Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Reincarnation anyone????????

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 2
DrowningFish 8
Lilteapot 6
Mary C 2
duflochy 7
bbjones 35
lulajean 11
Only Daughter 4
traveller 26
Justwatching72 4
yepyep 3
CountryChick 1
©Hanson♥ 2
lLackCreativity 1
JordanAlexander 1
amb07 4
SLP7962 2
qpc 12

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

traveller --- 20 years ago -

The Sleuth...Scientific Evidence for Reincarnation? By Jonathan Kolber August 23, 2006 I'm a big believer in the scientific method. It leads to some of the most powerful technological discoveries of our times, and some of the greatest investment opportunities as well. Some of them come out of left field. The scientific method requires a dispassionate willingness to let the data lead one to conclusions. It requires repeatability under controlled conditions. Essentially, in science, observations lead to conclusions -- whereas in religion, conclusions lead to observations. I consider both to be vital to a well-integrated life. I've personally had experiences of the sacred and even of the miraculous that I could not begin to prove scientifically. The advantage of scientific data is that they can be tested and verified by others. One of the most interesting subjects at the junction point of spirituality and religion is reincarnation. Many people consider it nonsense based upon their religious or scientific perspective, and I respect their right to this point of view. Personally, I've always kept an open mind about reincarnation. Jesus’ response to his disciples when asked, “Who sinned, this man or his parents that he was born blind?" seemed to leave open the possibility. He did not declare that they had made a mistake, but gave another explanation instead. Most other major religions assume reincarnation as fact, and a 2005 Gallup poll found that 20% of Americans do so as well. I personally had an experience in college that seemed to fit the bill. After consuming ½ dozen donuts (disclaimer: if I worked for the Drug Enforcement Administration I would investigate Krispy Kreme), I seemed to see a series of distant images that were at once historical and strangely familiar... Most interesting to me, the images explained some anomalies in my life and the information gained changed my perspective on some things. Since childhood, I had harbored hostile attitudes towards France, a country with which I had no apparent connection whatsoever. I regarded the French as irrational and prone to mob rule. I also had a phobia of being in crowds. After seemingly “remembering” a life as an insignificant member of the nobility in France, apparently born in 1756, all of my irrational attitudes disappeared. And for the first time in my life, I was able to enjoy vacationing in Quebec and listening to the French language spoken. In addition, during the “memory” I heard a waltz playing and saw the orchestra playing it. I should mention that I have never in my life composed music, much less a waltz. (I never even took a music class after grade school.) I was able to sing this well enough that it was recorded on cassette and given to a professor of classical music at my college. He declared it to be the work of “an unknown composer,” probably circa 1800. Coincidence? Hallucination? Perhaps -- but the subsequent changes were real and now it turns out I’m far from alone. Enter science. Last night, I heard Dr. Brian Weiss expound on his research into reincarnation through hypnosis. Dr. Weiss is a Yale-trained psychotherapist, and Chairman Emeritus of Psychiatry at the Mount Sinai Medical Center in Miami. His research is published in peer-reviewed journals. One can reasonably disagree with his conclusions, but one cannot ignore his credentials or body of work.  

traveller --- 20 years ago -

Anyone have an opinion on reincarnation that they would like to share? 

lLackCreativity --- 20 years ago -

My thoughts on it: This can't be all there is.... 

Lilteapot --- 20 years ago -

ASk Shirley Maclaine! 

bbjones --- 20 years ago -

This is what Christianity says about reincarnation. The idea or theory of reincarnation is not accepted by Christianity because it was not a revelation from God and it undermines other revelations from God. First, it renders futile God’s sovereignty over creation, transforming Him into a helpless spectator of the human tragedy. Because He is sovereign and omnipotent over creation, God can punish evil and will do it perfectly well at the end of history (see Matthew 25,31-46; Revelation 20,10-15). There is no need for impersonal karma and reincarnation to play this role. Second, believing in reincarnation may affect one’s understanding of morality and motivation for moral living. An extreme application of reincarnationist convictions could lead to adopting a perverted stand to crime, theft, lying and other such social plagues. They could be considered nothing else but normal debts to be paid by their victims, originated in their previous lives. Following this reasoning, social injustice should not be punished at all in order to not complicate even more someone’s karmic debt. Third, the theory of reincarnation is contradictory to the very essence of Christianity: the need for Christ’s redemptive sacrifice for our sins. If we are to pay for the consequences of our sins ourselves in further lives and attain salvation through our own efforts, the sacrifice of Christ becomes useless and absurd. It wouldn’t be the only way back to God, but only a stupid accident of history. In this case Christianity would be a mere form of Hindu Bhakti-Yoga. As a result, no matter how many attempts are made today to find texts in the Bible or in the history of the Church that would allegedly teach reincarnation, they are all doomed to remain pure speculations. People believing in reincarnation use Biblical text, such as the text mentioned in the article about the healing of the man born blind in John 9,2, to say that the Bible implies reincarnation. Considering the apostles' question: "Rabbi, who sinned, this man or his parents, that he was born blind?", it is obvious that the first option (the man was born blind because of his sin) implies that he could sin only in a previous life. According to the classic theory of reincarnation, he might have been a cruel dictator who got the just reward for his bad deeds. However, the apostles' question about the possibility of having sinned before birth just confirms that some religious factions believed that the fetus can sin in his mother womb. If Jesus had considered reincarnation to be true, surely He would have used this opportunity - as was His custom - to explain to them the law of karma and reincarnation, as an immediate application to that man’s situation. Jesus never missed such occasions to instruct his disciples on spiritual matters, and reincarnation would have been a crucial doctrine for them to understand. Nevertheless, by the answer Jesus gave to them, He rejected both options suggested by the apostles. Both the idea of sinning before birth and the punishment for the parents' sins were wrong. Jesus said: "Neither this man nor his parents sinned, but this happened so that the work of God might be displayed in his life" (John 9,3). "The work of God" is described in the next verses, when Jesus healed the blind man as a proof of His divinity (v. 39). As for "past life" experiences, an answer to this is found in Christian theology. Psychiatry attempts to find an equivalence between evoking "personalities from past lives", by the use of hypnosis, and the multiple personality phenomenon. In psychriaty, there remains an unexplained element in the attempt to understand both phenomena on a purely naturalistic basis: How are the personalities distributed in their roles, or who decides which one is to act next in the show? Psychriasts say that there must be a "director". Parapsychologists tend to attribute the "director’s" role to some personal external entities, which act through the process of channeling. Hypnosis generates perfect conditions for contacting these entities as a result of abolishing normal consciousness. Instead of presenting their true identity, they could introduce themselves as personalities evoked from previous lives. Now if we pass from the realm of parapsychology to Christian Biblical teaching from God's Word, it is obvious that such "external personal entities" exist, and have sufficient reason to lie to us about spiritual reality. They are called demons and have developed the most ingenious techniques to fool mankind about spiritual reality. The Apostle Paul states: "And no wonder, for Satan himself masquerades as an angel of light. It is not surprising, then, if his servants masquerade as servants of righteousness. Their end will be what their actions deserve" (2 Corinthians 11,14-15). Since Biblical revelation tells us that demons exist and do their best to fool us about spiritual reality, why is it hard for people to accept the demons involvement in producing reincarnation proofs, a concept that blatantly contradicts the essence of Christianity but at the same time fits well with their purpose? If the best conditions are created to express themselves through the person undergoing hypnosis (when self-consciousness is abolished), why should they not act? Why should they not respond to the invitation to fulfill their purpose in such a fascinating way for a credulous and ignorant public? You wrote "One can reasonably disagree with his conclusions, but one cannot ignore his credentials or body of work." Yes you can and I believe I just did. 

traveller --- 20 years ago -

I don't think Shirley McLaine is on KU. How about you? 

Lilteapot --- 20 years ago -

I personally haven't given it much thought.. There are some that belive we come back time and time again until our purpose is served. There are some that think it is a bunch of crap. Who knows? It is a personal opinion. I swear my hubby was a cowboy in a past life though, and hung out with Whyatt Earp! LMAO 

traveller --- 20 years ago -

bb, these are quotes from a newsletter, not my own quotes. The bible is full of speculation and unproven stories, you take it as truth because it is your faith. I was asking for people's opinions, not what the bible and christianity has to say about it. Don't you have an opinion?? 

bbjones --- 20 years ago -

Why do I need an opinion other than to believe what God has revealed to us? Mankind gets itself into trouble EVERYTIME it tries to "outthink" God. 

bbjones --- 20 years ago -

The bible is full of speculation and unproven stories Please show me the proof for the speculation in your untrue statement. 

traveller --- 20 years ago -

Show me proof that Jesus rose someone from the dead: and don't use a bible quote to make your point. There is no proof. It is your choice to believe, not mine, so to me it is speculation. I am not a tunnel visioned believer as you are, therefore I have an opinion. And my opinion is just a valid as anyone else's. 

duflochy --- 20 years ago -

Good job bb...sic'em 

traveller --- 20 years ago -

Sic'em? He hasn't proven anything, other than he knows the bible word for word. 

bbjones --- 20 years ago -

Typical answer from a non-believer. Answer a question with a question. There has been NOTHING that was written through God's inspiration that has been proven to be false - NOTHING. As for your opinion, "For my thoughts are not your thoughts, neither are your ways my ways, saith the LORD. For as the heavens are higher than the earth, so are my ways higher than your ways, and my thoughts than your thoughts." (Isaiah 55:8-9) 

duflochy --- 20 years ago -

I may not agree with bb and his delivery all the time but I have not seen him twist the bible in knots and spit it out as some have.....get'em bb... 

duflochy --- 20 years ago -

He hasn't proven anything, other than he knows the bible word for word. AT LEAST HE KNOWS THAT....ITS A GOOD ROADMAP FOR ANY HUMAN...... 

traveller --- 20 years ago -

As usual,you have lost the original idea for this thread. I was asking for people's opinions, not what the bible says on it. I should have realized that you don't have an opinion. You are probably afraid to voice an opinion other than what the bible tells you to to think. By the way, your answer is typical of someone who has no proof other than bible quotes. Opinions bb, everyone's got one. 

duflochy --- 20 years ago -

wELL GO AHEAD AND PUT SOME OF YOUR "PROOF" ON HERE, LETS SEE WHAT IT SAYS..... 

duflochy --- 20 years ago -

mY OPINION IS " NO WAY DO i BELIEVE IN REINCARTION".....The Bible is plain about when and where we will spend eternity....I chose to believe it.... 

traveller --- 20 years ago -

You are all missing the point. I never claimed to have any proof. However bb and people like you do claim to have proof. In reality, there is no proof for either side, so it it boils down to belief, speculation, etc.. If you want to speak about any truths, what about the speed of light, formation of the planets, evolution, etc... Why do you so called christians look down on anyone who questions the bible? 

bbjones --- 20 years ago -

As do I. 

bbjones --- 20 years ago -

I was not looking down on you - only God can do that. 

bbjones --- 20 years ago -

There is NO factual proof for evolution. 

traveller --- 20 years ago -

That's fine. I respect anyone's opinion and their right to express it. I just can't fathom why anyone becomes so beligerent and adamant when someone expresses a different opinion. If everyone shared the same opinions and thoughts, the world would be a very boring place. 

duflochy --- 20 years ago -

. I just can't fathom why anyone becomes so beligerent and adamant The only one who is trying to be adamant is traveller....bb is cool...I'm cool..... whats your point... 

traveller --- 20 years ago -

Again, you hear and see what you want. If you read back to the beginning, I was just looking for people's opinions to have an interesting discussion. I am in no way being adamant or beligerent. You and bb are doing a good job of that. As I said I was looking for opinions, nothing else. I don't care what the bible says about reincarnation. And you don't have an opinion, you choose to believe what the bible says about it. 

duflochy --- 20 years ago -

" NO WAY DO i BELIEVE IN REINCARTION"..... Thats about as plain as I can get..... thats all I have to say on the subject 

lulajean --- 20 years ago -

I am all for it! I hope it is true. Those who live an inhuman life, AND those who live a kind and giving life- get to come back to this world and reap the "rewards" of their past actions. (there is more than one book in the is world, for those of you who don't wish to stay in the dark ages, read some of them & draw your own conclusions) 

traveller --- 20 years ago -

That's fine. It's a shame other people won't offer an opinion on this. 

Lilteapot --- 20 years ago -

If you punch in the words "reincarnation in the bible" on google there are ton of sites that support the theory it is written in bible and early christian's believed in it, and also a ton that rebuke it. It boils down to interpretaion of the bible. Also your personal beliefs. 

lulajean --- 20 years ago -

:( you sound so discouraged... It is a fascinating article, (wether you believe in reincarnation or not), please don't be discouraged by those who use every thread as an opportunity to quote the bible- some people aren't comfortable forming their own opinion. 

traveller --- 20 years ago -

lulajean I'm not discouraged at all. It seems to me that certain people are afraid to have their own opinions on many subjects as it may go against the bible. You are right on the money when you say that some people aren't comfortable forming their own opinions. Alot of people have viewed this thread but only a very few have actually commented. I would have liked to see more views on it. Thanks for the comment! 

yepyep --- 20 years ago -

I want to come back as a Christian. Then I wont get put in the ice box rotfl. 

whatchamacallit --- 20 years ago -

Sorry Yep Yep, no one is exempt not even BB or Anderson! 

yepyep --- 20 years ago -

Getting off topic here, but want to answer your comment wharchmacallit: You are right, but it should be used for the intent is was put there for. I know my icing wasnt but there ya go! 

whatchamacallit --- 20 years ago -

Yes, not for personal revenge... 

Justwatching72 --- 20 years ago -

Reincarnation, I dunno, it is very interesting. and if it is dealing with what you did in this one determines what you come back as in next life then I hope the first 24 or so odd years do not count, if they do I am in a world of hurt. Past lives is alwasy very tricky.. I guess I would like to beleive in it. But if I did then it would go against my other beliefs, not christianity, just the belief in karma pretty much. for if there was reincarnation, and what you did in this life determines the next one, that would pretty much set down that there is some higher being controlling all of it. randmom chance would not be able to set up your next life based on your last one. Now, if it's just reincarnation without the whole what you did in the past life thing and it just keeps going around adn around, then I spose i would have to go with that one since that one would not go against my beliefs I have now. Sorry all this is so jumbled, I think while I type. 

traveller --- 20 years ago -

I don't think your past life would determine what future lives may hold. (if you believe in reincarnation) Like you, I would not want to bet my future on my past. I am quite convinced I lived a past life. 

yepyep --- 20 years ago -

yeah, but you dont know for sure if it does or not right? IF you believe in it in the first place. 

traveller --- 20 years ago -

yepyep You are right. There are no definite answers; no right or wrong. It is just interesting to hear other points of view. 

page 1 2 3 4
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground