Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Is internet a utility that should be controlled and taxed by the government?

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 3
smartypants 1
* 1
ladybeachbum 1
SoupIsGoodFood 15
FANCY PANTS 1
voice of reason 2
AwesomeTattooedDragon 2
Dr Aborto 7
queenofclean 1
kwgraniteguy 2
Texan65 2
Emperor of Kingwood 6
Not KU 9
Butterbean 3
Franklin 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

whatchamacallit --- 12 years ago -

Obama Wants to Reclassify the Internet as a Utility
Posted on November 10, 2014 by Michael Minkoff
In a recent speech, President Obama laid out his plan for protecting the freedom of the internet. It involved reclassifying the internet as a utility.

Regulating internet service under Title II would mean reclassifying it as a utility, like water. This means that internet providers would just be pumping internet back and forth through pipes and not actually making any decisions about where the internet goes. For the most part, that?s controversial idea in the eyes of service providers alone. It means that they?re losing some control over what they sell, and that they can?t favor certain services to benefit their own business. Instead, providers would be stuck allowing consumers to use the internet as they want to, using whatever services they like without any penalty. If that sounds pretty great, it?s because that?s basically how the internet has worked up until now.

Yes. That is how it has worked up until now. And tell me, why would we need to reclassify the internet as a utility in order to protect a deregulated internet? Because certain companies want to restrict their own services? Sure. And why does that really matter again? If people care, they won?t buy internet service from such draconian service providers as Comcast and the like, right?

Well, it?s not that simple. Comcast has what some people might call a monopoly in large swaths of the US. And because of the infrastructure required to build an internet network, it?s difficult for other providers to break into the market in places where Comcast already dominates. And I?m sure you will be very surprised about this, but Comcast lobbies the civil government pretty heavily. And there is a revolving door between the FCC and Comcast. All of which makes it harder for the little guys to compete.

So then, the problem is actually civil government regulation and interference. So why should we believe reclassifying the internet as a utility is the answer? You can see the problem pretty clearly when you put Obama?s plan in other words: ?We should regulate the internet to keep it deregulated.? Yeah. I?m not buying it.

This is a classic case of the growing specter of the civil government?s ?Hero Syndrome.? In an effort to appear heroic, there is no end to the mischief our government will concoct. Trusting the civil government on this is like relying on an arsonist fireman to put out fires he started. The problem with the current internet situation is government corruption and regulation. Have no fear! The civil government is here to fix the problem they created?by getting even more involved. I?m sure that will do the trick.

Try this instead. Don?t protect Comcast or AT&T or any of the other big boys from competition. Do not reclassify the internet as a utility. Full disclosure: I don?t think public utilities need to be public either. I think, for instance, that roads could easily be locally funded and maintained by common agreement among the people who own the land around them. It would cost us less, and the roads would probably be better.

And the same goes for the internet. There is no reason why a local community could not create its own internet service. In fact, many local companies have invested in local infrastructure to provide better, more reliable, faster internet than Comcast or the other bottom liners. If the public would just refuse to buy service from people who don?t give good service, we wouldn?t need all the regulations. Believe me.

But if you think current utilities should continue to be public, why would you deny that the internet functions similarly to transportation, electricity, and water utilities? On what basis do you reject reclassifying the internet as a utility? Is it just because Obama recommends it? I don?t think that?s a good enough reason to reject proposed legislation. But perhaps I?m just too open-minded. 

whatchamacallit --- 12 years ago -

Obama to be given the right to shut down the internet with 'kill switch'
By PAUL THOMPSON FOR MAILONLINE
UPDATED: 03:41 EST, 25 June 2010

Barack Obama will be given a 'kill switch' in times of national emergency
President Obama will be given the power to shut down the Internet with a 'kill switch' in a new law being proposed in the US.
He would be able to order popular search engines such a Google and Yahoo to suspend access to their websites in times of national emergency.
Other US based Internet service providers as well as broadband providers would also come under his control in times of a 'cybersecurity emergency.' Any company that failed to comply would be subject to huge fines.
Critics of the new law, which has been proposed by former presidential candidate Joe Liebermann, said it would be an abuse of power to let the White House control the internet.
TechAmerica, one of the largest U.S. technology lobby groups, said the new law had the 'potential for absolute power.'.
The proposed legislation, introduced into the US Senate by Lieberman who is chairman of the US Homeland Security committee, seeks to grant the President broad emergency powers over the internet in times of national emergency.
A sustained terror attack on multiple cities would be considered a national emergency as would a cyber attack by 'hackers' on the US financial system.
The director of National Intelligence Dennis Blair warned earlier this year that the US is 'severely threatened' by malicious cyber attacks.
The number of attacks on Government departments has increased by 400 per cent in the last three years.
Under the proposed bill, which has been dubbed an Internet 'kill switch', the US Government would effectively seize control of access to the internet.
Lieberman argued the bill was necessary to 'preserve those networks and assets and our country and protect our people'.
He said: 'For all of its 'user-friendly' allure, the Internet can also be a dangerous place with electronic pipelines that run directly into everything from our personal bank accounts to key infrastructure to government and industrial secrets.
Traders work on the New York Stock Exchange floor.
Traders work on the New York Stock Exchange floor. US senators fear a cyber-attack on the US could paralyse the nation
'Our economic security, national security and public safety are now all at risk from new kinds of enemies--cyber-warriors, cyber-spies, cyber-terrorists and cyber-criminals.'
His bill is formally titled the Protecting Cyberspace as a National Asset Act, or PCNAA.
While the US Government would not be able to control the internet in other countries access to the most popular sites would be cut off.
Google,Yahoo and YouTube, the top three most visited sites, are all based in the US.
Google logs an estimated two billion hits a day from 300 million users.
Under the cyber law any company on a list created by Homeland Security that also 'relies on' the Internet, the telephone system, or any other component of the U.S. 'information infrastructure' would be subject to command by a new National Centre for Cybersecurity and Communications (NCCC) that would be created inside Homeland Security.
Google, the world's most popular search engine, refused to comment. A spokesman said the law was not yet Government policy.
-------------------

Did this ever pass? 

whatchamacallit --- 12 years ago -

Obama Quietly Gives Himself Power to Seize Internet
Wednesday, 11 Jul 2012 08:29 PM
By Todd Beamon

Another late-Friday afternoon release from the White House ? this one on how agencies should communicate with the public in emergencies ? has Internet privacy advocates crying foul over a possible power grab.

The executive order ? ?Assignment of National Security and Emergency Preparedness Communications Functions? ? was released last Friday in the late afternoon. The Friday before, the White House issued data showing that its payroll had increased 14.1 percent over the last year of the Bush administration.

President Barack Obama?s new order outlines procedures for government agencies to follow in preparing plans so they can communicate with ?the public, allies, and other nations? should a national crisis occur, CNBC reports.

Essentially, it says the government can take control of private telecommunications technology, presumably including those used for the Internet, for government communications in an emergency.

?Under the Executive Order the White House has ? granted the Department [of Homeland Security] the authority to seize private facilities when necessary, effectively shutting down or limiting civilian communications,? wrote the Electronic Privacy Information Center in a blog post.

This is what has Internet privacy advocates worried. They say the document represents a power grab on behalf of the federal government, CNBC reports.

They?re particularly concerned about language like this, from section 5.2(e): ?The Secretary of Homeland Security shall ? satisfy priority communications requirements through the use of commercial, Government, and privately owned communications resources, when appropriate.?

But White House officials told CNBC that the order does nothing more than update existing authority dating from a 1984 executive order signed by Ronald Reagan to reflect modern communications technology.

No new expansions of authority come in the order, they said, and the measure just directs agencies to develop plans for the government should they need to communicate with the public during a natural emergency like a nuclear attack or terrorist strike.

?The Internet is an international network of networks; no one person, organization or country can control or shut down the Internet,? a government official wrote in an email to CNBC.

?The United States relies on the Internet to perform essential functions including to operate critical infrastructure and to maintain essential national security capabilities. That is why the President has designated our digital infrastructure as a strategic national asset.

?This Order is about communications resilience ? the Administration?s goal is to maintain this connected environment during the worst disasters, even in circumstances when our adversaries may wish to deprive us of their use,? the email said.

But that did not satisfy everyone. The Daily Caller that the federal government already has its own emergency communications network, the National Communications System, which allows members of the federal government to make use of private carriers during the event of a disaster.

And the blog ExtremeTech asked, "If there?s a possible terrorist threat, is that grounds for locking down the US cellular carriers? If Iran attacks the US with a Stuxnet-like virus, is that grounds for the disabling of core internet routers?" 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

No, and hell no- kiss goodby any site that doesn't have a store here- no more absence of taxes- 

Dr Aborto --- 12 years ago -

And tell me, why would we need to reclassify the internet as a utility in order to protect a deregulated internet? Because certain companies want to restrict their own services? Sure.

You answered your own question. Obama is for net neutrality. Some big internet companies don't want that. They want their services to stream faster than others. 

ladybeachbum --- 12 years ago -

Obama needs to stay with what he knows which is nothing. Two more years can't go fast enough. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

Another government money and power grab. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

To squander on something stupid- 

Not KU --- 12 years ago -

Im pretty sure Internet providers dont care if everyone wants to be on the internet or if we have equal access. But I cant help but think companies that sell things on line wouldn't appreciate slow internet speeds slowing down sales. But worse, Gov keeping tabs on citizens might be difficult if less folks were communicating on line due to slow speeds. IDK just a thought 

Dr Aborto --- 12 years ago -

Best way to know if this will be good for the consumer is to see who backs the President's plan. See what websites like Google, Facebook, Wikipedia, Yahoo, etc have to say. Not the actual internet providers. So far, the Oatmeal is not for what Ted Cruz is saying.

Check out the link it has a good explanation on what the Net Neutrality fight is about. The Oatmeal Link 

FANCY PANTS --- 12 years ago -

They want their services to stream faster than others.?

If they have the ability then, why not? If they spent the money, have the man power, then why not? The government has no business controlling the internet or being able to turn it off. That's too much government. They should not be able to shut down our means of communication. That's too much control. 

* --- 12 years ago -

That SOB needs to GO! 

Not KU --- 12 years ago -

That's too much control.
* --- 2 min ago - quote - hide comments

That SOB needs to GO!



pffft 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

They want their services to stream faster than others.

...... and this matters why? 

Dr Aborto --- 12 years ago -

0 

Dr Aborto --- 12 years ago -

0 

queenofclean --- 12 years ago -

Because the government does such a great job......never a problem with the way social security, Medicare, IRS and other GREAT government run agencies......NOT! They simply want a way to get a new tax out of us.....all we are is a never ending bank for them to withdraw funds to WASTE! 

Butterbean --- 12 years ago -

No gubmmint interference in the internet.

What if there really wasn't.

Shut down every government server that directs internet traffic. Shut down every wireless internet service in the USA. Shutdown and vigorously defend every governmental patent on every device and/or method of transmitting internet traffic. Shutdown every police, fire, and utility internet service anywhere that uses government servers or technology. Shutdown any telephony operations that use the internet. Shutdown every commercial television, radio,or telegraph service in the USA.

Shut them all down. Damn gubmint, they just want to tax us some more. 

Dr Aborto --- 12 years ago -

Because the government does such a great job......never a problem with the way social security, Medicare, IRS and other GREAT government run agencies......NOT!

FCC is ready to drop down some internet rules. Some internet providers want to have privileges for using their service. Obama is urging the FCC to keep the internet neutral and not favor one company over another. It's not a new government agency or tax. 

Franklin --- 12 years ago -

Dr Aborto is the only poster here who actually understands this issue.

Predictably, everyone else is too busy just assuming that, since it comes from Obama, it must be BAD!!!!!11

Think, people. THINK. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

What makes you think the govt won't do the same thing?

What if they start censoring websites that aren't "friendly" to the administration?

Having the govt getting involved with monitoring the internet is BAD. 

voice of reason --- 12 years ago -

let's face it, if the pubies came up with the idea they'd be gung ho. the whole world knows that regarless of the benefit of whatever it may be, if it comes from the dems the pubies just say NO. NFW.

i hope they choke on their own obstruction. 

Franklin --- 12 years ago -

Net neutrality has nothing to do with "monitoring the internet" the way you're talking about it. (Hello....they already do that...) Essentially net neutrality is about all bits getting equal treatment. The zeros and ones flowing from Netflix, from from Twitter, from Ted Cruz's website- no ISP (Comcast, AT&T) should be allowed to give preferential treatment to some bits over others. It should completely be up to web users what sites they want to use.

For example, AT&T has (and maybe still is?) instituted a monthly cap on internet usage- Netflix counts against that cap, but their own video service doesn't. That way watching tons of movies in HD on Netflix chips away at your cap, but unlimited use of their service doesn't. This is a way for an ISP to leverage their position as service provider to reduce customer choice, to avoid competing with another video service. It anti-capitalist. It's un-American. Net neutrality forbids this. No matter what those 1s and 0s are, they all travel without discrimination- but still within whatever bandwidth tier you are paying for. This is not about regulating speeds of individual customers. This is about preventing monopolistic ISPs from leveraging their position to gouge you.

Imagine the highways are public, but the smaller roads that lead from the highway to your home are private, owned by a monopoly, and you have no choice for another road system. That TV you ordered from Amazon hasn't arrived. Comcast, the owner of the roads to your home, says: "Oh, you want that TV? We don't permit UPS on our roads. You have to use our delivery service BendOverAndTakeIt. It will cost you... a little extra." [maniacal laughing]

Net neutrality says that the monopolistic owners of the roads to our homes don't get to say who drives to our house, or where we drive to. We pay them to get to use the road, and they have to maintain the quality of the roads. Period. 

Dr Aborto --- 12 years ago -

What makes you think the govt won't do the same thing?

What if they start censoring websites that aren't "friendly" to the administration?


That can happen with anything and not just government controlled but privately controlled. 

Butterbean --- 12 years ago -

Having the govt getting involved with monitoring the internet is BAD.

Is there anyone on earth, other than Soup,that thinks that the "govt" is not involved with monitoring the internet? 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

Is there anyone on earth, other than Soup,that thinks that the "govt" is not involved with monitoring the internet?

I know they monitor. Just not monitoring to control what content gets seen or not. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

That can happen with anything and not just government controlled but privately controlled.

I guess it all comes down to whom you trust more to control. Private industry or the government? 

Dr Aborto --- 12 years ago -

Private industry or the government??

Government and publicly traded companies at least have accountability, checks and balances. You can see what they are up to. I still tend to go with the one that has the least amount of financial incentive. 

voice of reason --- 12 years ago -

0 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

I still tend to go with the one that has the least amount of financial incentive.

But they are the ones who actually have something to lose.

Govt has nothing to lose. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

Don't get me wrong here. I'm all for stopping these cable companies from blocking or throttling. I'm just not too keen on having the govt step in to control them. The govt usually makes the problem worse. 

Franklin --- 12 years ago -

I am a registered Republican. I am NOT an Obama supporter. Far from it.

But that doesn't mean I'm going to automatically go against every idea he presents just because it was him that presented it, ala Ted Cruz.

What's right is right. And this is the right thing to do. And one of the rare times I actually agree with Obama. 

Not KU --- 12 years ago -

Franklin --- 1 hours ago - quote - hide comments

Dr Aborto is the only poster here who actually understands this issue.


Lets make him our leader...lol.kidding :D 

Not KU --- 12 years ago -

Franklin --- 1 min ago - quote - hide comments

I am a registered Republican. I am NOT an Obama supporter. Far from it.

But that doesn't mean I'm going to automatically go against every idea he presents


No offense Franklin. But who cares? By that I mean. You dont vote on legislation and your congressman (if you live in KW) Ted Poe does not ask his constituents their opinion on issues. And should you be a constituent that engages our good congressman. Its not likely he would base a decision on your opinion. So when you vote GOP and a congressman such as Ted Poe. In short. You are automatically against any and all ideas presented by the President. At least until such time the GOP goes along w/this president. And what do you figure the odds are on that? 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

Ted Poe does not ask his constituents their opinion on issues

Sure he does. Maybe you were asleep.

https://www.facebook.com/events/524318281048376/ 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

So when you vote GOP and a congressman such as Ted Poe. In short. You are automatically against any and all ideas presented by the President

Your ignorance knows no bounds, Mark. 

Not KU --- 12 years ago -

Your ignorance knows no bounds Soupypants.

Town hall meetings are NOT for discussion. Its more of an FYI as to his direction in congress. Regardless of your likes or dislikes. I have sat thru several phone town halls with the hope I could speak to him.
Posta-pleeze you are a L.S.M. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

Town hall meetings are NOT for discussion.

You've obviously never been to a town hall meeting. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

At least until such time the GOP goes along w/this president. And what do you figure the odds are on that?

So Mark, when does this POTUS reach across the aisle and engage in a meaningful way with the GOP? 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

i hope they choke on their own obstruction.

Like Harry Reid choked on his obstructionist tactics? 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground