Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Torture and morality

who's talking here?

freshhell 2
steinhoister 1
NoNameNoLastName 2
R.E.B. 3
justforfun 5
rEVOLution 4
MomTimesFive 2
Meme2my5 1
Possum 1
Agent of Change 4
Allimama 22
Hiro Protagonist 7
voice of reason 2
JohnLynch 23
NewNanna 2
*momof5* 4

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Allimama --- 17 years ago -

With waterboarding so much in the news, I wanted to hear what KU thinks about the morality of torture. Can the end ever justify the means, why or why not? This is a tough one for me. I am horrified by torture techniques, yet I am terrified of what Iran could do to us with nukes and I'd like the US to have the intelligence to counter it. Can torture be moral? 

MomTimesFive --- 17 years ago -

I think more prisoners would be talking if waterboarding was truly torture. I know if someone were threatening to cut off one of my fingers, I'd tell them anything they wanted to know. The prisoners have complete control over the situation. If they give the information that they know, the waterboarding stops. If the information can prevent the deaths of innocent people, then I think the means are justified. Particularly since the prisoner has control over whether or not to talk and thus stop the questioning. 

Allimama --- 17 years ago -

Forgive me for playing devil's advocate here, but I haven't decided what my stance on torture is yet. I understand that you are saying that the prisoners have control over whether to talk or not, but wouldn't that be the same reasoning used in the Spanish inquistion? I also don't know the torture laws or how they are followed. 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

I don't know what the right answer is but lets say we could possibly save hundreds of thousands of lives compared to one or two to get information. You make that call. Who lives and who suffers a little? 

steinhoister --- 17 years ago -

 

Allimama --- 17 years ago -

I know JFF, it's one of those truly tough morality calls. Do you remember the question: You are hiding from Nazi soldiers in an attic and are holding a small baby. Suddenly the baby begins to cry. If you cannot stop the crying, your entire party will be found and sentenced to death in a concentration camp. Do you smother the child to save the party? I know that terrorists can't be compared with innocent babies, but you get the similarities. In the above scenario, I've always thought that it would be immoral to smother the baby, because the end never justifies the means. However, I can't help but want my child safe from terrorists who want to harm him, simply because was born an American. I can't figure this one out. Thanks for the video Stein, I wasn't sure what waterboarding really was. 

Allimama --- 17 years ago -

Has anyone thought about this from a Christian perspective? Any realizations? 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

I know that terrorists can't be compared with innocent babies, but you get the similarities. In the above scenario, I've always thought that it would be immoral to smother the baby, because the end never justifies the means. However, I can't help but want my child safe from terrorists who want to harm him, simply because was born an American. Would I want to or would I smother my child? That is so very hard because we don't have that mentality here in this country so It's hard to answer. At this very moment would I smother my child, no. Could I do it to save others, I'm not sure? Would I want or allow my child to survive to suffer who knows what at the hands of enemies, never. 

Allimama --- 17 years ago -

Hmm, I hadn't thought about what the baby would go through in the hands of the Nazis jff. Good point. Now I have to rethink my whole answer. So what would Christ think about torture. Surely He would be against it, right? 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

Hmm, I hadn't thought about what the baby would go through in the hands of the Nazis jff. Good point. Now I have to rethink my whole answer. So what would Christ think about torture. Surely He would be against it, right? That I'm not sure of either. The Bible talks of judging so that's a toughie. Maybe someone else could answer this for us. 

JohnLynch --- 17 years ago -

Water Boarding not Torture by a Long Shot Water boarding is misclassified as torture. Only three terrorists were ever waterboarded in the US. by Kevin Roeten Friday, May 8, 2009 Many redefine definitions, and readjust known words to fit one's politics. It's been done before, and is being done now. Definitions of marriage, movie ratings, euthanasia, adultery, and torture have all been changed and modified to fit what many say they should mean. If one takes the word "torture", the Thorndike-Barnhart dictionary defines the word as "the act of inflicting very severe pain; a very severe pain or sufferingagony". That definition was published in 1979. That definition includes eye gouging, electrical shock, cutting out of tongues, cutting off appendages, putting live bodies into shredders, etc., etcare normally employed by your average terrorist. Now, many roll a number of other items into that definition called "enhanced interrogation methods". They include "walling" (people pay' to have rougher things done to them at Cedar Point Amusement Park), the "attention grasp", the "facial slap", "dietary manipulation", "sleep deprivation", a "stinging insect" (harmless caterpillar), and worst of all"water boarding" (simulated drowning). 

freshhell --- 17 years ago -

If torture is not ok for your kids, it is not ok for anyone else's kids. We are Americans. We don't do this, ever. That is what makes us better than other countries. 

freshhell --- 17 years ago -

Only three terrorists were ever waterboarded in the US. Surely you know that most of our torture is done offshore. 

Allimama --- 17 years ago -

We are Americans. We don't do this, ever. That is what makes us better than other countries. See, I think I agree with this. 

JohnLynch --- 17 years ago -

I do not believe in torture, but I also do not believe that waterboarding is torture. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 17 years ago -

I do not believe in torture, but I also do not believe that waterboarding is torture I believe that JohnLynch is a tool that likes to follow momof5 all over ku. 

JohnLynch --- 17 years ago -

Surely you know that most of our torture is done offshore. Surely you understand that anywhere our military has a base, it is sovereign U.S. territory whether it is offshore or not. We are Americans. We don't do this, ever. That is what makes us better than other countries. Are you serious? You worry about whether or not we waterboard some terrorist. We aren't better than other countries. We murder babies in the womb. How naive. 

JohnLynch --- 17 years ago -

I believe that JohnLynch is a tool that likes to follow momof5 all over ku. I do not care about momof5. She just happens to have made some outrageous statements today. I can't believe anyone could really think that way. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 17 years ago -

Surely you understand that anywhere our military has a base, it is sovereign U.S. territory whether it is offshore or not. First of all, we farmed out torture to other countries, so it wasn't on our bases. We captured them and turned them over to people that we knew would torture, that was what the rendition program was all about. Are you serious? You worry about whether or not we waterboard some terrorist. We aren't better than other countries. We murder babies in the womb. How naive We have been better than the backward 3rd world and inquisition minded countries that still continue this barbaric practice. Just because you believe that every little sperm is sacred doesn't make abortion equal to torture. That is debate about when life begins, not a debate over what is humane or inhumane treatment of an unarguably living being. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 17 years ago -

I can't believe anyone could really think that way. Well... I'm going to see how you think John. I'm your new bestie! 

JohnLynch --- 17 years ago -

Just because you believe that every little sperm is sacred doesn't make abortion equal to torture. That is debate about when life begins, not a debate over what is humane or inhumane treatment of an unarguably living being. This has nothing to do with sperm. You are right. Abortion is not equal to torture. It is worse. It doesn't matter that I believe that life begins at conception. Abortions occur long after conception and when there is definite life. And we are not better than any other country as long as we continue the barbaric practice of abortion. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 17 years ago -

And we are not better than any other country as long as we continue the barbaric practice of abortion Is the U.S. the only country that performs abortion? So I guess we can only be better than the ones that do. Those other countries we just will have to aspire to be better than. Funny. My guess is the countries you will find that don't perform abortions will most often fall in the muslim run variety. You know.... the countries that hate us and treat their woman like property. 

JohnLynch --- 17 years ago -

Is the U.S. the only country that performs abortion? No, but what does that have to do with anything. We shouldn't base our actions on what others do "if we are to be better". Just because others do it, that doesn't justify it. So I guess we can only be better than the do What does that mean? Only better than "the do"? You know.... the countries that hate us and treat their woman like property. We treat our women like property when we use them for sex and then dispose of the consequences. Those countries do hate us and it is mainly because of our lack of morals. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 17 years ago -

Those countries do hate us and it is mainly because of our lack of morals Oh, I see it's our fault they hate us. How can you say this. Do you hate America? They hate us not because our "lack of morals" but because they think their imaginary friend is better tha our imaginary friend. As per usual... religion is the problem. 

JohnLynch --- 17 years ago -

Oh, I see it's our fault they hate us. There goes that liberal mindset. Where did I say that it was our fault? They hate us not because our "lack of morals" but because they think their imaginary friend is better tha our imaginary friend. As per usual... religion is the problem. It is actually our lack of morality that they hate. They actually believe that our God is the same as their God. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 17 years ago -

There goes that liberal mindset. Where did I say that it was our fault? Actually, it's normally libs that try to point out the reasons they hate us, and they are usually treated with the response I gave you. It is actually our lack of morality that they hate. They actually believe that our God is the same as their God. You are correct sir. They believe that their god, the christian god, and the Jewish god are the same. Doesn't stop them from hating Israel does it? They also believe (the more extreme Muslims) that it is their duty to make the world Islamic and to follow shariah law. So is it really the morals or is it because they're religous fanatics? The answer is obvious. 

JohnLynch --- 17 years ago -

Actually, it's normally libs that try to point out the reasons they hate us, and they are usually treated with the response I gave you. You didn't answer my question. The liberal dodge,,, They also believe (the more extreme Muslims) that it is their duty to make the world Islamic and to follow shariah law. Are "the more extreme Muslims" really Muslim? So is it really the morals or is it because they're religous fanatics? I have already answered that and it is because of morals - our lack of them. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 17 years ago -

You didn't answer my question. The liberal dodge,,, Apparently you need the obvious pointed out to you. If you are saying that "our" lack of morals is what they hate you are inferring that it is our fault they hate us. Simple. The same argument that is given to libs when they have tried to point out that some of our policies in the middle east have led to some of the anger. Are "the more extreme Muslims" really Muslim? Yes. I have already answered that and it is because of morals - our lack of them And you were wrong. 

Allimama --- 17 years ago -

The radical Muslims don't hate us because of our lack of morals--that's just their excuse. They hate us because they used to be the top--think about their developments in mathematics centuries ago, and now they are in total poverty. The west has surpassed them in education, wealth and power and they can't figure out what happened. They are mad that Israel was reinstated and that the Israelis are much better off than they are. They are looking for someone to blame for their plight, and the Koran allows for hatred of Christians and Jews--so there you have it. It could only be the work of evil that we are so much more successful given our lack of Sharia law. They are brainwashed into this hatred as children and grow up blaming us for everything wrong with their lives and political climates. They are awaiting the return of the 12th Imam who will restore them to power and help them kill all of the Christians and Jews. The real radicals, (leader of Iran for one) thinks they can bring the Imam back early by killing off America and Israel (Great Satan and little Satan). It's some scary stuff. The good news is that there are plenty of reformists tying to "take back" the religion of Islam from the radicals, and there is a Christianity explosion going on over there that will hopefully start to change some of the dynamic. 

JohnLynch --- 17 years ago -

The radical Muslims don't hate us because of our lack of morals--that's just their excuse. They say that they despise our lack of morals. How is it that you are able to discern that it is only an excuse? They are looking for someone to blame for their plight, and the Koran allows for hatred of Christians and Jews--so there you have it. I am a Christian. Eventhough the Koran is not the Word of God, it does not "allow hatred" for Christians and Jews. Don't know where you got that false information. 

voice of reason --- 17 years ago -

I do not believe in torture, but I also do not believe that waterboarding is torture. if they waterboarded you, you would call it torture. 

R.E.B. --- 17 years ago -

Torture is not supposed to be fun. It is supposed to make the suspect spill the beans. I see three ways they do it; Pain, Fear and fatigue. I oppose using pain(or any technique that damages or maims), but I don’t have a problem with fear (Waterboarding falls in this category) or fatigue. I do feel, however, that they better have evidence to support the suspect might have information that would save lives. Here is a question: If they could have prevented 9/11 from waterboarding the information out of one of the Hijackers, would you have supported that? 

Meme2my5 --- 17 years ago -

Here is a question: If they could have prevented 9/11 from waterboarding the information out of one of the Hijackers, would you have supported that? Yes, I would. If I knew they had helped in planning and carrying out 9/11 I would still do it. There are over 1300 children that are orphaned from 9/11 and altogther almost 2800 children are bereaved from this. The torture and pain they live with everyday is a whole hell of a lot worse than waterboarding. I'm sure they wish that's all that happened to their parents. 

MomTimesFive --- 17 years ago -

I would call waterboarding extremely unpleasant, but my idea of torture is that it is something that maims or causes excruciating physical pain. 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

Here is a question: If they could have prevented 9/11 from waterboarding the information out of one of the Hijackers, would you have supported that? that's an unfair question because we can't go back and change it. There's no way to predict if what they're telling you is the truth when it's coming from torture, because they'll say anything to get it to stop, and they'll hate you for doing it in the first place, making it easier for them to lie. JMO. I don't have the answers, but I think torture is wrong, period. 

R.E.B. --- 17 years ago -

that's an unfair question because we can't go back and change it. I don't think it is unfair, but okay, lets say it is. They are saying that waterboarding an Al Qaeda suspect prevented a 9/11 type attack against Los Angeles. Was that worth it? 

voice of reason --- 17 years ago -

Here is a question: If they could have prevented 9/11 from waterboarding the information out of one of the Hijackers, would you have supported that? they didn't need waterboarding. they had evidence the attack was coming and the idiots ignored it. 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

I don't think it is unfair, but okay, lets say it is. They are saying that waterboarding an Al Qaeda suspect prevented a 9/11 type attack against Los Angeles. Was that worth it? Again, there's no way to know for sure that going a different route wouldn't get the same or better results. I'm not saying we should give them fuzzy blankets and kittens, but severe torture is wrong. We should be better than those that use torture, look what they do in these African nations, torture, rape, horrible disgusting things. I do not want to be in the same boat as they are, EVER. 

R.E.B. --- 17 years ago -

they didn't need waterboarding. they had evidence the attack was coming and the idiots ignored it. Nice dodge. If waterboarding a terrorist could have prevented the attack, would it have been worth it? If you are saying such acts are immoral, and you want America to take the high road, then you will have to accept the losses that come with it… and next time they could be your loved ones. Are you ready to sacrifice them to take this moral high ground? This is an honest question that America must realize and accept if we want to give up torture as a means to gain information. Don't dodge it. 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

If waterboarding a terrorist could have prevented the attack, would it have been worth it? If you are saying such acts are immoral, and you want America to take the high road, then you will have to accept the losses that come with it… and next time they could be you loved ones. Are you ready to sacrifice them to take this moral high ground. See, that's the thing REB, there's no way to know FOR SURE that torture would be the only way to get the information ahead of time. So, I cannot give you a conclusive answer, because I don't think there is a conclusive answer. I think when you use torture as a means to get information, you're setting yourself up to get wrong info because they just want it to stop, and they're hating you every moment it is occuring. If that's a "liberal dodge" to you, I don't know what to tell you. That's my honest opinion. I'm against the death penalty too, because sometimes, the wrong guy gets sent to prison, and I think death is the easy way out for some of the sickos on death row. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground