Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Thyroid Question

who's talking here?

Unichic 7
Denise C 1
Fiona 2
MyPiggyBank 4
cgwifemom 2
Syrah1214 1
kwdad 1
Too Tired 3
BFC_Fitness 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Too Tired --- 18 years ago -

I had results from a blood test returned to me today and it says that my T4 (total) is 6.1 and T4 (free) is 1.8. They want me to begin taking thyroid medication. He said my T4 should be between 10-12. I really don't want to begin taking something that I will always have to take. Does anyone know if the Dr.'s advice sounds correct? 

Denise C --- 18 years ago -

You need to pm unichic. She is awesome on this kind of stuff. She has helped me tremendously. 

Unichic --- 18 years ago -

Are you SURE the free t4 was 1.8 and not .8????? 1.8 is the top of the range, range being .8 -1.8. A healthy thyroid will typically be at LEAST mid range or higher in that range. 

MyPiggyBank --- 18 years ago -

Did you go to an endocrinoligist or a g.p.? A general prac doesn't always test everything that goes into making a decision on medicine and dosage. I would see a specialist. I use Dr. Petak and love him. He is in the med center but worth the drive...IMO. Definitely worth a follow up! 

Too Tired --- 18 years ago -

I went to Kingwood Health and Wellness. Here are the stats: TSH 1.39 T3, Uptake 30 T4, Total 6.1 T4, Free 1.8 

Unichic --- 18 years ago -

oh, that's free t4 index (I know he does NOT do the free t4). What was the range on the index? 

Too Tired --- 18 years ago -

He said between 10 and 12? 

Unichic --- 18 years ago -

I believe the range is something like 4.5 - 12. It is not the most reliable of tests. I am not saying that he/she is not correct in their diagnosis over there, but I would have your free t4, free t3, tsh, and thyroid antibodies done as well. I can tell you that when I was diagnosed, my t4 was 8.6, considerably higher than your 6.1, so I would look deeper to see what is causing the low t4 numbers. Did he check progesterone? I disagree with piggy because most people I have chatted with on my thyroid board and another, feel that endocrinologists are too busy looking at labs and not symptoms. They typically look at the TSH only, in which you would be disregarded right there with that 1.3 level. Yes, rightfully it looks good, but if you have a faulty pituitary, then that would explain that low TSH. Before 1973, people were diagnosed with low thyroid by symptoms and temps etc... They were then given a trial of thyroid meds. If improvement was seen, then a definitive diagnosis was made. I reccomend going here: www.stopthethyroidmadness.com 

MyPiggyBank --- 18 years ago -

Actually, Dr. Petak does not only look at lab test. He looks at symptons as well and I am walking example. While I agree there are some really bad endos out there, Dr. Petak is very knowledgable AND thorough. He does not like to check labs and push you on through but discusses how you are feeling and anything beyond a blood test that plays a role in his diagnosis. 

Unichic --- 18 years ago -

Yes, I have heard several of you talk about him now. The question is, does he or will he give t3 as well (e.g. Armour thyroid)? A lot of these docs get perks for prescribing one drug over another. SOme push levoxyl, some push synthroid. There are absolutely no perks with Armour, and so if a doc will prescribe it, that's a good thing. They are at least somewhat looking out for the patient's best interest. Piggy, where is he at again? 

MyPiggyBank --- 18 years ago -

Just went back and read this thread and wanted to answer Unichic... Dr. Petak is in the professional building adjoining Texas Womens Hospital in the med center. I did ask him about Armour thyroid on one of my last visits and he does prescribe it. He did say he does not prescribe it to women who might not be done having children because there are not enough studies about what it pulls from the fetus (can't remember if the question is about t4 from the fetus or what). He did say it has been effective in treating some of his patients and that their practice does not prescribe any one drug. He even pointed out the whole concern for pharmaceutical companies getting in with a doc and assured me that they are very set on prescribing whatever is going to help their patients, not what some rep wants them to push. He also saw my interest in learning more and said if that was something I felt I wanted to explore I could see how I felt on it...but that is when the whole pregnancy issue came up (not prego but hanging on to the possibility of #3). Hope that gives you some insight on Dr. Petak. 

cgwifemom --- 18 years ago -

I was taken off the Armour last November because it was not giving stabilizing results. They have me starting again on Synthroid. 

Syrah1214 --- 18 years ago -

A lot of these docs get perks for prescribing one drug over another. I have to respectfully disagree. Doctors don't get any perks for prescribing one drug over another. They look at the patient, symptoms, labs, history, other medications, then make the determination. Synthroid works well for "most" thyroid cases, so that's where most will start. If symptoms or abnormal labs persist, they look to change medications. Yes, drug reps bring in lunches frequently, but that is to get a chance to sit down with the doctor for one-on-one time to discuss their medication and the benefits of it versus some of the other treatments out there. There is no pay-off though so to speak for a doctor prescribing one over the other. 

Fiona --- 18 years ago -

I really don't want to begin taking something that I will always have to take I just have to comment on this because when I was first diagnosed I felt the same way. If you do have a thyroid issue may as well prepare yourself now you will more than likely have to be on the meds. Sorry but unless you get remission and even then it could come back. I have graves which is a hyperthyroid and will be on meds probably for the rest of my life. If they remove your thyroid then you will need the replacement and same as if you do radiation. I also see Dr. Petak and love him. I was going to a endo here in Humble that was telling me that you should only stay on meds for up to 18 months then I would need to decide if I wanted to remove my thyroid or have radiation. This was a major concern to me but Dr. Petak put my fears to rest he said if the meds are working for you then why not just stick with that you can take them forever no need to jump to make a decision or worry over. 

MyPiggyBank --- 18 years ago -

Totally agree Fiona. Plus, if you were a diabetic would you ignore the problem because you don't want to take insulin? Risk feeling bad and putting your life in danger? No! Your thyroid effects so many functions of your body that it is worth taking a tiny pill every day versus not being able to function. 

BFC_Fitness --- 18 years ago -

Here's my $0.02: Take the meds and clean up your diet and add exercise (if you don't already). My wife had an over-active thyroid. Her doctor wanted to radiate. (No thyroid = meds for the rest of your life.) We opted for the medicine and cleaned up our diet- filtered water, mostly organic foods, less eating out, etc. A year later, she was off the meds completely and bloodwork came back normal. Hope that helps. 

kwdad --- 18 years ago -

Dr. Petak is a great endo, and was actually the past president of the American Association of Clinical Endocrinologists. I would trust him much more than anyone at Kingwood Health & Wellness. 

Fiona --- 18 years ago -

A year later, she was off the meds completely and bloodwork came back normal. Please be sure that she continues to have her bloodwork done. She has probably reached remmission but as quickly as it left it can return. She should be extra careful because she has hyperthyroid your thyroid effects your heart rate and blood pressure noticably. 

Unichic --- 18 years ago -

He did say he does not prescribe it to women who might not be done having children because there are not enough studies about what it pulls from the fetus (can't remember if the question is about t4 from the fetus or what). I have never heard of this. Armour has been used for over 100 years and quite successfully. It was the number one thyroid med until the early 70's when synthetic t4 was created (aka synthroid/levoxyl). I have NEVER heard of such a thing. Certainly a new one on the list of odd reasons why people should not take Armour (On the thyroid board, we have laughed at a few of the crazier ones). Just for kicks though, I am going to look this one up. P.S. Do you ever read the Mary Shomon ABOUT.com articles? I like her. She's a well known thyroid health advocate. 

Unichic --- 18 years ago -

I have to respectfully disagree. Doctors don't get any perks for prescribing one drug over another. They look at the patient, symptoms, labs, history, other medications, then make the determination. Synthroid works well for "most" thyroid cases, so that's where most will start. If symptoms or abnormal labs persist, they look to change medications. Docs, and I respectfully disagree with you. They do get perks, free lunches, trips, paid schooling - yes they do. I have a thyroid board filled with about 300 unhappy people that are not doing well on synthroid alone (not to say that some people do not do well on it however). I am totally on 300mcg of synthroid right now and I am a complete mess. I want my armour back. Feeling good means that you lose weight, feel energetic, no more insomnia, anxiety, high cholesterol, body aches, carpel tunnel, muscle twiches, heart palps, depression, dry skin, thinning hair, puffy eyes etc.... WHen all those are gone and you are on synthroid, then it's working for you. Many people do not do "optimally well" on a t4-only med. BFC, you better watch over her. It is not at all uncommon for a person who was at one time hyper to slip back into a euthroid (normal) state. I did this for 15 years. It wasn't until I had children that the poop hit the fan - BIGTIME! 

cgwifemom --- 18 years ago -

Howdy Unichic - Dr. Fox at the Sadler Clinic has taken me off the Armour and put me back on Synthroid. How do I explain it to the Doc that the dose is not working and I am totally unable to wake up every 2 days now. I have my next appt on the 28th. I get in the office and always pretend like it is not as bad as it really is. 

Unichic --- 18 years ago -

CG, what do you mean? Do you mean you are not doing well on the synthroid or that you couldn't wake up on the Armour. The one thing about Armour is that it will bring your TSH down really low. This is TOTALLY normal. The numbers your doctor should be most concerned with are the free t4 and the free t3, in which your numbers shold be at LEAST mid range (e.g. range is .8 - 1.8 and mid range would be 1.3), but the higher in the range the better or be based upon how you feel. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground