Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

*School: Breathalyzer Or No Graduation

who's talking here?

hummer 2
Red Heifer 1
ExLady In Blue 1
rEVOLution 13
Laurabeth 13
Dr Aborto 1
sweetscreaminmonkey 1
Work in Progress 4
LiveFreeOrDie 2
itstxdaddy 6
txsassy 2
Infidel II 10
Joker 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

rEVOLution --- 14 years ago -

ST. CHARLES, Minn. (WCCO) – Some parents are considering suing their kids’ school for what they consider a violation of their rights.

Seniors at St. Charles High School had to take a breathalyzer test at their graduation rehearsal on Friday.

Parent Jim Welp says he was shocked when his son Alec called Friday morning to tell him he’d be given a breathalyzer test at school.

Alec tested negative. He told his Dad all 73 of his classmates were also tested.

“When he said that right away I knew, they can’t do that,” said Welp.

Welp immediately drove to the school to question administrators about their authority to administer breathalyzers.

“They said they did, I said you don’t, I said you have to have probable cause,” he said.

Faculty told Welp and other parents they had smelled alcohol on some of the students.

“I said you can’t test them all because some of the students have alcohol,” he said.

Superintendent Mark Roubinek says teachers told the principal they observed unusual behavior by a group of 20 or more students.

He says administration feared several of those students would be driving after rehearsal was over.

“It was a bad situation, it would’ve been a terrible situation if some kids would’ve gotten hurt or killed,” said Roubinek.

School policy says when kids appear intoxicated at school, police are called.

“In our discussions and working with them, we moved on to the next stage,” said Roubinek.

That stage was testing the entire class.

Although the school declined to tell exactly how many tested positive, they do say it’s a number in the double digits.

Several of the parents of the seniors are planning on attending the school board’s meeting on June 11 to voice their concerns.

The graduation ceremony was Sunday. Everyone walked, including students who tested positive.

The superintendent did say those students did face consequences.



Link to video 

itstxdaddy --- 14 years ago -

great job by the school!!!! 

Infidel II --- 14 years ago -

Unfortunately, since the schools are run by the state, minors often give up some of their civil liberties while at school.

I think they should have tested those who gave them suspicion of being drunk (probable cause) but not everyone. It's a sad lesson we are teaching our youth, i.e. you live in a police state and have no rights of privacy and must succumb to the whims of those with authority, no matter whether it is reasonable. It is good training, if we want to have a society of lemmings, ready to fall off the cliff, one after another. 

Laurabeth --- 14 years ago -

Gotta say.......I agree with the school. Kids should not be drinking alcohol........period.

I wouldn't have a problem with my child being tested while on school property for a school sponsored event. 

txsassy --- 14 years ago -

PC run amok. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

I'd be pretty ticked, actually. If my kid isn't acting suspiciously, don't treat him like a criminal!

And if my kid DOES drink, and I find out about it, I'll be a lot harder on him than the state would be. I want the chance to handle it. 

Infidel II --- 14 years ago -

If my kid isn't acting suspiciously, don't treat him like a criminal!

Agreed. The biggest problem with treating non-criminals like criminals is that they start acting like criminals. They feel like if no one is going to treat them with respect, they might as well start acting like the criminal they're being made out to be. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

lol, when my sis was in high school, she came home drunk after homecoming. My mom didn't say anything to her that night. But at 5 a.m., she woke her up with a airhorn, made her eat a huge breakfast (which she promptly lost), then made her clean the whole house top to bottom.

Afterwards, she had the big lecture on the dangers of underage drinking, followed by the threats of what would happen if mom caught her again! Then she was grounded. When her friends called, my mother answered, "I'm sorry but _________ made some bad choices at homecoming. She won't be seeing her friends for a while."

It was highly effective :) I would totally do that. 

ExLady In Blue --- 14 years ago -

Work in Progress --- 7 min ago - quote - hide comments

lol, when my sis was in high school, she came home drunk after homecoming. My mom didn't say anything to her that night. But at 5 a.m., she woke her up with a airhorn, made her eat a huge breakfast (which she promptly lost), then made her clean the whole house top to bottom.

Afterwards, she had the big lecture on the dangers of underage drinking, followed by the threats of what would happen if mom caught her again! Then she was grounded. When her friends called, my mother answered, "I'm sorry but _________ made some bad choices at homecoming. She won't be seeing her friends for a while."

It was highly effective :) I would totally do that.


Ooooooo, your mom was wicked, but I like that! Good job, Mom of WIP! 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

My mom is 4'11, and she scares the hades out of me! Little women are mean!!!!!

We did NOT cross her. 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -

Just getting them ready for the nanny state. 

Red Heifer --- 14 years ago -

So underage kids should be able to come to school events under the influence?

Schools have the right to open any and all lockers, no questions asked. How is this different when it comes down to it? 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

Because the school owns the lockers, they don't own the kids. 

itstxdaddy --- 14 years ago -

So underage kids should be able to come to school events under the influence?

of course. and by all means, give them a ribbon to help their self esteem as well.

sheesh people, they had to take a breathalyzer not get strip searched.

Because the school owns the lockers, they don't own the kids.

i would be willing to bet that there was some kind of info sent out that informed the parents that this could and would happen as a prerequisite of attending graduation...don't you? 

rEVOLution --- 14 years ago -

Those of you who favor these activities do you also favor this...

0

this...

0

this...

0

this...

0

this...

0

and this...

0

In my opinion there is little difference between treating these children like criminals to "Protect" them than what the school did in lining the teens up and treating them all like drunken suspects.

It offends me that after all of the nanny and police state actions that are being taken against the people of our FREE REPUBLIC that anyone still thinks that these things are being done to "Protect" or help anyone. The same people that supported the TSA groping teens at a prom in Arizona last year. Or the fact that some schools are now offering vaccines to children as young as nine without parental consent. These things are not being done to protect us, the ENTIRE war on TERROR is a farce that they created and are using to condition us all for the tyranny that is about to escalate in this country when the bottom falls out on the economy.

Please understand that if you support these actions that I'm not attacking you, I just want you on the right side when this all falls apart and the only way to do that is for you to understand that nothing is being done these days that we can't do ourselves if we need protection. Sobriety tests of those who were suspect would have been more than sufficient to find any drunk children. I can't even imagine what this cost the school district and tax payers. It was a stupid move and a violation, hands down. Just as every single TSA agent who have ever touched anyone is a violation. 

Laurabeth --- 14 years ago -

Those of you who favor these activities are more than likely in favor of this...



Of course not, but way to use your poor judgement and lump it all together........what a moronic thing to assume that those that agree with the schools that take nonevasive measures to help keep our kids safe and law adiding would condone this..........I wish I could tell you what I think of you right now "REV the mod" but I would certainly be iced. 

Infidel II --- 14 years ago -

sheesh people, they had to take a breathalyzer not get strip searched.

Next year, you'll be saying "Sheesh people, they only got strip searched and fondled a bit, they did not get a cavity search.

Then, the year after that, you'll be saying, "Sheesh people, they only got an anal probe, they didn't get all of their cavities searched."

i would be willing to bet that there was some kind of info sent out that informed the parents that this could and would happen as a prerequisite of attending graduation...don't you?

Well, according to the article, many parents were upset and apparently had not been informed that the school was going to strip the students of some of their Fourth Amendment rights. Moreover, what if the school had "informed" the parents? How would the school's unilateral decision to take away students' rights against unreasonable search and seizure have made it any less objectionable?

These kids have to go to school by law, but that shouldn't mean they have to leave their rights at the schoolhouse doors. 

Infidel II --- 14 years ago -

what a moronic thing to assume that those that agree with the schools that take nonevasive measures to help keep our kids safe and law adiding

Before you call people morons, at least get your terminology right. It's "non-invasive," not "nonevasive," whatever that means.

Further, if you can't see the connection, maybe you ought to think a bit longer about the whole proposition of civil liberties and what the Fourth Amendment protects us against. Perhaps, you'll have second thoughts, but you don't have to get nasty about it if it's all too hard for you to "figger" out. 

sweetscreaminmonkey --- 14 years ago -

my son was random drug tested to be able to participate in sports.. i have NO problem with that since he is clean and has nothing to hide.. kids should be under the influence and be able to participate PERIOD.. 

Laurabeth --- 14 years ago -

Bite me Infidel......No one was trying to take away their rights. Do you advocate then that minors should be allowed to drink and drive? Of course not, and Rev's connection to assuming that we all agree with what he posted is moronic.


Before you call people morons, at least get your terminology right. It's "non-invasive," not "nonevasive," whatever that means.

oops...pardon my typo. 

itstxdaddy --- 14 years ago -

edited by request
Please understand that if you support these actions that I'm not attacking you,

COMPLETELY inappropriate. to say that because i don't care that some high schoolers were given a breathalyzer somehow equates to me supporting children being groped is as disusting as anything ever said on this site.

that was uncalled for, you should ice yourself REV. 

rEVOLution --- 14 years ago -

Of course not, but way to use your poor judgement and lump it all together........what a moronic thing to assume that those that agree with the schools that take nonevasive measures to help keep our kids safe and law adiding would condone this.

That's not what they did. They made children line up like criminals in a jail, blow their DNA into an electronic device when most of the kids had done nothing wrong and without parental consent. Assuming that was done "for everyone elses safety" is where folks have got it wrong.

Our first mistake was giving the schools and education system over to the states, our second mistake was allowing the states to raise our children. Stop excusing the schools controlled indoctrination as safety and security. They are not the same thing. As I said before the school could have simply pulled anyone suspect of drinking aside and handled them case by case instead of making half the class who know their rights feel like criminals and the other half who felt the need to be safely taken care of by the school, protected with that false sense of security that the states so gladly sell us all these days.

The government can not protect us all from ourselves. If we don't all learn that really quickly, we are setting our children's futures up to be more like slavery than freedom. With Freedom comes great responsibility. 

itstxdaddy --- 14 years ago -

They made children line up like criminals in a jail

these were not children rev. you know that. stop sensationalizing to try and prove some point.

you should not be allowed to make those type of accusations on this forum. 

Dr Aborto --- 14 years ago -

0 

Laurabeth --- 14 years ago -

Right....then there would be a lawsuit from the little darlings that were tested, because they were picked on.......or profiled....Whatever. I don't have a problem withthe school drug testing my child while he is on school property, like I stated before. 

rEVOLution --- 14 years ago -

I wish I could tell you what I think of you right now "REV the mod" but I would certainly be iced.

No by all means don't hold back. I will edit my statement but before I do please try to understand that my saying "More than likely" is not the same as my saying you or anyone else falls in that category. And I do not think it was uncalled or in any way. I find it just as offensive that anyone would wish a child to be treated like that when they were not suspect of the actions. That offended me but I certainly would not ice anyone for expressing their beliefs. That's your right just as it is my right to show some similarities. Our nation is falling apart at the seems and all we do is bicker back and forth about who called someone this or that or how someone got offended by what someone else said.

If we are going all be adults, let's be adults and have some serious debates in a civil manner. These are the children of our future we are discussing here. 

Laurabeth --- 14 years ago -

So do you believe that it is wrong for the school to drug test the students at all? 

itstxdaddy --- 14 years ago -

let's be adults and have some serious debates in a civil manner

the first step in doing that is not sensationalizing what happened. you saying that the people who did not have a problem with this also would be ok with children being groped was childish. not even stretch armstrong could make that connection. 

rEVOLution --- 14 years ago -

these were not children rev. you know that. stop sensationalizing to try and prove some point.

The majority of them are not of age to vote, join the military (yet) without parental consent, still live under mom and dads roof, use mom and dads money, nor did they really have a choice in the matter since their "Authority" figures at school told them to do it or else. Children or Teens, what was done to them could not have been done by a police officer on the street without probable cause. Just as the TSA does things by touching people in a way that a police officer on the street can not do without probable cause. That being said, we are being conditioned to except these measures as normal practice despite the fact they are not legal the way they are being done. 

rEVOLution --- 14 years ago -

So do you believe that it is wrong for the school to drug test the students at all?

Only with parental consent or probable cause. We have thousands of laws in place for these sorts of things that have been working for a long time. There's no need to just throw them all out the window speeding the process up by ignoring the laws. Just because we turn our children over to the state 8 hours a day does not mean they should have the right to treat them in ways that police officers are restrained from doing. 

rEVOLution --- 14 years ago -

you saying that the people who did not have a problem with this also would be ok with children being groped was childish. not even stretch armstrong could make that connection.

That's your opinion and I respect that. If you were offended that was not my intent. I over reacted and I edited my comments. 

Laurabeth --- 14 years ago -

that police officers are restrained from doing.


These were police officers that were present at the school to conduct the testing. This after students admitted to being at a party and consuming alcohol the night before.

I'm more sadden by the fact that the school needed to acknowledge the students drinking issues instead of the parents of these teens........At least the school cares enough to punish the kids for their wrong doing! 

Infidel II --- 14 years ago -

oops...pardon my typo

A typo is when you accidentally hit the wrong key; not when you don't know the difference between two words with entirely different meanings. So, stop trying to "evade" my critique. "Evade," not "invade," get it? 

Infidel II --- 14 years ago -

I don't have a problem withthe school drug testing my child while he is on school property, like I stated before.

(edited, let's please keep this civil) 

Laurabeth --- 14 years ago -

Alec Welp and 73 of his classmates

So out of 74 students....at least double digits tested positive for alcohol at the end of the school day.......hmmmmm. So apparently it's a big issue with this group of kids to say the least. And I wonder how long after you drink can you still "blow" positive, can someone research that? It would be interesting to see if that could prove whether or not they were drinking during school hours or not.... 

Laurabeth --- 14 years ago -

A typo is when you accidentally hit the wrong key; not when you don't know the difference between two words with entirely different meanings. So, stop trying to "evade" my critique. "Evade," not "invade," get it?


Does that make you feel good about yourself? 

rEVOLution --- 14 years ago -

I am also glad that the school took some action but it's the actions taken that I'm unhappy with. The police officers in my opinion should also be reprimanded and reminded of the law. I might be wrong and if so I'll apologize but I do not believe that an officer can randomly give a breathalyzer or sobriety test to just anyone without probable cause, much less with the threat and coercion of not allowing a student to graduate. That's a threat. Much less these allegations were based on activities that occurred the night before off campus. Again they should have handled this on a case by case basis. 

itstxdaddy --- 14 years ago -

that police officers are restrained from doing.

police officers are not restrained from giving people breathalyzers when they suspect drinking and driving. it happens all the time.

these were 18 year olds...not 6 year olds.

i actually would not have an issue with testing them before and after any school event. 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -

Again they should have handled this on a case by case basis.


I agree with this, but it sounds like they tested many kids indiscriminately, and that's where I take issue. 

Laurabeth --- 14 years ago -

much less with the threat and coercion of not allowing a student to graduate.


They did not threaten to not let them graduate....there you go making it worse, they told them that they would not be allowed to participate in the ceremony! which I think is wrong anyhow. If they tested positive, they should have been arrested for underage drinking....... 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground