Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Deaf Rights

who's talking here?

bobbi 3
Doublestuff 1
lLackCreativity 1
rose8304 1
browneyes 5
addipie 7
~Shannon~ 2
Carole 3
ZoomZoom 2
SuperFantastic 1
ZimmerT 2
deafmatt22 2
beautyblond 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

ZimmerT --- 18 years ago -

Hello, we are Paloma Towner and Trystan Zimmer, Presidant and Vice Presidant of ASL Club at Lone Star College Kingwood Campus. We are setting up for Deaf Rights. We and the rest of the members wanted to change the law about American Sign Language vs. English Sign Language. The reason why we're doing this because it is not fair for the Deaf must sign English Sign Language. Why are hearings are learning ASL to communicating with Deaf and not Deaf using or learning ASL? They are being force by the hearing to use English Sign Language in public schools.We're as Deaf think it isn't fair that the hearing people have been teaching the ASL program on any public schools that we aren't allow signing ASL because they are afraid that it will affect our learing. It isn't true, how can it affect our learning skills? Here is the true story about a Deaf girl who cannot allow using ASL in her public school. When she is out of class, going on lunch break and she is being cautious using ASL, if her teacher caught her, points will be taken off her grade and it hurt her grades at the end of the year. That why we are fighting for our Deaf Rights. 

addipie --- 18 years ago -

I taught at Oak Forest for a few yrs and there was a child there that used ASL and had an interpreter in class with her. I am sure it was ASL not signed English b/c I have a MA in Deaf Ed from Lamar...I guess my point is that it really depends on the situation. By the way, nice to meet ya:) 

ZoomZoom --- 18 years ago -

This is something that I know zero about. Can you please explain the difference between the two? When they have people signing on TV which of the two languages is most commonly used. Which is most often spoken in the US. 

addipie --- 18 years ago -

ASL is its own language...differnt syntax, grammer etc... Signed English is basically signing in English word order and using signs that have a lot of English initialization Example: Butterfly ASL: has it's own sign that requires both hands and looks similar to a butterfly flying in the air Signed English: 1st sign "butter"(what you eat) then sign "Fly" I totally agree that Signed English is pretty useless b/c it doesn't flow the same make sense??? 

Carole --- 18 years ago -

I thought the college taught ASL. Am I wrong? I think it should be a required language instead of Spanish or some other foreign language. Shouldn't we learn the language of our own citizens BEFORE we learn another language? I have been wanting to take it but without someone to use it with, I will never hold it. I have some tapes that teach ASL but can't seem to retain it without practice. :-( 

addipie --- 18 years ago -

I thought the college taught ASL. I think it is an elective. I am not sure if Zimmer is still on but, what he is talking about does happen quite often. Many parents of deaf (Deaf) kids want them to be more like thier peers so they want them to learn signed English. It really is not fair 

Carole --- 18 years ago -

It really is not fair Well no joke! I always thought ASL was pretty much the "official" sign language. 

addipie --- 18 years ago -

I always thought ASL was pretty much the "official" sign language there is actually a great divide between Deaf (ASL, Deaf proud, involved in Deaf community, etc) and deaf (try to conform to hearing population) Now if you go to TSD (Texas School for the Deaf) yes, they use ASL there. The problem usually exists in public schools where the kids are trying to be mainstreamed and taught to conform 

lLackCreativity --- 18 years ago -

Well thats dumb! That is like telling kids if they don't use a certain type of english, they can't talk at all. And I would think it would be hard for kids to learn ESL and ASL and NEVER mess up and use ASL when they are supposed to only use ESL. Just from a tad of reading ESL seems almost like "slang" sign language? 

addipie --- 18 years ago -

Just from a tad of reading ESL seems almost like "slang" sign language? there is it's own slang in ASL but I don't think a Deaf person would use Signed English whether it is slang or not JMO maybe Zimmer can add more since he obviously has more experience:) 

bobbi --- 18 years ago -

my dd is NOT deaf but we use ASL with her.....i can't understand why anyone would require ESL. 

rose8304 --- 18 years ago -

I wanted to take ASL at KW College but don't have anyone to use it with either, so I know I would not learn it well. They do teach it there as a humanities course or a multicultural one, just like all the other languages. 

browneyes --- 18 years ago -

When you say ESL do you mean Signed Exact English? SEE I've always heard that it is better than ASL because it follows the way hearing people talk with proper syntax. I'm not for either way...just asking so please don't attack. 

deafmatt22 --- 18 years ago -

I am supporting Deaf Rights and the idea of the public school banning our is a case of discrimation because ASL is the language of Deaf people, I love to see hearing people who take an interest in learning ASL but when the school board said that ASL is not allowed for deaf people, it piss me off becuase it is our language and the public school don't have the rights to do this 

Doublestuff --- 18 years ago -

What school is it that is banning ASL? I know that it is used by several of the children at our elementary school. It was my understanding that communication choice was made by the parents (and student as they get older) and could not be mandated by the school system. 

addipie --- 18 years ago -

when the school board said that ASL is not allowed for deaf people, it piss me off becuase it is our language and the public school don't have the rights to do this what school board would possibly say this? When you say ESL do you mean Signed Exact English? SEE yes, I was assuming that what he meant 

Carole --- 18 years ago -

OK, so let me get this straight...our schools actually put special Spanish speaking teachers in class to teach Mexican children that don't speak English yet we are telling our countrymen that they can't speak their own language in the schools that their tax dollars help pay for? Canada is looking better and better... 

browneyes --- 18 years ago -

I think the argument is between ASL and SEE...SEE is grammatically correct and some think it is better because it corresponds with how everything is written etc. 

~Shannon~ --- 18 years ago -

OK, so let me get this straight...our schools actually put special Spanish speaking teachers in class to teach Mexican children that don't speak English yet we are telling our countrymen that they can't speak their own language in the schools that their tax dollars help pay for? Canada is looking better and better... So true. I am teaching dd ASL we actually had to limit how much we were teaching because she wasnt talking. My mom said to me one day. I cant understand her. I told her then learn AMS. DD is almost 3 for those who dont know.Spanish will be the last thing I teach her. When she has mastered ASL. 

bobbi --- 18 years ago -

my dd is language delayed...she has excellent receptive language...but her expressive language skills are behind...so we really use ASL to help communicate. she is 3 now....i'm wondering what will happen when she is old enough to start school but is still lacking the language. 

browneyes --- 18 years ago -

It's funny...in my profession they don't use sign to help the hearing impaired learn to speak because they will rely on it too much. But in ECI we used simple signs simultaneously with the spoken word to get the kids to start talking! Kinda backwards but with a lot of lang delayed kids it works. You just have to keep reinforcing the spoken word also. 

browneyes --- 18 years ago -

bobbi..they will continue with speech therapy until they decide she isn't making any progress...then they may look into a communication device. But they will keep trying. She's still young. :) 

bobbi --- 18 years ago -

are you a ST in ECI? my dd used to be in ECI....we always use spoken word with the sign....at first it was us really pushing the signs but now she requests signing time, etc videos and is teaching herself new signs. 

browneyes --- 18 years ago -

i'll pm you...dont' want to hijack too much :) 

~Shannon~ --- 18 years ago -

DS was in ECI where we were at there was a great teacher. You just have to stay on top of things. Deaf and blind kids kind of take the back seat at school so to speak. At times I want to shout at them. So many point fingers back and forth. Just like now ds has an appointment to see dr of UH eye clinic school suggested and agreed to pay for it. Now they don't know a thing about it.Now I have to pay for it. Lucky is is cheap enough. 

ZimmerT --- 18 years ago -

We apologize that it took so long to get back. We have been so busy with our classes work and all. Just to let you know that Zimmer is a she. We are so surprise on how many have response and who support our Rights. We have been research for more informations about Public Education for Deaf. We will write to each every one of you with your concern questions. Thanks, Paloma Towner and Trystan Zimmer 

ZoomZoom --- 18 years ago -

We are so surprise on how many have response and who support our Rights. We have been research for more informations about Public Education for Deaf. We will write to each every one of you with your concern questions. Thanks, Paloma Towner and Trystan Zimmer Thanks for bringing this to our attention. Like I said before, I had no idea that there were two languages and have learned a lot about it. Hope the powers that be start listening to you. 

addipie --- 18 years ago -

had no idea that there were two languages There actually many variations of it...ASL and SEE (signing Exact English) are what you hear the most about 

SuperFantastic --- 18 years ago -

WHAT? 

deafmatt22 --- 18 years ago -

Yeah, I am impressed with the responses we already gotten, hopefully this will help us to prove to the school board that ASL must be allowed for deaf people.-Matt and yes there is more variations of ASL USA and even in different country, they have their own sign language for deaf people 

beautyblond --- 18 years ago -

 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

connecting
help
politics


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground