Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Beware the Terrible Simplifiers - truth and experience

who's talking here?

JDB2 4
bbjones 15
AuthorMan 1
NoNameNoLastName 3
Going off air 6
Clown Vomit 3
accent_ 22
irt339 1
ZITA 4
~sassy~ 6
Peacekeeper 1
boomer 3
KwdFoodie 1
IceTea*4*Me 1
Forecaster 1
CoralReef 1
AprilJoy 2
brian* 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

'Beware the Terrible Simplifiers' By Bill Moyers Bill Moyers Journal May 3, 2008 I once asked a reporter back from Vietnam: 'Who's telling the truth over there?' 'Everyone,' he said. 'Everyone sees what's happening through the lens of their own experience.' That's how people see Jeremiah Wright. In my conversation with him and in his dramatic public appearances since, he revealed himself to be far more complex than the sound bites that propelled him onto the public stage. More than 2,000 people have written me about him, and their opinions vary widely. Some sting: 'Jeremiah Wright is nothing more than a race-hustling, American- hating radical,' one of my viewers wrote. Another called him a 'nut case.' Many more were sympathetic to him. Many asked for some rational explanation for Wright's transition from reasonable conversation to the shocking anger they saw at the National Press Club. A psychologist might pull back some of the layers and see this complicated man more clearly, but I'm not a psychologist. Many black preachers I've known-scholarly, smart, and gentle in person-uncorked fire and brimstone in the pulpit. Of course, I've known many white preachers like that, too. But where I grew up in the South, before the civil rights movement, the pulpit was a safe place for black men to express anger for which they would have been punished anywhere else. A safe place for the fierce thunder of dignity denied, justice delayed. I think I would have been angry if my ancestors had been transported thousands of miles in the hellish hole of a slave ship, then sold at auction, humiliated, whipped, and lynched. Or if my great-great-great grandfather had been but three-fifths of a person in a Constitution that proclaimed: 'We, the people.' Or if my own parents had been subjected to the racial vitriol of Jim Crow, Strom Thurmond, Bull Conner, and Jesse Helms. Even so, the anger of black preachers I've known and heard and reported on was, for them, very personal and cathartic. That's not how Jeremiah Wright came across in those sound bites or in his defiant performances since my interview. What white America is hearing in his most inflammatory words is an attack on the America they cherish and that many of their sons have died for in battle - forgetting that black Americans have fought and bled beside them, and that Wright himself has a record of honored service in the Navy. Hardly anyone took the 'chickens come home to roost' remark to convey the message that intervention in the political battles of other nations is sure to bring retaliation in some form, which is not to justify the particular savagery of 9/11 but to understand that actions have consequences. My friend Bernard Weisberger, the historian, says, yes, people are understandably seething with indignation over Wright's absurd charge that the United States deliberately brought an HIV epidemic into being. But it is a fact, he says, that within living memory the U.S. public health service conducted a study that deliberately deceived black men with syphilis into believing that they were being treated while actually letting them die for the sake of a scientific test. Does this excuse Wright's anger? His exaggerations or distortions? You'll have to decide for yourself, but at least it helps me to understand the why of them. In this multimedia age the pulpit isn't only available on Sunday mornings. There's round the clock media - the beast whose hunger is never satisfied, especially for the fast food with emotional content. So the preacher starts with rational discussion and after much prodding throws more and more gasoline on the fire that will eventually consume everything it touches. He had help - people who, for their own reasons, set out to conflate the man in the pulpit who wasn't running for president with the man in the pew who was. Behold the double standard: John McCain sought out the endorsement of John Hagee, the war-mongering, Catholic- bashing Texas preacher, who said the people of New Orleans got what they deserved for their sins. But no one suggests McCain shares Hagee's delusions or thinks AIDS is God's punishment for homosexuality. Pat Robertson called for the assassination of a foreign head of state and asked God to remove Supreme Court justices, yet he remains a force in the Republican religious right. After 9/11, Jerry Falwell said the attack was God's judgment on America for having been driven out of our schools and the public square, but when McCain goes after the endorsement of the preacher he once condemned as an agent of intolerance, the press gives him a pass. Jon Stewart recently played tape from the Nixon White House in which Billy Graham talks in the Oval Office about how he has friends who are Jewish, but he knows in his heart that they are undermining America. This is crazy and wrong -- white preachers are given leeway in politics that others aren't. Which means it is all about race, isn't it? Wright's offensive opinions and inflammatory appearances are judged differently. He doesn't fire a shot in anger, put a noose around anyone's neck, call for insurrection, or plant a bomb in a church with children in Sunday school. What he does is to speak his mind in a language and style that unsettles some people, and says some things so outlandish and ill-advised that he finally leaves Obama no choice but to end their friendship. We're often exposed to the corroding acid of the politics of personal destruction, but I've never seen anything like this - this wrenching break between pastor and parishioner played out right in front of our eyes. Both men no doubt will carry the grief to their graves. All the rest of us should hang our heads in shame for letting it come to this in America, where the gluttony of the non-stop media grinder consumes us all and prevents an honest conversation on race. It is the price we are paying for failing to heed the great historian Jacob Burckhardt, who said, 'beware the terrible simplifiers.' Bill Moyers is managing editor of the weekly public affairs program "Bill Moyers Journal," which airs Friday night on PBS. Check local airtimes or comment at The Moyers Blog at www.pbs.org/moyers. The video for this essay can be found on YouTube: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IvnMK1d9xE0  

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

Michael Moore made a good point in his interview with Larry King - if you had witnessed what Wright had, and had been treated like he was, you would probably be very upset too. I don't agree with his choice of words, and I don't agree with everything he said in that sermon, but some of what he said is actually true. Now there is one thing I find interesting - I understand he was Obama's pastor for 20 years. ~50 Sundays a year, that's 1,000 sermons. I'd be curious to hear other things that he said... Was the one we've seen ad nauseam the rule or the exception? I'm also curious about why the so called liberal media doesn't make a stench about the hate sermons from Hagee, and the fact that McCain is proud of his support. I probably shouldn't expect anything different from someone who was stepped on by Bush in 2,000, and now is happy to have his support. Whatever it takes to be elected, I guess... 

Peacekeeper --- 18 years ago -

Thank you! Finally, some meaningful exchange on this KU! Accent you are awesome! I've said so before. noname, i like what you said. Good points all around, really. 

boomer --- 18 years ago -

You know this is a gripe complain, gripe complain world. The best part is everyone blames the other guy. I love this world we live in. 

irt339 --- 18 years ago -

Thank you! Finally, some meaningful exchange on this KU! Accent you are awesome! I've said so before. May I second that. And certainly a very though provocating post by Moyers. Thank you for forwarding it. 

~sassy~ --- 18 years ago -

Even so, the anger of black preachers I've known and heard and reported on was, for them, very personal and cathartic. That's not how Jeremiah Wright came across in those sound bites or in his defiant performances since my interview. Good Lord most precious God Almighty when will we all ever understand that IT AIN'T ABOUT COLOR...IT'S ABOUT BEHAVIOR! I don't have the energy to delve into specifics tonight but what does it say about a race when a full 85% of our prison inmates are black? Are whites throwing these people in prison for the fun of it? Do these statistics prove that as a race, blacks aren't doing much, or enough to better themselves? What more can we do that we aren't already doing? The majority of welfare recipiants are black. In the 1980's Chicago built trade schools right next door to it's inner city projects, the first major city to do so - and a great idea we all thought but guess what? They closed down in less than two years because nobody came. True story. Whose fault is that? Ours? Oh yeah, blame it on the white guy Rev. Wright. Why work when dummy America will give you money for doing nothing - and never require something in return. And now we have the illegals marching in the streets deanding their share of the pie...wasn't it even said that America was built on their sweat because whitey is too lazy to do the work they do for practically nothing? Puhleeze - if you call free food, free medical and cheap housing for life nothing - geeze. 

~sassy~ --- 18 years ago -

Which means it is all about race, isn't it? REMINDER....NOT RACE, BEHAVIOR 

boomer --- 18 years ago -

Which means it is all about race, isn't it? REMINDER....NOT RACE, BEHAVIOR Some still think if they blame whitey all is good. You're right it isn't race but behavior. Thank you for posting that. 

IceTea*4*Me --- 18 years ago -

This whole Wright thing has gotten way overblown and it a clear attempt to widen the racial divide. I'm not biting. 

bbjones --- 18 years ago -

This whole Wright thing has gotten way overblown and it a clear attempt to widen the racial divide. Yes, Wright is trying to widen the racial divide. 

~sassy~ --- 18 years ago -

Yes, Wright is trying to widen the racial divide. I respectfully repeat that it isn't about race, it's about BEHAVIOR 

bbjones --- 18 years ago -

I respectfully repeat that it isn't about race, it's about BEHAVIOR It should be about behavior, but Wright, among others, is trying to make it about race. 

KwdFoodie --- 18 years ago -

The Wright horse died weeks ago, and has been beaten beyond recognition. It's old and beginning to stink. 

~sassy~ --- 18 years ago -

The Wright horse died weeks ago, and has been beaten beyond recognition. It's old and beginning to stink. 

~sassy~ --- 18 years ago -

The Wright horse died weeks ago, and has been beaten beyond recognition. It's old and beginning to stink. Sorry 'bout that - I was saying that my son has been in the hospital all week - six weeks right before that so this KUer hasn't had the chance to keep up. The beauty about KU is if a topic isn't to your liking..... 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

Yes, Wright is trying to widen the racial divide. Beware the ordinary simplifiers as well. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

It should be about behavior, but Wright, among others, is trying to make it about race. Only those who don't pay attention to the full context of what Wright says, and who swallow the brief soundbites served up by Hannity, Limbaugh, et al are trying to exploit the race issue. Wright never asked to be placed at the center of this controversy. 

brian* --- 18 years ago -

The last 10 years or so have been dominated by sound bytes. Bill Maher mentioned he thought the case for Iraq war was being built on slogans and he has a point. When you dumb down a statement or take it out of context, you are really putting the cart before the horse. You form the opinion, then create "facts" to bolster your opinion. I prefer to weigh the facts out and form my belief afterwards. 

boomer --- 18 years ago -

What part of his speech didn't we hear or should I say sermon? You mean it was censored? 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

and who swallow the brief soundbites served up by Hannity, Limbaugh, et al are trying to exploit the race issue as much as you consider yourself to be open minded, why do you continue to use the line above? You must listen to those guys with an open-mind...if you did, you'd surely feel the same as you do about wright, right? When are you going to quit swallowing what the left sided, short-term thinkers are telling you? Get beyond the sound bites accent... 

~sassy~ --- 18 years ago -

Wright never asked to be placed at the center of this controversy. It's been reported by several on TV that "Revrund" Wright gave speaking out much forethought. This story has been around for several months...and he decides to come forward just when the story was dying down? Sounds fishy to me. That speech he gave at the NAACP was meant to cause....just what it has. Why would he do this if not to hurt Obama? I'm no Obama fan, trust me, but I'm even less a Wright Fan. I don't care what color he is - it's his behavior I oppose. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

You form the opinion, then create "facts" to bolster your opinion. and it is too much the story of the current Presidential race, regrdless of party. The problem is us, though, guys. We are the ones with thumbs poised on the channel selectors, the ones with chronic attention deficit disorder. "We have met the enemy and he is us." -Pogo 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

You must listen to those guys with an open-mind...if you did, you'd surely feel the same as you do about wright, right? My lowering opinions of Hannity and Limbaugh and their ongoing struggle down to the very lowest common denominator is based on years of listening to each. I spend more time listening to those who don't reinforce my views than I do to those who do. I've listened to Limbaugh as long as he's been in the Houston market, am less impressed as time goes on. I'm not surprised, though, that you'd find Hannity and Limbaugh edifying, that you'd think to compare a Limbaugh and a Wright. 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

I'm not surprised, though, that you'd find Hannity and Limbaugh edifying, that you'd think to compare a Limbaugh and a Wright. I personally don't listen to any of them. Limbaugh isn't impressive, but it's even less impressive when you make the assumption that anyone not in agreement with the open-minded accent must listen to Limbaugh and Hannity. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

you make the assumption that anyone not in agreement with the open-minded accent must listen to Limbaugh and Hannity. No assumption necessary, jdb, though I'm sure that Hannity and Limbaugh would appreciate your admittedly uninformed but terribly open-minded knee-jerk defense. No, no assumption necessary, simply observation of, for the past few weeks, the selected bits from Wright being featured on both Hannity's and Limbaugh's shows, as appetizers and main courses. 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

admittedly uninformed that is about as ridiculous as claiming that military service by definition equates to patriotism. You should be able to do better accent, try again. I am very informed and unlike yourself, I am able to form my own opinion. wright has even been featured on your beloved Clinton News Network. He has pretty much been everywhere accent, but listening to one of his "sermons" does not necessarily mean you are informed. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

your beloved Clinton News Network. Sorry, bubba, no cable here. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

You must listen to those guys with an open-mind I personally don't listen to any of them. admittedly uninformed 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

I personally don't listen to any of them. so you think you must listen to hannity, limbaugh and wright in order to be informed? Read your own words there "bubba" because I don't listen to these three and that definitely does not mean that I am uniformed. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

so you think you must listen to hannity, limbaugh and wright in order to be informed? Not at all, but, if you choose to express an opinion on what Hannity, Limbaugh, or Wright says, without having listened to them, it could be argued that that opinion is uninformed. I am very informed I don't listen to these three and that definitely does not mean that I am uniformed. I'm sure you are very very informed, jdb, just not on those three, if you have not listened to or read them. I'll bet that there is oodles of stuff, though, that you are really informed on. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

You form the opinion, then create "facts" to bolster your opinion. That's precisely right. Preconception goes hand in hand with oversimplification. Some people even deny facts that don't match their opinion... We've seen this over and over here at KU... 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

"The fewer the facts, the stronger the opinion." - Arnold H Glasgow 

bbjones --- 18 years ago -

Some people even deny facts that don't match their opinion... We've seen this over and over here at KU... There is an old saying. The hen that cackles first... 

Going off air --- 18 years ago -

Let him that is without sin cast the first stone 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

The hen that cackles first... is the one nearest the coop window with the best access to hearing the cock crow, or has feather lice, or just had a bad dream, or didn't ever really get to sleep, or is the only one who saw the farmer approach with an axe, or... -old French proverb 

bbjones --- 18 years ago -

is the one nearest the coop window with the best access to hearing the cock crow, or has feather lice, or just had a bad dream, or didn't ever really get to sleep, or is the only one who saw the farmer approach with an axe, or... It is just like a lefty to want to change the truth. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

It is just like a lefty to want to change the truth. Famous Left Handed People: How many famous left handed people do you know? Most left-handers have at some stage in their life, been on the receiving end of a uncomplimentary comment on the subject of their favoured hand. This could have been during their school days, in the work place, or simply down the local pub. It‘s a fair bet though, that the instigator of these remarks might not have been so smug had they taken into account the thousands of famous left-handers, who throughout history have excelled in many varied fields. To produce a comprehensive list would be almost impossible, but below are just a small percentage, who make any southpaw proud to be left handed:- Possibly some of the most famous left handed people come from the world of sport. Greats like: Babe Ruth; Larry Bird; Pele; Sir Bobby Charlton; Ferenc Puskas; Sir Garfield Sobers; Dennis Compton; Arnold Palmer; Rod Laver; Mark Spitz and “marvellous” Marvin Hagler were/are all proud “lefties”. To be added to this dazzling list are more famous left handed people from more recent times, such as: John McEnroe; Jimmy Connors; Ivan Lendl; Martina Navratilova; Diego Maradona; Marco Van Basten; Jimmy White; Brian Lara and Alan Border. There are countless numbers of famous left handed people in the world of show business, with legends like: Cary Grant; WC Fields; Steve McQueen; Peter Ustinov; Charlie Chaplin and Fred Astaire, plus present day actors such as Robert Redford; Tom Cruise; Robert De Niro; Sylvester Stalone; Bruce Willis and Jim Carrey, all favouring the left hand. Not to leave the ladies out, famous actresses include many of the greats: Judy Garland; Greta Garbo; Betty Grable; Marilyn Monroe, they were all “lefties”, as are current screen stars like: Julia Roberts; Angelina Jolie; Nicole Kidman; Emma Thompson and Demi Moore. From the music industry, famous left handed people are well represented in the shape of: Bob Dylan; Jimmi Hendrix; Sir Paul McCartney; Sting; David Bowie; Phil Collins; George Michael; Marshall Mathers - Eminem; Annie Lennox; Celine Dion; Mark Knopfler; Paul Simon and Ringo Starr. Some more famous left handed people from miscellaneous backgrounds include: Mr Micosoft himself - Bill Gates; J Edgar Hoover - the former Director of the FBI; Mark Twain, HG Wells and Lewis Carroll from the world of literature; and Prince’s Charles and William. First man on the moon: Neil Armstrong and his co-astronaut: Buzz Aldrin; fashion designer: Jean-Paul Gaultier and The Simpsons cartoon creator: Matt Groening are all left handed, as are/were American Presidents: JF Kennedy; Gerald Ford; Ronald Reagan and Bill Clinton. Just to show that not all famous left handed people are, or were known for the all the right reasons, there have been a few bad apples in the shape of Billy the Kid; Jack the Ripper and The Boston Strangler. Finally some of the most famous left handed people from yesteryear, are without doubt some of the greatest and influential individuals who have ever lived. The likes of Horatio Nelson; Leonardo Da Vinci; Michelangelo; Pablo Picasso; Julius Caesar; Wolfgang Amedeus Mozart; Ludwig Van Beethoven; Winston Churchill; Napoleon Bonaparte - and Josephine; Queen Victoria; Alexander the Great; Joan of Arc; Marie Curie and last but certainly not least, Albert Einstein. They all had one predominant feature in common with each other - they were all left handed! It is worth noting that Einstein learned to speak late, had problems in almost every subject in school and was frequently labelled as being backwards! So there is certainly no need for any left-hander to have an inferiority complex! 

bbjones --- 18 years ago -

Famous Left Handed People: I was not referring to left handed people, but you know that. It is very ironic that your title would include truth as a simplifier, since your attempts are focused on making things more complicated. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

It is very ironic that your title would include truth as a simplifier, It is not ironic at all that you have it exactly backwards. Had that hyphen been a colon, there would be some justification for your leaping to an erroneous conclusion from your first impression, the facts to the contrary, but a quick glance through the initial post on the thread should have relieved you of that hasty conclusion. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

There is an old saying. The hen that cackles first... There is another one - if the shoe fits... I didn't mention any names, there was no reason for you to become defensive, bbjones. But that's a distraction from this - very interesting - discussion. I highly recommend this book -> Blink. Here is part of the review: Gladwell includes caveats about leaping to conclusions: marketers can manipulate our first impressions, high arousal moments make us "mind blind," focusing on the wrong cue leaves us vulnerable to "the Warren Harding Effect" (i.e., voting for a handsome but hapless president). In a provocative chapter that exposes the "dark side of blink," he illuminates the failure of rapid cognition in the tragic stakeout and murder of Amadou Diallo in the Bronx. He underlines studies about autism, facial reading and cardio uptick to urge training that enhances high-stakes decision-making. In this brilliant, cage-rattling book, one can only wish for a thicker slice of Gladwell's ideas about what Blink Camp might look like. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

news
politics
religion


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground