Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Why does Heavenly Father allow contention among His followers over beliefs?

who's talking here?

adam 4
mugglemom 2
Thoughtful 29
MissT 1
KatieR 1
eterry2 5
bbjones 19
Anderson 1
steel magnolia 1
JDaddy 7
Going off air 3
BaylorMom 1
Military Mom 6
accent_ 1
*emily 5

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Thoughtful --- 19 years ago -

This one is for you BB – but let’s try and keep it on the sunny side – no name calling Why were the scriptures written in confusing parables that can be interpreted in so many different ways? Mark 4:11 - 12 11 And he said unto them, Unto you it is given to know the mystery of the kingdom of God: but unto them that are without, all these things are done in parables: 12 That seeing they may see, and not perceive; and hearing they may hear, and not understand; lest at any time they should be converted, and their sins should be forgiven them. And if it is so confusing… how is anyone to know what is right or wrong? (There are extraordinarily smart people in all faiths) I have my answer – but first, curious to see what everyone else thinks... will wait until AM and PM crowd has time to comment before saying anything more...  

mugglemom --- 19 years ago -

I believe that Christ taught through parables so they could be interepreted differently for different times in our lives. I know that I have read the same scriptures and they have meant 2 different things to me depending on where I was in life at the time of reading them. (Hope that makes sense). 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Very simply, the answer is God gave us free will. He ALLOWS things to happen. Not only does man possess free will, but he can actually exercise his free will in a way that defies God's will. God wants a relationship with us based on mutual affection and love - not because of force. He wants those who will serve Him to do so freely, willingly accepting His instructions and guidance. To have real love, you have to allow freedom. With this freedom comes the ability of man to concoct any wacky misinterpretation that he wants. In understanding His Word, God wants us to be led by the Spirit, therefore, we should "lean not unto thine own understanding". So that leads us to the the parables. There is only one meaning to the parables, but because of man's freedom, faulty misinterpretaions come about because some people are actually not giving explanations - they are explaining the Bible away. When Jesus was asked, "Why do you speak to them in parables?" (Matthew 13:10), Jesus answered the question by quoting Isaiah, concerning people who have eyes but do not see, and have ears but do not hear (Matthew 13:11-17, Isaiah 6:8-10). In telling the parables, Jesus was bringing pressure to bear upon his listeners, to either open their spiritual eyes and ears and be enlightened, or to shut their eyes and ears tighter and be condemned. By using parables, Jesus could enlighten those whose hearts were receptive and who were hungering and thirsting for righteousness and receptive to the understanding of God's will(Matthew 5:6). On the other hand, there are people who deliberately block their ears and go deaf to God's voice. People misinterpret scripture because they want to be ACCEPTED by God by what THEY do - their "works". 

Thoughtful --- 19 years ago -

I have my answer OK - thinking about this, and I no longer have my own answer - this thought just got really ugly for me (vs 12 - Jesus seemingly not wanting to forgive many people... only an elect few, etc... sorry to bring this topic up - it is not very inspiring - sorry - but help me, please 

eterry2 --- 19 years ago -

Jamie, I recently posted similar thought to BB. He says that everyone must READ the Bible themselves to get the true story. But, from what I read on here, you would need an advanced degree to comprehend it that way. That would be unfair to the average person and the uneducated. I find it very hard to believe that God agrees with BB about not listening to our Christian clergy. Even God had disciples. disciple means teach. The word discipline does too. BB has stated that if you ask the holy spirit for help, it will be simple. I must be missing something. Why didn't God put the Bible in simple terms? The Kingdom of God is not exclusively for analytical minds capable of high level of thought. thanks for asking this question. 

Thoughtful --- 19 years ago -

So BB – back to vs 12 again – why Jesus not give everyone the information they need so that they would use their “Free will” correctly… 11-12 seems to say – if I told them then they would repent… so I don’t want to tell them – I don’t want them to repent – I want them to continue sinning in ignorance and damn themselves…. Again – very ugly (and my original answer was yours – should have stopped thinking while I was ahead…) 

KatieR --- 19 years ago -

God doesn't we bring that on ourself's by not being tolerant of other's. Everyone gets what they need and Everyone needs what they get. All who believe in God are right. His heart is big enough for all. Sadly some of his children haven't figured that out yet. 

Going off air --- 19 years ago -

In telling the parables, Jesus was bringing pressure to bear upon his listeners, to either open their spiritual eyes and ears and be enlightened, or to shut their eyes and ears tighter and be condemned. Excellent point bb 

Thoughtful --- 19 years ago -

Proverbs 22:6 Train up a child in the way he should go: and when he is old, he will not depart from it. so why is our parent - our Heavenly Father, seeming to refrain from training us? Free Agency - best training for some, is to train ourselves - some learn the easy way while others learn the hard way... but in the end, shouldn't we all be allowed to repent and make it through... should not a perfect God be able to plac everyone in the correct circumstances so that everyone could avoid ... hell.... 

Thoughtful --- 19 years ago -

eastern philosophies – yin yang – Heaven/hell good/bad define each other – can’t have one without the other… but is heaven really heaven if it has to be defined by hell? … again, really sorry I brought this topic up – PLEASE NO ONE LOOSE FAITH OVER THIS – I am sure there is a correct explanation to this, I am just too stupid (or too smart) to see it right now. 

Military Mom --- 19 years ago -

That is called Free Will, He put's the information out there, it is up to us to accept it or not. He said Go unto ALL THE NATIONS, He is making it available for everyone. He is the One that inspired man to write the Bible, and the Word says to 'Study to shew thyself approved'. He gave us preachers and teachers to help guide us along, but He also wants us to do our part. He said All who call upon me. I know that is a lot of "He said's", I don't have my Bible handy, but I will look up the scriptures and give them to you. 

Thoughtful --- 19 years ago -

New question - why does there have to be a hell? It has to be more than just yin-yang.... 

Going off air --- 19 years ago -

He said Go unto ALL THE NATIONS Perfect! we should do all we can and were told to do. leave the rest to God who no doubt will do the righteous thing in whatever happens to anyone. 

Thoughtful --- 19 years ago -

It is a commandment to have hope – to not be a pessimist… I guess we will each have our faith tested… is the answer, we don’t know right now – but just have faith that Heavenly Father does indeed know what’s best (even if what’s best for someone is hell – is it loving to send someone to hell?) If I were in His shoes – I guess I do not have a better solution…but then I am not perfect… 

Military Mom --- 19 years ago -

Jamie, the only thing I know about hell is that I do not want to make it my eternity. I can't answer why God didn't just snap his fingers and make sin disappear. He certainly has the power, but then where would Free will come in? In raising my children I have always tried to teach them the basic's of living, touch the stove while it is on and you will get burned. He established guidelines for our living healthy, productive,fulfilling, joyous and victorious lives. Now it is up to us if we are going to touch that stove or not. It's a free gift for all who ask for it...your choice, always your choice, what are you going to do with it? BTW--these are all questions every Christian has asked at some point in their life. They are healthy questions, you should know what you believe in. I am learning a lot about what I believe and why I believe it by reading all of these discussions. 

Thoughtful --- 19 years ago -

It sounds bad – but maybe it is actually loving to send some people to hell – just like a bum would not feel comfortable going to an opera where everyone around him is all dressed up and sophisticated… maybe some people – given the choice – would actually be happier in hell. That is maybe what I really don’t understand… why would someone – given the info/experiences they need – actually choose to damn themselves? Again, sorry so dark – I really did not intend for this to be the way the conversation goes… 

Military Mom --- 19 years ago -

He is a just and loving God. He doesn't choose to send people to hell even though He created it. But HE did not create it for mankind...He created it for Satan. No one would be happier in hell, no one. I don't know why some would choose the alternative to Heaven. Ignorance? Pride? Not opening themselves up to the possibilty? I believe that if everyone truly looked deep within, they would find God, after all we were created in His Image, but they have to be honest with themselves and really look deep. He's there, just waiting and longing for each one of us to trust in Him to accept him for the Righteous One He is. 

Thoughtful --- 19 years ago -

I am learning a lot about what I believe Thanks military mom - I just have to remind myself - (talking to myself here) I am NOT questioning my faith My quetions are to increase faith Whatever crazy scary thoughts are put in my head - I have faith they will eventually be resolved, and my weaknesses will become strengths. 

Going off air --- 19 years ago -

why would someone – given the info/experiences they need – actually choose to damn themselves? I'm with you there, its like a prisoner on death row who gets a pardon from the governer but says NO we are going thru with this sentence. I cannot fathom why one would choose this way. we jus no they do 

Thoughtful --- 19 years ago -

I agree Military Mom I take back what I said - happier in hell - some people may not want to be happy at all... Our poor Heavenly Father, how crushing it must be... Lesson learned? Please help me to choose to be happy! 

Military Mom --- 19 years ago -

That a girl Jamie! You know how it is when kids are little they ask so many questions and sometimes as adults we get mad about repeating ourselves, but how else do they learn, how else do we learn? Just be very careful, know what you believe and stand firm in it. If you aren't so sure about something don't get to caught up in 'discussion' over it, because it could cause you to forget what you believed in in the first place. When you have a doubt, go to a trusted source, rely on God's Word, and rely on God. Ask him for direction and He will guide you...I PROMISE! 

adam (Wizard) --- 19 years ago -

- happier in hell - What is hell? 

*emily --- 19 years ago -

any place outside of the presence of Heavely Father. At least here on Earth we can feel His Spirit. JMO 

Thoughtful --- 19 years ago -

Thanks – you guys really are great – I am commonly awestruck at the hidden divinity in some of the people around me … 

*emily --- 19 years ago -

Trust your heart and listen to the still small voice. Don't let anyone make you doubt what you know to be true. 

Military Mom --- 19 years ago -

Oh, two thatagirls in one day! You go Emily. Same thing I told her. It's been fun talking to y'all, now I better get back to work...bills to be paid. 

*emily --- 19 years ago -

See ya MM! 

eterry2 --- 19 years ago -

Some people believe that the reason religions have heaven/hell is to keep humans on the high road. We have to rely on faith and we have no proof of what is after death. Even those religions that teach reincarnation have a hierarchy. To return in a higher form, you must be good. I guess you could say that religion is necessary for society. Without it, there would be chaos. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Jamie, I recently posted similar thought to BB. He says that everyone must READ the Bible themselves to get the true story. But, from what I read on here, you would need an advanced degree to comprehend it that way. That would be unfair to the average person and the uneducated. I find it very hard to believe that God agrees with BB about not listening to our Christian clergy. Even God had disciples. disciple means teach. You do not need an advanced degree. Where do men get their degrees? From being taught by other men. We are responsible for our own salvation and our own learning. God tells us that we do not need teachers (See 1 John 2:27, John 16:12-15). If we rely on others to tell us what to believe, then we can be deceived, and we deserve the consequences. That being said, I am not saying that you can not listen to Church leaders or use reference material. What I am saying is this. EVERYTHING you do hear or read OUTSIDE the Bible needs to be compared to the rest of Scripture to ensure that it does not conflict with other Bible passages. That is important because God DOES NOT contradict Himself. As for Christians who are uneducated not being able to understand, that will be true IF they try and learn on their "own understanding" and do not allow the indwelt Spirit of God to teach them. The Holy Spirit is God and knows ALL. 1 Corinthians 2:16 says "For who hath known the mind of the Lord, that he may instruct him? But we have the mind of Christ." Why didn't God put the Bible in simple terms? The Kingdom of God is not exclusively for analytical minds capable of high level of thought. For the most part the Bible is very simple. Some things God wanted only His children to know. Why was that? He wants us to rely upon Him. If everything in the Bible could be understood without the Holy Spirit's guidance, then man would rely upon his own understanding and knowledge and become self-righteous! I do not have any advanced theological degrees, but using Bible study in context with the rest of the Scriptures, reference materials and the guidance of the Holy Spirit, I am able to understand what God is revealing to us. If God can do that through me, then He can do the same through you. 

*emily --- 19 years ago -

For the most part the Bible is very simple. Some things God wanted only His children to know. Why was that? He wants us to rely upon Him. If everything in the Bible could be understood without the Holy Spirit's guidance, then man would rely upon his own understanding and knowledge and become self-righteous! I do not have any advanced theological degrees, but using Bible study in context with the rest of the Scriptures, reference materials and the guidance of the Holy Spirit, I am able to understand what god is revealing to us. If God can do that through me, then He can do the same through you. I like this BB. Uplifting and not condescending. This is the approach you need to keep when sharing your thoughts! :) 

MissT --- 19 years ago -

- happier in hell - What is hell? Maybe the lowest level of heaven for you? Why does Heavenly Father allow contention among His followers over beliefs? Remember the story of the Tower of Babel? 

JDaddy --- 19 years ago -

What is hell? Jesus referred to Hell and referenced that there is fire in it. You could probably start an interesting debate on hell. Its a hard concept for Christians and others, so it would be another thing that causes contention among believers. I have a friend that converted from Hindu to Islam and is currently having a crisis over the fate of her parents. If she takes the Muslim teachings to heart, her deceased parents are doomed to a fiery and awful eternity. Yet, she married a Muslim and has a child with him, so she won't back out of the Muslim church. As a Christian, what do I tell her? Right now I can't tell her anything because the answer breaks my heart. Why does she ask me, a follower of Jesus, this question in the first place? It would be easier to be a Mormon, where the concept of hell is divided up a bit, but this isn't what the Holy Spirit has told me is the truth. Do you care to expound on your beliefs? 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

I can't answer why God didn't just snap his fingers and make sin disappear. I can. If He did that, then we would have to be robots - a creation with no free will. 

Military Mom --- 19 years ago -

I can't answer why God didn't just snap his fingers and make sin disappear. I can. If He did that, then we would have to be robots - a creation with no free will. I said that BB in the very next sentence. 

adam (Wizard) --- 19 years ago -

What is hell? I ask that question because we talk a lot about avoiding hell and getting saved. We don't talk much about what hell is and what saved is. I think understanding what hell is and what saved is helps us understand what it takes to get to one or the other. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

The reason why there is a Hell is due to the fact that God can not have fellowship with sin. The people who reject His Son Jesus Christ, the perfect sacrifice for sin, had to have a place to go for their eternal punishment, because they can not be with God. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

I like this BB. Uplifting and not condescending. This is the approach you need to keep when sharing your thoughts! :) I only appear to be condescending when I write something that someone does not like to read. 

Thoughtful --- 19 years ago -

Be careful – don’t start pondering hell too much… Agents in charge of tracking down counterfeit money do not study the counterfeits – they study the genuine article… Rather than being motivated by fear – get motivation through understanding the bliss of heaven. Understanding the bliss of heaven. Yea! This discussion is turning into something happy after all! 

Thoughtful --- 19 years ago -

So Adam... What is Heaven? 

JDaddy --- 19 years ago -

I think understanding what hell is and what saved is helps us understand what it takes to get to one or the other. Where would you start? Are there two options - 1)Saved and 2)Not Saved or do you find evidence that there are other stops in between? 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

recommendations


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground