Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

school projects?

who's talking here?

freshhell 1
Fallon 1
planemom 4
Deltadawn 1
Zionist NightOwl 6
browneyes 4
Homeschool mom 2
reh6110 3
mommytbone 1
fishlady 8
Rhea 2
POTUS 1
Polly Ester 1
April 1
toxiccutie 1
*OH SNAP* 1
***maryc 3
vegas 1
Mago4058 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

fishlady --- 16 years ago -

I sent a letter to a teacher today after seeing the BIG project for this last 9 weeks for the 5th graders...... I am signing this project card and sending it back and I understand the need to have the kids learn to research and prepare presentations BUT, all I see is something that is going to end up costing me money for her to complete. I know you always say use stuff from home, but I see having to have a display board, building a diaorama(which I always end up buying stuff for), a miniature museum?, a model of the backyard and the "finishing" touches. I just know there are several families that cannot go to Hobby Lobby and spend 30-40.00 for a school project. I know this is not your fault but I really think the school and the planning committees need to start taking these lower income kids into account when you are asking for this kind of a project. I have no problem if it is all done at school during class time and all the materials are provided for them to complete it but when all these large projects are sent home it turns into parent homework whether the teacher wants to admit it or not. You can look at the projects that are turned in and know the parents had a huge hand in completing them, where if it was all done at school you would know the child did it all on their own. I am sure my child will work hard and make hers nice, but again I am sure there will be money spent. What about the kids that do not have that option? I know just looking at it even if she used stuff from home it is still looking at 20.00 min. for poster boards, markers, glue and art supplies to complete the project. thanks for listening to me complain, I normally would not say anything BUT I personally have spent over 60.00 already this year on Middle school projects just for one child and I know not every family can afford that. Am I wrong in sending this? I feel kinda bad now that I sent it to her. The teacher is so nice and a great teacher but I still think big projects like this should ONLY be done at school, otherwise it turns into parent homework and ends up costing parents lots of money......and this is ONE huge project it includes a dozen different things at least. Just wanted a few honest opinions.... 

Homeschool mom --- 16 years ago -

I think your letter sounds fine. It is asking a lot for parents to come up with that kind of money right now to complete a project. 

April --- 16 years ago -

I always wondered how some families could afford to pay for projects when they have several kiddos. I know I spent over $100 per semester for projects since my kids started school. Some projects were $40 for just one. I agree with you FL but doubt the teachers can change much. I know they pay for a lot of stuff themselves. 

***maryc --- 16 years ago -

What about children whose parents have lost their jobs....... 

POTUS --- 16 years ago -

Sounds fine to me. The teacher is just doing what they tell her, so make sure you hand write at the very top "MRS. _______ , THIS LETTER IS INTENDED FOR __________ (principal or head of department)". That way she'll know right away you aren't directing it towards her and won't have a mini panic attack reading it. She'll know her @$$ is covered, basically. 

browneyes --- 16 years ago -

I talked to one teacher because I ended up spending close to $100 on a stupid project. I told him I'm not creative and would never think of using beans or macaroni for a indian mission..... I think it's ridiculous! I hate projects...I hate them!!!!! 

Deltadawn --- 16 years ago -

Since I have never once had to create a diorama as an adult, I think alternative assignments should be available. 

Rhea --- 16 years ago -

The last project my kiddo brought home to do was to make an armadillo out of what ever you could find at your house. We made it out of strips of a bisquick box and some grey paper, some pasta noodles and a stapler. Didn't cost us a penny and my kid learned how to make due with what he had around here and be creative. I have to say it turned out pretty cute. You don't always have to run out to hobby lobby if you use some creativity. You might actually get a better grade for thinking outside of the box. The letter sounds fine but school projects should be done from things around the house. The parents make these projects really too complicated trying to make them perfect. That's why most of the time everyone ends up running to hobby lobby. We've done quite a few projects around here from what we had. It really teaches the kids to use their heads. 

browneyes --- 16 years ago -

yes..IF you are creative..which I am NOT!!! Neither are my kids....so those types of projects are very stressful. Examples need to be shown TO PARENTS..cause kids never come home and say everything the teacher says about how to do the project. 

fishlady --- 16 years ago -

That mission cost me 40.00 and that WAS using a lot of stuff from around the house! I thought they would have learned just as much drawing it in detail on a poster board and labeling everything....IMO The wagon thing in Middle school cost me 30.00 and that was us buying stuff to build stuff out of.... There are some projects that you can get creative with but I am sorry I have four kids and a very full schedule and sometimes it is harder for me to spend hours trying to come up with something to use. It comes down to me not having time for "homework" and trying to buy something to make it easier.... But even for this project the display board, markers and just glue and building supplies has to come to at least 20.00...... I also think these kind of project should be done at school, if it comes home it becomes parent homework whether the teacher wants it to be or not...... 

fishlady --- 16 years ago -

If they want to teach the kids to help them in Middle school, high school and college make them do power point presentations to the class with slides of their research........this is a skill that will help them in their future grades... I also know the teachers have a set curriculum that they have to go by, I understand it is not their fault but schools have to start taking these things into consideration.... 

browneyes --- 16 years ago -

The wagon one....I think sucked! we used things from around the house...but I had no idea how to make a bushel of whatever it was they wanted. Half of it ended up being cut out of construction paper...which I know the teacher did not want...but WTH was I suppose to use??? I don't have a creative bone in my body..and not everyone has boxes or oatmeal containers handy to do these things. 

planemom --- 16 years ago -

My kids know they are on their own when it comes to projects. I'll get needed/wanted supplies within reason but that's it. So far that hasn't hurt my kids grades. For the most part, teachers can tell which projects where done by kids and which projects had parental help. I've also started buying extra poster board and displays boards when they are on sale at the beginning of the year. They slide behind my dresser so are out of the way. 

browneyes --- 16 years ago -

the mission project...didn't require poster board..you had to have 2 churches, fences, 2 wells, a garden, living quarters for indians. That was a tough project....after I talked to the teacher he gave me ideas...AFTER it was due....I would have never thought of those things.. That is why I am saying...they should be specific about what to use....and give examples for those of us..including kids who are not creative. 

fishlady --- 16 years ago -

LOl browneyes....the wagon project was hard! We looked around the house for an hour trying to find stuff that would work and couldn't find anything, he tried making stuff out of a cut up box....lol.....he is a non creative boy and it didn't even look like what he was trying to make! it was really sad....... Those display folding boards are 9.99! A .99 poster board doesn't bother me..... planemom, my kids do their own projects. I helped my oldest when he was younger but now with four I do not have time, so they come up with it on their own. I will buy the list of stuff they need or can't make but they assemble it themselves.....my poor middle school child, his projects were so sad looking......I laughed and said at least the teacher will know you did it all on your own.......lol 

fishlady --- 16 years ago -

that mission project was hard, I ended up in the flower section of hobby lobby buying styrefoam blocks to carve out churches and houses and then we spray painted them with that stone looking paint, had to buy felt and construction paper, lots of glue.....again a power point presentation or drawing it in detail and labeling it on a poster board would have accomplished the same learning goal.... 

Zionist NightOwl --- 16 years ago -

Fishlady, my DD was given that same assignment last month and is working on it now, but only the GT kids were invited to do it, and it is completely optional. (GT kids are not clustered in her school.) It's not even for a grade. The parents have to give their permission for the kids to even be allowed to take it on. Is your kid's whole class doing it? The last such project she was assigned, there were several kids given the opportunity, and most didn't take it. (I think only 5 started it.) Only DD and one other girl finished it. It was a HUGE project, but DD enjoyed doing it. I do agree that this project is, similarly, very involved and time-consuming. DD has to work on it at home, although she has a meeting with the teacher overseeing it once every two weeks so she can check on DD's progress. So today, instead of enjoying the beautiful weather at recess, DD had to do her check-in. However, DD is a very creative person, and is looking forward to all of the design and building she has to do. 

fishlady --- 16 years ago -

YES, this is the same project and ALL of fifth grade is doing it and they will all have check in days and it is for everyone and I looked at it and couldnt' believe what all it was calling for, poetry, a fictional story, a flipbook, a personal reflection,maps, tables, safety signs, a watercolor, a food chain, a t chart all to be put in a portfolio. Then they still have to build an exhibit with the display board, diorama, flipbook, miniature museum, backyard model, and finishing touches! LOL, I do not remember ever even doing a project in college that was this all consuming.....a 15 page essay or report with research sited.....but it just seems like a lot of work. AGAIN, if it was all done at school I have no problem with it, but when it comes home it becomes parent homework and adds to the stress of added homework and time at home..... 

Polly Ester --- 16 years ago -

When I was in school the teacher's always assigned these projects the weeks before open house so they would have stuff to display when the parents came for the show, lol. I always thought that was kind of lame..I mean, why come to see a project that you saw get made at home. Parents want to come to school and see what you did at school with the teacher's help, not what you did with your mom's help. 

Homeschool mom --- 16 years ago -

Fishlady, what is the topic of the project? 

freshhell --- 16 years ago -

When I taught 7th grade at Humble MS, I knew there was no way many of those kids would be able to come up with supplies for a project. I spent my own money on all supplies, and planned it so that all work on the project would be done during class, and all projects remained in my classroom for the duration of the lesson. I was aware that many of the kids' home lives were chaotic, and it would be unfair to grade kids on how much support they got at home. 

***maryc --- 16 years ago -

Well, freshhell, we can safely assume you were a better teacher than most!! 

Zionist NightOwl --- 16 years ago -

I looked at it and couldn't believe what all it was calling for, LOL. I know. Same here. I was overwhelmed just reading it all. BUT, I will say this. The Civic Mission she had to do last semester was just as big of a project (same company/same format), although it had a lot more typing for the portfolio, whereas this is weighted more for the design/build part. I didn't know how DD was going to find time to do all of it. It just seemed like a monumental task. But it was an incredible experience for her. DD had to partner with a volunteer organization, brainstorm on a way she could help them, and carry out a civic mission. She chose ARCC, a committee that encourages developers and businesses to maintain/replant trees, to try to keep Atascocita from looking so industrial. As part of that project, she also met with some area businesses and talked with them (the store managers), wrote an email to TxDot about maintaining a median when/if the 1960 widening occurs, met with the school principal and the leader of the school's Go Green Club, got some trees planted at her elementary school, made a presentation to two classes that the principal, AP, teachers, and even Dr. Sconzo attended, and was interviewed and photographed twice for the newspapers. I had to help a little, such as showing her how to laminate something for her mobile, and driving her to her meetings, etc., but then she did the work. I was amazed at how much she learned and how much she accomplished in this project. The good thing about it not being for a grade is that I was able to pretty much give her free reign. If she failed, she failed. She wanted to be as independent as possible on the project (for which I was very happy.) I thought the project (which they call an "independent study") was a little involved for a 4th grader, but in the end, she learned more than I would have imagined. 

Zionist NightOwl --- 16 years ago -

Fishlady, what is the topic of the project? The kids are supposed to design a one-acre backyard getaway, including a relaxation area, a recreation area, a water habitat, a state or country tribute area, and a garden. They were given a 25-page instruction guide. 

***maryc --- 16 years ago -

That sounds like fun! I mean that sincerely! Watch a few days of HGTV and you will have all the ideas you will need. 

Zionist NightOwl --- 16 years ago -

DD is stoked! This is right up her alley. She is incredibly creative, and it's a good outlet for that. 

Zionist NightOwl --- 16 years ago -

But, the design part comes easily for her. The time-consuming part is all that other stuff fishlady mentioned, such as the mini-museum, the model, the diorama, the flipbook, the tribute cards. Fishlady, don't forget about the tribute artworks, one of which must be a sculpture! LOL. It really is kind of an insane project for a 4th or 5th grader in terms of how much WORK is entailed. 

toxiccutie --- 16 years ago -

when I was in the 4th grade I had to make a "nature" project i.e...waterfall, volcano's, mountains, forest...etc... mine was a waterfall and spring... built out of toilet paper roll covered in clay and painted blue (for the small waterfall) then I simply painted the spring onto the board and added rocks and small grass for texture. I picked up rocks and moss out of the yard along with sticks and leaves and created the surrounding area of the waterfall... cost? uh, well I had everything single thing at the house. The board my mom gave me was an old large box she cut up...and I covered it with paper and painted to make it look even. paint? well what kid doesn't have paint, markers or at least colors? My mom refused to spend lots of money..and made me use all resources I could at the house. Forced me to expand and use my creative mind. I do think its ridiculous the projects nowadays that are assigned that DO in fact require out of pocket. 

Rhea --- 16 years ago -

My kids go to a private school so I don't know what projects you guys are talking about. Most projects are done in class and the teachers update us by email of their progress. If they fall behind in class then they have to do it for homework. Most of the work is done in the computer lab researching and designing graphs for presentations. They just have to take a project board to school. I agree with you from what I've read about these projects. They should be taking class time to research and discuss ideas for these projects, expecially if they are that detailed. 

Mago4058 --- 16 years ago -

Wow, I'm lucky if I get math homework back...but alot of projects done in class cost the teacher money. Unfort. schools just aren't funded the way they used to be...sad... 

Mago4058 --- 16 years ago -

Wow, I'm lucky if I get math homework back...but alot of projects done in class cost the teacher money. Unfort. schools just aren't funded the way they used to be...sad... 

Fallon --- 16 years ago -

Unfort. schools just aren't funded the way they used to be...sad...  No they get more funding now than ever have in the past. We always had projects to do at home. And my mom did not ever take us to Hobby Lobby, cause we didn't have one:) lol We had no Wal Mart either. So everything we used, but poster paper was from home. Yes you do have to be creative, and it would help if the teachers could give the parents some ideas in that area. But these projects do get kids to think and plan ahead, and even to be creative. Because you do have to be creative as an adult, and make do with things you have. Instead of sending this to the teacher you should send it to the school board, or principle. But you know they don't care. If it isn't about TAKS, they are not concerned. 

vegas --- 16 years ago -

I'm aware of this 9-week project and know this was at the discretion of the grade level team...not the school board, principal, or superintendent. It really is a cool project...using lots of different subjects. If I remember, these projects are to be done at school...not at home so parents don't do it for the kids. I feel bad for teachers sometime...if they do TAKs related stuff with kids..parents complain. Teachers do real-life higher level thinking projects and people complain. 

Zionist NightOwl --- 16 years ago -

Teachers do real-life higher level thinking projects and people complain. I'm not complaining one bit. In DD's case, the project is optional, and if I didn't want DD to participate, then I just wouldn't agree to it. I think it's a great project. I honestly do think that it was designed for much older kids. However, I also believe in challenging kids to reach beyond the norm. If I remember, these projects are to be done at school...not at home so parents don't do it for the kids. Definitely not the case at DD's school. First of all, only a few kids are doing it, not an entire class, so it's not something they can devote class time to. Second, the only school time she gets to work on it is during her recess, and that happens once a week, although her work isn't checked every week; she has set "check-point" days. Third, her adviser just confirmed to the kids today that ALL of the model-building, etc. work was to be done at home. They can do some of the drawing or research, such as researching and analyzing types of terrain and climate in Texas, during these recess meetings, but not the model-type work. Fourth, the scope of these projects really is enormous. There is NO way a class could do all of this work during school-time without compromising the rest of their curriculum. You really have to look at the guide to understand the depth of this project. It's not science fair. Fifth, I, personally, have NO inclination to do DD's work. I don't think that's a concern of the adviser. These kids are bright, independent, creative thinkers who WANT to do the work. 

*OH SNAP* --- 16 years ago -

I'm with you Fishlady. This stuff gets EXPENSIVE. I think the schools are expecting more and more money from parents these days, and a lot of us just don't have it. If it's not some project, it's a t-shirt or a recorder or book fair or fund-raising or the school carnival and so on and so forth. Maybe it doesn't seem like much when it's one thing at a time, but it can be overwhelming when a bunch of it hits at once and you're on a shoestring budget. 

planemom --- 16 years ago -

Whoever said it's a free education was wrong. Only one of mine is in public school and we are nickled and dimed for this and that. I can't imagine it multiplied by 4. 

reh6110 --- 16 years ago -

If you think it is expensive for one parent to provide the supplies for one child can you imagine how much it costs for 1 teacher to provide the supplies for 20+ kids? That just isn't always a possiblity. As far as you thinking it is going to cost so much I would suggest stocking up at the beginning of the year. You know there are going to be projects, HW, etc. that require extra supplies (cryaons, markers, gue, etc). You can buy those things for a quarter or less at the end of the summer. I hope you do know that you don't have to go to Hobby Lobby. For the most part Walmart, Target or even the dollar store has all of the items you may need. 

reh6110 --- 16 years ago -

 

mommytbone --- 16 years ago -

Thank you for making that point, Reh! Forget expensive projects...I would love it if all of my students would come to school with a pencil and red pen. Unfortunately, I am constantly having to use my own money to buy pencils so that my students have something to write with during class. Who sends their kids to school without something to write with? I will never understand it! 

planemom --- 16 years ago -

In defense of the parents, when we send in all the supplies at the beginning of the year we believe our child will have pencils and paper. After that we need to know they are gone so we can send more. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground