Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Less Than Half of all Published Scientists Endorse Global Warming Theory

who's talking here?

bbjones 1
planemom 1
Justwatching72 5
gking 5
maverick 1
CyberSage 2
Tyrus 1
Going off air 1
ChezML 2
proudmomoftwo 2
Cicero 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Tyrus --- 19 years ago -

August 29, 2007 Posted by Matthew_Dempsey@epw.senate.gov (4:45pm ET) Last week in his blog post, New Peer-Reviewed Scientific Studies Chill Global Warming Fears, on the Inhofe EPW Press Blog, Marc Morano cited a July 2007 review of 539 abstracts in peer-reviewed scientific journals from 2004 through 2007 that found that climate science continues to shift toward the views of global warming skeptics. Today, Michael Asher provides more details about this new survey in his blog post, Survey: Less Than Half Of All Published Scientists Endorse Global Warming Theory. Asher writes that the study has been submitted for publication in the journal Energy and Environment. DAILYTECH SURVEY: LESS THAN HALF OF ALL PUBLISHED SCIENTISTS ENDORSE GLOBAL WARMING THEORY; COMPREHENSIVE SURVEY OF PUBLISHED CLIMATE RESEARCH REVEALS CHANGING VIEWPOINTS Michael Asher August 29, 2007 11:07 AM In 2004, history professor Naomi Oreskes performed a survey of research papers on climate change. Examining peer-reviewed papers published on the ISI Web of Science database from 1993 to 2003, she found a majority supported the "consensus view," defined as humans were having at least some effect on global climate change. Oreskes' work has been repeatedly cited, but as some of its data is now nearly 15 years old, its conclusions are becoming somewhat dated. Medical researcher Dr. Klaus-Martin Schulte recently updated this research. Using the same database and search terms as Oreskes, he examined all papers published from 2004 to February 2007. The results have been submitted to the journal Energy and Environment, of which DailyTech has obtained a pre-publication copy. The figures are surprising. Of 528 total papers on climate change, only 38 (7%) gave an explicit endorsement of the consensus. If one considers "implicit" endorsement (accepting the consensus without explicit statement), the figure rises to 45%. However, while only 32 papers (6%) reject the consensus outright, the largest category (48%) are neutral papers, refusing to either accept or reject the hypothesis. This is no "consensus." The figures are even more shocking when one remembers the watered-down definition of consensus here. Not only does it not require supporting that man is the "primary" cause of warming, but it doesn't require any belief or support for "catastrophic" global warming. In fact of all papers published in this period (2004 to February 2007), only a single one makes any reference to climate change leading to catastrophic results. These changing viewpoints represent the advances in climate science over the past decade. While today we are even more certain the earth is warming, we are less certain about the root causes. More importantly, research has shown us that -- whatever the cause may be -- the amount of warming is unlikely to cause any great calamity for mankind or the planet itself. Schulte's survey contradicts the United Nation IPCC's Fourth Assessment Report (2007), which gave a figure of "90% likely" man was having an impact on world temperatures. But does the IPCC represent a consensus view of world scientists? Despite media claims of "thousands of scientists" involved in the report, the actual text is written by a much smaller number of "lead authors." The introductory "Summary for Policymakers" -- the only portion usually quoted in the media -- is written not by scientists at all, but by politicians, and approved, word-by-word, by political representatives from member nations. By IPCC policy, the individual report chapters -- the only text actually written by scientists -- are edited to "ensure compliance" with the summary, which is typically published months before the actual report itself. By contrast, the ISI Web of Science database covers 8,700 journals and publications, including every leading scientific journal in the world.  

proudmomoftwo --- 19 years ago -

I kinda think its a crock myself!! 

Going off air --- 19 years ago -

I kinda think its a crock myself!! No! Polish scientists are smart and Polished scientists are even smarter 

planemom --- 19 years ago -

Do you think the UN might have skewed the report a bit to make the US look bad? Or too slow down growth in the US so other nations can catch up? 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Do you think the UN might have skewed the report a bit to make the US look bad? Yes 

maverick --- 19 years ago -

I am going to have to consult with Al Gore about this. Or maybe NOT. 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

Why the big debate about Global Warming anyway? What the heck does it matter if it's true or not. It's a useless argument. 

CyberSage --- 19 years ago -

This debate is about one thing and one thing only, in my opinion. That is, the redistribution of wealth from the have's to the have nots via any means necessary. The truth is irrelevant. Any time you see a committed capitalist who endorses the current man-made global warming theory, that person/company is being duplicitous. In reality, they are not acknowledging the man-made hypothesis, but rather that its acceptance by the global community is inevitable. Thus, they are really angling to make a buck off the whole deal, either by selling "green" products, improving their environmental image, or avoiding boycotts, etc. Pure and simple. 

proudmomoftwo --- 19 years ago -

Ask Al, you will find him in his "lockbox". 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

Thus, they are really angling to make a buck off the whole deal, either by selling "green" products, improving their environmental image, or avoiding boycotts, etc. Seems to me that there's money to be made from both sides of the argument. Honestly, right or wrong it wouldn't hurt us to clean up the planet a little. 

gking --- 19 years ago -

I wouldn't begin to argue with those of you who hold on so dearly to one belief or another about this issue of "global warming", or the more accurate term: climate change, however, I would like to point out something in regard to what is being suggested by the title of this topic.....SO WHAT! Many many times in mankind's history, explanations and beliefs about lesser (or non) understood phenomenon were held as fact and truth by most if not all of civilization, only to be proved differently as consequences played out, more observations and discoveries were made, and a greater understanding came to be known. Historical examples would include: - a flat earth - a geocentric universe - the nature and states of matter So it should come as no surprise at all that something that is still not quite that well understood by scientists would divide them. And even less surprising that new understandings are much less convincing to those who don't understand it at all! You know, for thousands of years everyone believed that the Earth was the center of the Universe, that the Sun and the planets and everything else seen with the naked eye revolved around the Earth. And through the ages, some very heavyweight "scientists" and thinkers were believers and proponents of this notion, including Aristotle and Ptolemy - whom created very convincing theories and models that everyone steadfastly believed as truth and fact. It wasn't until relatively recently that this notion was challenged - after thousands of years! And just because everyone in the world didn't believe what Copernicus believed - that the Earth, together with the moon and the planets revolved about the Sun - didn't, and doesn't - make it false. I'd say way more than half the scientists didn't endorse the heliocentric theory back in the 1500's. And still way more than half disagreed when Galileo came on board and even proved and refined the heliocentric theories with observations made with his new-fangled instrument: the telescope. It boggles my mind that we continue to doubt so vehemently that which we barely understand in the face of all the compelling evidence, and that we use such lame logic as citing how many so-called "scientists" won't go down on paper as "endorsing" this phenomenon or not. I guess we need to either destroy the planet, or at least render it uninhabitable for humans (I believe the planet will not feel a thing actually), just as Columbus was willing to sail off the edge of the Earth before we can look back and say - wow, maybe we should have done something just in case. 

ChezML --- 19 years ago -

This debate is about one thing and one thing only, in my opinion. That is, the redistribution of wealth from the have's to the have nots via any means necessary. The truth is irrelevant. How right you are about the economics. Here's an abstract in the current issue of that journal: Hot planet, cold wars: climate change and ideological conflict Author: Kane, Thomas M. Source: Energy & Environment, Volume 18, Number 5, September 2007 , pp. 533-547(15) Publisher: Multi-Science Publishing Co Ltd Abstract: Shared challenges can bring out the best in people, but they can also do the opposite. Global climate change is an archetypal shared challenge for humanity, and although the threat has inspired a substantial amount of international co-operation, efforts to moderate it have already proven divisive. These divisions go beyond economically-driven haggling over who must reduce greenhouse gas emissions by what amount. Attempts to mitigate human civilisation's effects on the climate raise questions of political principle. Moreover, these questions have the specific potential to mobilise certain states and quasi-states against certain other ones, and this has implications for the field of security studies. Thus, climate change threatens to revive ideological dispute among armed, organised economically-developed societies. Although the idea of a world war over carbon remains far-fetched, the parallels with the international politics of the mid-20th century are disturbing. Policymakers would be wise to take the political questions of climate change more seriously than they appear to have done in the past. Scholars may note that disputes over global warming challenge influential models of contemporary global politics. This paper explores the reasons why controversies over climate policy are likely to prove particularly divisive in international politics. The first section discusses the relative ideological consensus that has prevailed among developed societies since the collapse of the Soviet Union. Even pessimistic theorists initially took this consensus for granted. As of 2005, however, this consensus is stretched thin on numerous issues. One of these issues is climate policy. A second section of this paper discusses the stakes in the climate debate, suggesting that this dispute is likely to be a particularly important one. The third section notes that attempts to limit global carbon dioxide emissions raise questions about citizens' relationships to each other and to the state. Historically, such questions have raised issues of principle. These issues have had moral and emotional implications that run far beyond the material issues involved. Many nations, notably the US, have resolved these issues by adopting the political system known as republicanism. A fourth section discusses the concept of a republic and the problems it presents for those who wish to develop an international policy to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. The fifth section notes that a broad, if informal, movement in early 21st century politics directly challenges republicanism. Debates over climate policy have already served to deepen this division. A conclusion sums up the paper's findings and reflects on their implications. Future work in the field of security studies will need to address the potential friction between republican and anti-republican political entities, and this paper highlights one of the forms this friction may take. 

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

I wouldn't begin to argue with those of you who hold on so dearly to one belief or another about this issue of "global warming", or the more accurate term: climate change, however, I would like to point out something in regard to what is being suggested by the title of this topic.....SO WHAT! Many many times in mankind's history, explanations and beliefs about lesser (or non) understood phenomenon were held as fact and truth by most if not all of civilization, only to be proved differently as consequences played out, more observations and discoveries were made, and a greater understanding came to be known. Historical examples would include: - a flat earth - a geocentric universe - the nature and states of matter So it should come as no surprise at all that something that is still not quite that well understood by scientists would divide them. And even less surprising that new understandings are much less convincing to those who don't understand it at all! You know, for thousands of years everyone believed that the Earth was the center of the Universe, that the Sun and the planets and everything else seen with the naked eye revolved around the Earth. And through the ages, some very heavyweight "scientists" and thinkers were believers and proponents of this notion, including Aristotle and Ptolemy - whom created very convincing theories and models that everyone steadfastly believed as truth and fact. It wasn't until relatively recently that this notion was challenged - after thousands of years! And just because everyone in the world didn't believe what Copernicus believed - that the Earth, together with the moon and the planets revolved about the Sun - didn't, and doesn't - make it false. I'd say way more than half the scientists didn't endorse the heliocentric theory back in the 1500's. And still way more than half disagreed when Galileo came on board and even proved and refined the heliocentric theories with observations made with his new-fangled instrument: the telescope. It boggles my mind that we continue to doubt so vehemently that which we barely understand in the face of all the compelling evidence, and that we use such lame logic as citing how many so-called "scientists" won't go down on paper as "endorsing" this phenomenon or not. I guess we need to either destroy the planet, or at least render it uninhabitable for humans (I believe the planet will not feel a thing actually), just as Columbus was willing to sail off the edge of the Earth before we can look back and say - wow, maybe we should have done something just in case. gking, boyscout post: Furthermore, I sure am sick and tired of the soapbox lectures on this forum.  

ChezML --- 19 years ago -

My apologies, JW ;-) 

gking --- 19 years ago -

gking, boyscout post: Furthermore, I sure am sick and tired of the soapbox lectures on this forum. So, what relevance does this have to this discussion? For that matter, what relevance does any of your finger-pointing posts have to the threads you post them on? How do they at all contribute to the subject matter of the thread? Do they serve any purpose other than to give you a sense of purpose and righteousness oh great one? Does it make you feel better? You've proven you're an ass and a pot-stirrer and quite hung up on yourself. I refuse to engage further with you and digress from whatever thread it is you choose to attack on. But, I'm sure - we all appreciate your valuable input. 

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

Just pointing out your hypocrisy is all Jorge.. ChezML, i dont mind the soap box stuff..but gking seems to have a problem with it when it's other people doing the talking, but for him it's still ok. 

gking --- 19 years ago -

ChezML, i dont mind the soap box stuff..but gking seems to have a problem with it when it's other people doing the talking, but for him it's still ok. So very sorry that you manage to confuse soapbox lectures with an intelligent presentation of a viewpoint. I know it's not all your fault. A real education might have helped you. But others might become confused. (learning how to spell would be a great start for ya!) 

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

(learning how to spell would be a great start for ya!) threats in pm's towards me would NOT be a good start..oh wait....you already did that.. 

gking --- 19 years ago -

threats in pm's towards me would NOT be a good start..oh wait....you already did that.. You might also learn the difference between a threat and a warning. But feel free to twist anything around as you see fit - it seems to be your style. 

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

so what are the consequences if i do not heed your 'warning'? by the way, telling me the name of my wife, and where i live and then saying.. 'You would be well advised not to get into your childish and vindictive games with me here.' should be construed as what? 

gking --- 19 years ago -

What do you want Mike? Huh? What is it that you want? What's going to make you happy? You want me to go away? Is this your board to police (still)? Are you still going into people's PM's and reading there private notes to each other? Are you still tracing everyone's IP addresses and keeping your little list up to date? You get off on terrorizing those you target? Is that what kind of place you like KU to be? You want to write me a ticket and send me on my way? Huh? What? I wasn't quite aware until now that we all exist here to please your whim. What is thy bidding, my master? Oh, and before you even entertain answering any of that - You can kiss my ass! 

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

So Georgie...keeping away from what might happen to me if i dont heed your threat huh? typical.. really whose ip's do i keep? and how exactly do you get into an encrypted SQL database to check pm's? not possible as far as I know. you can be ticked all you want...you made a post, i commented that i thought you were being a hypocrite...sucks huh? 

CyberSage --- 19 years ago -

Anyhoo... MY point is that most of the political debate over global warming has nothing to do with science, but is rather a veiled attempt to reintroduce the failed economic theories of Marx, Lenin, Pol-Pot, and Mao. If voluntary collectivisation of carbon can be achieved, it will make it all the more easy for the one world government assume power. Of course, thinking people know that it is folly to make the trees equal by "hatchet, ax, and saw;" and that in reality, the resultant new world will be one where "some animals are created more equal than others." However, if the political powers espousing human-induced climate change win their argument, they will be able to move toward this system without uncloaking their objective. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground