Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Business travellers: What's your opinion on....

who's talking here?

marthas attic 3
~grandma again~ 1
cmi 1
Mr. Brady (L's D) 1
gking 20
AuthorMan 1
Pet Lover 1
OhCheesecake! 2
I Kissed Frogs 2
mamajulie 1
txjboy 1
sparkle 5
Ialwayswantedtobenamedsara 2
Vedette 1
ghostpost 1
Bigben 2
Stonebridge 1
Wickenburg 2
Intel Inside® 4
Transported Man 1
Atasca Mom 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Business travellers: What's your opinion on....

Private Car Vote
 
 39.4% (13)
Commercial Flight Vote
 
 60.6% (20)
gking --- 18 years ago -

Taking a private car versus a commercial airline for one day trips to Dallas, Fort Worth, San Antonio, Austin, etc. Things to keep in mind: Private car - will cost about 3x's as much as last-minute airfare, but could actually cost less if 3 or more travel together. - would pick you up at your door and take you right to your ultimate destination. This eliminates unproductive time getting to the airport early, checking in, going through security, non-use of electronic equipment during ascent and descent, taxiing time, deplaning and baggage claim hassles. - allows for much better utilization of travel time for "conferencing"/productivity. - eliminates the need for ground transportation to and from departure and destination airports (or relying on colleagues to pick you up, etc.). - could be booked last-minute for exactly what time you wanted/needed to come and go - even while you were away, the car would be at your service. Commercial Airline - as already mentioned, would necessitate planning extra hours (and expense) to get to and from airports, check-in procedures, baggage check, security check, etc. - get herded on and off plane - very little actual time to do anything productive on such short flights. - rare availability of exactly the departure times desired, and even then - subject to change or cancellation So....given these factors to consider - the question is: Given the choice, would you book a private car service or get on travelocity to book a trip for a 1:00 meeting in Dallas....tomorrow! 

gking --- 18 years ago -

I'm also curious to know why you would choose one over the other, if you care to comment. Thanks! 

Atasca Mom --- 18 years ago -

I like to fly. TX is such a big such a big state but if you fly your travel time is very minimal. I have flown to Dallas in the morning for a 9am mtg and flew back the same day. That flight is only about 50 min. The Austin flight is about 30 min. You just cant beat it. In addition, SW has some 29.00 flights (each way) if you book in advance and are willing to go to Hobby. 

I Kissed Frogs --- 18 years ago -

I have flown to Dallas several times and that is one bumpy ride! But I have also driven to Dallas and with the road construction been stuck in hours of backed up traffic. With the flight you know pretty much when you are going to get there - with traffic you never know. 

Atasca Mom --- 18 years ago -

I have flown to Dallas and spent more time in traffic getting to the meeting than in the air. Their traffic sux. 

gking --- 18 years ago -

That flight is only about 50 min. The Austin flight is about 30 min. You just cant beat it. In addition, SW has some 29.00 flights (each way) if you book in advance and are willing to go to Hobby. Understood....however, I am asking you to consider that your 30-50 minute flight time also needs to be added to by the time it takes you to: - get to the airport - an hour in advance - taxi to your gate (upon arriving) - deplane - walk to baggage claim - wait for baggage - time to drive to meeting Now how long is that short flight? AND - how much of that time would you be able to actually use your blackberry, laptop, or conference with your travel-mates? Also - I understand that fares are pretty irresistible when you're able to book enough time in advance (we'll see how much longer that lasts, with fuel prices going the way they are), however, I'm talking strictly about last-minute arrangements - as business meetings often are. 

Bigben --- 18 years ago -

When we make those trips, we are given the option to drive our own car and be re-imbursed 50.5 cents per mile, or we can take a flight, and rent a car and be fully remibursed for both. Its whatever you prefer. 

gking --- 18 years ago -

Oh - and just to be clear. The private car would come with it's own private driver. You don't drive. You don't park. You don't need to even know how to get there. You would basically travel first class. Not talking about a taxi-ride here. Executive class service only. 

Atasca Mom --- 18 years ago -

Yes, I understand G. Hands down-- FLY IMO. I just went on my last biz trip 2 wks ago and I sailed through the airport. You can do w/o your devices for 30 min or so :) I wouldnt even THINK of driving given the choice. 

cmi --- 18 years ago -

I would rather do the car service. I get very irritated at the time wasted in airports. Oh, and I won't get on a plane anyways! But, still, I have always argued the point that when you add up drive time to/fr airport, time at airport, etc. It takes just as long for a short trip. 

gking --- 18 years ago -

You can do w/o your devices for 30 min or so Gotcha - but you're still missing my point. You would be doing without your devices from the time you left your house for the airport until you arrived at your meeting. That's much more than 30 minutes or so. The additional point is this: virtually the entire "travel" time can be utilized for "officing", instead of being a big interruption to your work flow. I know it sounds like I'm trying to sell the idea. But I am really trying to find out if most of us (myself included) really realize just what the trade-offs are - and if having someone pick you up at your doorstep and take you directly to your meeting - allowing you to work the whole way there and avoid all the usual hassles of flying commercially (private jets - whole 'nother thing) - would that not sometimes be more appealing? And again, if you traveled with colleagues, not only would it become more economical, but potentially more productive. Just trying to sort out the pros and cons. I really appreciate your comments. Keep 'em coming. 

gking --- 18 years ago -

It takes just as long for a short trip. That's kinda what I'm getting at. Obviously not a very practical option for trips any further away. 

Bigben --- 18 years ago -

Throw some price comparisons out there and show us the cost. Ive never heard of the service that you are talking about, but it sounds interesting. 

Pet Lover --- 18 years ago -

And again, if you traveled with colleagues, not only would it become more economical, but potentially more productive. Well, I think this is a super idea when we want to ride into town and drink and not drive for sure...jmo! 

I Kissed Frogs --- 18 years ago -

As you basically talking a limo where you can seat people comfortably and where they could look at each other? If not I would hate to be the one person that gets stuck up from with the driver and has to keep turning around in my seat the whole time to converse with the people in the back. 

txjboy --- 18 years ago -

If you've had hip replacement surgery, you must take time for the "pat down". How many times have I heard, "Need male assistance". 

~grandma again~ --- 18 years ago -

Personally, I do not like to fly. I do not like to have to go through all of that stuff at the airport. If I can ride or drive anywhere I am a happy camper! 

gking --- 18 years ago -

Throw some price comparisons out there and show us the cost. Ive never heard of the service that you are talking about, but it sounds interesting. Well....you can start with going to any travel or airline site and punching up a last minute trip to any nearby city. First - it's gonna be high. That's to be expected. Second - you'll be lucky to get the exact times that you ask for. Third - add to that whatever cost might be involved for getting you to and from the airports on either end of the trip. If you drive yourself, count the gas and parking, then the rental car on the other end (and its gas). Otherwise there's the taxi or other car service costs. I just did an example leaving Houston tomorrow at 6:00 am to make a meeting by 9:00 in Dallas and be back home in time for a late dinner (meeting's over by 3:00, race to airport to make a 5:00 departure) The closest times I could get still available was 7:20am departure from IAH - which would make me late to my meeting, and 5:25 departure from DFW. And one of those flights involved flying in to or out of Dallas Love field which is way inconvenient to where I'd need to go when I got there. The best fare was $350 round trip per person. That would be $1050 for 3. I choose 3 because with 3 people traveling in a multi-media equipped SUV where everyone could sit comfortably all "in back" - a proposed rate would be about $1000 to $1300. Some of that might depend on how much "running around" was required at either end of the long part of the trip. Taking into account the cost for fuel, parking fees and car rentals - even the $1300 rate would potentially cost less for a group of 3. An SUV could accommodate twice that easily without really affecting the rate. Now - even with a single passenger - the rate would still be near a thousand bucks, but they could ride in an executive sedan all to themselves - spacious and smooth enough to even sleep comfortably in the whole way if they chose. I kinda envision such a service as actually being somewhere between flying commercially and flying private. It's like a slow private jet service that never leaves the ground - and not nearly as expensive as the private jet. And much more convenient than any other method - period. Again - imagine, your meeting ends, you walk outside the building into a waiting car and are halfway home already before your flying colleagues even buckle-in on their short 68 minute flight, after they've endured an aggravating race to the airport in early rush hour traffic, check-in, security, and boarding. You are driven right up to your front door - able to call home at anytime during the trip. Dinner is warm and on the table as soon as you walk in. Your flying colleagues will have just driven their fatigued and aggravated selves home in late rush-hour traffic - or - troubled their spouse to delay dinner and come pick their butt up at the airport. Anyone like navigating the damned airport pick-up system? Parking and going in? Yick. The private car client can drink whatever they want on the way, they can stop anywhere they want or need to on the way. They don't have to worry about putting anything in little baggies. Heck they can just meet their spouse at a restaurant and then go home with them. You get the drift. Does that help a bit Bigben? 

marthas attic (Mod) --- 18 years ago -

I would rather fly. Any business my dh has done has been flying either by corp. jet or commericial and I would much rather him fly than have him in a car. When he has driven someplace close like Austin or Dallas many times he has been stuck in traffic and that is something unforseen and can cause great delays for meetings ect. He also has done the same amount of work in an airplane as he would in a car. SO I guess I am not really seeing the benefits of having someone drive you 3-4 hours when you can fly so much quicker. 

gking --- 18 years ago -

He also has done the same amount of work in an airplane as he would in a car. He gets more work done during a 40-60 minute flight as he would in a 3-4 hr drive? How's that? Where is the traffic congestion most likely to be encountered - on the interstate between cities or in the cities, the part he would be driving in anyway on the way to and from any airport? 

marthas attic (Mod) --- 18 years ago -

He would not work for 3 - 4 hours in the car, now he may take a nap, but honestly I don't see him working in the car for that long. I think he would rather fly, get to the office where his meeting is and have some prep time there, get the business done and come home. As far as traffic you never know where you will encounter it. I guess its going to boil down to how people want to spend their time. Now someone like me can work on a laptop, read ect in a plane but get car sick if I try to do it in the car. You asked for opinions and thats what I gave you..I did not expect to have you agree since you stated all the pros of driving in your eariler post. 

Transported Man --- 18 years ago -

Honestly, I think a professional driver would be good for short term commutes. I can't think of any of my colleagues that get things done more efficiently in a car. Besides, you get served on a flight with drinks/snacks. Drivers would provide that service? And a driver WOULD cost more for a 3 hour drive than a flight would. I would NEVER want to be in a vehicle for 3 hours while attempting to get my work accomplished. Statistically, flying is safer and more comfortable. As far as time being burned getting to the airport, being herded on/off a plane, and driving to a destination....it's never been a problem. The biggest problem I've been faced with when meeting a driver is them actually being in the right place to meet you once you deboard and them actually being skilled enough to navigate through Houston. I choose 3 because with 3 people traveling in a multi-media equipped SUV where everyone could sit comfortably all "in back" Wow, you have one of these??? Again, sitting in a vehicle is UNCOMFORTABLE! Even in a limo. spacious and smooth enough to even sleep comfortably in the whole way if they chose. Um....I don't think so. Have you been a passenger in a Sedan. Sleep is the last thing you can do in one of those. You are driven right up to your front door - able to call home at anytime during the trip. Dinner is warm and on the table as soon as you walk in. Your flying colleagues will have just driven their fatigued and aggravated selves home in late rush-hour traffic - or - troubled their spouse to delay dinner and come pick their butt up at the airport. Anyone like navigating the damned airport pick-up system? Parking and going in? Wow. Where do YOU live? I want my dinners to be warm when I get in! Honestly, driving one's self home from IAH is not that big of a deal. And I would never ask my spouse to pick me up. Cab fares are about 40 bucks to where I live. I know what you are working out but we Americans really can't be bought out of our comfort and convenience. :) 

mamajulie --- 18 years ago -

dh makes lots of last min trips to the Dallas area. He has gone back and forth with the driving vs flying. His opinion is that the time needed is about equal; and since these are all business trips the cost isn't out of our pockets. After 9/11 he stopped flying; didn't want to have to check the suitcase of tools and equip that he has to take with him. Now he decides whether to fly based on what side of Dallas he is going to be in; if not to far from Love Field, he will usually fly, otherwise he will drive. He always travels alone, so the private car thing would not work for him. I would guess that he makes about 12 -20 trips to Dallas a year. 

Vedette --- 18 years ago -

gking. lol. it sounds like you've already made up your mind. But I voted for car because of all the reasons you are arguing for. I would just leave a bit early, which may take more time but just to be sure you get where you are going in case there is traffic...and potty breaks...and you have to stop for jerky. lol. 

gking --- 18 years ago -

And a driver WOULD cost more for a 3 hour drive than a flight would. Absolutely. This was established already. Wow, you have one of these??? Again, sitting in a vehicle is UNCOMFORTABLE! Even in a limo. Doesn't everyone? Seriously - most SUV's I see anymore have DVD players and screens in them. And I would take sitting in large leather seats with plenty of leg room over economy class seats on an airplane (or standing in line to go through security, etc.) anytime. Have you been a passenger in a Sedan. Yes, I have. Again, compared to the seating arrangement on an airplane, I could sleep much more easily - and for longer - than on the 40-60 minutes I'm actually able to "sit" on a flight. Wow. Where do YOU live? I want my dinners to be warm when I get in! Honestly, driving one's self home from IAH is not that big of a deal. And I would never ask my spouse to pick me up. Cab fares are about 40 bucks to where I live. I live in Kingwood. Speaking in general - what if the traveler lives in Sugarland, or Katy? Some might have their spouses pick them up, Was only citing a common scenario. The point is - one way or another, the traveler will still have to find a way to his doorstep from the airport. we Americans really can't be bought out of our comfort and convenience. :) Understood, but actually I was thinking that this option might provide greater comfort and convenience. I guess you could tell that I would rather not deal with the airport hassles when it would be virtually the same time spent in transit. I think I would find the door to door "Service" much more convenient and the ride much more comfortable. I think I would welcome the opportunity to actually be able to make use of all that transit time rather than lugging my bags around the airport, standing in lines, getting pat down, squeezing into an airline seat, etc. But - other than my own personal preference, I am just trying to point out some potential benefits that may not be readily apparent. I really do appreciate the comments and feedback. It helps me to determine how likely most people may be to consider deviating from their habits. 

gking --- 18 years ago -

I did not expect to have you agree since you stated all the pros of driving in your eariler post. I'm not disagreeing. I am simply trying to determine the validity of your argument. I can certainly appreciate that someone may just not want to spend more than 30 minutes working out of a 3-4 hour block of time spent traveling (air or land), but does that apply to everyone or even most? Many may choose to take more time replying to e-mails, making phone calls, preparing reports or meeting agendas, etc. - if they could. Many may choose to take attempt to take a nap if they had a quiet environment and knew that they weren't going to be interrupted by the flight attendant taking and serving drink orders to those sitting next to you. I took the position of pointing out the pros of taking a car because I am assuming that everyone is well acquainted with flying, but not so much with actually using an executive car service for such a trip. I get that being driven is not an attractive option to you, and I appreciate your reasons. Just trying to determine if those are the kind of reasons that every traveler would have, or are just quirky preferences. Everyone's feedback has been very helpful. 

Ialwayswantedtobenamedsara --- 18 years ago -

Fly, hands down, no exceptions. I've taken the trip by car numerous times and driven numerous times. Even with all of the extras at the airport, I feel like I get to my meeting and home faster. I can get up at 5:00 and be in Dallas for an 8:00 am meeting. Leave at 3:00 and be home for 5:00. 

gking --- 18 years ago -

I can get up at 5:00 and be in Dallas for an 8:00 am meeting. Leave at 3:00 and be home for 5:00. Really? Would your meetings be at the airport? If you get up at 5:00 - I'm assuming you mean leave your house at 5:00....takes about 20 minutes to get to the airport from Kingwood. Also assuming you're getting there at least 1 hour ahead of scheduled departure time - that would be a 6:20 flight at best. A non-stop flight to Dallas is about an hour gate to gate. Now it's about 7:20. Let's say you have no baggage to claim (which would be the usual case for a day trip) so you can just get off the plane and zip out of that airport - at least 10 minutes to the curb. Now you are 30 minutes away from reaching your meeting on time. Takes 10 minutes or more just to get out of DFW airport - easy half hour either direction to downtown Dallas or Fort Worth. I guess that's doable. I'm thinking it's cutting it close enough that I'd want to budget at least another hour in there. Coming back - leaving your meeting, getting to the airport, boarding, taking off, landing, deplaning and driving home all inside of 2 hours? Really? You're good! 

sparkle --- 18 years ago -

GKing, good luck on your get rich scheme number 4,235! Here's an idea for you and its free of charge. Your clients can peruse your sales brochures concerning id theft seminars while they snack on your biscotti listening to your piano cd's. Your driver can be well outfitted in KU wear and don't forget to have your boy scout bumper sticker on the back with a 1-800 number where they can buy the 5.00 popcorn. Hmmm..did I leave anything out, could it be I covered all your little business ventures in the last 12-14 months? 

Mr. Brady (L's D) --- 18 years ago -

I can get up at 5:00 and be in Dallas for an 8:00 am meeting. Leave at 3:00 and be home for 5:00. I have done this to Dallas several times. But, I fly to Love Field and catch a cab to Downtown office. Have someone either drop you back at the airport or catch another cab back. Not a bad day at all. 

Stonebridge --- 18 years ago -

My DH always flies up there and then takes a cab to downtown Dallas. He leaves his car at the Spot. 

AuthorMan --- 18 years ago -

Transporter (beam me up, Scotty) is much faster. Of course, it does not exist yet. lol 

gking --- 18 years ago -

Thanks for your rude comments Sparkle. Wish I could indulge your fantasies, but I'm actually conducting a little impromptu market research for an established transportation company I am consulting for. And - to further answer your question, not that it deserves it, no, no you haven't covered any of my business ventures. Sorry to find you so confused about such things. 

gking --- 18 years ago -

Transporter (beam me up, Scotty) is much faster. Now, you're on to something! 

marthas attic (Mod) --- 18 years ago -

but I'm actually conducting a little impromptu market research for an established transportation company I am consulting for. I understand that everyone has an opinion as I had mine. But George if you are doing market research for a company you are working for I would think you would state the facts and just sit back and listen to the opinions of everyone that answers instead of trying to skew the results your client would desire. You stated your facts on the company and people have stated their opinions. Seems to me your working very hard to sway people to your thinking and you really should remain unbiased on the issue for true results. JMO 

gking --- 18 years ago -

Thanks Martha. The feedback has been exactly what I was seeking. I wanted to elicit an argument "against" the concept so that I could get at the objections faster. Again, your comments have been most helpful and valuable to that end. Also, as I said this is impromptu and is only a tiny component of my study. Nonetheless still insightful. Thanks again everyone. 

Ialwayswantedtobenamedsara --- 18 years ago -

Really? Would your meetings be at the airport? yes, really, and no my meetings are downtown. I do live closer to the airport than Kingwood though. Even living in Kingwood if you budget another hour, it's faster than driving and less hassle. Driving in a car for 4 or 5 hours wears you out, no matter if you are the one doing the driving or not. 

gking --- 18 years ago -

So...would it be fair to say, in regard to most who have commented so far, that it's more an issue of road fatigue than price? Airport hassles are negligible compared to being in a car that long? At any price? 

Wickenburg --- 18 years ago -

Wish I could indulge your fantasies, but I'm actually conducting a little impromptu market research for an established transportation company I am consulting for. Dude, you are not consulting for the company. You DRIVE for them! So...would it be fair to say, in regard to most who have commented so far, that it's more an issue of road fatigue than price? No. People just don't want to sit for hours in a vehicle other than aircraft. But George if you are doing market research for a company you are working for I would think you would state the facts and just sit back and listen to the opinions of everyone that answers instead of trying to skew the results your client would desire. You stated your facts on the company and people have stated their opinions. Seems to me your working very hard to sway people to your thinking and you really should remain unbiased on the issue for true results. Well that's because George is a limo driver and is trying to justify why he wants to provide this service and why we should support it no matter what. 

gking --- 18 years ago -

Dude, you are not consulting for the company. You DRIVE for them! Dude, not this company. No. People just don't want to sit for hours in a vehicle other than aircraft. Sitting in a vehicle for hours is what I meant by road fatigue. Sorry that wasn't clear. trying to justify why he wants to provide this service and why we should support it no matter what. I do not want to provide this service. There is no consequence to me whatsoever - positive or negative - regarding any such service. I am not looking begin a "venture". I am only seeking some opinions - as I've stated and for reasons I've stated. Nothing more. The overall results of my research, which will include some of what I've learned from comments made here, are what interest and are of value to my client. Not whether or not such a service is implemented. 

page 1 2
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground