Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Nye Debates Ham (young-earth creationism)

who's talking here?

The Awe Inspiring JoelleDrees 2
RiteWingKing 6
zapper007 1
Warren Peace 1
jtcitrus 8
AwesomeTattooedDragon 3
JohnLynch 31
james osterberg 1
Dr Aborto 2
In AbsentiaW 3
Clovis 2
SagaciousSighFiGurl 1
KingOfSomewhereHot 5
JAMS 3
Not KU 1
Lord Cheezus DeSufferbus 8
Jepperd 1
AMDG 7

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

jtcitrus --- 12 years ago -

link title 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

bill nye is going to get trounced... 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

I'll watch it tomorrow-thanks for the post- 

jtcitrus --- 12 years ago -

pretty interesting.

I'll give Hamm credit for doing his best (not sure he was the best representative for YEC in this format?).

The win goes to Nye on this one. not because he was the better debater, but because at the core he has better assumptions (to me).

Natural laws may be presumed to be constant through time.

vs.

natural laws are changeable (radically so) because that's the only way (ham's) literal reading of genesis can be rationalized. 

jtcitrus --- 12 years ago -

your axioms will likely per-determine whomever you think won the debate. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

The win goes to Nye on this one. not because he was the better debater, but because at the core he has better assumptions

LOL...you proved ken ham's point with your statement...nye's ASSUMPTIONS 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

nye lost because he kept saying that a person couldn't accomplish anything unless they believed in evolution as nye does...even though it has been PROVEN that creation believing scientists have made very significant scientific discoveries 

Clovis --- 12 years ago -

0 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

very telling when even fred flintstone knows more than you do... 

Not KU --- 12 years ago -

JohnLynch --- 9 hours ago - quote - hide comments

bill nye is going to get trounced...


LOL JL. Your a shining star on this thread. I knew this would be good but unfortunately I missed the debate. 

JAMS --- 12 years ago -

Experts gave the win to Nye.

Intelligent people gave the win to Nye.

Anyone who has ever opened a book other than the bible gave the win to Nye.

JL gave the win to a dinosaur riding Jesus believer.

LOL 

Lord Cheezus DeSufferbus --- 12 years ago -

That wasn't a debate between evolution and creationism, it was just another chance for a fundamentalist to tell everyone that he's right while he worships at the idol of his own certainty. I'm so glad they're a dying breed. Bill Nye shouldn't have acknowledged Ham as having any sort of legitimate claim to debate in the intellectual arena. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

sorry jams...but that isn't true

wise people KNOW that Ham spoke the truth

Nye told several lies...and repeated those lies several times 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

That wasn't a debate between evolution and creationism, it was just another chance for a fundamentalist to tell everyone that he's right while he worships at the idol of his own certainty.

it's apparent that you didn't watch the debate 

JAMS --- 12 years ago -

Sorry JL, as usual, you are misguided and misinformed.

I agree with the notion that Nye shouldn't have given Ham any platform in the intellectual arena.

But he did, and Nye (despite often rambling and bumbling his thoughts and words) scolded Mr. Creationism.

It's OK JL...just put the lotion on the skin. It'll be OK ;) 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

But he did, and Nye (despite often rambling and bumbling his thoughts and words) scolded Mr. Creationism.

LOL...that's a joke...the person speaking about real science as Ham

even a believer in evolution wrote this in the NY Times...

"Last night, it was easy to pick out the smarter man on the stage. Oddly, it was the same man who was arguing that the earth is 6,000 years old." 

Lord Cheezus DeSufferbus --- 12 years ago -

it's apparent that you didn't watch the debate?

It's apparent that you're the same kind of idolater as Ham. You've both replaced reasoning with regurgitation of Bible verses. 

Lord Cheezus DeSufferbus --- 12 years ago -

Nye told several lies...and repeated those lies several times?

Of course you have no real evidence to back up that claim, other than, "The Bible says so." 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

They were very nice to each other! A lot of, "with all do respect" was said and I have to give the win to both sides for respect and courtesy. And since
this debate will never end or either side be actually proven without doubts, the true winner is human beings being respectful and decent to each other.

We need that worse than we need to prove our points. Why? Because ThAT will actually improve quality of life on this planet. 

Warren Peace --- 12 years ago -

Here's an interesting article that preceded the debate: link title

Quotes:
The fundamentalist mindset of Young Earth Creationism doesn?t simply lead to a rejecting of science, but also leads to a rejection of sound Biblical scholarship, meaning they are doubly bad for the rest of us in the group. In short, the Young Earth Creationists add up the ages in Hebrew genealogies in the Old Testament and from that arrive at the assertion that God created the world on Sunday, October 23, 4004 BC. This becomes their starting point and all science is filtered through this (general) date/time-frame (they don?t all agree on an exact date, but arrive in the same general area)? nothing is allowed to contradict the fact that the earth and humanity were basically created yesterday.
Obviously, this is bad science (well, it?s not even science at all). But, it?s also crappy scholarship. What James Ussher failed to realize (he?s the guy who added these ages up in order to arrive at a date of creation- a work from the 17th century), was that Old Testament genealogies were never intended to be comprehensive genealogies that included all descendants of a family line. In the type of genealogy used in the Old Testament, it is completely permissible to use the term ?beget? (Hebrew, yalad ילד) to refer to a descendant many generations later.


In short, and to be perfectly blunt, trying to date the earth by adding up the ages and names of some people in the Bible is actually stupid. It doesn?t pass basic science, nor does it pass basic biblical scholarship.
Unfortunately, Ken Ham is neither a scientist or a credible bible scholar, so I actively oppose him and side with the science guy who I believe, will more accurately represent how God created the heavens and earth.
Why?
Because Ken Ham and the Answers in Genesis people are making you and I look like idiots and therefore are harming the cause of Christ. Try viewing this through the eyes of an outsider: were someone to ask ?what is a creationist like?? and you were to show that person Ken Ham, that person would understandably assume that creationists are people who reject 4th grade science and who shouldn?t be taken seriously on anything they claim. Sacrificing such credibility, means that we are at a horrible disadvantage to ever point people to the truth that there (a) is a God that (b) God made everything you see in creation, let alone ever arrive at the most important (c) that this God actually loves you and has redeemed you.
 

In AbsentiaW --- 12 years ago -

very telling when even fred flintstone knows more than you do...


You really dignified this thread with that sarcastic and unneccessay crack, John. Just coudn't miss the chance could you? 

KingOfSomewhereHot --- 12 years ago -

JohnLynch ---

LOL...you proved ken ham's point with your statement...nye's ASSUMPTIONS



JL, aren't you ASSUMING that the Bible is the sacred word of God? ... Do you have any evidence of that, other than the Bible itself?

Assumptions aren't a bad thing ... we cannot live without making them. Assumptions are accepted to be true when they are backed by evidence and (as Bill pointed out) able to make accurate predictions. 

Jepperd --- 12 years ago -

For those who didnt watch....it pretty much boiled down to this...

Bill Nye: "The earth can't possibly be only 6000 years old, look at all this evidence"

Ken Ham: "You weren't there, how do you know? Look what the bible says"

This debate should of never happened. The two sides are so radically at opposite sides that they would never agree" 

KingOfSomewhereHot --- 12 years ago -

Debate isn't about "coming to agreement".
(...that would be an argument... and they rarely work.) 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

You've both replaced reasoning with regurgitation of Bible verses.

Ham rarely "regurgitated" Bile verses...more proof that you didn't watch the debate...therefore your comments have absolutely no merit

Of course you have no real evidence to back up that claim, other than, "The Bible says so."

Nye's lies were about what he says Ham didn't do...so you are WRONG again 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

Here's an interesting article that preceded the debate

waren...that article from a progressive (liberal) who wants to call himself a Christian has absolutely no merit

he stated that "Old Testament genealogies were never intended to be comprehensive genealogies that included all descendants of a family line."...this statement has no merit because the comprehensive genealogies of ALL descendants of Adam are NOT needed to have the necessary data to come up with a proper timeline...there is no gap in the genealogies

fyi...in addition to the genealogies...established dates in history were also used to compute the age of the earth 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

You really dignified this thread with that sarcastic and unneccessay crack, John.

i was responding to a sarcastic, false and unnecessary cartoon posted by one of your ilk...funny how you didn't make a comment to HIM...shows your bias...and therefore your comment has no merit 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

JL, aren't you ASSUMING that the Bible is the sacred word of God? ... Do you have any evidence of that, other than the Bible itself?

nope...i'm not...as Ham stated in the debate...if you seek God...He will reveal Himself to you...He has done that

Assumptions aren't a bad thing ... we cannot live without making them. Assumptions are accepted to be true when they are backed by evidence and (as Bill pointed out) able to make accurate predictions.

when it comes to science...the study of what we can observe...assumptions are a bad thing

none of Nye's assumptions were backed up with evidence 

jtcitrus --- 12 years ago -

LOL...you proved ken ham's point with your statement...nye's ASSUMPTIONS


keep reading JL, if you read the rest of my statement you see that Hamm misses his own point:

Without any evidence, Hamm assumes that the his group's literal interpretation of Gensis MUST be true. Therefore, any evidence or principle that cannot be reconciled with it must be rejected. The only way to reject the ever mounting physical evidence that the Gensis didn't happen the way he thinks it did is to reject the universality of natural law.

Nye doesn't reject this principle: that the natural world obeys laws, and those laws are constant over time. (it's up to us to discover those laws)

this basic axiomatic difference renders the debate moot. As I said above: your axioms will determine whomever you think won. -not the actual "debate".




As to Nye's statements that you can't be a YEC and be a good scientist, stems from the fact that, outside of current mechanistic applications, to BE a YEC requires that you divorce yourself from an ever-increasing body of sound empirical science. at some point, the YEC renders/will render themselves useless for ALL but mechanical applications of science.



JL,
YOU seem to believe in a similar literal reading of the bible/gensis to what Hamm expressed (at least, the major points). And that's fine. Revel in the strength of your faith in a world where the whims of an omnipotent God and the laws of physics flux wildly.

But people shouldn't confuse an expression of "Faith", which can have great personal and social value, with an objective, reasoned critique of empirical science and it's implications.


again, I think Nye won, not be cause he was a better debater, but because I find his essential assumptions plausible, while I find Hamm's assumptions to be implausible. 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

IMHO - the big winners last night were Bill Nye and Ken Hamm - who are both selling a "brand". The "debate" was a great free infomercial for them.

Mr. Hamm and his non-profits need a shot in the arm - They have gone from a $2.1M surplus a few years ago, to a $500k deficit.

Not sure of Mr. Nyes finances - but imagine this type of exposure is good.

The established scientific community (best way I could describe it - I don't want to have a semantic fight over it) - is never in favor of this type of debate. (no - they are not afraid of the creationist argument) - they believe in the process. And the process is to publish in some reputable journal, and subject yourself to peer review.

You can believe the process is jaded, prejudiced, or blatantly wrong. It is, however the process - and there is significant empirical evidence that it has worked pretty well so far. 

Lord Cheezus DeSufferbus --- 12 years ago -

From On The Literal Meaning Of Genesis by St. Augustine of Hippo, someone with much more credibility as a Christian than either Lynch or Ham:

"Usually, even a non-Christian knows something about the earth, the heavens, and the other elements of this world, about the motion and orbit of the stars and even their size and relative positions, about the predictable eclipses of the sun and moon, the cycles of the years and the seasons, about the kinds of animals, shrubs, stones, and so forth, and this knowledge he holds to as being certain from reason and experience. Now, it is a disgraceful and dangerous thing for an infidel to hear a Christian, presumably giving the meaning of Holy Scripture, talking non-sense on these topics; and we should take all means to prevent such an embarrassing situation, in which people show up vast ignorance in a Christian and laugh it to scorn.

The shame is not so much that an ignorant individual is derided, but that people outside the household of the faith think our sacred writers held such opinions, and, to the great loss of those for whose salvation we toil, the writers of our Scripture are criticized and rejected as unlearned men. If they find a Christian mistaken in a field which they themselves know well and hear him maintaining his foolish opinions about our books, how are they going to believe those books in matters concerning the resurrection of the dead, the hope of eternal life, and the kingdom of heaven, when they think their pages are full of falsehoods on facts which they themselves have learnt from experience and the light of reason?

Reckless and incompetent expounders of holy Scripture bring untold trouble and sorrow on their wiser brethren when they are caught in one of their mischievous false opinions and are taken to task by those who are not bound by the authority of our sacred books. For then, to defend their utterly foolish and obviously untrue statements, they will try to call upon Holy Scripture for proof and even recite from memory many passages which they think support their position, although ?they understand neither what they say nor the things about which they make assertion." 

zapper007 --- 12 years ago -

with regurgitation of Bible verses...
with regurgitation of Bible verses...
with regurgitation of Bible verses...
with regurgitation of Bible verses...
with regurgitation of Bible verses...
with regurgitation of Bible verses...
with regurgitation of Bible verses...
with regurgitation of Bible verses...
with regurgitation of Bible verses...
with regurgitation of Bible verses...
with regurgitation of Bible verses...
with regurgitation of Bible verses...
with regurgitation of Bible verses...
with regurgitation of Bible verses...
with regurgitation of Bible verses...
with regurgitation of Bible verses...
with regurgitation of Bible verses...
with regurgitation of Bible verses...
with regurgitation of Bible verses...
with regurgitation of Bible verses...
with regurgitation of Bible verses...
with regurgitation of Bible verses...
with regurgitation of Bible verses...
with regurgitation of Bible verses...
with regurgitation of Bible verses...
with regurgitation of Bible verses...
with regurgitation of Bible verses...
with regurgitation of Bible verses...
with regurgitation of Bible verses...
with regurgitation of Bible verses...


ad naseum


Thanks JL for the original thjoughts...lol 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

Thankfull,, there is no need to suspend you rationality, and disbelieve in the physical world to try and know Christ, to love Christ, and to follow Christ. Many, maybe most, understand that the Bible is inherent in its message and purpose. And its? purpose is moral, not scientific or historic.

For those on the fence, you should not think that you must have a dogmatic view of a literal bible to have the only "real" vision of God. So, if that doesn't make "sense" then why bother. If you do, you are looking in the wrong place anyway. You should be looking for God in your heart, and in your feelings. 

KingOfSomewhereHot --- 12 years ago -

JohnLynch ---
when it comes to science...the study of what we can observe...assumptions are a bad thing...?


It ALL starts with assumptions ... or what would more properly be called a "hypothesis" ... when that hypothesis is then backed up with evidence and experimentation, and analyzed for errors by both proponents and opposition (AKA "Peer Review"), and only then determined to be the best explanation for the original hypothesis, it is accepted as theory.



JohnLynch ---

...none of Nye's assumptions were backed up with evidence?



Now who wasn't watching the debate? 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

Without any evidence, Hamm assumes that the his group's literal interpretation of Gensis

nope jt...he doesn't

As to Nye's statements that you can't be a YEC and be a good scientist, stems from the fact that, outside of current mechanistic applications, to BE a YEC requires that you divorce yourself from an ever-increasing body of . at some point, the YEC renders/will render themselves useless for ALL but mechanical applications of science.

that is absolutely FALSE...the creationist doesn't deny any sound empirical science...evolution doesn't fit into that category...assumptions aren't sound empirical science 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

From On The Literal Meaning Of Genesis by St. Augustine of Hippo, someone with much more credibility as a Christian than either Lynch or Ham:

this is coming from a person who distorted the tenets of Christianity...he has little credibility outside the catholic religion

btw...someone please help zapper...he's losing it... 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

Thankfull,, there is no need to suspend you rationality, and disbelieve in the physical world to try and know Christ, to love Christ, and to follow Christ.

creationists don't suspend rational thought...and i hope you meant science when you said "disbelieve in the physical world" because "belief" in the physical world is what a follower of satan does...when they believe the literal Genesis account

For those on the fence, you should not think that you must have a dogmatic view of a literal bible to have the only "real" vision of God. So, if that doesn't make "sense" then why bother.

that is false teaching...it is absolutely necessary to be dogmatic about the Bible being literal

You should be looking for God in your heart, and in your feelings.

absolute false teaching...the Scriptures are what brings a person to Christ/God...and the Bible specifically teaches us to NOT live by our feelings


And it's purpose is moral, not scientific or historic.

nope...the purpose of the Bible isn't moral

however...in matters of any included morality, science and history...it is absolutely correct 

Lord Cheezus DeSufferbus --- 12 years ago -

this is coming from a person who distorted the tenets of Christianity...he has little credibility outside the catholic religion

You need to get a better grip on reality. Your incredible ignorance is glaring.

And Augustine will always have more credibility as a Christian that you ever will. 

Lord Cheezus DeSufferbus --- 12 years ago -

that is false teaching...it is absolutely necessary to be dogmatic about the Bible being literal


Says who? Bigots and pedophile lovers like you0 and Ham?0 

The Awe Inspiring JoelleDrees (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

Without reading the rest of the thread, this is my opinion. Which is all anyone can ever have on this subject, really, an opinion, regardless of fact or reason...

I am a firm believer of evolution. I think we have evolved and adapted to become the humans we are today, and we continue to evolve and adapt to become the humans we will be tomorrow.

But as far as our creation, I am simply at a loss. Descartes, in his meditations, asked if he created himself. How did I come to be, he asked. Did I create myself? No, my parents created me. Well then, who created my parents? Their parents, and so on and so forth. But who was there at the beginning? Who created life itself? Who created the universe? Something just doesn't appear out of nowhere. Something must have set the ball rolling. That "something" is referred to as the Unmovable Mover.

I think this Unmovable Mover, or God, as we call Him is so unfathomable, so complex, that our puny brains can't even begin to comprehend it's magnificence. If we got even the slightest inkling of what actually happened, we would implode.

I think that once it got to a point where scientific fact could start backing up claims, dating and time measurement is pretty accurate. I also think Genesis was written to explain what, at the time, they couldn't comprehend. There is still so much to learn, and discover. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground