Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Making Judgements Without Judging Others

who's talking here?

Thoughtful 1
Fallon 3
bbjones 2
GHYC 1
accent_ 3
Reality is good 2
mamajulie 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

MAKING JUDGMENTS WITHOUT JUDGING OTHERS SCRIPTURE READINGS: Luke 6:37-38 I John 4:1 A few Sundays ago I preached a sermon based on a text from St. Paul about the sin of judging others, but did not take time to do that text justice. A few members made comments that indicated they were not just listening to the sermon, but thinking about it. One said, fairly gently, that for a preacher who talks a lot about not judging others, I can sound pretty judgmental about Fundamentalists. Another named a political leader with whom she disagrees vigorously and admitted that she had a hard time not judging his moral character. And a third raised the question that lies at the heart of today’s sermon: how can we obey the command “judge not lest ye be judged” and yet make the critical judgments, large and small, that underlie all moral choices and decisions? That’s a tough question, but an important one. Can we make the judgment that a person’s actions are clearly wrong without also in some sense judging the content of that person’s heart and soul? Can we judge something a sin without also judging the sinner? I believe we can and we must, but that it requires profound humility: the most dangerous and destructive people are always those who hold no doubt whatsoever that their views are correct. There is only one God and it’s not us, so we should be slow to anoint ourselves God’s official spokesperson. We do not have God’s knowledge or wisdom, and we cannot know the depth of another human being’s heart. But if you want a sense of just how hard it can be not to judge others, I have two words for you: Steven Avery. He has not yet been found guilty in a court of law, but if I collected a dime from every person present who believes he is innocent I suspect that I would still not be able to buy a cup of coffee. Given the strong hints that the death of the unfortunate victim was prolonged and so horrific that I try to keep images from forming in my mind, it is hardly surprising that we tend not only to assume his guilt, but to judge him to be one of the most monstrous people ever to have walked this earth. I try out my usual little rationales – he must suffer from a profound character disorder, a compulsion beyond my understanding – but it really does not help. “Judge not lest ye be judged” is a spiritual ideal that we will never fully live up to, no matter how hard we try, but if we would obey Jesus we must make the very best effort we possibly can. So to be a follower of Jesus means we must work diligently at not judging others, even knowing we will not always succeed. We are not to label another person or group of people as evil or immoral: Jesus prohibited us from casting stones unless we ourselves are without sin. But to be a follower of Jesus also means sharing in a community of common judgment called the Church. Let me share a portion of an essay written by Stanley Hauerwas and Mike Budde when we were founding an organization called The Ekklesia Project: “Friendship. If the Ekklesia Project is about anything it is about friendship. Most of us on the whole think we are ‘sorry excuses’ for being Christians, but like it or not, it turns out that is who we are. We are unsure what it means for us to be Christians, but we are very sure we cannot do it on our own. God, to our amazement, has raised up brothers and sisters in Christ from near and far and made it possible for us to claim one another as friends. That we can claim one another as friends even before we know one another well needs to be explained, [for it requires] rethinking what is meant by friendship in our society. Thomas Aquinas claimed that our final destiny is to be made friends with God – a view that obviously challenges the superficial understanding of friendship that assumes friends ‘like’ one another. We call each other ‘friends’ not because we expect to like one another, but because we cannot become friends with God unless we first become friends with others who seek to be friends with God. Charity, according to Aquinas, is the agent that makes such friendship possible. To be formed by charity, [by Christian love] … does not mean that we all share a common ‘experience,’ but – more important – that we share common judgments.[1]” There’s the word: judgment. We are fellow members of Christ’s body – friends – because we share essential judgments about what is true, what is good, what is right and wrong, and how we are called to live. As Christian friends we help one another to live lives that embody reconciliation, non-violence, compassion, generosity, honesty, and faithfulness. The judgments we share that shape the way we live come not just from our collective opinion that this is the right thing to do – they flow from God’s Word in Holy Scripture, the traditions of the Christian church passed down through the centuries, including the unique teachings of our own specific heritage, and the movement of the Holy Spirit in our midst. We seek to be formed by God, not by ourselves. We are not free to live as we please, do as we choose, or believe whatever we wish. We are accountable to God, and we are accountable to one another as Christian friends. We all have “casual friends” who are fun to be with and who share our tastes and interests, but what Plato called “virtuous friends” are the people who help us to become better persons by sharing our vision of what is right and good and having the courage to tell us when our life is veering from the path of virtue. Real friends take the risk of getting in each other’s faces and speaking the truth, including the truth we are not eager to hear. I hope this makes some sense to you: that the goal of Christian life is to develop and enjoy a friendship with God, and that to get there we need honest Christian friends. As Christian friends we share common convictions that help us to make and live sound moral judgments. As a called pastor and preacher to this community of Christian friends, I carry a special responsibility to speak the truth we need to hear if we are to make sound judgments. If I offer you nothing but my own opinions I fail you, fail myself, and fail God. My challenging task is to speak God’s truth as contained in Holy Scripture, the traditions of the Christian church, and the progressive Reformed tradition that has shaped us as the United Church of Christ. No preacher always gets it right, but I am grateful that you have trusted me all these years to speak God’s truth to you with some degree of integrity. It is your task to let me know when I get it wrong. Like every Christian, I need friends who will speak the truth to me. But take time to sort out whether it is me or God you disagree with. After all, if I do not upset you from time to time, I am not preaching God’s word. If I have been guilty (and I probably have) of speaking judgmentally of Fundamentalist Christians, it was wrong of me, and I regret it. Many Fundamentalists are better Christians than I am. Our own tradition has always had significant differences with Fundamentalism – we believe that the truth-claims of faith can comfortably coexist with the truth-claims of science while they do not is just one example – but I could respect and appreciate their witness across the lines of our differences. But today there are dimensions of Fundamentalism as a movement – a movement within all religions, not just Christianity – being proclaimed in the world that my understanding of our faith leads me to view not only as wrong, but dangerously wrong, and I do not apologize for saying this from the pulpit. Some Christian Fundamentalist leaders have been guilty of speaking in ways that are hateful, inflammatory, or flat-out unChristian, as when Pat Robertson called for the assassination of a head-of-state. I do not consider it judgmental to term such speech a perversion of the Gospel of Jesus Christ, any more than it is judgmental for faithful Muslims to condemn suicide bombings by Islamic extremists. I take the lessons of Christian history very seriously, and I see contemporary Fundamentalism repeating a sin committed by our own Puritan ancestors in the 17th century. Instead of speaking God’s truth to worldly power, they are attempting to impose their religious and cultural agendas upon the world by assuming worldly power. It is the grievous sin of hubris: being so certain that we know God’s will and possess God’s truth that we seek to impose it on everyone, Christian and non-Christian alike. The faith-claims of Christianity shape my entire life, but they do not belong in public classrooms or courtrooms. Our Puritan ancestors turned the courts of the New England colonies into puppets of a narrow-minded, intolerant, judgmental church that believed itself to be incapable of sin or error, and that led directly to the Salem witch trials. We have repented of that sin, but we must never forget it. Ironically, one of the reasons that Christian Fundamentalism has become such a dominant force in our society today is that we in the liberal Christian tradition have been so silent on matters of public and private morality. We have focused so much on “judge not” that we have failed to make sound judgments and proclaim them with passion and integrity. It is one thing to be “the church of the Open Door,” quite another to be “the church of anything goes.” If thoughtful, tolerant people of genuine faith are to stem the tide of Fundamentalist extremism – and again I do not mean only Christians – we must offer not just non-judgmentalism towards others, but we must offer, and live, sound moral judgments as well. May God help us in these critical tasks. Amen. Sermon preached by Reverend John T. McFadden at First Congregational United Church of Christ, Appleton, Wisconsin on November 20, 2005. 

Fallon --- 19 years ago -

I am agreeing with you Steve. I understand we as Christians have to take the high road, and not be harsh in our judgements of others. But there is just no way you can go thur a day and not make judgements. We should try to temper the thoughts maybe. But as a Christian, or even if I were an Athiest, there is some behavoir I would and will not ever condon. And that does not make me judgemental. I cannot condon adults hurting children. I cannot condon rape, and in these situations how do you not make a "judgement"? 

Fallon --- 19 years ago -

Oh I get that. And forgiveness is a must. To not forgive is to keep a heavy heart, and that does get in the way of doing Gods will. I wish more would forgive. But to forgive is one thing, to pretend some things never happened is not very realistic. I can't imagine a woman being raped and forgiving easily. And if she does forgive, she would still want to see the perpetrator punished. I guess that is the crux of the matter. Just because forgiveness is offered, no way does that mean punishment should not put forth. 

Fallon --- 19 years ago -

very well put! Yes there is consequences of sin. 

mamajulie --- 19 years ago -

in a very simplistic way, when were raising our four sons, I often would say, (to them) I love you very much, but this behavior is unacceptable. With kids I think it is easy to "love the sinner, hate the sin". As older (hopefully wiser) adults, and in dealing with folks whose belief system is so different from mine it seems harder to not be judgemental. Also I think another thing has greatly changed in the past 10 - 20 years. The level and nastiness of public retoric has invaded almost all levels of our lives. We can listen to almost any broadcast media out there and find people are just not "civil" to each other. It has been not only OK, but apparently acceptable to denigrate the person because you don't agree with a particitular position they have taken on some issue. I just believe this is sooooo wrong. I know that I can only be responsible for myself, but prayers can and are said daily for change. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

we in the liberal Christian tradition "Beware lest any man spoil you through philosophy and vain deceit, after the tradition of men, after the rudiments of the world, and not after Christ." (Colossians 2:8) 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

I believe we can and we must, but that it requires profound humility: the most dangerous and destructive people are always those who hold no doubt whatsoever that their views are correct. There is only one God and it’s not us, so we should be slow to anoint ourselves God’s official spokesperson. We do not have God’s knowledge or wisdom, and we cannot know the depth of another human being’s heart. 

Reality is good --- 19 years ago -

1Cor11:14 Doth not even nature itself teach you, that, if a man have long hair, it is a shame unto him? Didn't Jesus have long hair? 

Reality is good --- 19 years ago -

I find it odd that there is that part in the New Testament (so it is laws that we are to follow, as opposed to OT that are no longer to be followed) and that the majority of paintings showing Jesus, shows him with long hair. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

I believe we can and we must, but that it requires profound humility: the most dangerous and destructive people are always those who hold no doubt whatsoever that their views are correct. There is only one God and it’s not us, so we should be slow to anoint ourselves God’s official spokesperson. We do not have God’s knowledge or wisdom, and we cannot know the depth of another human being’s heart. You quoted a man's thoughts, whereas, I quoted God's thoughts. "For my thoughts are not your thoughts, neither are your ways my ways, saith the LORD. For as the heavens are higher than the earth, so are my ways higher than your ways, and my thoughts than your thoughts." (Isaiah 55:8-9) 

GHYC --- 19 years ago -

I love this poem, I have it hanging at work and at home and read it everyday. To help me to understand what really matters in this crazy world Anyway People are often unreasonable, illogical and self centered; Forgive them anyway If you are kind, people may accuse you of selfish, ulterior motives; Be kind anyway. If you are successful, you will win some false friends and some true enemies; Succeed anyway. If you are honest and frank, people may cheat you; Be honest and frank anyway. What you spend years building, someone could destroy overnight; Build anyway. If you find serenity and happiness, they may be jealous; Be happy anyway. The good you do today, people will forget tomorrow; Do good anyway. Give the world the best you have, and it may never be enough; Give the world the best you've got anyway. You see, in the final analysis, it is between you and God; It never was between you and them anyway. 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

Thanks, GHYC. The poem's a keeper. 

Thoughtful --- 19 years ago -

There is much of the worst in the best of us and much of the the best in the wrost of us so it behooves all of us not to judge the rest of us! ... or something like that - could not find the original... My opinion - I don't mind others judging me - I want to know their honest opinions so I can change and become better... It is OK to admit you are not perfect - just let whoever you upset know that you are trying to change... If you decide to "judge" another, just be sure to let them know that you have problems too - first let them tell you how YOU can cahnge, then talk about how you BOTH can change... Never make it a one-sided I'm better than you lecture :) 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

religion


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground