --- 18 years ago -

Some do it because they know how much time is wasted in public schools. 

momof5 --- 18 years ago -

With the amount of work my kids do at school and at home, I find that hard to believe. The people that I know that do homeschool, spend maybe 3 hours a day on lessons. That's a shorter day than public school. 

ditsterz --- 18 years ago -

i also could see someone homeschooling b/c their child has problems fitting in w/ peers and being accepted. 

momof5 --- 18 years ago -

That's an understandable reason to homeschool, you don't want your child to not have an education because the environment is so difficult for them. 

Itty Bitty Prints --- 18 years ago -

My mom taught 5th grade for 35 years in a public school in my hometown. She says that every single year she got at least 1 child who had previously been home schooled. They were coming back to public school for the first time at that point. She said they were always way behind the other kids. She said they always struggled to stay on the grade level work. My mom chalked it up to this....she said the home schooled child would know TONS about one thing and zero about something else. She was not a fan of homeschooling for that reason. I applaud the moms who do it. It is not an easy job. 

cmi --- 18 years ago -

With the amount of work my kids do at school and at home, I find that hard to believe. The people that I know that do homeschool, spend maybe 3 hours a day on lessons. That's my point. There is a lot of time wasted in a school day that doesn't get wasted at home with just a few kids to educate. 

Sweetie Pie --- 18 years ago -

In my opinion, don't homeschool and then put them in public HIGH school here in Kingwood. Homeschool them all the way thru high school. I have a friend whose son was literally in such a culture shock by being placed in a regular high school he couldn't function. A lot of what is learned in school, other than academics, is social survival, just like in the rest of the world. If kids are sheltered from this skill for years and placed in a school like KHS its a huge problem. 

Homeschool mom --- 18 years ago -

We homeschool for several reasons. My oldest needs more focused attention, and he can't get that in a classroom of twenty or more students. We incorporate the Bible into our homeschool as well, something else not possible in the public schools. Our children are learning at their own pace in a loving, supportive environment. We are able to take field trips with other homeschoolers, my K son takes a PE class at Kingwood Athletic Club twice a week where he interacts with children of all ages, not just ones his age. We find this works for us. It is not for everybody though. I don't claim that this is the "only" way. We are finishing up 2nd and K right now. 

amb07 --- 18 years ago -

Some do it because they know how much time is wasted in public schools. ITA- why a student has to sit through an hour lesson on something he/she understood the first time the teacher explained it is a total waste of time. When I was in middle school you could choose to take your math and grammar courses through modules. They were great and no time was wasted. Most of us completed the whole course well before the end of the year. It was great because you had to pass each module before moving on. The education was much more personalized. I imagine that is what homeschool is like. 

lLackCreativity --- 18 years ago -

I want to homeschool and DH is very against it. My reasons FOR it are: I can ensure she gets a broad education that covers all the things, I as her parent, feel are important. Not just want the state says. I also would like to avoid introducing her into a world of peers that are accepting of "bad" things like drugs sex and violence. I will/do teach her about those things in MY way, a way that I feel is safer and more productive. And lastly I feel by homeschooling her the right way I can ensure that she becomes a strong, productive, smart, confident young woman in whatever world she may end up in. His reasons against are: She will not have proper socialization skills. She will not be prepared for confrontations and complicated situations. Her education will be varied and possibly lack in areas. Her ability to fit in later will be hampered. She will resent us and feel like she was repressed or sheltered too much. 

momof5 --- 18 years ago -

ILackCreativity, I can see both sides. However, I agree more with your husband. The problem with not allowing them to socialize in a school setting from a young age on, and having them only around people of your choosing, makes it difficult for them later in life. When they go to college and work they are now faced with people and personalities they've had no exposure to, and lack the skills to deal with them. I think it's possible to instill your morals and values and have your children in public schools. They're at home as much as they are at school. As long as you give them a good foundation and are supportive all along the way, they'll do great. The world is out there, we can do what we can to protect them from it, but putting them in a bubble isn't the answer. That's just my opinion of course. Good luck with your decision. 

Tyrus --- 18 years ago -

She will not have proper socialization skills. She will not be prepared for confrontations and complicated situations. Those reasons are fallacies. Homeschooled children obtain plenty of socialization. "Homeschool Myths: Kids Who Home School Have Poor Social Skills Personal Experience and Research on Homeschooling and Socialization By Momie Tullottes, published Mar 17, 2008 As the concept of homeschooling continues to ease back into the mainstream, where it began, more and more questions and myths seem to follow. There is a great deal of controversy and confusion surrounding what exactly homeschool is, where it originated, what motivates people to choose homeschooling, and what may or may not be involved in the daily activities of a home school. In this, and other articles on the myths of homeschool, I plan to explore and help shed some light on some of these myths surrounding homeschool. My findings will come from personal experience and sometimes be combined with research studies or other evidence. One myth that is very often assumed of home schooled kids is that they do not have proper social skills or don't interact with others. If I had a dollar for every time someone asked me about my children or home school in general in relation to socialization, I'd likely be rich. Unfortunately for my wallet, that isn't the case. While at first thought, considering the fact that school is often assumed to be done only inside the home, it seems that a social environment may be unavailable. However, a homeschooled child may actually have more opportunity than others to gain positive social skills and interact with people. One reason for this is that because of the flexibility in class scheduling, as well as the unique opportunity to learn whenever or wherever desired, homeschoolers are often around a variety of people during the day. In fact, in a study published by the NHERI (National Home Education Research Institute), home school students had scores in social skills that were higher than those of kids in public schools. As a home school parent, this study doesn't surprise me at all, as I continue to see positive social results from home school in my children who previously attended public school." 

Cherish You --- 18 years ago -

i have homeschooled for 6 years now. what i'm reading here is a vast misinterpretation of what one assumes happens to homeschoolers across the board. May i first say there are plenty of public school children who are carrying more problems than they should for their age due to "socialization". I think that term is used loosely, and many people feel that a teen is healthier if they get to "hang out" with their peers. I personally find that a child with a vision and dream finds more satisfaction pursuing that with his spare time than hanging out at the mall. What you are not aware of is how much is offered to homeschoolers. There is so much, that you literally have to choose what is best for your family! And all of these opportunities afford homeschooled students a vast array of interactive experiences with the real public. When they go to college and work they are now faced with people and personalities they've had no exposure to, and lack the skills to deal with them I disagree with this...take your average office job...what is the age range of the folks in there? you'll find young folks all the way to up to folks who have been there from the beginning. The real world interaction is not an age based peer interaction. There are people of differing ages and experiences. The homeschooled child who has been afforded the vast array of opportunities will be better equipped to handle the differences verses a teenager who spends most of their time with "peers". Another great benefit of homeschooling is beginning in 10th grade, these students are being accepted into Jr college and finishing Associate degrees by the time they graduate from high school...now how's that for real life interaction! and while your public school students are eating cheetos with each other during lunch...homeschooled families across america are working businesses and reaching the elderly. research shows that most homeschooled students are above average academically than they were years ago when homeschooling first started. They're at home as much as they are at school really? most leave at 6:30 a.m. and are not home till 4:30 p.m. public school students are gone an average of 8 - 10 hours away from family influence. who is influencing them during those 8 - 10 hours? then they come home for dinner, homework, tv and bed. so lets say 5 - 9 p.m. 4 hours. that's a huge difference of time! and let's get even more real...most of that 4 hours at home is spent with the tv on! so how much influence is the parent really doing? We all have a huge job of raising our children the best we can...and just because someone chooses a different route that you would doesn't make them wrong, and nor does it mean they made a poorer choice. No one is above messing up. Location of education is not the answer...it's the training at home that matters!!!! 

lLackCreativity --- 18 years ago -

I think a bubble is a deadly idea. Its like tossing a baby seal in a shark tank. My opinion: I want to give her all the tools she needs to survive, teach her all the morals, show her right from wrong and then cross my fingers. She will attend public school but DH has accepted that I will teach her at home too and be a VERY active participant in her education. All any parent of a kid, homeschool or regular, can do is try to be there for the kid:) 

momof5 --- 18 years ago -

All any parent of a kid, homeschool or regular, can do is try to be there for the kid:) I agree completely! I appreciate everyone's posts and input on the subject. I think making your family a priority is what really matters. 

m•t•v --- 18 years ago -

and just because someone chooses a different route that you would doesn't make them wrong, and nor does it mean they made a poorer choice. No one is above messing up. Location of education is not the answer...it's the training at home that matters!!!!  You just said just cause it's different doesn't mean it's wrong, but then that the training at HOME does... What's the difference bt training at home and home schooling, exactly??? jumbo shrimp, dry ice, whatever other contradiction you can think of.... 

lLackCreativity --- 18 years ago -

IMO training at home isnt something you do only with a kid in homeschool. Parents should teach the kids all the time at home. How to be responsible, how to be kind, how to be polite, how to use logic, etc etc. My DD is going to be in public school but what I teach her when she is at home with me will be just as important as what the teachers do! 

Cherish You --- 18 years ago -

salt on watermelon! ROFL 

m•t•v --- 18 years ago -

IMO training at home isnt something you do only with a kid in homeschool. Parents should teach the kids all the time at home. How to be responsible, how to be kind, how to be polite, how to use logic, etc etc. My DD is going to be in public school but what I teach her when she is at home with me will be just as important as what the teachers do!  OK - sorry, was thinking the terms were being used interchangeably 

ditsterz --- 18 years ago -

lpublic school students are gone an average of 8 - 10 hours away from family influence. my kids are gone 7 hrs a day and thats ok w/ me b/c i dont feel the need to create a clone of myself that is brainwashed w/ my ideas and beliefs. 

BaylorMom --- 18 years ago -

I just wonder also, if they protect their kids from the world now, and they expect them to go to college, how prepared will they be? The only authority for education they've had is their own parent! The influences at college are far greater and temptations to do "bad" things stronger, how will they handle that never having to deal with their peers on a daily basis? I have a friend who homeschooled her two sons all through their 12 years of school. Both of her sons went to Baylor, one graduated and is an engineer, the other on just graduated Baylor Law school and is a lawyer. They were actively involved in college, on student council and in many activities. In fact they were more adjusted then most coming from public school. Can I also say they both got scholarships due to their SAT scores. You cannot judge some kids that come from homeschool, just like you can't judge all public school kids. My point is usually homeschool kids are better adjusted to handle everyday issues. Everyone assumes that homeschool kids are locked away in their homes and not socializing with anyone. In fact quite the opposite, they can get along with more age groups than public school kids, because they are with more than just their own age group. 

momof5 --- 18 years ago -

that's quite a success story for your friend. She definitely did an excellent job with her sons. I hope most people do that well. The ones that I personally have come into contact with seemed immature for their age, and didn't understand social cues. These were kids that were in my children's dance classes and baseball teams. So, I have somewhat limited exposure, but based on my personal experience, I didn't see the maturity or social growth expected of their age. 

BaylorMom --- 18 years ago -

She will attend public school but DH has accepted that I will teach her at home too and be a VERY active participant in her education. The way you worded this sounds like your child isn't in school. The problem is the public school doesn't want the parents involved in the schooling. Yes they want you to help with their homework and such as that, but they really don't want you input on anything else. I had a teacher once tell me that she spent most of her time controlling the students that caused trouble, that she didn't have much time to teach or help the ones that really needed it. I am not talking about kids that just talk or something little like that. Now days it is alot more than that. 

Sue --- 18 years ago -

Most of the time, I guess, home schooling is ok. I read of a homeschooled stduent that was at the top of the class somewhere.. However, the guys who desecrated the grave in Humble were supposedly homeschooled. Obviously it did them no good. We have neighbors who homechool their elementary twins. Those boys never play with any neighborhood children, are only out when a parent is which is rare. I believe that's wrong. 

ditsterz --- 18 years ago -

i dont think having your kids socialize w/ only peers that are just like them is ideal. 

ditsterz --- 18 years ago -

The ones that I personally have come into contact with seemed immature for their age, and didn't understand social cues same here 

BaylorMom --- 18 years ago -

dont think having your kids socialize w/ only peers that are just like them is ideal. Or you trying to refer that homeschooled kids only socialize with peers that are just like themselves. First of all that isn't so, they socialize with alot of different people. Most homeschooler do volunteer work and all. Now my kids are grown, but I don't think I have to allow my kids to socialize with druggies and rebellious children just so they can be well rounded. By the way, I don't think it is wrong for a parent if they choose public school, at the same time I think if you want to homeschool that is fine also. 

ladybeachbum --- 18 years ago -

We did it all starting with Christian Schools which for values is good but I wouldn't advise for learning. Then in 5th we left to homeschool until the 8th because we really wanted to stay more at the beach. In 8th back to Christian until I realized he wasn't being taught. Now, he is graduating from Quest. He did have a hard time not knowing anyone at first but he loved it and tells our neighbor that homeschools to put the kids in school. He was never behind but because of vocabulary issues with the Christian School, I often think he is lacking in that area. Man, he knows the Bible though! You just have to do the best thing for your child and your family and hope that it works out and your child turns out great. Mine did and for that I praise God and all the teachers along the way. 

BaylorMom --- 18 years ago -

We did it all starting with Christian Schools which for values is good but I wouldn't advise for learning I wouldn't characterize all Private schools here, there are good ones and bad ones, just like in public schools. My children come from a Private school, they went to up in Arlington Tx. Almost all of the class went on to college, and in fact most of them said there first year at college was a breeze because of the hard courses that they took in private school. I just read that there are approximately 380,000 students in college that fail each year. One of the reason was that they weren't prepared to handle the work. The article stated that student coming into college weren't used to the amount of work, doing it on there own. That is why they fail, and that is why my oldest son's school prepared them. Now my second son went private all his life through tenth grade, we had to move to humble due to a divorce, and he chose public school. He went to Humble High, with the counselor saying he should go back to private because they wouldn't take the credits due to the private school not accredited. They said noone had gone in with what suppose to be his junior year with no credits and graduated on time. Guess what he did graduate on time, he had to take a summer class and many test but he did it. The funny thing is in public school he made almost all A's and few B's. Where in private he was a B and C student. Why, because the private was alot harder than the public was, according to him. I am sorry for this long comment, just I hate it when people have a bad experience with one private school and charaterize all of the schools to be bad. 

cmi --- 18 years ago -

I didn't see the maturity or social growth expected of their age. Which could be why they were homeschooled. My son is going into K. He is delayed socially and exhibits immature behavior for his age. He is great academically and he has been great with his little PPCD class of 5 kids. But, when he goes into K, if he shuts down b/c of the social issues, we will homeschool him. However, it is b/c of the social delays and immaturity. The homeschooling isn't what will cause it. 

village_mom --- 18 years ago -

His reasons against are: She will not have proper socialization skills. She will not be prepared for confrontations and complicated situations. I was homeschooled my highschool years because the church school I attended was not accredited and I would have had to repeat a grade. The school would not let me test in. The worst part about home schooling for me was missing out on socialization skills. It has really affected my ability to interact with other adults now. If you homeschool, please make sure she has plenty of opportunities to interact with other kids her age. It's very important. 

lovetoteach --- 18 years ago -

Ilackcreativity, if you want to homeschool, there is a great homeschool/private school called Paideia. The kids go to school on Wednesdays, and then you teach them the curriculum the other days of the week. Plus, there is something called "Fun Fridays" where homeschooled kids take fun classes for about four hours on Friday. Also, in Kingwood, there is a homeschool boy scout troop. If you want your child to be well-rounded, there are many opportunities. There are boy/girl scouts, a musical instrument lesson, AWANA (a Christian club), a sport, etc... All those things where they can socialize with kids their own age! I am so excited next year to be homeschooling my son. He is only 6. I don't want to throw him out into the "real world" yet. I need to build a strong foundation on which he can stand, and the way some children are not being protected from adult situations makes even elementary school the "real world." 

qpc --- 18 years ago -

The way I see it, you will find "weird" kids that have been homeschooled, "bad" kids that have been homeschooled, "socially immature" kids that have been homeschooled, etc, BUT you will find EVERY SINGLE ONE of those traits in PUBLICLY EDUCATED and privately educated kids as well. I think we have the tendancy to look at just a very small sample (1-2 families) and judge the whole lot based on what we see from them, especially if it fits our preconceived notions about what something is like. For instance, the person who mentioned that the boys who desecrated the grave were homeschooled as an example of homeschooled kid behavior.....If the kids had gone to public school, would it then have been how the majority of public school kids act? My kids have been in public, private, and homeschooled (however, this was for a very short time). I see the value in each and every one of the options have pros and cons for our family (as they would for every family). What is best for one family is not necessarily best for every family. My kids are in public school this year after coming from a private Christian school. I will say that they tested "gifted and talented" (all four of my school aged kids) and were WELL above many of their classmates in many subject. They've also been "educated" in some less than appropriate subject matters too and picked up some really bad behavior patterns which we are fighting to counter (this is esp true with the older kids). We are happy with our decision, but there are DEFINITELY some NEGATIVES to having our kids in public school. When I was working at a school in the Dallas suburbs, I was called in (I was the nurse) because a 2nd grader told his classmates all about "69" and they wanted ME to do damage control (I guess they thought that since I was a nurse it was somehow better). OK....so the kids were "socialized", but do they NEED to be socialized in that way at the age of 8? This was also 10 years ago, so I can only imagine some of the socialization that goes on now. I know many homeschooled families. Some have "weird" kids but most have very intelligent, well-rounded, and VERY normal children. I would suggest that you hang out with Blessed's or Goldilock's families if you want to see some of the "normal" homeschooled families :) I can TOTALLY understand why they do what they do, and they are quite successful at it. 

lovetoteach --- 18 years ago -

Thank you, QPC! I wanted to say more, but didn't quite know how to put it so nicely. (o: Also, my dad just told me that there is a court ruling or law (can't remember which one) that homeschooled kids can go to classes at the public school and can also join the sports teams in public school. 

JerseyGirl --- 18 years ago -

I don't know how these home schooled children are going to function in the real world when they get out in it. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground