Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

A letter from just 6 of those who have been exonerated after years on death row

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 1
GCan 1
JDB2 11
bbjones 15
Justwatching72 2
NoNameNoLastName 16
Big Daddy 6
accent_ 16
txdaddy 10
Paula 1
haroldoftherocks 1
WHO'syourdaddy 1
get_the_lead_out! 5
naturegirl 1
ffup 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

[Every time that an innocent person is convicted of murder, a criminal gets away with murder] Exonerated Men Urge DNA Testing For Death Row Inmate Posted on Wednesday, 26 of December , 2007 at 8:16 pm MONTGOMERY, AL–Six men who were wrongfully convicted of brutal murders, sentenced to die, and sent to death row – only to be exonerated years later through DNA testing – have urged Alabama Governor Bob Riley to order DNA testing for Thomas Arthur, whose execution was delayed by the U.S. Supreme Court earlier this month. Arthur maintains his innocence, and DNA testing on evidence from the crime scene could show whether he is guilty or innocent. The Innocence Project has been requesting DNA testing in the case since August, but Riley has refused. Hours before Arthur was set to be executed earlier this month, the U.S. Supreme Court issued a stay in the case until constitutional questions about lethal injection are resolved. Noting that DNA testing can be completed in less than a month, the Innocence Project has again asked Riley to order testing in the case (while the execution is stayed). In a letter sent to Riley, six men who were sentenced to die and later exonerated through DNA testing asked Riley to order DNA testing in Arthur’s case immediately. “In each of our cases, juries heard evidence they believed was overwhelming and proved our guilt beyond doubt. Prosecutors, judges or governors rejected our initial pleas for DNA testing,” the letter says. “Each of us sat on death row, wondering whether the truth would come out before we were executed. And each of us was spared when the irrefutable science of DNA proved that we were innocent.” The letter to Riley marks the first time that several people who were exonerated through DNA after serving time on death row have directly asked a governor to order DNA testing in a case, the Innocence Project said. Since the Innocence Project launched a web-based letter-writing campaign earlier this month, 1,200 people in Alabama and across the country have written to Riley urging him to order testing in Arthur’s case. The exonerated former death row inmates who signed the letter to Riley include Earl Washington of Virginia, who came within nine days of being executed in Virginia; DNA proved his innocence in 2000. Ryan Matthews, who was just 17 years old when he was sentenced to die in Louisiana, also signed the letter to Riley; he served five years on death row until he was exonerated through DNA testing in 2004. Following is the text of the letter sent to Riley: December 20, 2007 By Facsimile and Overnight Mail The Honorable Bob Riley Governor of the State of Alabama State Capitol 600 Dexter Avenue Montgomery, AL 36130 Re: Thomas Arthur Dear Governor Riley: Over the last several days, you have heard from hundreds of people in Alabama and across the nation asking you to order DNA testing for Thomas Arthur, who is on death row in Alabama. We write to you today because we were all convicted and sentenced to die for crimes we did not commit, only to be exonerated years later through DNA testing. In each of our cases, juries heard evidence they believed was overwhelming and proved our guilt beyond doubt. Prosecutors, judges or governors rejected our initial pleas for DNA testing. Each of us sat on death row, wondering whether the truth would come out before we were executed. And each of us was spared when the irrefutable science of DNA proved that we were innocent. We do not know whether Tommy Arthur is guilty or innocent. None of us has met him, nor have we reviewed all of the briefs in his case. We do know it’s entirely possible that DNA testing could provide compelling proof of his guilt or innocence – and we know, based on our own experience, that when science can reveal the truth, DNA testing must be conducted. If we had never been granted DNA testing, we might not be alive today. Few people have been in Mr. Arthur’s position, but we have – and that’s why we’re appealing to you to order DNA testing in this case. His execution has been delayed by the U.S. Supreme Court for other reasons, leaving plenty of time for DNA testing to be completed if you order it now. Any of us would welcome the opportunity to talk with you or your staff about our cases – and about the DNA testing that proved our innocence and kept the state from carrying out an irreversible miscarriage of justice. You or your staff can contact the Innocence Project attorneys who have been in touch with you about Mr. Arthur’s case to arrange a discussion with any of us. Sincerely, Rolando Cruz Exonerated though DNA testing in 1995 – a decade after being sentenced to death in Illinois Charles Irvin Fain Exonerated through DNA testing in 2001 – more than 17 years after being sentenced to death in Idaho Ray Krone Exonerated through DNA testing in 2002 – a decade after being sentenced to death in Arizona Ryan Matthews Exonerated through DNA testing in 2004 – five years after being sentenced to death in Louisiana Curtis McCarty Exonerated through DNA testing in 2007 – 21 years after being sentenced to death in Oklahoma Earl Washington Exonerated through DNA testing in 2000 – 17 years after being sentenced to death in Virginia The Innocence Project, which does not represent Arthur and does not have a position on his guilt or innocence, has said for several months that DNA testing in the case could show whether the initial story from the victim’s wife was, in fact, accurate. (She initially claimed a stranger – someone other than Arthur – broke into their home, raped her and killed her husband. Police suspected she was lying, and she was charged and convicted in her murder. She then changed her story and testified against Arthur in order to be released from prison earlier.) Several pieces of evidence – the victim’s wife’s blood-stained clothing, a rape kit collected from her after the crime, and hairs in the victim’s wife’s car – could be subjected to DNA testing. The testing could show that her testimony against Arthur was false; hers was the only testimony linking him to the crime. For example, it’s possible that the testing could show that her original story was true and that she was raped, and the DNA profile from evidence in the rape could be entered in the federal DNA database and yield a hit to a man matching her initial description of the intruder at the couple’s home. 12-26-07  

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

you are not remotely open-minded! Do you realize what you would find if you opened your mind? You'd find the exact opposite of what you spend your efforts on currently. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

KUers, think of all the times that some high profile crime has taken place, and you've been convinced that the trial was a joke, and that the judge and the jury let a murderer off, or with just a "slap on the hand". Think of all the times that you've thought that the judicial system didn't get it right. Think of all the times that you've been convinced that the judge and the jury had made a mistake. A couple of questions for those who might be reading the thread: Would you support the death penalty even if it meant occasionally executing an innocent person? Would you support cutting off appeals, and shortening the time between conviction and execution, even if it meant occasionally executing an innocent person? 

whatchamacallit --- 18 years ago -

Do you sit at your computer hours on end looking this stuff up? I am starting to wonder if you have a personal interest in the use or non-use of the death penalty. Is someone you love on death row or been executed? 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

New district attorney strikes a blow for justice 09:12 AM CST on Wednesday, December 26, 2007 As a campaign strategy, it seemed like a tough sell. Pledging to be "smart on crime" in a high-crime atmosphere was a risky move. Still, Craig Watkins convinced voters that the tough tactics they'd come to expect from the district attorney's office weren't working. He's a Democrat and a former defense lawyer – two distinctions that would have spelled certain political doom in Dallas County's recent past. But in January, Mr. Watkins became Texas' first black district attorney. No doubt the Carter High School graduate was helped by a rising Democratic tide in winning election. Once he took the helm, though, Mr. Watkins quickly made a national name for himself with a progressive approach to crime and punishment. Under Mr. Watkins, an office that once seemed focused on a "lock 'em up" strategy now embraces the need to "let 'em out" when mistakes have been made. He has opened his doors – and Dallas County's files – to the Innocence Project, working with the New York-based group to uncover wrongful convictions. Dallas has had more DNA exonerations – 14 so far – than any other county in the nation. Mr. Watkins has not tried to play down these grievous errors and instead has focused on ensuring that Dallas County gets it right under his watch. He is as committed to ensuring that innocent men walk free as he is to punishing the guilty. And when the falsely accused have had their names cleared, Mr. Watkins has been in the courtroom to apologize for the injustice. So far, Mr. Watkins has struck a balance, emphasizing both the importance of rehabilitating minor offenders and the need to slam the jail cell shut on career criminals. He also has gone public with his personal misgivings about the death penalty, walking a narrow line as he tries to uphold Texas law and explain his own convictions. And while this juxtaposition at times has been awkward, Mr. Watkins' willingness to point up capital punishment's inherent flaws is commendable. Mr. Watkins, who is 40, says he aspired to this job for two decades. One year in, and he still is finding his footing as Dallas County district attorney. But Mr. Watkins' bold ideas and innovative approach to the job put him among the finalists for Dallas Morning News Texan of the Year. Already other district attorneys in Texas and beyond are taking notice of Mr. Watkins' initiatives. And now, "smart on crime" doesn't seem like such a tough sell after all. 

txdaddy --- 18 years ago -

Would you support the death penalty even if it meant occasionally executing an innocent person? even if the men were not guilty of the specific crime...i do not believe they are totally innocent either....you ever been "mistakenly" put on death row? Would you support cutting off appeals, and shortening the time between conviction and execution, even if it meant occasionally executing an innocent person? cutting off ALL appeals? no, they get one...that's it. so the wording of your question is flawed...one and done...the judge should not even be able to hit the gavel on the bench before the switch is flicked 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

Would you support the death penalty even if it meant occasionally executing an innocent person? even if the men were not guilty of the specific crime...i do not believe they are totally innocent either....you ever been "mistakenly" put on death row? "Logic" symptomatic of the disease that is the death penalty in Texas 

get_the_lead_out! --- 18 years ago -

so the problem isn't with the punishment itself according to this article, it's the system itself. We work and live with the best way to bring criminals to justice. If there is a way to tweak the system itself then we should do it but as for the punishment being death for certain crimes committed I don't have a problem with that. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

My take on this - Executing someone who is not guilty of a specific crime just because they may be guilty of some other crime sounds like a really bad twist of our justice system and our laws. I can't believe anyone would support that. Not in this country. If you do, perhaps you should punish your children once a week even if there is no reason - just in case, as they will never be totally innocent. I'm sure that will do wonders for their education. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

I asked on the other threads, and I'll ask again here - produce any data supporting the theory that capital punishment helps reduce crime. 

get_the_lead_out! --- 18 years ago -

My take on this - Executing someone who is not guilty of a specific crime just because they may be guilty of some other crime sounds like a really bad twist of our justice system and our laws. I can't believe anyone would support that. Not in this country. If you do, perhaps you should punish your children once a week even if there is no reason - just in case, as they will never be totally innocent. I'm sure that will do wonders for their education. But when they are guilty of a crime grievous enough to warrent the death penalty, the question should be asked do you believe in it then? Say the criminal even confesses to his crimes? Trying to frame the argument that we should get rid of the death penalty because of flaws in the system is different than do you believe that it is wrong to enforce the death penalty. 

get_the_lead_out! --- 18 years ago -

where did i say it helps reduce crime? Personal opinion is I believe it does but I am not using that for my arguement. Does going to prison help reduce the numbers of gang violence? I'm guessing the numbers wouldn't support that either and if that is true, why do we even bring criminals to trial? 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

But when they are guilty of a crime grievous enough to warrent the death penalty, the question should be asked do you believe in it then? No. As I said, it is not a matter of "belief", there is no concrete data showing that death penalty helps reduce crime. Why invest time and money trying to fix a pseudo solution? Let's put the effort identifying the real root cause of crime and fight it instead. I'll repeat again - I'd like to know what people really want, reduce crime or kill criminals. 

get_the_lead_out! --- 18 years ago -

The question isn't to me whether it reduces crime or not, its whether the crime deserves the death penalty. Do the numbers show a reduce rate in gang violence or hate crimes because of the penalties enforced on them at this time? So if just serving time in the slammer isn't a deterrent what is? Education? What will fill the gap between the way things are now and people are educated? 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

The question isn't to me whether it reduces crime or not, its whether the crime deserves the death penalty. Now the Christian will speak, and for the record, I think church and state should remain separate. The way I see it, if there is a chance that, by reflecting on his/her crime, a criminal may repent and save his/her soul, I think he/she deserves the opportunity. Lock them up for life, make them work to pay for the incarceration costs. So if just serving time in the slammer isn't a deterrent what is? Education? What will fill the gap between the way things are now and people are educated? Quote from Wikipedia - With few exceptions, there also seems to be a strong correlation between median household income and crime rates. In addition to having the country's lowest crime rates, New England states also had the country's highest median household income. Almost all of the nation's wealthiest twenty states, which included northern mid-western and western states such as Wisconsin and California, had crime rates below the national average. The nation's more dangerous states such as Arizona, Arkansas and Texas in turn ranked among those with a household income below the national median. For example, New Hampshire was the nation's wealthiest state and safest state. New Hampshire's total crime rate was 57.9%; its violent crime rate was 64.1% and its homicide rate 69.1% below the national average. Connecticut, the nation's fourth wealthiest state, had a crime rate 27% and a homicide rate 52.7% below the national average. This contrasts starkly to some of the nation's poorer states such as Georgia, Florida or Louisiana. Louisiana had a crime rate 27% and a homicide rate 130.9% above the national average and ranked as the nation's fourth poorest state with a median household income 20% below the national median. While these trends hold generally true, it should be noted, that several states who fell below the national median for household income such as New York, Maine and Kentucky also had crime rates below the national average, while some wealthier states such as Maryland and Hawaii had crime rates above the national average. 

txdaddy --- 18 years ago -

"Logic" symptomatic of the disease that is the death penalty in Texas when a disease is found, look for the cause...if the cause cannot be determined or remedied...remove the whole being. maybe you should move to a more pro criminal community? those who do not believe the death penalty is a "disease" will remain here and gladly pray for the vicitms and their families 

txdaddy --- 18 years ago -

If you do, perhaps you should punish your children once a week even if there is no reason - just in case, as they will never be totally innocent. I'm sure that will do wonders for their education. amusing...death row criminals compared to my children's "crimes"...i wuld expect nothing less than that kind of reach for an argument 

txdaddy --- 18 years ago -

as mentioned before, how would one determine if the death penalty dissuaded them from committing a crime? it is impossible to extract data from "almost crimes" 

bbjones --- 18 years ago -

Now the Christian will speak, and for the record, I think church and state should remain separate. That is definitely not a Christian response. A TRUE Christian should have Jesus as a part of EVERYTHING that they do in life. "And whatsoever ye do, do it heartily, as to the Lord, and not unto men;" (Colossians 3:23) There are some who believe themselves to be Christian just because they believe Jesus to be a great man and teacher and that by trying their "best" to follow Jesus' teachings, they "qualify" as a Christian, because in their minds a Christian is someone who "follows" Jesus. Jesus Himself tells us of those so-called Christians. Wherefore by their fruits ye shall know them. Not every one that saith unto me, Lord, Lord, shall enter into the kingdom of heaven; but he that doeth the will of my Father which is in heaven. Many will say to me in that day, Lord, Lord, have we not prophesied in thy name? and in thy name have cast out devils? and in thy name done many wonderful works? And then will I profess unto them, I never knew you: depart from me, ye that work iniquity." (Matthew 7:20-23) 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

This particular thread is about individuals who had each spent years on death row and who were then exonerated by DNA evidence and released. No Christian would claim that it is God's will that people be executed for crimes of which they were not guilty. 

get_the_lead_out! --- 18 years ago -

This particular thread is about individuals who had each spent years on death row and who were then exonerated by DNA evidence and released. so is this thread to bring attention to the 6 that were innocent or to the death penalty itself? In combination with the other threads you have started, the agenda seems to be about the death penalty itself? Everytime you find an article that you feels supports your side of an issue, you start a new thread instead of continuing and adding all in one thread. Why is that? To make it look like this is a hot issue with the community at this time if you have multiple threads about it? or to try an create a hot button issue on what you want to talk about? 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

so is this thread to bring attention to the 6 that were innocent or to the death penalty itself? Yes 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

when a disease is found, look for the cause...if the cause cannot be determined or remedied...remove the whole being. It's good that you aren't a doctor. 

bbjones --- 18 years ago -

No Christian would claim that it is God's will that people be executed for crimes of which they were not guilty. No one has said that but you. 

txdaddy --- 18 years ago -

It's good that you aren't a doctor. even better to know you aren't a judge 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

Wherefore by their fruits ye shall know them. Absolutely. James 2:26, "As the body without the spirit is dead, so faith without deeds is dead." Two points - 1. If there is a chance, no matter how small, that we kill an innocent person, this alone should be enough argument to abolish the death penalty. 2. If there is a chance, no matter how small, that if given time a criminal may repent and save his/her soul, we should give that person a chance. As a Christian, I think this is the right thing to do. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

amusing...death row criminals compared to my children's "crimes"...i wuld expect nothing less than that kind of reach for an argument Not comparing, since you will not sentence your kids to death for stealing cookies. Just give them some time off every week, they will know why they are being punished... 

bbjones --- 18 years ago -

1. If there is a chance, no matter how small, that we kill an innocent person, this alone should be enough argument to abolish the death penalty. Where is your proof for that statement. If there is a chance, no matter how small, that if given time a criminal may repent and save his/her soul, we should give that person a chance. As a Christian, I think this is the right thing to do. A person does not need a lifetime to make that decision for Christ. And what about the person they have killed or may kill in the future. What if that murderer took away their "chance" to repent? God allowed the death penalty to be carried out for man's disobedience, and He will allow it to STAND for all who do not become born again with a NEW Spirit from God. How is it that you think you know more than God? It may be that a higher percentage of the criminals that were executed came to know Christ than the ones that spend their entire life in prison. The instant fear of eternal damnation just might be the catalyst that saves them. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

Where is your proof for that statement. Did you read the article posted? There are 6 cases mentioned. What if that murderer took away their "chance" to repent? One mistake does not justify the other. God allowed the death penalty to be carried out for man's disobedience, and He will allow it to STAND for all who do not become born again with a NEW Spirit from God. I'll ask again - show me concrete data proving that death penalty reduces crime, and I'll take it into consideration. It may be that a higher percentage of the criminals that were executed came to know Christ than the ones that spend their entire life in prison. The instant fear of eternal damnation just might be the catalyst that saves them. Where is your proof for that statement? 

bbjones --- 18 years ago -

It may be that a higher percentage of the criminals that were executed came to know Christ than the ones that spend their entire life in prison. The instant fear of eternal damnation just might be the catalyst that saves them. Where is your proof for that statement? Did you forget to read the word "may"? Where is your proof for that statement. Did you read the article posted? There are 6 cases mentioned. That is no proof that we should abolish the death penalty just because some mistakes are made in the justice system. Mistakes are made in the airline industry and "innocent" people are killed. Should we abolish air travel? I'll ask again - show me concrete data proving that death penalty reduces crime, and I'll take it into consideration. God's Word is my proof. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

That is no proof that we should abolish the death penalty just because some mistakes are made in the justice system. Mistakes are made in the airline industry and "innocent" people are killed. Should we abolish air travel? Completely different situation - one can be avoided, the other can't. 

bbjones --- 18 years ago -

Completely different situation - one can be avoided, the other can't. Are you serious? Both could be avoided. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

Are you serious? Both could be avoided. You have an option to travel by plane or not. It is your choice. If you are mistakenly convicted and sentenced to death, the choice was made for you. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

There are people on KU, who call themselves Christians, who are willing to execute the occasional person not guilty of the crime for which they are executed in order to retain the death penalty. That speaks volumes. 

Big Daddy --- 18 years ago -

they're probably all black black people rape it's a proven fact AMEN! 

Big Daddy --- 18 years ago -

they're probably all black black people rape it's a proven fact AMEN! 

naturegirl --- 18 years ago -

Accent, Name one person that has been wrongly executed in the past 5 years. 

Big Daddy --- 18 years ago -

OJ simpson 

bbjones --- 18 years ago -

There are people on KU, who call themselves Christians, who are willing to murder the occasional person, not guilty of ANYTHING, in order to allow people to not be inconvenienced because they could not refrain from sex. That speaks volumes. 

Big Daddy --- 18 years ago -

you said that already shut up you retard 

page 1 2 3
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...

news
politics
religion


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground