Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Teen womb removal???

who's talking here?

GCan 2
ilovemykids1030 2
Curarie 1
archsbaby 4
cowboyswife 1
crrc 2
Syrah1214 3
proudmomoftwo 2
2coolboyz 3
proudmama1 1
Cristie 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

crrc --- 19 years ago -

teen girls mother wants to have her womb removed... What ya think?  

Syrah1214 --- 19 years ago -

My best friend growing up had Cerebral Palsy and was confined to a wheel chair. I know there are different areas of the body affected by CP, but going off of the one person I knew who had it, she was a straight-A student, went to college and hopefully someday will find a man who looks past her body and will marry her. She wants children. I think to remove her uterus to avoid menstruation cramps is crazy. Give her some tylenol or motrin the first few days of her cycle... but for goodness sake, don't alter the girl permanently unable to bear children because you think you're doing her a favor by taking away cramps a few days out of the month. 

ilovemykids1030 --- 19 years ago -

wow. i agree with her mother. 

2coolboyz --- 19 years ago -

I just read it... Honestly, I don't think it is degrading to the disabled. The womb is there to have kids - if she never will leave her parents home (which is what it sounds like) then why put her through the pain. Plus, as a caregiver - would you honestly want to deal with the periods on top of taking care of her every need? I know that sounds cruel, but it would be a fact to consider. 

Cristie --- 19 years ago -

I think that if the girl has cerebal palsy then why would she need her stuff? I think that if I had a daughter that had cerebal palsy I would do it to. 

GCan --- 19 years ago -

Not every woman has cramps, headaches or whatnot during their cycle. 

archsbaby --- 19 years ago -

I don't know...I am on the fence on this one. I can certainly see the mother's point of view on this, however. She would be sparing a child that would not understand a lot of discomfort, not to mention, if she is a total-care child, which it sounds like she is, it would be easier on her caretakers. I have worked in long-term care before, and seen mentally and physically disabled kids going through this. They see blood and automatically think, if they have the cognitive capability of doing so, that blood is associated with death or injury. Maybe in her case, it is the best thing. I can see this opening a huge can of worms, though. I do believe she has a valid argument....I guess my fear is, what does this open the door to? 

Curarie --- 19 years ago -

I didn't realize but I posted about this same issue. What if the parents are strict Catholics and don't believe in any form of birth control? 

GCan --- 19 years ago -

What if the parents are strict Catholics and don't believe in any form of birth control? They probably wouldn't believe in sterilization either. 

archsbaby --- 19 years ago -

I don't think this is a case of a cognitive kid with CP. It sounds like she is severely disabled. If she wasn't, then I am sure she would have a voice in this. My niece that passed in June would never have left home. Her disabilities were mentally and physically crippling. I really believe that this is something that would have faced her parents. She would have never married, never had children, never would have had any desire to do such, as it was well beyond her realm of thinking. The more I think about this, and after reading the article again, I would side with the mother. I really believe that in her heart, she feels she is doing what is best for her child. 

Syrah1214 --- 19 years ago -

What if the parents are strict Catholics and don't believe in any form of birth control? If a woman has a medical condition and needs to have her uterus taken out, it's not against Catholic teaching. Things like tubal ligations, vasectomies, birth control pills, condoms, iud's, withdrawl, etc... those are all against the teachings because they're deliberately avoiding conception. However, if a woman has a hormone imbalance or what-not and her doctor says birth control pills are the way to handle the situation because it will balance the hormones, that's fine, but it's just when measures are taken to avoid pregnancy is when it's going against church teachings. 

crrc --- 19 years ago -

Dd is a teenager, and she has EXTREMELY painful cramping and cycles. I am seriously considering getting her 'on' something for it. She is a good girl and me and dh have went back and forth on the issue. But, she is of sound mind and body. I see kids every day with different illnesses, including CP. Some with MRCP. There are different levels of being affected. docswife, sounds like your friend is an exception to this. There are more severe cases of CP, where the individual has to literally be taken complete care of for their entire lifetime. I really have opinions going both ways-- thank the Lord I don't have to make that choice! 

ilovemykids1030 --- 19 years ago -

An IUD can minimize or stop menstruation. BC medication can regulate and sometimes prevent it. this is true! that should be an otion for her also! 

archsbaby --- 19 years ago -

What if the parents are strict Catholics and don't believe in any form of birth control? If they were, this would not even be considered, I am sure. I work for a Catholic hospital. Our insurance does not provide for birth control, sterilization, infertility treatments, and I am finding now, since I find out next week if I am having it done, there are strict guidelines as to when a hysterectomy can be performed. I think this is going to be more a legal battle about rights, more than what could be considered a "moral" battle. 

Syrah1214 --- 19 years ago -

What if the parents are strict Catholics and don't believe in any form of birth control? If they were, this would not even be considered, I am sure. It isn't mentioned, though, that the mother's intent on doing this is to avoid pregnancy in her daughter. She says she's doing it to avoid cramps, etc., which can be a medical condition if it's from endometriosis, etc. 

proudmama1 --- 19 years ago -

It depends on the cognitive level of the girl. If she can make her own decisions and can understand the consequences, I think it should be left to her, when the time is right. Until the time is right,put her on the shot to help with cramping, etc. 

archsbaby --- 19 years ago -

Sounds to me like this girl does not have a high cognitive level. The mother stated that she would not understand menstruation and all that comes with it. 

proudmomoftwo --- 19 years ago -

It could be possible the mom is just being lazy and not wanting to care for the daughters cycle etc.. Seems drastic to me.. I know its a long shot but what if a cure was found tomorrow? Just a thought. 

2coolboyz --- 19 years ago -

Catholics and don't believe in any form of birth control? They're not looking for BC, they are looking for a way to maintain her way of life. Why add to her problems with a period. 

2coolboyz --- 19 years ago -

It could be possible the mom is just being lazy and not wanting to care for the daughters cycle etc possible...but why be lazy over a 3-5 day of changing out pads when you are dealing with day to day issues that are much greater than that. Imagine having to wipe and clean your child everytime they went to the bathroom - at 15 yrs old. bathing, grooming, feeding, EVERYTHING... 

cowboyswife --- 19 years ago -

Wow, I had never even thought about something like this, and I thank God everyday that our children are HEALTHY. I can see the Mom's point on the matter, she just wants what is best for daughter in the long run, and like she said she will not understand what is happening monthly, cramps, bleeding, etc. I do not think the Mom is being lazy, I think she has her daughters best intrests at heart. I cannot imagine having to make a decision regarding something of this nature. 

proudmomoftwo --- 19 years ago -

well the child has to relieve themselves too.. So do we take care of that too? Its a sad subject, I dont have the answer. I would think though removing her female organs does pose a risk also.. Hormonal and it is a major surgery, not sure its worth the risk.. There are ways she could be made to only have a few cycles a year... 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground