Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Disputing Property Value--Last Minute HELP

who's talking here?

Denise C 1
ms_mm 1
Fiona 3
Lilteapot 2
cmi 7
buddercup 1
bbjones 4
planemom 1
kjones0125 2
bhudak 1
momofthreeatascosita 1
Scribbles 1
CrushedUpCokeCan 1
mamajulie 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

cmi --- 19 years ago -

My dad said I can fill out the initial form online. I can't find it. Can anyone help? 

bhudak --- 19 years ago -

It might be on hcad.org if you live in Harris Co. 

cmi --- 19 years ago -

I've been on HCAD and can't find it. Anyone know where it is on the site? 

CrushedUpCokeCan --- 19 years ago -

They don't have a link for it. I had to do a Yahoo search. It is: http://www.hcad.org/ifile Thank you, drive thru. 

cmi --- 19 years ago -

Thanks! So now, what the heck is my ifile code? 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Look on your Property Tax Notice of Protest and it is on the top right hand side. 

cmi --- 19 years ago -

Property Tax Notice of Protest Okay, I guess I know nothing. I didn't even know I got one of those. I just looked up the value online and they raised ours by alot. So, my dad told me to just go online and protest it. Can I fax it? 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

No, you cannot fax it. You have to either drop it off, mail it, or file online by tomorrow. 

cmi --- 19 years ago -

Who would the mail have come from? That will help me find it. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Harris County Appraisal District 

Scribbles --- 19 years ago -

Property Tax Notice of Protest mine was on green paper and came with the new Property Tax Statement 

Lilteapot --- 19 years ago -

I did all my neighbors tonight. I started at 4pm, just finished, lol It was a neighborhood meet! 

ms_mm --- 19 years ago -

On the news tonight, they said you could also e-mail it. 

mamajulie --- 19 years ago -

thanks everyone for all the info, I just realized that I needed it also, and here it was. Great 

momofthreeatascosita --- 19 years ago -

The HCAD website has information on how to do research for your protest and you can print out the evidence they will be using against you. Is Your Home’s Appraisal Equal and Uniform? The Texas Constitution gives taxpayers a number of rights (and responsibilities) concerning their property tax appraisals. First, the constitution makes all property in the state taxable unless exempt by law. Second, the constitution requires the appraisal districts to appraise all property at 100% of the value required by law. Third, and perhaps most important, the constitution provides that taxation must be “equal and uniform.” More than 120 years ago, the Texas Supreme Court described the equal and uniform requirement as follows: Taxation is "equal and uniform" when no person or class of persons in the territory taxed is taxed at a higher rate than are other persons in the same district upon the same value or thing, and when the objects of taxation are the same by whomsoever owned or whatever they be. Norris v. City of Waco (1882) 57 Tex. 635. Equality and uniformity thus has several elements. First, no one person or class of persons should pay a higher rate of tax on the same value than do other persons. Second, all items are taxed the same, irrespective of who may own them or what they may be. When the Texas Property Tax Code was enacted in 1979, there were serious problems with equality and uniformity across the state. At that time, there were no appraisal districts, and no appraisal review boards. There were no requirements that property tax appraisers hold professional certifications. Each taxing jurisdiction was responsible for setting its own appraisals. The frequency with which properties were reappraised and the values they received had more to do with politics than with good appraisal practice. In some areas, residential properties were appraised at a tiny fraction of their true value while business properties were appraised at a much higher fraction. In others, farm properties were appraised low and residences appraised high. In many, property would be reappraised if it was sold to a new buyer, while properties that did not sell would stay the same. In some areas, your ethnicity was as important as your property in determining the amount of property tax you paid. If the jurisdiction did have a reappraisal, it was generally because the jurisdiction wanted more revenue. The drafters of the code wanted to stop all that. Appraisal districts were created to ensure that you would pay taxes based on an objectively determined value that wouldn’t vary depending on who you were or the type of property you owned. The state was required to test appraisal districts on an annual basis to ensure that they were doing their jobs Harris County Appraisal District June 2004 Page 2 of 11 correctly. The legislature also created new and relatively easy methods for a taxpayer to right inequalities if the appraisal district did not correct them. Today, with over 20 years of experience in appraising property equally and uniformly, appraisal districts have stamped out the kind of inequalities that the constitution prohibits. For example, in 1983, the State Property Tax Board estimated that in Harris County residences were appraised at 88% of their true value, farm and ranch acreage was appraised at 69%, and oil, gas, and other minerals were appraised at 106% of their true value overall. By 2001, these categories were appraised at 98%, 101%, and 101% respectively. In 1983, while residential taxpayers in Harris County paid taxes based on 88% of their property’s value, residential taxpayers in Crockett County paid taxes based on 14% of their value. What do these percentages mean? Let’s say that in 1983, Mr. Jones in Harris County owned a home worth $60,000. Mr. Smith in Crockett County also owned a home worth $60,000. For the purposes of the example, lets assume that in each county, the total tax rate for county, school district, and city combined was $1.00 per $100. At 88% of market value, Mr. Jones’ home would be valued at .88 x $60,000, or $52,800, and his tax at $1.00 per $100 would be $528. At 14% of market value, Mr. Smith’s $60,000 home would be valued at .14 x $60,000, or $8,400, and his tax would be $84. In short, the disparity in valuation means the Harris County taxpayer in 1983 paid six times the amount his counterpart in Crockett County would have paid at the same tax rate. As of 2001, however, these disparities had almost disappeared. Harris was at 98% and Crockett at 96%. Equality and uniformity within categories has also improved dramatically. To track this, the state publishes the percentage of ratios that fall within plus or minus 10% of the overall percentage. For example, in Harris County in 1983, only about half of the residential ratios fell within 10% of the 88% median. This meant that while half of the taxpayers in Harris County paid taxes based on values ranging from 78% to 98% of true value, almost half the taxpayers in Harris county paid taxes based on values less than 78% of market value or more than 98% of market value. By 2001, however, almost 80% of the residential values fell within plus or minus 10% of the residential ratio. In short, modern appraisal practices in the appraisal districts are doing their jobs. You simply will not find the kind of gross disparities that existed under the old pre-appraisal district system. One of the reasons that appraisal districts have been so effective in eliminating inequities is the use of computerized mass appraisal systems. Appraisers are trained to collect property data in a uniform manner that does not vary from property to property. Computerized valuation programs apply this data to determine the value of each property, uniformly and without exception. A modern computerized mass appraisal system contains many checks and balances to catch inequality before it ever becomes a problem. Nevertheless, while the kind of inequality the drafters of the tax code were thinking about simply doesn’t exist any more, there are occasional instances where minor inequality may appear to exist. Harris County Appraisal District June 2004 Page 3 of 11 My neighbor and I have identical homes with identical values, but he pays lower taxes than I do. If the values are the same, then you and your neighbor probably qualify for different exemptions. Is your neighbor over-65 or disabled? Do you have a homestead exemption on your property? My neighbor and I have identical homes with identical market values, but her appraised value is lower than mine. In 1998, homes that qualify for a homestead exemption began receiving what we call the “cap” on appraisal increases. The appraisal district calculates a market value for the home every year, but if that market value is greater than the previous year’s value plus 10% (20% in some cases), the property’s “appraised value” will be the previous year’s value plus 10%. If you are in a neighborhood where properties have appreciated by more than 10% in any single year, identical properties with identical market values may well have different appraised values. This is because each property’s cap is set according to its value in the second year the owner receives a homestead exemption. In addition, if an owner adds improvements or remodels, the owner’s cap for that year will be increased. In short, unless your neighbor qualified for the cap in the same year you did, your values were the same in that year, and neither of you have made any improvements, you may have different appraised values. You will want to compare market values to determine inequality. Most of the values of homes in our neighborhood are about the same, but one or two are substantially lower. Those properties may have had their value reduced in an ARB hearing, or they may have problems that aren’t immediately apparent from the data available on HCAD’s website. If a property has been remodeled without a building permit, we may be unaware of the remodeling. My neighbors’ homes are appraised at a lower market value per square foot than is the case for my property. This often appears to be a sign of inequality. However, before you can conclude that you are being singled out, you need to be sure that all of the differences between your property and your neighbors’ have been accounted for. Home prices are not determined solely on the basis of square footage. Lot size and location, construction quality, design, materials, central air and heat, and add-ons like fireplaces, garages, decks, and swimming pools will each affect an individual property’s value. Age and condition are also very significant factors. In areas that are more than 10 years old, remodeling and renovation can be extremely important. What tools are available for me to tell if I’m being equally appraised? Harris County Appraisal District June 2004 Page 4 of 11 If you have access to the world wide web, look up your account on the HCAD website, www.hcad.org. Click the button for nearby addresses. If you’re in a residential subdivision, you’ll see a list of properties (usually on your street) along with their square footage, appraised value, and market value. Pick some of the properties that are closest to yours in size and amenities, and see how their market value compares to yours. If yours is substantially higher (more than $10 per square foot) than the next closest and you can’t find any difference in our recorded characteristics, you may want to file a protest. Once your protest has been received and scheduled, there will be more tools available for you. These are available at HCAD’s information center, or if you have access to the world wide web, you can use the iFile number that appears on your protest scheduling notice to access them on line. The first tool is called the Neighborhood Profile Report. In order to simplify valuation of residential property, HCAD has divided Harris County into over 5,000 valuation neighborhoods. Often a valuation neighborhood has the same boundaries as a subdivision, but in some cases a neighborhood may encompass several subdivisions or a subdivision may contain several neighborhoods. A neighborhood is a group of properties that have substantially the same economic characteristics. The neighborhood profile report for your property will show you how your property’s value compares with typical property values in your neighborhood. The top of the report lists information about your property. Next is a table showing how your property compares with the typical property in the neighborhood according to HCAD’s records, and with the typical sold property in your neighborhood. A sample appears on the following page. Harris County Appraisal District June 2004 Page 5 of 11 Sample Neighborhood Profile Report Owner Name : SAMPLE OWNER HCAD Account # : ###-###-####-### Service Address : SAMPLE PROPERTY Parcel ID : ################## Legal Description : SAMPLE DESCRIPTION Neighborhood Number : 8010 Market Value : $193,300 Property Characteristics Subject Property (Card 1 Only) Typical Property for Neighborhood Typical Sold Property for Neighborhood Land Size : 11,900 sq. ft. 10,669 sq. ft. 9,952 sq. ft. Sq Ft of Living Area : 2,498 sq. ft. 2,079 sq. ft. 1,922 sq. ft. Other Building / Yard Improvements : $3,491.00 $1,633.00 Auxiliary Value : $0.00 $1,475.00 Series Card Value : Value per Sq Ft of Living Area : $77.38 $87.54 $89.63 Story Height : 1 1 1 Exterior Wall Type : Brick Veneer Brick Veneer Brick Veneer Year Built : 1963 1955 1960 Remodel Type : Bedrooms : 4 3 3 Bathrooms : 2 / 0 2 / 0 2 / 0 Fireplaces : Yes No No Physical Condition : Good Good Good Garage : Attached Detached Detached Pool : No No No Grade : B- B- BCDU : Average Average Good If you are reading the report to judge whether or not you have been equally appraised, you will want to compare your property (the subject) to the typical property for the nieghborhood. In this example, the subject is somewhat larger than typical at 2,498 vs. 2,079 square feet. It is also somewhat newer and has more bedrooms than are typical. Its physical condition, grade, and CDU (a factor reflecting design and construction) are all the same as the typical property. HCAD has appraised the typical property in the neighborhood at $87.54 per square foot. At $77.38 per square foot, it certainly does not appear that this property has been singled out for a higher share of value than its neighbors. After this table is a second table. This shows the distribution of values and sale prices in the neighborhood, both on a total basis (left side) and per square foot basis (right side). Harris County Appraisal District June 2004 Page 6 of 11 Market Value and Sale Price Distribution Market Value and Sale Price Distribution Per Sq Ft (PSF) Range HCAD Values Sale Price Range HCAD Values PSF Sale Price PSF 100 - 10000 0 - 10 10001 - 20000 11 - 19 20001 - 30000 20 - 28 30001 - 40000 29 - 37 40001 - 50000 38 - 46 50001 - 60000 47 - 55 60001 - 70000 56 - 64 4 70001 - 80000 65 - 73 12 80001 - 90000 74 - 82 36 1 90001 - 100000 83 - 91 48 100001 - 125000 1 92 - 100 36 3 125000 - 150000 15 1 101 - 125 15 150001 - 200000 107 3 126 - 150 1 200001 - 250000 24 151 - 175 1 250001 - 300000 6 176 - 200 300001 - 400000 201 - 225 400001 - 500000 226 - 250 500001 - 1000000 251 - 300 1000001 - 301 - On the left hand, you can see the distribution of values. 1 home is valued between $100,001 and 125,000; 15 between $125,000 and $150,000, 107 between $150,000 and $200,000; 24 at $200001 to $250,000, and 6 above $250,000. At $193,000, you can see that the subject property falls well within the category where most home values fall. On the right hand side, our property falls in the lower half of the properties by square foot value. Again, in this instance, you can see that the property is not unequally appraised. The second tool is called the residential comparable property analysis. You can access this on the HCAD website after you receive your scheduling notice, or you can get a copy at the HCAD information center. A sample appears on the following page Harris County Appraisal District June 2004 Page 7 of 11 TAX YEAR : 2004 HARRIS COUNTY APPRAISAL DISTRICT DATE : 5/18/2004 ISD : 1F COMPARABLE PROPERTY ANALYSIS RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FAMILY PROPERTY DESCRIPTION NBHD NBHD GRP TOTAL MKT VAL LESS : LAND VAL LESS : OTH IMPR IMPR MKT VAL YEAR BLT / RMDL GRADE RMDL / C & D TOTAL ADJ ADJ IMPR VAL ADJ MKT VAL LIVING AREA TOTAL MKT PSFLA SUBJECT PROPERTY SUBJECT PROPERTY 8010 606 $193,300 ($58,900) $0 $134,400 1963 / 0 B- N/A $134,400 $193,300 2,498 SF $77.38 FILTERS APPLIED MAX DISTANCE 0.00 MI LTD TO NBHD : Y LTD TO GRP : N BLT RANGE ALL RMDL RANGE ALL MATCH GRD/SIGN MATCH SAME RANGE ±5% COMPARABLE PROPERTIES 1 SAMPLE COMP 1 8010 606 $234,400 ($70,300) ($22,090) $142,010 1960 / 0 B- ($22,408) $119,602 $211,992 2,457 SF $84.86 2 SAMPLE COMP 2 8010 606 $222,400 ($70,300) ($740) $151,360 1959 / 0 B- ($15,042) $136,318 $207,358 2,509 SF $83.01 3 SAMPLE COMP 3 8010 606 $172,300 ($52,500) ($2,320) $117,480 1959 / 0 B- $33,869 $151,349 $206,169 2,496 SF $82.53 4 SAMPLE COMP 4 8010 606 $176,200 ($52,300) ($480) $123,420 1959 / 0 B- $26,583 $150,003 $202,783 2,526 SF $81.18 5 SAMPLE COMP 5 8010 606 $174,000 ($52,500) ($2,100) $119,400 1961 / 0 B- $28,324 $147,724 $202,324 2,499 SF $80.99 6 SAMPLE COMP 6 8010 606 $172,000 ($52,300) ($2,700) $117,000 1958 / 0 B- $27,525 $144,525 $199,525 2,413 SF $79.87 7 SAMPLE COMP 7 8010 606 $190,800 ($55,600) ($2,110) $133,090 1956 / 0 B- $8,690 $141,780 $199,490 2,591 SF $79.86 8 SAMPLE COMP 8 8010 606 $189,600 ($71,000) ($1,610) $116,990 1960 / 0 B- $7,309 $124,299 $196,909 2,514 SF $78.83 9 SAMPLE COMP 9 8010 606 $168,000 ($52,500) ($6,170) $109,330 1960 / 0 B- $26,175 $135,505 $194,175 2,500 SF $77.73 MEDIAN ADJUSTED MARKET VALUE PER SQ FT: $80.99 SUBJECT MARKET VALUE AT MEDIAN: $202,400 

Denise C --- 19 years ago -

When you get your information and print this out, if you will send to me (in advance please) I can send you a report on these homes. I just did one this morning for someone and they had thrown in a couple that were in another neighborhood as well as a couple completely updated as well as one that had a pool and heated spa in the yard. If you don't have a pool, it's not comparable. If you don't have a home that has been completely redone, that's not a comparable. You have to compare chevrolet to chevrolet, not chevrolet to mercedes. 

cmi --- 19 years ago -

Okay, so does anyone know if you can really email it? And to what address? 

cmi --- 19 years ago -

And before you laugh at me for procrastinating, I was confused. That's why it's not done yet. 

buddercup --- 19 years ago -

I don't know anything about this stuff either. Ok so what should your house be apraised at. What you paid for it or do you compare neighbors? 

Fiona --- 19 years ago -

If you protest online do you still have to go to the meeting thing? 

planemom --- 19 years ago -

You compare to current sales prices. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

If you protest online do you still have to go to the meeting thing? From what I understand, most people still have to go in. 

Fiona --- 19 years ago -

Darn, I don't really want to have to go to the meeting. 

kjones0125 --- 19 years ago -

what meeting? i just filed my protest online. i did say i wanted a copy of the ARB hearing procedures though. 

Fiona --- 19 years ago -

They used to make you go to the hearing to present your case. 

kjones0125 --- 19 years ago -

ok - i just read the back of my green sheet from HCAD. it says they will let you know at least 15 days in advance when the hearing will be. if you cannot or do not want to attend your scheduled hearing in person, the law allows you to submit your evidence in the form of a sworn affidavit. the affidavit must state that you swear or affirm that the information it contains is true and correct, and you must execute it before a notary public or other public official who is authorized to administer oaths. to ensure the affidavit is available for consideration, it should be received at the hearing location at least two days prior to the date and time of the hearing. 

Lilteapot --- 19 years ago -

You protest your taxes. In approx. 2 weeks you will get an apointment date. You go, (off of rte 290), takes approx 1/2 hour, you speak with someone as to why you are protesting and your done. I did it last yr, well worth it. I did all my neighbors last night. If you cant make the apt. date, read kjones post. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground