Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

10 MYTHS — AND 10 TRUTHS — ABOUT ATHEISM

who's talking here?

mugglemom 1
freshhell 16
FirePrincess 1
Unichic 8
cmi 10
Curarie 1
bbjones 24
lulajean 1
rrazl 1
Anderson 2
likeke27 2
Trillian 2
gking 9
JDaddy 3
Corgiwyn 2
denhou1974 8
Neo 26
mykidsmom 1
qpc 6
AuthorMan 5
cowboyswife 1
JHMO 1
Going off air 7
TruthKing 11
mommiedearest 2
EmeraldEyes 1
*Sunny* 1
ChezML 3
zɹossıʞs 8
Brian 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Neo --- 19 years ago -

By Sam Harris 10 MYTHS — AND 10 TRUTHS — ABOUT ATHEISM Several polls indicate that the term "atheism" has acquired such an extraordinary stigma in the United States that being an atheist is now a perfect impediment to a career in politics (in a way that being black, Muslim or homosexual is not). According to a recent Newsweek poll, only 37% of Americans would vote for an otherwise qualified atheist for president. Atheists are often imagined to be intolerant, immoral, depressed, blind to the beauty of nature and dogmatically closed to evidence of the supernatural. Even John Locke, one of the great patriarchs of the Enlightenment, believed that atheism was "not at all to be tolerated" because, he said, "promises, covenants and oaths, which are the bonds of human societies, can have no hold upon an atheist." That was more than 300 years ago. But in the United States today, little seems to have changed. A remarkable 87% of the population claims "never to doubt" the existence of God; fewer than 10% identify themselves as atheists — and their reputation appears to be deteriorating. Given that we know that atheists are often among the most intelligent and scientifically literate people in any society, it seems important to deflate the myths that prevent them from playing a larger role in our national discourse. 1) Atheists believe that life is meaningless. On the contrary, religious people often worry that life is meaningless and imagine that it can only be redeemed by the promise of eternal happiness beyond the grave. Atheists tend to be quite sure that life is precious. Life is imbued with meaning by being really and fully lived. Our relationships with those we love are meaningful now; they need not last forever to be made so. Atheists tend to find this fear of meaninglessness … well … meaningless. 2) Atheism is responsible for the greatest crimes in human history. People of faith often claim that the crimes of Hitler, Stalin, Mao and Pol Pot were the inevitable product of unbelief. The problem with fascism and communism, however, is not that they are too critical of religion; the problem is that they are too much like religions. Such regimes are dogmatic to the core and generally give rise to personality cults that are indistinguishable from cults of religious hero worship. Auschwitz, the gulag and the killing fields were not examples of what happens when human beings reject religious dogma; they are examples of political, racial and nationalistic dogma run amok. There is no society in human history that ever suffered because its people became too reasonable. 3) Atheism is dogmatic. Jews, Christians and Muslims claim that their scriptures are so prescient of humanity's needs that they could only have been written under the direction of an omniscient deity. An atheist is simply a person who has considered this claim, read the books and found the claim to be ridiculous. One doesn't have to take anything on faith, or be otherwise dogmatic, to reject unjustified religious beliefs. As the historian Stephen Henry Roberts (1901-71) once said: "I contend that we are both atheists. I just believe in one fewer god than you do. When you understand why you dismiss all the other possible gods, you will understand why I dismiss yours." 4) Atheists think everything in the universe arose by chance. No one knows why the universe came into being. In fact, it is not entirely clear that we can coherently speak about the "beginning" or "creation" of the universe at all, as these ideas invoke the concept of time, and here we are talking about the origin of space-time itself. The notion that atheists believe that everything was created by chance is also regularly thrown up as a criticism of Darwinian evolution. As Richard Dawkins explains in his marvelous book, "The God Delusion," this represents an utter misunderstanding of evolutionary theory. Although we don't know precisely how the Earth's early chemistry begat biology, we know that the diversity and complexity we see in the living world is not a product of mere chance. Evolution is a combination of chance mutation and natural selection. Darwin arrived at the phrase "natural selection" by analogy to the "artificial selection" performed by breeders of livestock. In both cases, selection exerts a highly non-random effect on the development of any species. 5) Atheism has no connection to science. Although it is possible to be a scientist and still believe in God — as some scientists seem to manage it — there is no question that an engagement with scientific thinking tends to erode, rather than support, religious faith. Taking the U.S. population as an example: Most polls show that about 90% of the general public believes in a personal God; yet 93% of the members of the National Academy of Sciences do not. This suggests that there are few modes of thinking less congenial to religious faith than science is. 6) Atheists are arrogant. When scientists don't know something — like why the universe came into being or how the first self-replicating molecules formed — they admit it. Pretending to know things one doesn't know is a profound liability in science. And yet it is the life-blood of faith-based religion. One of the monumental ironies of religious discourse can be found in the frequency with which people of faith praise themselves for their humility, while claiming to know facts about cosmology, chemistry and biology that no scientist knows. When considering questions about the nature of the cosmos and our place within it, atheists tend to draw their opinions from science. This isn't arrogance; it is intellectual honesty. 7) Atheists are closed to spiritual experience. There is nothing that prevents an atheist from experiencing love, ecstasy, rapture and awe; atheists can value these experiences and seek them regularly. What atheists don't tend to do is make unjustified (and unjustifiable) claims about the nature of reality on the basis of such experiences. There is no question that some Christians have transformed their lives for the better by reading the Bible and praying to Jesus. What does this prove? It proves that certain disciplines of attention and codes of conduct can have a profound effect upon the human mind. Do the positive experiences of Christians suggest that Jesus is the sole savior of humanity? Not even remotely — because Hindus, Buddhists, Muslims and even atheists regularly have similar experiences. There is, in fact, not a Christian on this Earth who can be certain that Jesus even wore a beard, much less that he was born of a virgin or rose from the dead. These are just not the sort of claims that spiritual experience can authenticate. 8) Atheists believe that there is nothing beyond human life and human understanding Atheists are free to admit the limits of human understanding in a way that religious people are not. It is obvious that we do not fully understand the universe; but it is even more obvious that neither the Bible nor the Koran reflects our best understanding of it. We do not know whether there is complex life elsewhere in the cosmos, but there might be. If there is, such beings could have developed an understanding of nature's laws that vastly exceeds our own. Atheists can freely entertain such possibilities. They also can admit that if brilliant extraterrestrials exist, the contents of the Bible and the Koran will be even less impressive to them than they are to human atheists. From the atheist point of view, the world's religions utterly trivialize the real beauty and immensity of the universe. One doesn't have to accept anything on insufficient evidence to make such an observation. 9) Atheists ignore the fact that religion is extremely beneficial to society. Those who emphasize the good effects of religion never seem to realize that such effects fail to demonstrate the truth of any religious doctrine. This is why we have terms such as "wishful thinking" and "self-deception." There is a profound distinction between a consoling delusion and the truth. In any case, the good effects of religion can surely be disputed. In most cases, it seems that religion gives people bad reasons to behave well, when good reasons are actually available. Ask yourself, which is more moral, helping the poor out of concern for their suffering, or doing so because you think the creator of the universe wants you to do it, will reward you for doing it or will punish you for not doing it? 10) Atheism provides no basis for morality. If a person doesn't already understand that cruelty is wrong, he won't discover this by reading the Bible or the Koran — as these books are bursting with celebrations of cruelty, both human and divine. We do not get our morality from religion. We decide what is good in our good books by recourse to moral intuitions that are (at some level) hard-wired in us and that have been refined by thousands of years of thinking about the causes and possibilities of human happiness. We have made considerable moral progress over the years, and we didn't make this progress by reading the Bible or the Koran more closely. Both books condone the practice of slavery — and yet every civilized human being now recognizes that slavery is an abomination. Whatever is good in scripture — like the golden rule — can be valued for its ethical wisdom without our believing that it was handed down to us by the creator of the universe. [First published by the Los Angeles Times OpEd Page, Dec. 24, 2006]  

Neo --- 19 years ago -

undefined SAM HARRIS is the author of The End of Faith: Religion, Terror, and the Future of Reason and Letter to a Christian Nation. He is a graduate in philosophy from Stanford University and has studied both Eastern and Western religious traditions, along with a variety of contemplative disciplines, for twenty years. Mr. Harris is now completing a doctorate in neuroscience. He and his work have been discussed in Newsweek, TIME , U.S. News and World Report, The New York Times, The Washington Post, The Los Angeles Times, The San Francisco Chronicle, The Chicago Tribune, The Economist, The Guardian, The Independent, Der Spiegel, The Globe and Mail, New Scientist, Wired, SEED Magazine, and many other journals. The End of Faith won the 2005 PEN Award for Nonfiction. Mr. Harris makes regular appearances on television and radio to discuss the danger that religion now poses to modern societies. His essays have appeared in Newsweek, The Los Angeles Times, The Times of London, The Boston Globe, and elsewhere. He blogs for the Washington Post / Newsweek website: On Faith. Sam Harris' Home Page 

cowboyswife --- 19 years ago -

I feel very sorry for this man. He is sooooooo lost. He will be in my prayers. No need to rebuttle me here, I will not post anything else but this...:) 

freshhell --- 19 years ago -

Thanks Neo. Not the fire and brimstone I was expecting, but just wait... 

Neo --- 19 years ago -

I feel very sorry for this man. He is sooooooo lost. Others might say that you're the one that's brainwashed. 

freshhell --- 19 years ago -

Please don't say that you will include me in your "prayers". I tend to doubt your sincerity! 

Neo --- 19 years ago -

Regarding Sam Harris' book: Letter to A Christian Nation I dare you to read this book…it will not leave you unchanged. Read it if it is the last thing you do. — Richard Dawkins, author of The Selfish Gene and The God Delusion From his Foreward to the UK Edition It’s a shame that not everyone in this country will read Sam Harris’ marvelous little book. They won’t, but they should. — Leonard Susskind, Felix Bloch Professor in theoretical physics at Stanford University, author of The Cosmic Landscape Sam Harris’s elegant little book is most refreshing and a wonderful source of ammunition for those who, like me, hold to no religious doctrine. Yet I have some sympathy also with those who might be worried by his uncompromising stance. Read it and form your own view, but do not ignore its message. — Sir Roger Penrose, emeritus professor of mathematics at Oxford, author of The Road to Reality. Reading Harris’ Letter to a Christian Nation was like sitting ring side, cheering the champion, yelling “Yes!” at every jab. For those of us who feel depressed by this country’s ever increasing unification of church and state, and the ever decreasing support for the sciences that deliver knowledge and reduce ignorance, this little book is a welcome hit of adrenalin. — Marc Hauser, Professor of Psychology, Biology. and Biological Anthropology at Harvard University, author of Moral Minds If you believe in a religion, even the mildest form of Christianity, please read this book. It won’t take you long, but it might change your mind. — Matt Ridley, author of Genome and Nature via Nurture Sam Harris is a brave, intelligent, clear-sighted author whose brilliant essay should be read by every adult who has ever believed that a religious faith can solve the world’s problems. — Desmond Morris, author of Peoplewatching and The Nature of Happiness Sam Harris fearlessly describes a moral and intellectual emergency precipitated by religious fantasies. It is a relief that someone has spoken so frankly, with such passion yet such rationality. Now when the subject arises, as it inevitably does, I can simply say: Read Sam Harris’ Letter to a Christian Nation. — Janna Levin, professor of astronomy and physics at Columbia University, author of How the Universe Got Its Spots and A Madman Dreams of Turing Machines Read this book and decide your stance for the future. — Michael S. Gazzaniga, Director of the Sage Center for the Study of Mind, University of California, Santa Barbara, author of The Ethical Brain I can’t sign my name to this blurb. As a New York Times best selling author of books about business, my career will evaporate if I endorse a book that challenges the deeply held superstitions and bigotry of the masses. That’s exactly why you should (no, you must) read this angry and honest book right away. As long as science and rational thought are under attack by the misguided yet pious majority, our nation is in jeopardy. I’m scared. You should be too. Please buy two, one for you and one for a friend you care about. — Unsigned, New York Times best selling author 

mommiedearest --- 19 years ago -

is Neo an Atheist? What's the difference in Aetheist and Agnostic??? Or is it one in the same BB? 

freshhell --- 19 years ago -

Don't worry so much, Neo. I was probably your age during the Reagan administration. Talk about wound up! But I learned that nobody will listen to me or to anybody else that makes sense. So relax, at least we don't have to worry about the bomb anymore...LOL 

Curarie --- 19 years ago -

Nice to see you again Neo--been awhile 

freshhell --- 19 years ago -

Mommie,, most agnostics are actually atheists who are afraid to use the term atheist. 

Neo --- 19 years ago -

Oh....I'm not worried one bit. And, I am not an Atheist either. mommiedearest, you obviously have access to the internet. I would implore you to do your own research to answer your question. Why in the world would you ask bbjones, who is clearly biased and extreme in his beliefs, narrow-minded in his views, and only interested in keeping it that way? 

Neo --- 19 years ago -

Nice to see you again Neo--been awhile Oh.....I've been around. 

Neo --- 19 years ago -

Who believes in God? Many say their own faith is based in reason, but others' beliefs are grounded in emotion, writes Michael Shermer in Why Darwin Matters February 03, 2007 Michael Shermer Why do you believe in God? I have been asking people this question for most of my adult life. In 1998, Frank Sulloway and I presented the query in a more official format – along with the question "Why do you think other people believe in God?" – in a survey given to 10,000 Americans. Just a few of the answers we received: - A 22-year-old male law student with moderate religious convictions (a self-rated five on a nine-point scale), who was raised by very religious parents and who today calls himself a deist, writes, "I believe in a creator because there seems to be no other possible explanation for the existence of the universe," yet other "people believe in God to give their lives purpose and meaning." - A 43-year-old male computer scientist and Catholic with very strong religious convictions (a nine on the nine-point scale) "had a personal conversion experience, where I had direct contact with God. This conversion experience, and ongoing contacts in prayer, form the only basis for my faith." Other people believe in God, however "because of (a) their upbringing, (b) the comfort of the church, and (c) a hope for this contact." - A 36-year-old male journalist and evangelical Christian with a self-rated eight in religious conviction writes: "I believe in God because to me there is ample evidence for the existence of an intelligent designer of the universe." Yet, "others accept God out of a purely emotional need for comfort throughout their life and use little of their intellectual capacity to examine the faith to which they adhere." - A 40-year-old female Catholic nurse with very strong religious convictions (a nine on the nine-point scale) says that "I believe in God because of the example of my spiritual teacher who believes in God and has unconditional love for people and gives so completely of himself for the good of others. And since I have followed this path, I now treat others so much better." On the other hand, she writes that "I think people initially believe in God because of their parents and unless they start on their own path– where they put a lot of effort into their spiritual part of their life–they continue to believe out of fear." When Sulloway and I noticed the difference between why people believe in God and why they think other people believe in God, we decided to undertake an extensive analysis of all the written answers people provided in our survey. In addition, we inquired about family demographics, religious background, personality characteristics, and other factors that contribute to religious belief and skepticism. We discovered that the seven strongest predictors of belief in God are: 1. being raised in a religious manner 2. parents' religiosity 3. lower levels of education 4. being female 5. a large family 6. lack of conflict with parents 7. being younger In sum, being female and raised by religious parents in a large family appears to make one more religious, whereas being male, educated, in conflict with one's parents, and older appears to make one less religious. As people become older and more educated, they encounter other belief systems that lead them to see the connection between various personal and social influences and religious beliefs. This helps explain the differences we observed in reasons people give for their own beliefs versus the reasons they attribute to other people's beliefs. From the responses we received in a preliminary survey, we created a taxonomy of eleven categories of reasons people give for their own and others' beliefs. The five most common answers given to the question Why do you believe in God?: 1. The good design / natural beauty / perfection / complexity of the world or universe (28.6 per cent) 2. The experience of God in everyday life (20.6 per cent) 3. Belief in God is comforting, relieving, consoling, and gives meaning and purpose to life (10.3 per cent) 4. The Bible says so (9.8 per cent) 5. Just because / faith / the need to believe in something (8.2 per cent) And the six most common answers given to the question Why do you think other people believe in God?: 1. Belief in God is comforting, relieving, consoling, and gives meaning and purpose to life (26.3 per cent) 2. Religious people have been raised to believe in God (22.4 per cent) 3. The experience of God in everyday life (16.2 per cent) 4. Just because / faith / the need to believe in something (13.0 per cent) 5. Fear death and the unknown (9.1 per cent) 6. The good design / natural beauty / perfection / complexity of the world or universe (6.0 per cent) Notice that the intellectually based reasons offered for belief in God – "the good design of the universe" and "the experience of God in everyday life" – which occupied first and second place when people were describing their own beliefs dropped to sixth and third place, respectively, when they were describing the beliefs of others. Indeed, when reflecting on others' beliefs, the two most common reasons cited were emotion-based (and fear-averse!): personal comfort ("comforting, relieving, consoling") and social comfort ("raised to believe"). Sulloway and I believe that these results are evidence of an intellectual attribution bias, in which people consider their own beliefs as being rationally motivated, whereas they see the beliefs of others as being emotionally driven. By analogy, one's commitment to a political belief is generally attributed to a rational decision ("I am for gun control because statistics show that crime decreases when gun ownership decreases"), whereas another person's opinion on the same subject is attributed to need or emotional reasons ("he is for gun control because he is a bleeding-heart liberal"). This intellectual attribution bias appears to be equal opportunity on the subject of God. The apparent good design of the universe, and the perceived action of a higher intelligence in daily activities, are powerful intellectual justifications for belief. But we readily attribute other people's belief in God to their emotional needs and how they were raised. Excerpted from Why Darwin Matters: The Case Against Intelligent Design (Henry Holt and Co.) Michael Shermer is a columnist for Scientific American, the publisher of Skeptic magazine, and the founder of the international Skeptics Society. 

AuthorMan --- 19 years ago -

An agnostic thinks there is no God. An athiest thinks he can prove it. 

Neo --- 19 years ago -

I particularly like Julia Sweeney's take on intelligent design. Listen to a short excerpt HERE. 

zɹossıʞs --- 19 years ago -

Close haha.. agnosticism is the uncertainty of a higher power or the belief that it is impossible to know if god exists basically a skeptic about god. Atheism is the complete disbelief in the existence of any gods. 

AuthorMan --- 19 years ago -

As I said.... 

freshhell --- 19 years ago -

Wrong Authorman. An agnostic is not "sure" about what to believe. An atheist knows in their heart that there is no god, no santa, no magic, and has no problem with that. 

zɹossıʞs --- 19 years ago -

Neo.. listening to those clips now.. pretty funny! :D 

Neo --- 19 years ago -

From Wikipedia: Agnostic Theism is the philosophical view that encompasses both theism and agnosticism. An agnostic theist is one who views that the truth value of certain claims particularly existence of god(s) is unknown or inherently unknowable but chooses to believe in god(s) in spite of this. ____________________________________________ Atheism vs. Agnosticism In an article on About.com: Atheism vs. Agnosticism, the author talks about the differences in meanings of agnosticism and atheism, and claims that agnosticism is compatible with both atheism and theism. In the article the author disclaims the position that agnosticism is more “reasonable” than theism because it eschews theism’s dogmatism being inaccurate. One of the main points the author addresses is a belief he attributes to agnostics that, "If atheists are closed-minded because they are not agnostic, then so are theists." He also discusses how atheism and theism deal with belief, agnosticism deals with knowledge. Weak agnosticism is about personally not having knowledge of god, and strong agnosticism is believing that knowledge about god is impossible. The article summarizes that since belief and knowledge are independent, it's possible to be both. Link to full topic on wikipedia 

freshhell --- 19 years ago -

As a scientist, a math teacher, and a reader, I know the difference between a "proof" and a "feeling". The existence of emotional beliefs is not something that can be proven. 

Neo --- 19 years ago -

From religioustolerance.org..... The range of meanings of the term: "Agnostic:" Agnosticism is a concept, not a full religion. It is a belief related to the existence or non-existence of God. However, many people have started with an Agnosticism, and have added a moral code, rituals and other items to create a belief system with many of the attributes of a religion. When asked what their religion is, many Agnostics will reply "Agnostic." Since so many Agnostics regard this as their religion, we have a policy of capitalizing the term out of respect, as we do for all religions on this web site. This is not often seen on the Internet, but we feel that it is appropriate. Agnosticism implies uncertainty about the existence of God. The basic problem here is that there are many answers to the question "Does God exist?" However there is only this one term available to cover all of the meanings. Some of today's possible overlapping answers to the question are: * I don't personally know. * I don't know but will lead my life in the assumption that no God exists. * I don't know but will lead my life assuming that God does exist. * I cannot give an opinion because there is no way that we can prove the existence or non-existence of God given currently available knowledge. * I cannot give an opinion because there is no way to know, with certainty, anything about God, now and in the future. * Yes, God exists. But we do not know anything about God at this time. * Yes, God exists. But we have no possibility of knowing anything about God, now or in the future. Ultimately, the term "Agnostic" is something like "Christianity." Both refer to a wide diversity of belief systems, but in many cases, an individual asserts that their particular definition is the only fully valid one. The one principle linking all meanings of "Agnostic" is that God's existence can neither be proved nor disproved, on the basis of current evidence. Agnostics note that some theologians and philosophers have tried to to prove, for millennia, that God exists. Others have attempted to prove that God does not exist. Agnostics feel that neither side has convincingly succeeded at their task. Link to full topic. 

*Sunny* --- 19 years ago -

The existence of emotional beliefs is not something that can be proven. ha! Tell my husband that!! hehehe 

AuthorMan --- 19 years ago -

The mere fact that agnostics and athiests spend such a vast amount of energy into a disbelief in God, this in itself is proof enough for me that God exists. Personally, I do not expend any energy trying to prove the earth is flat, therefore it may not be. 

Neo --- 19 years ago -

From Merriam-Webster: agnostic Main Entry: ag·nos·tic Pronunciation: ag-'näs-tik, Function: noun Etymology: Greek agnOstos unknown, unknowable, from a- + gnOstos known, from gignOskein to know -- more at KNOW 1 : a person who holds the view that any ultimate reality (as God) is unknown and probably unknowable; broadly : one who is not committed to believing in either the existence or the nonexistence of God or a god 2 : a person unwilling to commit to an opinion about something [political agnostics] - ag·nos·ti·cism noun atheist Main Entry: athe·ist Pronunciation: \ˈā-thē-ist\ Function: noun Date: 1551 : one who believes that there is no deity 

mommiedearest --- 19 years ago -

 

Neo --- 19 years ago -

therefore it may not be. What? It would seem that theists spend way more energy believing and justifying their beliefs than agnostics or atheists do. Ever see an atheist go to Church 3 times a week? 

Neo --- 19 years ago -

That's a pretty picture mommiedearest. 

Neo --- 19 years ago -

What is an Agnostic? Bertrand Russell ------------------------------------------------------------- What Is an agnostic? An agnostic thinks it impossible to know the truth in matters such as God and the future life with which Christianity and other religions are concerned. Or, if not impossible, at least impossible at the present time. Are agnostics atheists? No. An atheist, like a Christian, holds that we can know whether or not there is a God. The Christian holds that we can know there is a God; the atheist, that we can know there is not. The Agnostic suspends judgment, saying that there are not sufficient grounds either for affirmation or for denial. At the same time, an Agnostic may hold that the existence of God, though not impossible, is very improbable; he may even hold it so improbable that it is not worth considering in practice. In that case, he is not far removed from atheism. His attitude may be that which a careful philosopher would have towards the gods of ancient Greece. If I were asked to prove that Zeus and Poseidon and Hera and the rest of the Olympians do not exist, I should be at a loss to find conclusive arguments. An Agnostic may think the Christian God as improbable as the Olympians; in that case, he is, for practical purposes, at one with the atheists. Since you deny `God's Law', what authority do you accept as a guide to conduct? An Agnostic does not accept any `authority' in the sense in which religious people do. He holds that a man should think out questions of conduct for himself. Of course, he will seek to profit by the wisdom of others, but he will have to select for himself the people he is to consider wise, and he will not regard even what they say as unquestionable. He will observe that what passes as `God's law' varies from time to time. The Bible says both that a woman must not marry her deceased husband's brother, and that, in certain circumstances, she must do so. If you have the misfortune to be a childless widow with an unmarried brother-in-law, it is logically impossible for you to avoid disobeying `God's law'. How do you know what is good and what is evil? What does an agnostic consider a sin? The Agnostic is not quite so certain as some Christians are as to what is good and what is evil. He does not hold, as most Christians in the past held, that people who disagree with the government on abstruse points of theology ought to suffer a painful death. He is against persecution, and rather chary of moral condemnation. As for `sin', he thinks it not a useful notion. He admits, of course, that some kinds of conduct are desirable and some undesirable, but he holds that the punishment of undesirable kinds is only to be commended when it is deterrent or reformatory, not when it is inflicted because it is thought a good thing on its own account that the wicked should suffer. It was this belief in vindictive punishment that made men accept Hell. This is part of the harm done by the notion of `sin'. Does an agnostic do whatever he pleases? In one sense, no; in another sense, everyone does whatever he pleases. Suppose, for example, you hate someone so much that you would like to murder him. Why do you not do so? You may reply: "Because religion tells me that murder is a sin." But as a statistical fact, agnostics are not more prone to murder than other people, in fact, rather less so. They have the same motives for abstaining from murder as other people have. Far and away the most powerful of these motives is the fear of punishment. In lawless conditions, such as a gold rush, all sorts of people will commit crimes, although in ordinary circumstances they would have been law-abiding. There is not only actual legal punishment; there is the discomfort of dreading discovery, and the loneliness of knowing that, to avoid being hated, you must wear a mask with even your closest intimates. And there is also what may be called "conscience": If you ever contemplated a murder, you would dread the horrible memory of your victim's last moments or lifeless corpse. All this, it is true, depends upon your living in a law-abiding community, but there are abundant secular reasons for creating and preserving such a community. I said that there is another sense in which every man does as he pleases. No one but a fool indulges every impulse, but what holds a desire in check is always some other desire. A man's anti-social wishes may be restrained by a wish to please God, but they may also be restrained by a wish to please his friends, or to win the respect of his community, or to be able to contemplate himself without disgust. But if he has no such wishes, the mere abstract concepts of morality will not keep him straight. How does an agnostic regard the Bible? An agnostic regards the Bible exactly as enlightened clerics regard it. He does not think that it is divinely inspired; he thinks its early history legendary, and no more exactly true than that in Homer; he thinks its moral teaching sometimes good, but sometimes very bad. For example: Samuel ordered Saul, in a war, to kill not only every man, woman, and child of the enemy, but also all the sheep and cattle. Saul, however, let the sheep and the cattle live, and for this we are told to condemn him. I have never been able to admire Elisha for cursing the children who laughed at him, or to believe (what the Bible asserts) that a benevolent Deity would send two she-bears to kill the children. How does an agnostic regard Jesus, the Virgin Birth, and the Holy Trinity? Since an agnostic does not believe in God, he cannot think that Jesus was God. Most agnostics admire the life and moral teachings of Jesus as told in the Gospels, but not necessarily more than those of certain other men. Some would place him on a level with Buddha, some with Socrates and some with Abraham Lincoln. Nor do they think that what He said is not open to question, since they do not accept any authority as absolute. They regard the Virgin Birth as a doctrine taken over from pagan mythology, where such births were not uncommon. (Zoroaster was said to have been born of a virgin; Ishtar, the Babylonian goddess, is called the Holy Virgin.) They cannot give credence to it, or to the doctrine of the Trinity, since neither is possible without belief in God. Can an agnostic be a Christian? The word "Christian" has had various different meanings at different times. Throughout most of the centuries since the time of Christ, it has meant a person who believed God and immortality and held that Christ was God. But Unitarians call themselves Christians, although they do not believe in the divinity of Christ, and many people nowadays use the word "God" in a much less precise sense than that which it used to bear. Many people who say they believe in God no longer mean a person, or a trinity of persons, but only a vague tendency or power or purpose immanent in evolution. Others, going still further, mean by "Christianity" merely a system of ethics which, since they are ignorant of history, they imagine to be characteristic of Christians only. When, in a recent book, I said that what the world needs is "love, Christian love, or compassion," many people thought this showed some changes in my views, although in fact, I might have said the same thing at any time. If you mean by a "Christian" a man who loves his neighbor, who has wide sympathy with suffering, and who ardently desires a world freed from the cruelties and abominations which at present disfigure it, then, certainly, you will be justified in calling me a Christian. And, in this sense, I think you will find more "Christians" among agnostics than among the orthodox. But, for my part, I cannot accept such a definition. Apart from other objections to it, it seems rude to Jews, Buddhists, Mohammedans, and other non-Christians, who, so far as history shows, have been at least as apt as Christians to practice the virtues which some modern Christians arrogantly claim as distinctive of their own religion. I think also that all who called themselves Christians in an earlier time, and a great majority of those who do so at the present day, would consider that belief in God and immortality is essential to a Christian. On these grounds, I should not call myself a Christian, and I should say that an agnostic cannot be a Christian. But, if the word "Christianity" comes to be generally used to mean merely a kind of morality, then it will certainly be possible for an agnostic to be a Christian. Does an agnostic deny that man has a soul? This question has no precise meaning unless we are given a definition of the word "soul." I suppose what is meant is, roughly, something nonmaterial which persists throughout a person's life and even, for those who believe in immortality, throughout all future time. If this is what is meant, an agnostic is not likely to believe that man has a soul. But I must hasten to add that this does not mean that an agnostic must be a materialist. Many agnostics (including myself) are quite as doubtful of the body as they are of the soul, but this is a long story taking one into difficult metaphysics. Mind and matter alike, I should say, are only convenient symbols in discourse, not actually existing things. Does an agnostic believe in a hereafter, in Heaven or Hell? The question whether people survive death is one as to which evidence is possible. Psychical research and spiritualism are thought by many to supply such evidence. An agnostic, as such, does not take a view about survival unless he thinks that there is evidence one way or the other. For my part, I do not think there is any good reason to believe that we survive death, but I am open to conviction if adequate evidence should appear. Heaven and hell are a different matter. Belief in hell is bound up with the belief that the vindictive punishment of sin is a good thing, quite independently of any reformative or deterrent effect that it may have. Hardly an agnostic believes this. As for heaven, there might conceivably someday be evidence of its existence through spiritualism, but most agnostics do not think that there is such evidence, and therefore do not believe in heaven. Are you never afraid of God's judgment in denying Him? Most certainly not. I also deny Zeus and Jupiter and Odin and Brahma, but this causes me no qualms. I observe that a very large portion of the human race does not believe in God and suffers no visible punishment in consequence. And if there were a God, I think it very unlikely that He would have such an uneasy vanity as to be offended by those who doubt His existence. How do agnostics explain the beauty and harmony of nature? I do not understand where this "beauty" and "harmony" are supposed to be found. Throughout the animal kingdom, animals ruthlessly prey upon each other. Most of them are either cruelly killed by other animals or slowly die of hunger. For my part, I am unable to see any great beauty or harmony in the tapeworm. Let it not be said that this creature is sent as a punishment for our sins, for it is more prevalent among animals than among humans. I suppose the questioner is thinking of such things as the beauty of the starry heavens. But one should remember that stars every now and again explode and reduce everything in their neighborhood to a vague mist. Beauty, in any case, is subjective and exists only in the eye of the beholder. How do agnostics explain miracles and other revelations of God's omnipotence? Agnostics do not think that there is any evidence of "miracles" in the sense of happenings contrary to natural law. We know that faith healing occurs and is in no sense miraculous. At Lourdes, certain diseases can be cured and others cannot. Those that can be cured at Lourdes can probably be cured by any doctor in whom the patient has faith. As for the records of other miracles, such as Joshua commanding the sun to stand still, the agnostic dismisses them as legends and points to the fact that all religions are plentifully supplied with such legends. There is just as much miraculous evidence for the Greek gods in Homer as for the Christian God in the Bible. There have been base and cruel passions, which religion opposes. If you abandon religious principles, could mankind exist? The existence of base and cruel passions is undeniable, but I find no evidence in history that religion has opposed these passions. On the contrary, it has sanctified them, and enabled people to indulge them without remorse. Cruel persecutions have been commoner in Christendom than anywhere else. What appears to justify persecution is dogmatic belief. Kindliness and tolerance only prevail in proportion as dogmatic belief decays. In our day, a new dogmatic religion, namely, communism, has arisen. To this, as to other systems of dogma, the agnostic is opposed. The persecuting character of present day communism is exactly like the persecuting character of Christianity in earlier centuries. In so far as Christianity has become less persecuting, this is mainly due to the work of freethinkers who have made dogmatists rather less dogmatic. If they were as dogmatic now as in former times, they would still think it right to burn heretics at the stake. The spirit of tolerance which some modern Christians regard as essentially Christian is, in fact, a product of the temper which allows doubt and is suspicious of absolute certainties. I think that anybody who surveys past history in an impartial manner will be driven to the conclusion that religion has caused more suffering than it has prevented. What is the meaning of life to the agnostic? I feel inclined to answer by another question: What is the meaning of `the meaning of life'? I suppose what is intended is some general purpose. I do not think that life in general has any purpose. It just happened. But individual human beings have purposes, and there is nothing in agnosticism to cause them to abandon these purposes. They cannot, of course, be certain of achieving the results at which they aim; but you would think ill of a soldier who refused to fight unless victory was certain. The person who needs religion to bolster up his own purposes is a timorous person, and I cannot think as well of him as of the man who takes his chances, while admitting that defeat is not impossible. Does not the denial of religion mean the denial of marriage and chastity? Here again, one must reply by another question: Does the man who asks this question believe that marriage and chastity contribute to earthly happiness here below, or does he think that, while they cause misery here below, they are to be advocated as means of getting to heaven? The man who takes the latter view will no doubt expect agnosticism to lead to a decay of what he calls virtue, but he will have to admit that what he calls virtue is not what ministers to the happiness of the human race while on earth. If, on the other hand, he takes the former view, namely, that there are terrestrial arguments in favor of marriage and chastity, he must also hold that these arguments are such as should appeal to the agnostic. Agnostics, as such, have no distinctive views about sexual morality. But most of them would admit that there are valid arguments against the unbridled indulgence of sexual desires. They would derive these arguments, however, from terrestrial sources and not from supposed divine commands. Is not faith in reason alone a dangerous creed? Is not reason imperfect and inadequate without spiritual and moral law? No sensible man, however agnostic, has "faith in reason alone." Reason is concerned with matters of fact, some observed, some inferred. The question whether there is a future life and the question whether there is a God concern matters of fact, and the agnostic will hold that they should be investigated in the same way as the question, "Will there be an eclipse of the moon tomorrow?" But matters of fact alone are not sufficient to determine action, since they do not tell us what ends we ought to pursue. In the realm of ends, we need something other than reason. The agnostic will find his ends in his own heart and not in an external command. Let us take an illustration: Suppose you wish to travel by train from New York to Chicago; you will use reason to discover when the trains run, and a person who though that there was some faculty of insight or intuition enabling him to dispense with the timetable would be thought rather silly. But no timetable will tell him that it is wise, he will have to take account of further matters of fact; but behind all the matters of fact, there will be the ends that he thinks fitting to pursue, and these, for an agnostic as for other men, belong to a realm which is not that of reason, though it should be in no degree contrary to it. The realm I mean is that of emotion and feeling and desire. Do you regard all religions as forms of superstition or dogma? Which of the existing religions do you most respect, and why? All the great organized religions that have dominated large populations have involved a greater or less amount of dogma, but "religion" is a word of which the meaning is not very definite. Confucianism, for instance, might be called a religion, although it involves no dogma. And in some forms of liberal Christianity, the element of dogma is reduced to a minimum. Of the great religions of history, I prefer Buddhism, especially in its earliest forms, because it has had the smallest element of persecution. Communism like agnosticism opposes religion, are agnostics Communists? Communism does not oppose religion. It merely opposes the Christian religion, just as Mohammedanism does. Communism, at least in the form advocated by the Soviet Government and the Communist Party, is a new system of dogma of a peculiarly virulent and persecuting sort. Every genuine Agnostic must therefore be opposed to it. Do agnostics think that science and religion are impossible to reconcile? The answer turns upon what is meant by `religion'. If it means merely a system of ethics, it can be reconciled with science. If it means a system of dogma, regarded as unquestionably true, it is incompatible with the scientific spirit, which refuses to accept matters of fact without evidence, and also holds that complete certainty is hardly ever impossible. What kind of evidence could convince you that God exists? I think that if I heard a voice from the sky predicting all that was going to happen to me during the next twenty-four hours, including events that would have seemed highly improbable, and if all these events then produced to happen, I might perhaps be convinced at least of the existence of some superhuman intelligence. I can imagine other evidence of the same sort which might convince me, but so far as I know, no such evidence exists. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

There can be No Hatred of the Light if there is No Light by Doug McHone John 3:18-19 "Whoever believes in him is not condemned, but whoever does not believe stands condemned already because he has not believed in the name of God’s one and only Son. This is the verdict: Light has come into the world, but men loved darkness instead of light because their deeds were evil." Worldwide, Christians are among the most hated, discriminated and persecuted of peoples. This persecution is generally done by people who think their answers are superior to the commandments of the Bible, so they use their resources in government, society, media and religion to attack any and all Christians for our supposed intolerance. Because of their disdain for God and their decisions to be the “masters and commanders” of their own lives, they often feel superior to the “less-intelligent” Christians who are actually proud to refer to themselves as sheep. Don’t they realize that they are undermining their own efforts? Can’t they see that, in their own hatred, they are proclaiming God to be real? Consider this analogy: I hate crickets. Always have, always will. They invade my garage every summer and chirp songs of defiance at me, daring me to seek them out with my trusty flat-bottomed shoe. Occasionally, one will have the audacity to leap to my basement and chirp their song of torment from within my own abode! I hate them for reasons too numerous to discuss here, but I couldn’t hate them if they weren’t real. That would be irrational. Not that chasing down crickets in my garage at 3 a.m. is rational, but work with me here. One thing that I don’t hate is the boogey man. I can’t hate him, even though he must terrorize millions of children each and every night. No matter. I can sweep Ben’s closet and the area under his bed for the boogey man without hatred, for I know that the boogey man is a mythical being that is created by the imagination of a boy who is unsure about this whole “sleeping in his own bed” thing. The hatred of the followers of Christ could not exist in a society that is as rational and intelligent as the one we are told we live in. If you don’t believe me, just ask any atheist if he or she is intelligent. They’ll tell you. But in order for them to hate the Light of the World, that Light must first exist, otherwise the overwhelming intelligence and rationality of the persecutors comes into question. If as much effort went into combating the boogey man as what goes into punishing Christians for the sake of their beliefs, we would have a dedicated UN strike force to patrol the neighborhoods at night to defend the nocturnal health of children everywhere. With this thought in mind, I submit the hatred of God’s church as proof of the existence of God and evidence of the truths found within the Bible. If anybody wishes to debate this truth, they must first proclaim that their hateful efforts to punish “misguided” Christians was done so with malice aforethought and with intentions that were irrational, unimaginative, irresponsible and unintelligent. On the flip-side, I affirm that public acceptance for such theories such as evolution, Scientology, social theism, transcendental meditation, channeling and many other forms of idolatry are proven wrong by the truth of this very passage of scripture and the rational thought of a Christian man who hates crickets, but not the boogey man. 

denhou1974 --- 19 years ago -

Now, someone post a big long clip about Islam or Buddhism. Let's put 'em all in. Like Gumbo. 

freshhell --- 19 years ago -

My sister once said, I never knew you were an atheist, I can't believe you hate god. I asked her if she hated Santa? Think about it bb. 

freshhell --- 19 years ago -

That was my big long clip. 

Anderson --- 19 years ago -

Everyone has the right to believe what you want... ....but don't discredit scripture by thinking it was written by men when you base your disbelief on things written by men. Contrary to popular belief.....Christians are not out to "change your mind" about God/Jesus they only desire to tell you the truth and to dispell falsehoods. It is up to the individual to accept the truth or not----not the witness. After all....the witness will not suffer punishment if you do not accept The Truth---only you will. 

cmi --- 19 years ago -

Ever see an atheist go to Church 3 times a week? Good point. I cracked up at that! You all need to get over the fact that not everyone can be brainwashed by a church. Sorry if that offends anyone, but that's exactly what happens. Most people can't justify their beliefs. Some can, but many more can't. There is nothing wrong or lost about someone saying, "You know what? I don't know the ultimate truth, no one does." 

Neo --- 19 years ago -

Ahem.... This thread was started to discuss atheism and atheists. Not so much for the atheists to have a party, but to present alternative viewpoints to the table for those "bright" enough to have an open mind. There's no need re-hash your viewpoints here bbjones - we are all well aware of them. There's also not a need to delve into all the aspects of the world's religions here either. That would be appropriate for another topic I think. 

TruthKing --- 19 years ago -

 

freshhell --- 19 years ago -

Did you ever see any scripture written by women? Evangelists actually only desire to make themselves feel superior. They are only human after all. 

freshhell --- 19 years ago -

 

page 1 2 3 4 5
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice
religion


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground