Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Do you spank your kids?

who's talking here?

Paige 7
FirePrincess 6
MissT 1
Scottie's Hottie 1
I Love Horses 2
likeke27 7
Valentine 3
Trillian 1
CountryChick 4
kuca 1
Hardshell 1
lilmommy 2
jjfingrainalready 1
denhou1974 1
cowboyswife 3
Zionist NightOwl 3
mommiedearest 2
Ibme 1
Catgirl 15
ChezML 1
accent_ 2
m•t•v 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Do you spank your kids?

I spank daily Vote
 
 1.4% (1)
I spank weekly Vote
 
 2.7% (2)
Maybe a few times a month Vote
 
 6.8% (5)
I only spank as a last resort Vote
 
 77.0% (57)
I will NEVER spank my kids Vote
 
 12.2% (9)
Valentine --- 19 years ago -

I'm not afraid, I'll admit it. I use spanking as a last resort. Usually I have pretty good results just from using time-out. We've got two small grey rugs and two kitchen timers with kids names on them. Works wonders! 

I Love Horses --- 19 years ago -

My kids will get a pop on the butt every now and then but i definanty dont lay into them or beat them! They know that a pop on the butt is a last resort if all else fails and i never spank out of anger or use objects besides my hand to spank them and its never on bare skin. I believe in spare the rod spoil the child! and that is why so many children these days have no respect for thier parents or anybody else because they are never disceplined. Granted there are some children iam sure that where never spanked that grew up well rounded and never disrespected anyone, but some children just need a spank as a back up if talking to and other measures fail. IMO 

lilmommy --- 19 years ago -

I believe in spare the rod spoil the child! and that is why so many children these days have no respect for thier parents or anybody else because they are never disceplined. Granted there are some children iam sure that where never spanked that grew up well rounded and never disrespected anyone, but some children just need a spank as a back up if talking to and other measures fail. IMO Couldn't have said it better myself..... Thank you... I spank my kiddos.... But by no means, beat them..... My kids love, respect, and fear me all at the same time. 

denhou1974 --- 19 years ago -

I haven't had to do this in a long time (maybe 8-9 months). Last resort only but never out of anger. 

Paige --- 19 years ago -

I started the thread because I think I am about tto start spanking mine :-( I am not one of the "I will never spank my kid" moms, but I have tried to refrain from it as long as I could. He is 3 and he absolutely doesn't listen. He has always had a really sweet side, but has lately been really trying to test me. He even kicked his teacher the other day. I am at a loss for how to discipline this for he is only turning 3 later this month. I am not sure that spanking him for something he did 5 hours earlier would be beneficial. I am a very laid back person, but everyone keeps telling me- if you'd just spank his butt he would quit that. Tears don't bother me, and I believe in teaching what is right. I was spanked and love my parents to death. For some reason though, it is so hard for me to raise my hand. 

Valentine --- 19 years ago -

My twins are almost 3 y/o. They get a pop about once a week, usually less. My dd needs it more than my ds. Ds is more obedient. Dd likes to challenge dh and myself- little stinker. 

Valentine --- 19 years ago -

Paige, have you tried time out? I have a book about using time out that's great- Time Out for Toddlers . It's a quick, easy read. 

Paige --- 19 years ago -

I have tried time out and "the naughty stool" but haven't had very good results with it. He is always very happy to go sit in time out. I almost feel like he thinks, "Man this is easy- for what I did." I will definitely check out the book though. Maybe I need to try a different way. 

I Love Horses --- 19 years ago -

I have tried time out and "the naughty stool" but haven't had very good results with it. He is always very happy to go sit in time out. I almost feel like he thinks, "Man this is easy- for what I did." I will definitely check out the book though. Maybe I need to try a different way. My 2 1/2 year old respondes well to a pop on the diaper, he thinks its the end of the world and will listen if i threaten to do it. Time out never worked for him he thinks its a game and laughs everytime he jumps up and i have to chase hime to put him back down. 

Hardshell --- 19 years ago -

Yes, but only as required, and with a few loving words after the sting has gone! 

Catgirl --- 19 years ago -

I don't understand why people spank their young children. Lack of parenting skills and self control would be my guess. If spanking works then why are you doing it over and over again??? 

likeke27 --- 19 years ago -

catgirl the same could be said with timeouts and talking to's 

kuca --- 19 years ago -

Never have and never will. 

MissT --- 19 years ago -

the ones who need spanking, yes..... not frequently, but occasionally. 

lilmommy --- 19 years ago -

Hey catgirl~~~ Is this your first child or do you have more? Really I'm not being mean... I had the same exact thinking before when my first born was just a baby. 

Zionist NightOwl --- 19 years ago -

If spanking works then why are you doing it over and over again??? LOL. I once said to my pedi, "We're still working on the whole 'You WILL mind Mommy, or there will be consequences' routine." She laughed and told me that that routine won't go away until, oh, maybe age 20 or so. Kids will test their parents to see how much they can get away with. Sometimes they re-test just to see if the rules have changed, or perhaps they wonder if some variation of the rules would be permitted. So yes, you may have to teach over and over again. It just depends on how strong-willed the child is. My personal philosophy is that parents should use time-out, spankings, restrictions, whatever reasonable discipline works for each individual parent/child relationship to show the child who is in control. Personally, I feel that infractions should have consequences that are somehow related to the offense, if at all possible. I reserve spanking for when the act is outright defiance or willful disobedience. Simple childhood irresponsibility never gets a spanking. E.g., I told my dd yesterday to pick up her clothes and her room. She dutifully marched upstairs and got started, but she got distracted by all the toys she was supposed to pick up. That's not willful disobedience; that's being 6 and needing to learn some discipline. No spanking. But had she stamped her foot and said "NO!", that would have been a challenge to me, and I would have won it decisively. Or, if she chose to ignore me, that would have been willful disobedience, too--probably a spanking. Can you tell I've read James Dobson's books? 

cowboyswife --- 19 years ago -

I don't understand why people spank their young children. Lack of parenting skills and self control would be my guess. If spanking works then why are you doing it over and over again??? Said the same BEFORE i had a toddler. 

m•t•v --- 19 years ago -

If spanking works then why are you doing it over and over again??? Because people (including) children repeat their mistakes. Did you learn from all of your mistakes the first time to a degree that you NEVER repeated them??? I remember as a child asking my mom why she would hit me if she loved me. I don't want to be a parent that spanks if I can find another way to discipline my son. I can't imagine there being NO OTHER WAY, but I also know that I have already spanked him and I will be the first to admit it was out of being angry with my son's behavior.. I don't understand the "never out of anger" claim.. being calm and still spanking him just seems soo cruel in a totally creepy (psycho) way.... JMHO 

Catgirl --- 19 years ago -

If spanking works then why are you doing it over and over again??? likeke27comment catgirl the same could be said with timeouts and talking to's Catgirl: I rather do timeouts. I know there are better ways to disapline a child that works just as good if not even better than spanking. I'm strongly against spanking. 

likeke27 --- 19 years ago -

but if you do it over and over again how is that working? not trying to say what you do is wrong. i personally do all of them. but comments like these are not needed Lack of parenting skills and self control would be my guess. every parent has different parenting skills and ways of doing things. 

Paige --- 19 years ago -

I don't understand why people spank their young children. Lack of parenting skills and self control would be my guess. I obviously have self control because I have waited 3 years to start, but I agree w/ you on my parenting skills. I have 2 boys 3 & 4 and the only skills I have are what I have learned with them and rmemebering what my parents did. I wish I had all the answers:-) more than that, I wish I felt more confident in the choices I make about them. I know I am a great mom- I just always say to myself, "I hope I am doing the right thing." 

Paige --- 19 years ago -

Someone feel free to tell me that is normal... LOL! 

Catgirl --- 19 years ago -

comments like these are not needed Lack of parenting skills and self control would be my guess. every parent has different parenting skills and ways of doing things. I know that is harsh. I'm sorry but, it is truely how I see it. 

cowboyswife --- 19 years ago -

Someone feel free to tell me that is normal... LOL! You are very normal Paige, lol... We all wonder the same thing!! We are only human though, we will make some mistakes, thats why it is best to think things through before acting! 

likeke27 --- 19 years ago -

i understand that is your viewpoint. it should be directed towards the parents that absoleutly do no kind of disicipline. and they are out there. 

FirePrincess --- 19 years ago -

Catgirl, I'd like to see what you think in about 4 years. When your 18 month old walks over to the electrical outlet, and saying "no" doesn't stop them. I'm sure you would NEVER spat their hand to make sure they don't get hurt. 

cowboyswife --- 19 years ago -

Exactly FP! 

likeke27 --- 19 years ago -

or your six year old son keeps pegging another kid with rocks for one day. and you talk to him. then he does the same thing the next day so he gets a spanking. and amazeling it stops on the thrid day. also remember each kid responds differently. 

Catgirl --- 19 years ago -

Lets face it if you spank or not there are some kids no matter what you do, they will not change. If they are smart they will do it behind your back and you can catch yourself being one of those parents who say "What??, not my child". LoL! If you spank or not, open -honest- communication works best at any age. 

FirePrincess --- 19 years ago -

If you spank or not, open -honest- communication works best at any age. I know someone that thinks just like you. Her child is a brat. She always "sits and talks with her" about her behavior. That girl has NOTHING to fear. She's a spoiled little brat with no respect. 

likeke27 --- 19 years ago -

If you spank or not, open -honest- communication works best at any age. i agree 100%. spanking is a last resort 

FirePrincess --- 19 years ago -

Oh, and I have a BIL that is now a criminal because his whole life everyone was told "Don't spank him...he's just a BABY!!!" 

Catgirl --- 19 years ago -

Only a few of you know this.... I have a son who is my flesh & blood, he is now 14 years old. At age 3 he was diagnosed with bipolar (I had been taking him to the doctors since he was 1). He has 5 tiny scares in his scalp because he was so self destructive. He would bang his head when throwing a fit. Trust me I have been in your shose and those of many others. Besides him being bipolare he was a stubborn lovable kid. His bipolar is now dormant since age 6. 

Catgirl --- 19 years ago -

If you spank or not, open -honest- communication works best at any age. I know someone that thinks just like you. Her child is a brat. She always "sits and talks with her" about her behavior. That girl has NOTHING to fear. She's a spoiled little brat with no respect. That is not my son at ALL. 

FirePrincess --- 19 years ago -

That is not my son at ALL. I'm sure it's all in the way you talk to them. It works for some, but not all. Most of the time I can just threaten to take my kids' favorite toy away and the behavior stops immediately. 

Catgirl --- 19 years ago -

Oh, and I have a BIL that is now a criminal because his whole life everyone was told "Don't spank him...he's just a BABY!!!" LOL! I'm sure there are more people in jail who were spanked or beaten. 

CountryChick --- 19 years ago -

Hey if they need it I tear their butts up! 

Zionist NightOwl --- 19 years ago -

why people spank their young children. Lack of parenting skills and self control would be my guess Trust me--not the case here. I have read soooooo many books on parenting. I also have a degree in behavioral science/math (double major). So I understand what the child psychologists and behaviorists have to say. And when I'm angry with my kids but feel they need a spanking, I give myself a time-out before I swat, just to make sure that I am not spanking in an inappropriate manner. I have been praised for my parenting skills by an EIC social worker who was in my home evaluating my ds for speech therapy. I have also been praised by total strangers who witnessed my parenting of my dd when she was 4 and having an all-out meltdown in Lowe's. And by others who have watched my kids behaving themselves. And by neighbors who have told me that my kids were the only ones on the street they wanted their kids playing with, etc. I'm not saying all of this to brag or to be in defense of spanking. I'm saying all of this because I want every parent reading this to know that spanking is NOT usually a lack of parenting skills, or a lack of self-control. I am 100% certain of that. If you feel a lack of confidence in parenting, go to the library, read a couple of parenting books, and you'll feel better. In fact, what you will find is that the "experts" won't always agree with each other. I believe that this is because they all have different kids. They will write from the perspective of what worked for their own children or counselees. But the books do have a lot of good, sound advice, and at least one of them will help you. Comments like that above can really hurt parents when they are struggling to do the right thing. They need support, not condemnation. So I want to give this message to all the parents reading this who are struggling with parenting issues and looking for the right way: "I don't care whether you choose to spank or not to spank your children. In fact, I don't care HOW you discipline your children so long as it is done in love and is not abusive or damaging, or humiliating, to the child. I just want to THANK YOU for disciplining your child at all. YOU know your child better than anyone else, and YOU know what works best for you and for your child. I applaud you for trying to be a good parent. You're doing better than you think you are." 

likeke27 --- 19 years ago -

"I don't care whether you choose to spank or not to spank your children. In fact, I don't care HOW you discipline your children so long as it is done in love and is not abusive or damaging, or humiliating, to the child. I just want to THANK YOU for disciplining your child at all. YOU know your child better than anyone else, and YOU know what works best for you and for your child. I applaud you for trying to be a good parent. You're doing better than you think you are." amen 

Catgirl --- 19 years ago -

Love, Hug, Listen, Understand, Comunicate, Spend time together and get to know one another is what makes a great parent and child. If you choose to spank or not it is not what makes you a good parent. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground