Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Darwin's Theory of Evolution - A Theory In Crisis

who's talking here?

freshhell 4
Thoughtful 2
Unichic 1
eterry2 3
bbjones 81
lulajean 2
Justwatching72 4
gking 9
sharky 1
JDaddy 14
Puppy again 5
qpc 5
4 wheelin 3
Tyrus 5
NoNameNoLastName 39
Zionist NightOwl 1
auraofpeace 45
*Sunny* 1
ChezML 1
accent_ 13
Authority 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Darwin's Theory of Evolution is a slow gradual process. Darwin wrote, "…Natural selection acts only by taking advantage of slight successive variations; she can never take a great and sudden leap, but must advance by short and sure, though slow steps." [1] Thus, Darwin conceded that, "If it could be demonstrated that any complex organ existed, which could not possibly have been formed by numerous, successive, slight modifications, my theory would absolutely break down." [2] Such a complex organ would be known as an "irreducibly complex system". An irreducibly complex system is one composed of multiple parts, all of which are necessary for the system to function. If even one part is missing, the entire system will fail to function. Every individual part is integral. [3] Thus, such a system could not have evolved slowly, piece by piece. The common mousetrap is an everyday non-biological example of irreducible complexity. It is composed of five basic parts: a catch (to hold the bait), a powerful spring, a thin rod called "the hammer," a holding bar to secure the hammer in place, and a platform to mount the trap. If any one of these parts is missing, the mechanism will not work. Each individual part is integral. The mousetrap is irreducibly complex. [4] Darwin's Theory of Evolution is a theory in crisis in light of the tremendous advances we've made in molecular biology, biochemistry and genetics over the past fifty years. We now know that there are in fact tens of thousands of irreducibly complex systems on the cellular level. Specified complexity pervades the microscopic biological world. Molecular biologist Michael Denton wrote, "Although the tiniest bacterial cells are incredibly small, weighing less than 10-12 grams, each is in effect a veritable micro-miniaturized factory containing thousands of exquisitely designed pieces of intricate molecular machinery, made up altogether of one hundred thousand million atoms, far more complicated than any machinery built by man and absolutely without parallel in the non-living world." [5] And we don't need a microscope to observe irreducible complexity. The eye, the ear and the heart are all examples of irreducible complexity, though they were not recognized as such in Darwin's day. Nevertheless, Darwin confessed, "To suppose that the eye with all its inimitable contrivances for adjusting the focus to different distances, for admitting different amounts of light, and for the correction of spherical and chromatic aberration, could have been formed by natural selection, seems, I freely confess, absurd in the highest degree." [6] [1] Charles Darwin, "On the Origin of Species by Means of Natural Selection, or the Preservation of Favoured Races in the Struggle for Life," 1859, p. 162. [2] Ibid. p. 158. [3] Michael Behe, "Darwin's Black Box," 1996. [4]"Unlocking the Mystery of Life," documentary by Illustra Media, 2002. [5] Michael Denton, "Evolution: A Theory in Crisis," 1986, p. 250. [6] Charles Darwin, "On the Origin of Species by Means of Natural Selection, or the Preservation of Favoured Races in the Struggle for Life," 1859, p. 155. 

auraofpeace --- 19 years ago -

well, you are running into some problems here when you start talking about evolution or even "Darwin evolution" in such terms. Charles Darwin died in 1882. He did most of his work specific to HIS theroy of evolution (he not being the only person or person to propose such an theory) in the mid 1800's. His understanding of the physical world, as a result of him being the frontrunner of this brand of science, as well as the limited technology of his time, will have to excuse him to a large degree for the science, technology, and discoveries to come. Another example of this might be Charles Babbage, a contemporary of Darwin, who initally proposed the idea of a programmable computer. I do not know if in his writings he ever proposed the postential limitations of a computer, but if he were put in a time machine and placed in front of the simple and basic PC I am typing on right now, it is very unlikley he would even recognize it as what he proposed, and would not likley understand or even be able to conceptualize the technology that goes into it that "we" take for granted today. Heck, there was a time in professional football (since we just had the Superbowl) that the idea of a "forward pass" was a novelty and nobody figured it would ever be integral to the game like the "drop kick" was at the time. Holding the entire of science, much less evolutionary science, to the words or ideas presented well over 100 years ago, when the ideas being presented were still new, very revolutiuonary, and undergoing their own "evolution" is ludicrous. If we are going to do that, we shall have to condemn the Church today for believing that the sun revolves around the earth and that spontaneous transmutation is why you find maggots in rotten meat. 

JDaddy --- 19 years ago -

That's a strange response auraofpeace. Darwin's principle of applying natural selection and huge quantities of time to explain the unknown is still alive and well today. The converse argument of applying simple childlike faith and accepting that the unknown is a gift from God is also alive. The difference is that the faith in my heart is met with a small, simple and clear, yet powerful voice that tells me I am right and that I am fearfully and wonderfully made by an all powerful creator. He is Loving and terrifying at the same time. While the Bible may be a little confusing and the Creation story could have been influenced by Jewish folklore, the underlying principles of creation and salvation are unchanging, unerring and proven to be true. These principles are the basis of the great religions of the world and they engage my heart much more than the thought that I am an accidental cloud of dust. If you believe I am in an uninformed fantasy that will be disproven by advances in science, then I am truly saddened that the great glory of God's creation bypasses some. It is a wonderful thing to look outside and admire the handywork of the Creator. To be blind to that glory would be a terrible thing for me. 

auraofpeace --- 19 years ago -

J-Daddy, I am not sure of anything in the Theroy of Evolution is in denial of God or your belief in Him. Certainly some proponents of evolution may be atheistic, etc., but the breakdown in evolution and Christianity is not that evolution says "there is not God", but that some Christians say that "evolution" (as a broad term) replaces the ideas presented in Genesis, and therfore cannot co-exist with an idea of a Christian God. I have not stated anything such as: (you are) in an uninformed fantasy that will be disproven by advances in science Nor has the theory of evolution. At the worst (in those terms) the idea of evolution presents some certainties that must be reconciled with Biblical truth. Much like the idea, and Church doctrine of the past, that the sun and universe revolved around the earth. A childlike faith that there is a God is a wonderful thing and I would not, and do not, challenge that. A childlike faith that a strict literalist intepretation of anything the Bible says or implies is "the truth" is no more sensible than a strict and literalist interpretation of anything. 

auraofpeace --- 19 years ago -

sorry. FOrgot to adress this.... That's a strange response auraofpeace. Darwin's principle of applying natural selection and huge quantities of time to explain the unknown is still alive and well today. absolutely. But it is also in a lot different state than it was when Darwin proposed it. Darwin proposed it, and generalized it, in the beginning around a species of birds and (IIRC) a species of turtle. Obviously, he began to develop it more over time, and in the 120 odd years since his death, it has gone into a vast array of specializations and directions and such. My point is if you begin and end your defense or attack on "evolution" based upon what Darwin wrote about it 120 years ago, you are not really making an arguement for or against evolution, so much as you are about what Darwin thought 120 eyars ago. 

JDaddy --- 19 years ago -

My point is if you begin and end your defense or attack on "evolution" based upon what Darwin wrote about it 120 years ago, you are not really making an arguement for or against evolution, so much as you are about what Darwin thought 120 eyars ago. I think "Darwin's Theory of Evolution" is a common point that most people are familiar with and allows us to quickly define polarities of opinion. However, perhaps you are correct that the argument of "irreducible complexity" was applied in too limited a fashion to the Darwinian foundation. From my way of thinking, this argument can be applied to any theory other than creation by an Intelligent Designer. Could an Intelligent Designer use an evolutionary process? As a believer in God, I would not begin to argue that his power is limited in this regard. Did God want us to have the benefits of the geology of a mature Earth? Sure! At a basic level, how could God have created a "Garden of Eden" without soil for the plants in the garden? Soil isn't created overnight, so I think the Bible states very clearly that the Earth has a maturity. When God "breathed life" into Adam, did he give a Neaderthal a soul that did not exist previously? I don't think that matches up with the principles I see in the Bible and in his creation, but again, I wouldn't begin to limit the power of God. What is important to me is that I am sure I'm not here by mistake. As far as evolution goes... science has not begun to give me enough transitional elements out of the fossil record to support evolution. If support is found, it will not change my beliefs. Is this similar to your opinion? 

Authority --- 19 years ago -

BB, Join me in my fight to bring peace to the comunity! 

auraofpeace --- 19 years ago -

What is important to me is that I am sure I'm not here by mistake. As far as evolution goes... science has not begun to give me enough transitional elements out of the fossil record to support evolution. If support is found, it will not change my beliefs. Is this similar to your opinion? I would say it is human nature to seek our origings and to find some sense of intellectual and emotional, and certainly spiritual, security in them. As well, most people look for some sense of explanation of the world around them. Your, or my, belief in a God doesn't have to be challenged in that. What may be challenged, should you engage in such discussions or pursuits, is the mechanics of God and His nature. 

JDaddy --- 19 years ago -

That said, I think irreducible complexity is an arguable concept and I learned something from this article. The mechanics of God and His nature are exciting things to prove... and much more substantial than the musings of Darwin. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Certainly some proponents of evolution may be atheistic, etc., but the breakdown in evolution and Christianity is not that evolution says "there is not God", but that some Christians say that "evolution" (as a broad term) replaces the ideas presented in Genesis, and therfore cannot co-exist with an idea of a Christian God. Belief in evolution does deny the one true God. To believe in God is to believe that he is Truth. To believe that God is Truth is to believe Him when he reveals something to us in the Bible. Evolution says that death has occured continually over millions of years before man evolved. God tells us in the Bible that death did not occur on the earth until Adam sinned against God. You can not believe in both because both scenarios can not be true. To believe that evolution is the method that created man is to tell God that He lied to us. If death did not come to this earth because of Adam's sin, then there was no need for Jesus to die on the cross to pay the penalty for sin. 

auraofpeace --- 19 years ago -

That said, I think irreducible complexity is an arguable concept absolutely it is! The only caveat I would add to that is that you can certainly START your arguements against it, or evolution, with Charles Darwin. You just cannot end them there, and justify your disagreement with ALL of evolution by what Darwin said 120 odd years ago or more. 

auraofpeace --- 19 years ago -

God tells us in the Bible that death did not occur on the earth until Adam sinned against God. Genesis, Chapter 2 8 Now the LORD God had planted a garden in the east, in Eden; and there he put the man he had formed. 9 And the LORD God made all kinds of trees grow out of the ground—trees that were pleasing to the eye and good for food. If there was immortality, by original design, why the neccesity of food? Maybe answer that over on the "other thread" though. 

JDaddy --- 19 years ago -

death did not occur on the earth until Adam sinned against God Would you not say that "death" in the context of Genesis is separation from God (aka sin)? I never took Genesis to say that no creature ever died? If you look at the entire universe and the distance light travels, plus the dynamics of stars being born and stars dying, you see the concept of death being perpetuated over and over (eliminating the argument of how long it takes for light to get to us). Unless Adam was created on a different plane of existence than us, I just don't see how you can eliminate physical death from the Garden of Eden? I really have a hard time with eliminating evolution on the basis of "no death until Adam sinned". 

Unichic --- 19 years ago -

YES, this is one thread I am going to leave quickly. All the newcomers can battle it out with our fundamentalist Christians and I will just sit back and watch this round lol. Have fun!!!!!! 

auraofpeace --- 19 years ago -

JDaddy, in your last post, i.e: Would you not say that "death" in the context of Genesis is separation from God (aka sin)? I never took Genesis to say that no creature ever died? If you look at the entire universe and the distance light travels, plus the dynamics of stars being born and stars dying, you see the concept of death being perpetuated over and over (eliminating the argument of how long it takes for light to get to us). the orginal comment referred to, about sin and death was not made by myself, but by BBJones. I was commenting back to him, and part of the context of that actually resides in another thread. 

JDaddy --- 19 years ago -

YES, this is one thread I am going to leave quickly. All the newcomers can battle it out with our fundamentalist Christians and I will just sit back and watch this round lol. Have fun!!!!!! Honestly, I'm fundamentalist, which means that I believe in the basic principles of the Bible. One of the basic principles of the Bible is that we can see the truth of God's Word in the world around us. God created the universe and God created me in his image. How he did that is not crucial to my faith. If I see inconsistencies between the natural record and a literal interpretation of Genesis, well, I'm going to stick to the principle and take the basics of Genesis and match them up with the world around me. 

JDaddy --- 19 years ago -

auraofpeace - I just went back and skimmed that thread... I see what you are talking about. It seems that this is an argument of the literalist interpretation of Genesis, which BBJones may be rewarded one day for defending using 2nd Timothy 3:16, but my conviction is to STUDY God's Word and challenge myself to understand the context of scripture instead of smacking people in the back of the head with the translation. 

gking --- 19 years ago -

but my conviction is to STUDY God's Word and challenge myself to understand the context of scripture instead of smacking people in the back of the head with the translation. AMEN! 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Would you not say that "death" in the context of Genesis is separation from God (aka sin)? I never took Genesis to say that no creature ever died? If you look at the entire universe and the distance light travels, plus the dynamics of stars being born and stars dying, you see the concept of death being perpetuated over and over (eliminating the argument of how long it takes for light to get to us). That is only AFTER Adam's death. If you want to believe in a universe that is billions of years old and disregard God's account as a lie, then you would believe that death was perpetuated over and over. However, if you are a Christian, how do you reconcile evolution's theory that encompasses death in the absence of Adam's sin with this verse in Romans 5:12 "Wherefore, as by one man sin entered into the world, and death by sin; and so death passed upon all men, for that all have sinned:" JDaddy, just how am I smacking anyone in the back of the head with the translation? What translation? The King James Version? What exactly am I translating - english to english? 

JDaddy --- 19 years ago -

What exactly am I translating - english to english? An account of Jewish history that was handed down through word of mouth through numerous generations and finally recorded in the understanding of presumably Moses, but more likely scribes that came before him. Then there are the translations post-Moses... If we take the translations completely literally, then there is no way that the Ark would have ever floated. We assume, based upon consistency with the natural world/record, that Noah must have taken all of the animals close to him and the domesticated or "named" animals, but blindly assuming Noah stuck every species on a hand-made boat is ignoring the physical laws of the Universe that God set into motion. The principle that all Scripture is God-breathed and useful for teaching, rebuking, etc. is a GREAT principle. But let's not be blind! God gave us the ability to think and interpret! 

auraofpeace --- 19 years ago -

JDaddy, your points are valid, but they have been discussed and explained to the point of absurdity. The very points you are making. Unless you just like jacking with BBJ, you are spending time that could as easily and more productively in being bored. 

JDaddy --- 19 years ago -

Thanks auraofpeace and bbjones. It may be that you guys have hashed this out before, but the discussion makes me challenge my own way of thinking. I am a lifelong student and am always willing to learn from differing points of view. Since bbjones appears to have been called to be a teacher, very often giving instruction to the KU populace, I submit my advice. Please change your method. As you know, Socrates was not the inventor of the Socratic method. Jesus didn't bark out commands to the disciples. He asked his disciples to articulate what they held by faith. Faith seeking understanding is the terminology for it. By focusing on a students need for understanding, I think you could be a much better teacher. Are you frustrated that your attempts to instruct are met with hostility? Why respond with brutal facts? Establish agreement on the principles we can agree upon and then lets work together to understand the rest. I may be making too many assumptions here, but I don't think we always have to differ with each other. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

If we take the translations completely literally, then there is no way that the Ark would have ever floated. Now why would you say that? Many engineers have said that the ark would definitely float. God gave Noah the instructions and the exact dimensions of the ark. don't you think that God would know whether it would float or not? This quote was in the Copenhagen newspaper, Dagbladet, of 31st August, 1904; "The Royal Shipbuilding yard has recently completed the construction of a remarkable vessel. It is 30 feet long, 5 feet wide, and 3 feet high, and with its slanting sides most resembles the roof of a house. It is a new Noah's Ark, constructed after the design of Mr. Vogt, the engineer, the Carlsburg Fund bearing the expense of its production...The remarkable thing about the Bible measurements is that after thousands of years' experience in the art of shipbuilding they must be confessed to be still the ideal proportions for the construction of a big ship... the Ark was not intended to sail, but to lie still on the water, and to give the best and quietest condition for the comfort of its inhabitants" We assume, based upon consistency with the natural world/record, that Noah must have taken all of the animals close to him and the domesticated or "named" animals, but blindly assuming Noah stuck every species on a hand-made boat is ignoring the physical laws of the Universe that God set into motion. Explain to me why you think that your statement is true? 

auraofpeace --- 19 years ago -

Well, JDaddy, I must admit that you are distracting him from another task involving sticks and spotted goats. 

JDaddy --- 19 years ago -

Explain to me why you think that your statement is true? Because of the sheer number of species and subspecies in the world today. (There is an argument that less than this number was needed to repopulate the Earth... supposing that species could have produced the subspecies characteristics afterwards) Because of the problems with loading the Ark. Because of the care of the animals. Because the predators would have to start hunting as soon as they got off the Ark (assuming they hibernated during the time on the Ark). All of which I give God full credit for being able to do... I do not question his power. I just don't see it as being consistent with the way the world works today and I think God consistently applies his principles of natural law, therefore I see a disconnect. note... I do believe in a Great Flood. The evidence is plain to me, considering the geologic and fossil record. I find the argument that coal beds and possibly oil reserves are a dynamic of a water-covered (great flood) earth to be compelling and I would love to see more research in this area. I think its possible that we apply too many years to the Earth and the Universe's age as a convenience to explain things we don't understand, but from what we do understand, I just can't reconcile the 7 day Creation. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

The principle that all Scripture is God-breathed and useful for teaching, rebuking, etc. is a GREAT principle. But let's not be blind! God gave us the ability to think and interpret! What does God say about interpreting the Bible? Proverbs 8:8-9: “All the words of my mouth are in righteousness; there is nothing froward or perverse in them. They are all plain to him that understandeth, and right to them that find knowledge.” This is God’s claim in the Bible, quite a tough claim. This is a statement of assurance, or guarantee, to the readers of the Bible. If there are lies in the Bible - any lies, then God is a liar, and Jesus is a lie, and therefore Christianity is nothing more than an interesting museum piece. It has no objective validity or reality. Why do you think that you would have to interpret God's message. Don't you think that God would know that each individual person would interpret differently and why would He leave that to our fallible, error prone brains? 2 Timothy 3:16 "All scripture is given by inspiration of God, and is profitable for doctrine, for reproof, for correction, for instruction in righteousness:" Inspiration deals with God's revelation of truth which man did not know and which man could not know apart from Divine revelation. "For my thoughts are not your thoughts, neither are your ways my ways, saith the LORD. For as the heavens are higher than the earth, so are my ways higher than your ways, and my thoughts than your thoughts." (Isiah 55:8-9). God could not leave it to man to "interpret" His revelation of truth, so he "spelled it out" for us so there would be no need for interpretation. What does God say about OUR wisdom? "For I am not ashamed of the gospel of Christ: for it is the power of God unto salvation to every one that believeth; to the Jew first, and also to the Greek. For therein is the righteousness of God revealed from faith to faith: as it is written, The just shall live by faith. For the wrath of God is revealed from heaven against all ungodliness and unrighteousness of men, who hold the truth in unrighteousness; Because that which may be known of God is manifest in them; for God hath shewed it unto them. For the invisible things of him from the creation of the world are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made, even his eternal power and Godhead; so that they are without excuse: Because that, when they knew God, they glorified him not as God, neither were thankful; but became vain in their imaginations, and their foolish heart was darkened. Professing themselves to be wise, they became fools, And changed the glory of the uncorruptible God into an image made like to corruptible man, and to birds, and fourfooted beasts, and creeping things. Wherefore God also gave them up to uncleanness through the lusts of their own hearts, to dishonour their own bodies between themselves: Who changed the truth of God into a lie, and worshipped and served the creature more than the Creator, who is blessed for ever. Amen." We are also told in 1 Timothy 6:20-21: "O Timothy, keep that which is committed to thy trust, avoiding profane and vain babblings, and oppositions of science falsely so called: Which some professing have erred concerning the faith. Grace be with thee. Amen." Evolution denies there is a creator. It turns the creator into animals just like God said fools would do in Romans 1:25 "...changed the truth of God into a lie, and worshipped and served the creature more than the Creator..." It is idolatry. Evolution denies the words of the creator as he spoke all things into existance. Evolutionists deny the creator and, then, deny their denial. 

*Sunny* --- 19 years ago -

wow...this is a deep thread. Good luck to all.....howabout going to watch some mind dumbing TV???? 

auraofpeace --- 19 years ago -

We are also told in 1 Timothy 6:20-21: "O Timothy, keep that which is committed to thy trust, avoiding profane and vain babblings, and oppositions of science falsely so called: Which some professing have erred concerning the faith. Grace be with thee. Amen." we are also told in Timothy: "..instruct certain men not to teach strange doctrines, nor to pay attention to myths and endless genealogies, which give rise to mere speculation rather than furthering the administration of God which is by faith.." if you want to discuss the virgin birth of Jesus, you will know that the term "almah" simply means "young woman", which is how Mary is described in prophecy of Isiaih. The term "bethulah", which means "virgin" appears four times in Isaiah, but never in reference to any prophecy regarding Jesus. The Isaiah prophecy itself, of a woman bearing a child she will call Immanuel, is a direct reference to Isaiah Chapter 7, and King Ahaz as a asign he will not be defeated in battle. In the Book of Timothy, Paul is telling the reader to not get caught up in the discussions of geanolgies of Jesus that are merely confusions and add nothing to the reliance of Faith. MArk and John basically ignore the circumstance of Jesus birth, in fact. Now, if you look at the actual geanology of Jesus, and ignore the advice of Paul, you start seeing more problems. Newe Testament geanologies are used to prove His kingship, but they break down in investigation. If you use the geanology of Matthew, for example, you find that Jesus is related to Jeconiah, of whom it is said: "Write this man down as childless, a man who will not prosper in his days, for no man of his descendants will prosper sitting on the throne of David or ruling again in Judah." (Jeremiah 22:30) etc., etc., etc. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Because of the sheer number of species and subspecies in the world today. Noah did not need to take sea animals because they would not necessarily be threatened with extinction by a flood. Noah did not need to take plants either—many could have survived as seeds, and others could have survived on floating mats of tangled vegetation, as seen today after severe storms. Many insects and other invertebrates were small enough to have survived on these mats as well. According to Genesis 7:22, the Flood wiped out all land animals that breathed through nostrils except those on the Ark. Insects do not breathe through nostrils but through tiny tubes (tracheae) exiting through pores (spiracles) in their exterior skeleton (‘shell’). The dimensions for the ark given in Genesis are 300 cubits long, 50 cubits wide and 30 cubits high (Genesis 6:15). What is a cubit? A cubit is an ancient unit of measurement, the length of the forearm from the elbow to the longest finger (the term “cubit” comes from the Latin word “cubitum” which means elbow. The Hebrew word for cubit is “‘ammah”). As everybody’s arms are different in length this unit may seem a bit ambiguous to some but scholars generally agree that it represents somewhere between 17 and 22 inches (43-56 centimeters). The ancient Egyptian cubit is known to have been 21.888 inches. So let’s do the math… 300 x 22 inches = 6,600; 50 x 22 inches = 1,100; 30 x 22 inches = 660 6,600/12 = 550 feet; 1100/12 = 91.7 feet; 660/12 = 55 feet. Thus, the ark could have been up to 550 feet long, 91.7 feet wide and 55 feet high. These are not unreasonable dimensions. But how much storage space does this amount to? Well, 550 x 91.7 x 55 = 2,773,925 cubic feet. (If we take the smaller measurement, 17 inches, we end up with 1.278,825 cubic feet). Of course, not all of it would have been free space. The ark had three levels (Genesis 6:16) and a lot of rooms (Genesis 6:14), the walls of which would have taken up space. Nevertheless, it has been calculated that if the ark had only 1,518,750 cubic feet of free space, a little more than half (54.75%) of the 2,773,925, it could store up to 125,000 sheep-sized animals (see - http://www.icr.org/bible/bhta42.html). John Woodmorappe, author of the definitive Noah's Ark: A Feasibility Study, estimated that only about 15% of the animals on the ark would have been larger than a sheep. This figure does not take into account the possibility that God may have brought Noah “infant” animals, which can be significantly smaller than adult animals. How many animals were on the ark? Woodmorappe estimates about 16,000 “kinds.” What is a “kind”? The designation of “kind” is thought to be much broader than the designation “species.” Even as there are 400-something dog breeds but they all belong to one species (Canis familiaris), in the same way many species can belong to one kind. Some think that the designation “genus” may be somewhat close to the Biblical “kind.” Nevertheless, even if we presume that “kind” is synonymous with “species,” “there are not very many species of mammals, birds, amphibians and reptiles. The leading systematic biologist, Ernst Mayr, gives the number as 17,600. Allowing for two of each species on the ark, plus seven of the few so-called “clean” kinds of animals, plus a reasonable increment for known extinct species, it is obvious that not more than say, 50,000 animals were on the ark.” (Morris, 1987) Some have estimated that there were as many as 25,000 kinds of animals represented on the ark. This is a high-end estimation. With two of each kind and seven of some the number of animals would exceed 50,000, though not by very much relatively speaking. Regardless, whether there were 16,000 or 25,000 kinds of animals, even with two of each and seven of some, scholars agree that there was plenty of room for all of the animals on the ark, plus food and water with room to spare. 

auraofpeace --- 19 years ago -

Noah did not need to take sea animals because they would not necessarily be threatened with extinction by a flood. if it was a "fresh water flood", such as rain, the dilution of the salt content in the water would likley kill the salt water fish. If it was simply a raising of the sea water, any fresh water fish would have died. This figure does not take into account the possibility that God may have brought Noah “infant” animals, which can be significantly smaller than adult animals. How do infant animals make a cross country trek to an ark, from hundreds or even thousands of miles away? plus a reasonable increment for known extinct species, it is obvious that not more than say, 50,000 animals were on the ark.” (Morris, 1987) do you have any idea of the amount of defecation and urine 50,000 animals will produce in a day? A lamb weighs approx. 100 lb. Since there were many animals ont eh ark smaller than a lamb, and many quite a bit larger, we will use the lamb is median in size and weight. That equals 5,000,000 lb. in cargo. Or, 2500 tons. That is 2500 deadweight tons to ADD to the food, passengers, and ship weight itself. Do you understand how much displacement that is in water volume? 

eterry2 --- 19 years ago -

been there, done that. 

JDaddy --- 19 years ago -

bbjones, Sorry I had to drop off the conversation. You obviously put a lot of work into your responses. I'm a sinner. I don't have the understanding or wisdom I wish I had. I am fallible and I can be dead wrong, even when I am using scripture to support my argument. I have asked for forgiveness of my sins and professed Jesus as my Lord and Savior. Yet, I disagree with you regarding the possibility that the Genesis account allows for an old earth. Why? I think God warned us not to change his Word and even told us that all scripture is God-Breathed. He did not tell us that he had filled in all the blanks for us and told us by your very quote in Isaiah that we do not think the same way He does. Therefore, I feel justified in using the term "interpret". Moses may have been given the Genesis account directly from God, but he may also have gotten the account from oral testimony or transcribed accounts in cuneiform tablets originally written by Adam, Shem, Noah, etc. I say maybe, because we don't know. We also don't know how much of the account may have been limited by the understanding of the writer or narrator. If Adam wrote that the Earth was created in seven days, did he have a concept of long periods of time? The vastness of the world? How can we know? I sense that you feel like you are "fighting the good fight" and we should all see the truth through your eyes because God has given you his wisdom. I have also prayed for wisdom, which God promised in James' letter. This was one of my first prayers, prayed with childlike faith. I'll pray again and ask God that if you are correct, then let me see things your way. However, it is offensive for you to rebuke me for not understanding things the way God understands them and imply that you have complete understanding. It is offensive to tell me that my allowance for God's almighty power to work through an old earth and even evolution (admittedly, I have a hard time with evolution matching up with Biblical principles) is to deny God. It is offensive for you to capitalize on my use of the term "interpret" and tell me a whole lot of what I already knew. You need to understand this and examine why I am offended. Could you have done something differently? If the answer is no, then what could you tell me to keep me engaged? Do you enjoy these debates? My use of the Ark was an example... If you just want to tell me its a bad example, then there's no need to write a four pager on it or quote me somebody else's four pager. I learned a few things by reading and looking up some information on the Ark, but I don't want to engage in an Ark/Great Flood discussion. I wish you well BB. I pray that your passion for scripture and doctrine translates into evangelism and love for your neighbor. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

How do infant animals make a cross country trek to an ark, from hundreds or even thousands of miles away? God brought them there. Do you have trouble believing that He could do that? I think that if He can create a universe, He could round up a few animals. How could fish survive a world wide flood? during the flood, there would be a mixing of salt and fresh water. Many fish species found today are specialized and do not survive in water that is of an extremely different salinity than their natural habitat. How did they survive the flood? No one knows how salty the sea was before the flood. The flood was initiated by the breaking up of the "fountains of the great deep" (Genesis 7:11). Because of the enormous weight of the amount of water released from the deep, the flood probably was associated with massive earth movements, which would have resulted in great volcanic activity. Volcanoes emit huge amounts of steam, and underwater lava creates hot water/steam, which would dissolve minerals and add salt to the water. In addition, erosion brought about by the the movement of receding water from the continents after the flood would have added salt to the oceans. Therefore, the pre-flood ocean waters were probably less salty than after the flood. Fish have trouble coping with saltiness for these reasons: 1) fish in fresh water tend to absorb water, because the saltiness of their body fluids draws in water through osmosis. 2) Fish in saltwater tend to lose water from their bodies because the surrounding water is saltier than their body fluids. Many of today's species of fish are able to adjust to both fresh water and salt water. There are migratory species of fish that travel between salt and fresh water. For example, salmon, striped bass, and Atlantic spurgeon spawn in fresh water and mature in salt water. Eels reproduce in salt water and grow to maturity in fresh water streams and lakes. There is also evidence of post-flood specialization within a kind of fish. For example, the Atlantic sturgeon is a migratory salt/freshwater species but the Siberian sturgeon (a different species of the same kind) lives only in fresh water. Many families of fish contain both fresh and saltwater species. These include the families of toadfish, garpike, bowfin, sturgeon, herring/anchovy, salmon/trout/pike, catfish, clingfish, stickleback, scorpionfish, and flatfish. Snce most of the families alive today have both fresh and saltwater representatives, this suggests that the ability to tolerate large changes in salinity was present in most fish at the time of the flood. The loss of this ability in many species today probably resulted from specialization through natural selection. Fish can adapt to water of different salinity, and do so in their own lifetime, if the salinity is changed slowly enough. This ability of fish to adapt to a salinity different than their normal habitat allows public aquariums to exhibit freshwater and saltwater species together. Since fresh water can sit on top of salt water for extended periods of time, some scientist hypothesize that it is also a possibility that stable fresh and saltwater layers developed and persisted in some parts of the ocean. They also believe that turbulence may have been sufficiently low at high latitudes for such layering to persist and allow the survival of both freshwater and saltwater species in those areas. Of course, do not forget about the awesome power of God. He could have easily kept fish alive. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

He did not tell us that he had filled in all the blanks for us and told us by your very quote in Isaiah that we do not think the same way He does. Therefore, I feel justified in using the term "interpret" The point, that I was trying to convey, is if we do not think the way that He does, then how could we even begin to interpret what He means unless He reveals it to us? Moses may have been given the Genesis account directly from God, but he may also have gotten the account from oral testimony or transcribed accounts in cuneiform tablets originally written by Adam, Shem, Noah, etc. I say maybe, because we don't know. We also don't know how much of the account may have been limited by the understanding of the writer or narrator. If Adam wrote that the Earth was created in seven days, did he have a concept of long periods of time? The vastness of the world? How can we know? We as Christians can "know" because God reveals to us in 2 Timothy 3:16 that "All scripture is given by inspiration of God, and is profitable for doctrine, for reproof, for correction, for instruction in righteousness:" Consider God's choice of words. Paul described Scripture using the Greek term "theopneustos". The first part of the word, Theo, means "God." The second part is pneustos meaning "breathed." So the apostle Paul writes, as some translations put it, "All Scripture is God-breathed," meaning it came directly from the mouth of God. Why would Adam need to know about "a concept of long periods of time?" I sense that you feel like you are "fighting the good fight" and we should all see the truth through your eyes because God has given you his wisdom. No, you can see the truth through your own eyes by having faith in God. The "gift" of faith is received by hearing the words of Jesus. This is accomplished by simply reading, studying, and understanding the Bible because Jesus is the Living Word of God. Open your heart to the Holy Spirit as you read the Bible and you will understand. However, it is offensive for you to rebuke me for not understanding things the way God understands them and imply that you have complete understanding. I am not rebuking you. If you feel that way, it is possibly God working through the Holy Spirit convicting you. It is offensive to tell me that my allowance for God's almighty power to work through an old earth and even evolution (admittedly, I have a hard time with evolution matching up with Biblical principles) is to deny God. JDaddy, you have to understand that it is offensive to me for you to call God a liar. How do you do that? You do that by questioning God's account of creation. It makes me sad that so many people who profess to be Christian can not believe that God's Word is the truth. They will believe some scientists that they do not know instead of God who they are supposed to have a very personal relationship with. You need to understand this and examine why I am offended. Could you have done something differently? I know why you are offended. You do not like hearing God's Truth. You are not alone - not very many people do. Even I have had a problem with it. Maybe I could have done something differently. It is very hard to fully express yourself through writing. However, I have been as truthful as I can, and sometimes the truth is harsh. I feel that if you love your neighbor, you will tell them the truth. I feel that it does not do a person any favors by lying to them and watering down the truth. How can I keep you engaged? I can not abswer that for you. You have to want to seek the truth and be willing to hear what God is telling you. Do I like these debates? Not really. It saddens me, especially when I see fellow Christians deluded and deceived by Satan. My prayer would be that everyone would read God's Word for themselves and understand what He reveals to us through His Word so that all could have eternal life through Jesus Christ our Lord and Savior. My use of the Ark was an example... If you just want to tell me its a bad example, then there's no need to write a four pager on it or quote me somebody else's four pager. JDaddy, do you think that maybe you are exagerrating somewhat? When I respond to someone on this forum, I try to include enough information so that others might benefit. I learned a few things by reading and looking up some information on the Ark, but I don't want to engage in an Ark/Great Flood discussion. I am confused. If you did not want to have a discussion involving the Ark, then why did you introduce the topic into this thread? Why do I respond with brutal facts? Well, when I write using Scripture, they are God's facts that He has laid upon my heart to share with others. Some people do not like the way I present things, some people do. I just think that it is the way people perceive things. I think that if you look at what I write as informative rather than a bias towards judgement, then I think that your outlook will be different. Whether you believe it or not, I am trying to help! 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

if you want to discuss the virgin birth of Jesus, you will know that the term "almah" simply means "young woman", which is how Mary is described in prophecy of Isiaih. I do not know where you are getting your information, but in my Strong's Concordance "almah" means "virgin" or "young woman". Isaiah 7:14 says "Therefore the Lord himself shall give you a sign; Behold, a virgin shall conceive, and bear a son, and shall call his name Immanuel." (KJV) If you use the geanology of Matthew, for example, you find that Jesus is related to Jeconiah, of whom it is said: "Write this man down as childless, a man who will not prosper in his days, for no man of his descendants will prosper sitting on the throne of David or ruling again in Judah." (Jeremiah 22:30) The King James Version is "Thus saith the LORD, Write ye this man childless, a man that shall not prosper in his days: for no man of his seed shall prosper, sitting upon the throne of David, and ruling any more in Judah." Jeconiah was considered so wicked that the LORD put a blood curse on his descendants, stating that none of his offspring will ever again sit on the throne of David. Jeremiah 22:30 was only speaking to being "written childless" which refers to posessions and inheritance not actual live descendants. For 1 Chronicles 3:17 says "And the sons of Jeconiah; Assir, Salathiel his son". Salathiel is also listed in the genealogy of Jesus. 

auraofpeace --- 19 years ago -

I do not know where you are getting your information, but in my Strong's Concordance "almah" means "virgin" or "young woman". Isaiah 7:14 says "Therefore the Lord himself shall give you a sign; Behold, a virgin shall conceive, and bear a son, and shall call his name Immanuel." (KJV) http://www.jewsforjesus.org/publications/issues/9_1/almahnull Jeconiah was considered so wicked that the LORD put a blood curse on his descendants, stating that none of his offspring will ever again sit on the throne of David. Jeremiah 22:30 was only speaking to being "written childless" which refers to posessions and inheritance not actual live descendants. For 1 Chronicles 3:17 says "And the sons of Jeconiah; Assir, Salathiel his son". Salathiel is also listed in the genealogy of Jesus. there you go. Jesus is related to Jeconiah, who had a curse from God place upon his head and his offspring. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

there you go. Jesus is related to Jeconiah, who had a curse from God place upon his head and his offspring. So what is your purpose for writing that? Are you trying to say that God cursed Jesus, therefore, Jesus could not be the true Son of God? 

auraofpeace --- 19 years ago -

So what is your purpose for writing that? Are you trying to say that God cursed Jesus, therefore, Jesus could not be the true Son of God? if you accept the lineage of Jesus, via the New Testament, that places Jeconiah in His ancestry, then there is a definite problem in either the Old Testament or the New, on that issue. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

if you accept the lineage of Jesus, via the New Testament, that places Jeconiah in His ancestry, then there is a definite problem in either the Old Testament or the New, on that issue. Well, tell me. What is that problem? Spell it out for me! 

auraofpeace --- 19 years ago -

Well, tell me. What is that problem? Spell it out for me! it has already been spelled out. I stated the problem, you commented on it and asked me a quetion, and I answered it. Are you wanting to start again? I also wish you would tell me how sheep mating in front of colored sticks makes them bear young the same colors as the sticks. I am curious as to that being the work of God or magic. 

page 1 2 3 4 5 6
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground