Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Five Reasons Not To Give Up Something for Lent

who's talking here?

la guerita 1
Justwatching72 1
steinhoister 5
jjfingrainalready 5
Syrah1214 3
Donkey Hodie 2
Goddess 1
ExLady In Blue 1
Agent of Change 2
Hiro Protagonist 11
JohnLynch 23
OH SNAP 8
freebyrd 4
Work in Progress 3
Puss In Boots 1
Mabs 1
Dr Death Defying 28
Clock 25
Bornanraisedkw 1
Ares 5
Fuck Bitches M Star 1
BiggieSmalls 7

CAUTION: This topic is dangerous. Enter at own risk.

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

Posted March 5th, 2009 @ 7:00 am by Nathan Bierma

For Lent, I’m giving up the idea of giving up something for Lent. There are some good reasons to do it, but I can think of a few reasons not to.

1. It’s not the Self-Denial Olympics.

If the point of giving up something for Lent is nothing more than self-congratulation for feats of abstinence, I’m not interested. Fasting, in centuries of monastic practice, is only worthwhile as far as it increases your spiritual focus, your meditation, your awareness of utter dependence on God. In our diet-happy culture, simply avoiding something is itself is an accomplishment, a triumph of willpower and demonstration of self-control that, ironically, gives you a higher, not a lower, view of yourself. “The New Testament has lots to say about self-denial, but not about self-denial as an end in itself,” said C.S. Lewis in his timeless sermon “The Weight of Glory.” “We are told to deny ourselves and to take up our crosses in order that we may follow Christ.” Which brings me to #2.

2. Chocolate Ain’t a Cross.

I have friends giving up chocolate, or alcohol, or TV, or ice cream, for Lent. I admire their sacrifices. But those are still pretty trivial sacrifices. I’d be more impressed if people gave up not a minor indulgence but a supposed non-negotiable of modern life. Driving. E-mail. Mirrors. Consumer goods produced more than 100 miles from your house.

That would impress me. But I still don’t think it would impress God. “Take up your cross and follow me.” It’s a call to complete self-emptying.

3. We’re not trying to beat Christ at his own game.

Sometimes I wonder if giving up something for Lent comes out of a twinge of guilt about Jesus’ suffering—”Jesus went through so much pain for me, the least I can do in return is keep my hand out of the cookie jar for a month.” First, Christ endured hell precisely so that we don’t have to (not that a lack of cookies is hell; see #2 above). He emptied himself in order to invite us to a life of abundance. Not self-indulgence. Not indifference. Not hoarding. But abundance. A life of fasting and feasting.

4. Fuzzy Math, Part 1: 40 does not equal 46.

A pastor pointed out in passing last year that Lent is not actually 40 days, but 46. To get to 40, you have to subtract the six Sundays between Ash Wednesday and Easter. Why? Because Sunday is always a day of Resurrection, a “mini-Easter.” Our jubilance about Jesus’ defeat of death interrupts even our somberness in a season dedicated to his suffering.

That was brand new to me. But I love it; I love Easter’s persistence in piercing our gloom. Do Lenten self-deniers know this quirk of the church calendar, and do they, accordingly, let the chocolate flow on those six Sundays?

5. Fuzzy Math, Part 2: One does not equal 40.

In his stirring new book Surprised By Hope, N.T. Wright says, “I regard it as absurd and unjustifiable that we should spend forty days keeping Lent, pondering what it means, preaching about self-denial, being at least a little gloomy … and then, after [Holy Week], we have a single day of celebration.”

Easter, Wright points out, is a whole season, 40 whole days of its own before Ascension Day, not “simply the one-day happy ending tacked on to forty days of fasting and gloom,” as he puts it. So after fasting for 40 days (give or take; see #4 above), how will we feast for 40 days? Chocolate cake for dessert every night? 40 bottles of wine? Or would that would be as trivial as giving them up? No matter what, we have to let Easter be a whole season—a whole year, really—a feast that’s as good as the fast. 

Dr Death Defying --- 15 years ago -

 

Dr Death Defying --- 15 years ago -

 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

And one reason to:

In our culture of instant gratification and self-indulgence, where we "give" ourselves over to hedonism because we "deserve" it, learning how to say NO to yourself is a good thing. Perhaps it isn't defined within scripture as worship, but it is practice for self-discipline, which is called for in the Bible.

So people start with chocolate, or soda, or whatever minor little indulgence they have. It's a start! Many of us have never sacrificed much of anything, and we are learning how.

Every time that someone reaches for the soda, then remembers that he/she gave it up for lent, he/she is strengthening his/her ability to say NO. I think that God is pleased with that. 

OH SNAP --- 15 years ago -

Every time that someone reaches for the soda, then remembers that they gave it up for lent, they are strengthening their ability to say NO. I think that God is pleased with that.

Exactly the point Docswife made in the red thread that John crapped all over. 

Justwatching72 --- 15 years ago -

Deleted by mod 

freebyrd --- 15 years ago -

Well "HELLO there" JW72!!! 

Dr Death Defying --- 15 years ago -

all it said was (edited by mod) come on! 

jjfingrainalready --- 15 years ago -

all it said was (edited by mod) come on!
no kidding. that was ridiculous. how is that any different from (edit) or (edit) or (edit) or any of the other various ways people find to curse on here?

Warning. Continued profanity will result in icing. 

freebyrd --- 15 years ago -

Wow... I'm impressed...... 

jjfingrainalready --- 15 years ago -

with what Brown? 

Dr Death Defying --- 15 years ago -

wow... really?

that is ridiculous...

well... time to post punk rock...

 

jjfingrainalready --- 15 years ago -

Let's not forget STFU, OMFG, LMAO, LMFAO, etc. 

freebyrd --- 15 years ago -

jff ...to this much attention to "detail????!" at this hour! 

jjfingrainalready --- 15 years ago -

I am seriously asking.

EDITED to add: Cause I'm not on here much, but every time I am, the rules seem to be different. I don't do anything to offend, and I avoid the drama threads. But even with my little interaction, it is easy to see that what's good for one goose is not necessarily good for another gander.
 

jjfingrainalready --- 15 years ago -

jff ...to this much attention to "detail????!" at this hour!

I was just thinking the same thing. It's one freaking thirty. 

Dr Death Defying --- 15 years ago -

 

freebyrd --- 15 years ago -

It's one freaking thirty.

Careful now........ 

Dr Death Defying --- 15 years ago -

 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

Every time that someone reaches for the soda, then remembers that he/she gave it up for lent, he/she is strengthening his/her ability to say NO. I think that God is pleased with that. 

sorry alli, but that is a reason not to...

"In our diet-happy culture, simply avoiding something is itself is an accomplishment, a triumph of willpower and demonstration of self-control that, ironically, gives you a higher, not a lower, view of yourself."

why would giving up something TEMPORARILY, something that God didn't ask you to do, be pleasing to Him?...especially when it is a tradition established by man and not the Word of God and brings attention to yourself for what you accomplished on your own, and not what God accomplished through you 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

Exactly the point Docswife made in the red thread that John crapped all over.

and there you go again with that lying, antagonistic attitude...telling the truth isn't "crapping" all over anything...lying accomplishes that feat perfectly 

Dr Death Defying --- 15 years ago -

telling the truth isn't "crapping" all over anything

It's only YOUR truth.

 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

It's only YOUR truth.

quoting the Bible would be giving God's truth...it's a shame you can't or won't recognize that 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

22 But the fruit of the Spirit is love, joy, peace, forbearance, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, 23 gentleness and self-control. Against such things there is no law. 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

I agree that tradition for tradition's sake is not of God. However, I don't think that the practice of denying ourselves, even if only for 40 days, is going to hurt anyone in our culture.

How many of us even practice fasting for spiritual reasons? I don't. 

Fuck Bitches M Star --- 15 years ago -

I think that not being Christian is a good reason to not give up anything for Lent. 

Puss In Boots --- 15 years ago -

To each his own. The Lord knows what is in your heart whether you give up something for Lent or not. I cannot suppose that a bunch of people on KU can discern my motives.

Trying to convince someone to give something up or not give something up is pointless in that regard.

My Lord and Savior knows my heart and thoughts. 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

22 But the fruit of the Spirit is love, joy, peace, forbearance, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, 23 gentleness and self-control. Against such things there is no law.

self-control in that verse doesn't mean givivng up some trivial thing in your life and the self-control is to be daily, not for only 40 days a year...if you are going to give up something, give up a sinful action, not something that isn't sinful like eating meat, watermelon, etc., and give it up for the rest of your life 

Donkey Hodie --- 15 years ago -

***Hey all you GOP and right-wing folks - if the Religious Right takes over the country, it will put people like JohnLynch in charge of your laws and culture. It won't be the friendly Lutheran or Methodist, it will be the fundies like Lynch who will control every last detail of your life, including the specifics of how you worship God.*** 

Syrah1214 --- 15 years ago -

I honestly believe that any kind act done in sacrifice or honor of God is not frowned upon by our Lord. God knows our hearts more intimately than we know them ourselves.

The Bible says to tithe 10% of our earnings. Does that mean God will be upset with us because we give more than that to Feed the Children in HIS honor to help feed His children who are starving?

The Bible does not command us to go to church everyday, yet my husband does. Does this make him a bad person? I certainly don't think so. It makes him committed. He is making time everyday to set aside and drive out of his way to attend church. He is giving that time to God, in God's honor. Does that mean God is displeased because one of His children is going to church daily in spite of the fact that it's not written in the Bible? Doubtful.

The Bible serves as our book of rules along with consequences and rewards... but like a lot of things in life, some of what we are supposed to do or not do is simply common sense. God gave us "Common Sense" for a reason. One of which is to be able to know what to do and not do which will GLORIFY HIS Holy name.

Because someone gives up something for 40 days and uses that time to reflect on God's sacrfice is far from a sin, if you ask me. I go back to my opening statement. ANY act done in sacrifice or honor of God is most likely not frowned upon by the Lord... at least not the Lord I know. 

OH SNAP --- 15 years ago -

I honestly believe that any kind act done in sacrifice or honor of God is not frowned upon by our Lord.

WRONG! JohnLynch has spoken. There is no need for further discussion. 

Mabs --- 15 years ago -

One reason to listen to only your heart and passion. YOU. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 15 years ago -

WRONG! JohnLynch has spoken. There is no need for further discussion.


I'll give his answer for him. JohnLynch hasn't spoken, god has spoken and he is just repeating what god says. 

ExLady In Blue --- 15 years ago -

LOL at the amount of atheists that post on a thread about something they don't believe in. Must be a slow day on KU. 

OH SNAP --- 15 years ago -

I'll give his answer for him. JohnLynch hasn't spoken, god has spoken and he is just repeating what god says.

My bad. 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

The Bible says to tithe 10% of our earnings. Does that mean God will be upset with us because we give more than that to Feed the Children in HIS honor to help feed His children who are starving?

there is a difference between tithing and charitable giving...God tells us to do BOTH

The Bible does not command us to go to church everyday, yet my husband does. Does this make him a bad person? I certainly don't think so.

the Bible doesn't command us to go to church at all

He is giving that time to God, in God's honor.

that IS what God wants from us...but we aren't commanded to do it in any special place

The Bible serves as our book of rules along with consequences and rewards...

nope...the Bible is there to show us we need a Savior

God gave us "Common Sense" for a reason. One of which is to be able to know what to do and not do which will GLORIFY HIS Holy name.

sorry, but you are uninformed...the Holy Spirit was given to know what to do and not what to do

Because someone gives up something for 40 days and uses that time to reflect on God's sacrfice is far from a sin, if you ask me.

wow!...way to go at mischaracterizing what someone says...never said it was a sin...just said it wasn't necessary and wasn't scriptural

some people need to read the Bible that they so often reference...there seems to be a lack of understanding about it's purpose and what it says 

steinhoister --- 15 years ago -

6. god isn't real. 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

LOL at the amount of atheists that post on a thread about something they don't believe in. Must be a slow day on KU.

the atheists are posting about something that they have VERY little knowledge of...the quote "Any bets on how long it took for him to become that delusional?" is proof of what i just said...and they do so in an effort to distort the truth... and what is amazing to me is that people who say they are Christians AGREE with their contradiction of what the Bible says 

OH SNAP --- 15 years ago -

and what is amazing to me is that people who say they are Christians AGREE with their contradiction of what the Bible says

Either that or you're misinterpreting what the bible says, not that your ginormous ego allows you to even consider the possibility. 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

Either that or you're misinterpreting what the bible says

snappy, the Bible is very clear to those who WANT to learn...

fyi, you can't misinterpret something that isn't there

not that your ginormous ego allows you to even consider the possibility.

that's a laugh...i attribute what i say to the Bible...you attribute what you say to YOU...it's obvious to see that the ego problem is in your court 

page 1 2 3 4
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground