Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Trump VS Clinton Tax Plan for Average American

who's talking here?

wayward1 2
SoupIsGoodFood 7
jackass 1
Dorothy Parker 2
Iwonder 3
Emperor of Kingwood 9
Judas 1
Butterbean 8
AMDG 7
them 2
Giorgio Tsoukalos 1
CartmanUK34 4
Karras 8

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Karras --- 10 years ago -

This example taken from another website"

"I compared Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump's tax plan to see how it would effect me as a middle class tax payer. Here's the break down using $75,000 of taxable income.

Hillary Clintons website does not list a table of tax brackets and so I must assume that her rates will remain the same as it is currently and as it pertains to the middle class. This places that salary in a 15% tax bracket (married filing jointly). The standard deduction is currently $12,600 which brings my income down to $62,400.

Under Hillary this brings my federal tax bill to $8,432.50 per year. That's around $700 per month or $325 a paycheck. (my salary is divided over 26 pay periods).

Donald Trump places that salary in a 12% tax bracket. His standard deduction is $30,000 which reduces my taxable income to $45,000.

Under Trump this brings my federal tax bill to $5,400 per year. That translates to me paying close to $450 a month in fed tax or around $220 per paycheck.

Donald Trump's tax plan would put an extra $125.00 a paycheck in my pocket every paycheck. That's almost $250.00 a month or $3,000.00 per year in extra money.

If I were to invest that $125 each paycheck into my mutual fund that has a lifetime average rate of return of 13% I would have....almost 2 million dollars when I retire around 30 years from now....

Think about that when you consider who you are going to vote for in November. An extra $3,000 can go an extremely long distance in most people's households (especially for my family of 5).

Hillary doesn't identify her proposed tax brackets on her website but here is her tax plan to look for yourself.

https://www.hillaryclinton.com/issues/a-fair-tax-system/

And Trumps tax plan is here

https://www.donaldjtrump.com/policies/tax-plan/ 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

Here is the critical difference in the argument above.

The author is comaparing something that is (current rates) - against a campaign promise. And gives them both equal weight.

See here is the problem, the president does not make law, he can make proposals to congress, he can use his influence to try and get it done, but it is very far from a done deal that if Trump did get elected, he could ever pass his tax bill.

Evaluating an existing situation against some possible situation, that may or may not happen without some level of probability attached is bad analysis and bad logic. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 10 years ago -

LOL....... 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

for the originator of the post -

just in case he/she is not doing this - go work for some one with a 401k matching plan.

contribute the $125 per check now ( since it is pre tax, you would be forgoing $106.25 every 2 weeks, or about $7.59 a day.

in 30 years at a modest 10% - you will have $1.18M 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 10 years ago -

more LOL 

Karras --- 10 years ago -

Here is the critical difference in the argument above. The author is comaparing something that is (current rates) - against a campaign promise. And gives them both equal weight.

Previous president's have worked with congress and passed new tax plans. For example some major tax overhauls came from Kennedy and Reagan.

The illustration shows that Trump's plan helps the middle class, Hillary's does not.

contribute the $125 per check now

Under the Trump proposal, they could contribute more. 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

The illustration shows that Trump's plan helps the middle class, Hillary's does not.

No it doesn't - it shows the assumption the trump plan become law is better than the authors assumption that the Clinton plan's tax bracket is the same as today bracket.

Previous president's have worked with congress and passed new tax plans. For example some major tax overhauls came from Kennedy and Reagan.

No doubt, and Trump if elected may be able to do the same. But until then it is not a reality, it is a plan, a campaign promise, and should not be weighted equally in a comparative analysis to the status que. 

Karras --- 10 years ago -

Clinton plan's tax bracket is the same as today bracket.

Maybe Clinton should be more forthcoming about her tax plan. Trump's is pretty easy to find and comprehend. What is Clinton hiding? 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

In simpler terms - what if I told you you can have this $100 bill in my hand right now, or I will give you $200 tomorrow if my wife and kids say it is ok.

You would do some quick internal analysis to evaluating if - I am good for my word, and the odds that my wife and kids would say yes.

So analytically it is not $100 vs $200, it is a sure $100 vs the probability of $200. 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

Maybe Clinton should be more forthcoming about her tax plan. Trump's is pretty easy to find and comprehend. What is Clinton hiding?

No argument at all - agree 

CartmanUK34 --- 10 years ago -

I happen to fall firmly into the tax bracket in person and I think the simplistic view that cutting what I pay in tax "benefits the middle class" is very naive and oversimplified. Cutting tax like that is going to affect other things and make life on the whole worse for more people. Conversely Hilary's plan is going to affect more than what you have in your pocket each month, you have to take into account far more than just the pay in your pocket, we pay taxes to benefit society, if you are so selfish that that extra $125 is the be all and end all to you then that is your choice. I for one am happy to keep paying the tax I pay now if those at the top pay their share and society benefits.

It is important to note at this point that trickle down didn't work, and trumped up, trickle down has a snowballs chance in hell of working any better. 

Karras --- 10 years ago -

Here's an idea. We go with Trump's plan so people can keep "their" money (it doesn't belong to the government or "society") to spend it how they please, and for the socialists they can send in the extra money back to the feds with their tax forms. 

Karras --- 10 years ago -

if you are so selfish that that extra $125

Only a nasty liberal would think that someone keeping their money would be selfish.

For a middle class family that $125 means:
1. Extra groceries. Maybe a little bit better food.
2. Better daycare
3. Help pay increasing property taxes
4. Help pay increasing utility costs
5. Help pay increased gas prices
6. New clothes for the kids
7. A little nicer Christmas

And maybe they can take their extra $125 and buy something at a local store. Which in turns helps the local business owner, who can then buy from other businesses or hire an additional employee.

That makes more sense then to hand the money back to the government. Only a fool would think that the government can spend money better than the individual. 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

(it doesn't belong to the government or "society")

I can make you a pretty good case it doesn't really belong to you. it goes like this -

it is economically acceptable to you to trade your labor for you current after tax earnings. That is true form many reasons for many reason, but in general because you do not see a better alternative.

If all taxes were abolished, why would a business continue to pay you more money than you are willing to take right now. Labor markets would adjust - and you would make the same thing you make today.

I think the best way to think of it is the entire economy is sitting on top of a black box of taxes. Money comes out of the box to the private sector to buy stuff, and money goes back in as taxes - to re fuel the system ( actually more to control inflation but that is a touch esoteric)

You can have small changes in taxes and labor markets wont adjust maybe, but in my experience those shortfalls are not made up by reduced spending - so "other taxes" in one form or another - tolls, sin taxes, gas, sales - etc rise to make up the difference. 

Karras --- 10 years ago -

I think the best way to think of it is the entire economy is sitting on top of a black box of taxes. Money comes out of the box to the private sector to buy stuff, and money goes back in as taxes

so you are saying government is the driver of the economy? I think you need to go read an econ book or Adam Smith's Wealth of Nations. 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

so you are saying government is the driver of the economy? I think you need to go read an econ book or Adam Smith's Wealth of Nations.

no that is not the point I was making - quite the opposite actually. More like a small platform that the large economy operates on top of. 

CartmanUK34 --- 10 years ago -

You live in society, you contribute, taxes are not YOUR money, they are your contribution for getting to remain part of society as a whole. They MAY spend it at a local business but on the whole they don't because if they did trickle down would work and we see time and again that it does not.

It IS selfish and unreasonable to expect to live in a country and not have to contribute to the things that allow that country to work.

I AM that middle class family, and I accept without reservation that I must contribute to the country in which I live. That $125 would be a big deal to my family but I do not feel entitled to it to the detriment of society at large. 

wayward1 --- 10 years ago -

What's wrong with the current Bush tax level? Why do we need to change it? 

Karras --- 10 years ago -

You live in society, you contribute, taxes are not YOUR money

See, we had this problem with the UK over a couple hundred years ago, in fact, we kicked their arses because of it. I guess you still don't get it.

That $125 would be a big deal to my family but I do not feel entitled to it to the detriment of society at large.

You are telling me that everything the government spends money on is necessary? How 'bout the government eliminates all unnecessary programs, they show us respect as to how they spend our money then we can talk about that extra $125.

Until then it is selfish of people like you and the government to expect one extra penny from the American worker. 

Butterbean --- 10 years ago -

You live in society, you contribute, taxes are not YOUR money, they are your contribution for getting to remain part of society as a whole. They MAY spend it at a local business but on the whole they don't because if they did trickle down would work and we see time and again that it does not.

It IS selfish and unreasonable to expect to live in a country and not have to contribute to the things that allow that country to work.

I AM that middle class family, and I accept without reservation that I must contribute to the country in which I live. That $125 would be a big deal to my family but I do not feel entitled to it to the detriment of society at large.


Bears repeating. Yes. 

wayward1 --- 10 years ago -

We fought over taxation without representation. Not because of having taxes. 

Karras --- 10 years ago -

Bears repeating. Yes

Still trying to find Hillary's tax plan. She still hasn't told us who the middle class is.

We fought over taxation without representation. Not because of having taxes.

And we fought over the heavy burden the king was putting on us through taxation. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 10 years ago -

it is economically acceptable to you to trade your labor for you current after tax earnings.

Before tax earnings. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 10 years ago -

I think the best way to think of it is the entire economy is sitting on top of a black box of taxes.

What? Money (or thing of value) does not originate with the government. 

jackass --- 10 years ago -

 

Judas --- 10 years ago -

Clinton has really gotten under all the repugnant's skin especially Soupty. They are all afraid, very afraid. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 10 years ago -

Anything that lowers individual and corporate taxes is a good thing. 

Butterbean --- 10 years ago -

Anything that lowers individual and corporate taxes is a good thing.

Absolutely correct. Disband the military, eliminate the electric grid (and all utilities}, Dig up the interstate highways, and close all airports. That'll be a good start. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 10 years ago -

Absolutely correct. Disband the military, eliminate the electric grid (and all utilities}, Dig up the interstate highways, and close all airports. That'll be a good start.

How about getting rid of discretionary unfunded entitlements. How about getting rid of the back door welfare called EIC. How about getting rid of trillion dollar payments to rouge regimes that that us. How about getting rid of support for illegals. 

them --- 10 years ago -

Where do you people that want higher corporate taxes expecting the money used to pay the tax to come from? 

Butterbean --- 10 years ago -

Not nearly enough fat to eliminate there, Emp. Not nearly enough.

You're going to love the next 8 years. 

them --- 10 years ago -

That is so cute.

Honey, you don't know your candidate. 

CartmanUK34 --- 10 years ago -

See, we had this problem with the UK over a couple hundred years ago, in fact, we kicked their arses because of it. I guess you still don't get it.

LOL yeah, and given the fact that the country could be about to elect Donald Trump I don't think that is going so well. Trump had the campaign slogan partly right... it should really be "Make America Great Britain Again!"

You are telling me that everything the government spends money on is necessary? How 'bout the government eliminates all unnecessary programs, they show us respect as to how they spend our money then we can talk about that extra $125.

Until then it is selfish of people like you and the government to expect one extra penny from the American worker.


No I am not saying that at all, of course there are things that are unnecessary, but the problem is we will never all agree on what is necessary and what isn't, that is why there are elections to choose the people who best represent your views.

But to call the people are FOR helping those less fortunate the selfish ones is comical at best. 

Iwonder --- 10 years ago -

"It IS selfish and unreasonable to expect to live in a country and not have to contribute to the things that allow that country to work."

I RESENT EVERY SINGLE ONE OF THEM!

On average, those in the bottom 40% of the income spectrum end up getting money from the government. Meanwhile, the richest 20% of Americans, by far, pay the most in income taxes, forking over nearly 87% of all the income tax collected by Uncle Sam.

45% of Americans pay no federal income tax

0

0 

Butterbean --- 10 years ago -

I RESENT EVERY SINGLE ONE OF THEM!

Who or what is "them"? 

Giorgio Tsoukalos --- 10 years ago -

 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 10 years ago -

Who or what is "them"?

The 40% who pay nothing or get back more than they paid in. They have no skin in the game. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 10 years ago -

But to call the people are FOR helping those less fortunate the selfish ones is comical at best.

Help all you want, no one is stopping you. Why can't you voluntarily write a bigger check to the treasury? Why can't you invite illegals to live in your house?

Instead you want the government to do what you should be doing and you want the government to force helping by your definition of helping on me. 

Iwonder --- 10 years ago -

Those not helping pull our wagon.

The TAKERS

And no - not the children/retired/handicapped 

Butterbean --- 10 years ago -

You saying I'm not a taker? 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground