Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

How to Fix the Economy

who's talking here?

Carla 1
maverick 23
ukchristine 1
AuthorMan 10
NoNameNoLastName 1
CommonSense 11
donottreadonme 1
Cicero 5
R.E.B. 1
Bliz 3
david 3
~sassy~ 1
rEVOLution 2
MomTimesFive 1
Nightstorm 7
RiteWingKing 14
keepinitreal09 4
PS 1
Allimama 1
Hiro Protagonist 2
TakeTheGlovesOff 4
razumikhin 2
RCSKI 1
voice of reason 14
wordman777 1
jtcitrus 3
NewNanna 1
TommyTwoToes 1
Stella111 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

CommonSense --- 17 years ago -

I believe the name John Maynard Keynes is going to be coming up a lot more in the coming months and years of the Obama Administration, so I figured I would give a small explanation of the Keynesian Multiplier and its effect on the economy since it is at the heart of the new stimulus bill. I also figured this is a good way to quantitatively prove that Bush tax cuts are idiotic (as any economist will tell you) for all those whose solution is cutting taxes. The concept is simple: +The government creates an exogenous increase in spending +People receiving the money spend most of it +Money spent means businesses need more workers, who in turn spend more, so on and so forth (of course this is a greatly simplified model) So when Obama gives, say, $20 million to fix a failing bridge that $20 million does not stop there. The construction workers are going to drop by the local restaurants for lunch, which in turn means more employment there and those people going other places to spend money. The workers may also get a new computer at home, a new car, smash a few cell phones by accident and replace them, etc. All this with their wages. Part of it goes to suppliers too, who in turn spend it on other things like better equipment, employees, etc. And obviously the owner of the construction company with the contract will spend more and probably save some as well, which in turn becomes more money through fractional reserves (outside the scope of this though). Different actions by the government have different multipliers. Instead of boring you with equations you may go to Mark Zandi's page on economy.com here and download the PDFs where he neatly figured it all out and presents the results. If there are any skeptics I will be glad to provide you the actual equations and you can pull the economic data off the Treasury site and do it yourself. The good stuff: Republicans' solutions: Bush tax cuts provides a multiplier of .31 Cutting corporate tax rates provides a multiplier of .30 Capital gains tax elimination has a multiplier of .38 Democrats' solutions: Extend unemployment insurance = multiplier of 1.63 Temporary increase in food stamps = 1.73 multiplier Infrastructure spending = a multiplier of 1.59 Multiplier = the effect of one dollar on GDP. This means that the $20 million bridge upgrade in my example above becomes 31.8 million in the economy. If instead you just gave a corporation an additional 20 million in tax cuts it would shrink to 6 million in the GDP. I'll add in this pretty picture from the source above too:  

NewNanna --- 17 years ago -

I hope what Obama's done will work, and am greateful that he's looking out for everyone not just the rich few like Bush did. 

rEVOLution --- 17 years ago -

While I'm not a supporter of bailouts or more government spending of tax payers dollars against their will, I'm also not any sort of expert on the economy or how we should fix it. This was something that a friend sent me on his thoughts on how to fix the economy. http://www.kingwoodunderground.com/topic.jsp?topicId=11302235 

AuthorMan --- 17 years ago -

I believe the name John Maynard Keynes is going to be coming up a lot more in the coming months and years of the Obama Administration So will the names Karl Marx, Stalin, Lenin, etc. 

rEVOLution --- 17 years ago -

So will the names Karl Marx, Stalin, Lenin, etc. You hear those names almost daily on talk radio these days. And I've heard the name Hitler more in the past year than I ever have in my life. While I don't see O as Hitler I certainly don't like all of the Government expansion. Our constitution calls for less government and it has done nothing but grown over the past few decades. 

AuthorMan --- 17 years ago -

So when Obama gives, say, $20 million to fix a failing bridge that $20 million does not stop there. The construction workers are going to drop by the local restaurants for lunch, which in turn means more employment there and those people going other places to spend money. 25% of construction jobs goes to labor. The rest is material, equipment, overhead, etc. So 25% wounds up in people's hands. Plus, when the job is complete, who is going to replace the workers at the diner? Guess the added labor goes home again. Put the money (100%) in the hands of the people. Works better. 

razumikhin --- 17 years ago -

The rest is material, equipment, overhead, etc. So 25% wounds up in people's hands. All the material, equipment, etc had to be manufactured involving labor, so that portion (75% by your estimate) largely goes into "people's hands" also (or as return of capital employed by the entrepeneurs who ran the manufacturing enterprise). 

CommonSense --- 17 years ago -

So will the names Karl Marx, Stalin, Lenin, etc What a constructive, well-versed, intelligent reply. Did you even read past the first sentence or two? Put the money (100%) in the hands of the people. Works better. Never mind, that answers it. Read the bold portion, I already addresses this commonly-held and very false belief. 

Carla --- 17 years ago -

Theory is great, but facts are better. The Bush tax cuts resulted in an increase in total tax collected from the wealthiest 5 percent. Economists do not agree that the stimulus is the correct course. The current stimulus bill is the New Deal Part II. Economists are split on whether the first New Deal helped or just actually prolonged the Great Depression. What they do agree on is that Republicans gaining back control of Congress in the 1936 election relieved fears and investment picked up almost immediately. You know, if companies weren't afraid that they were going to get beat into the ground with taxes, reinstating the projects that they put on hold would have the same effect. Businesses buy from suppliers and pay their employees. They in turn spend money in the economy. Prosperity is about the flow of money, and the government isn't necessary to make it churn. 

razumikhin --- 17 years ago -

Theory is great, but facts are better. Exactly. Lets hope the economists are working overtime during this recession. All of these multipliers, effects, etc. that people argue about are testable hypotheses using modern econometrics. We should learn a lot no matter what happens. 

david --- 17 years ago -

Ahhh but we c,t forget this construction owner also has to pay higher taxes for that 20 million contract how many employees did he not hire to offset the tax? 

CommonSense --- 17 years ago -

Theory is great, but facts are better. The Bush tax cuts resulted in an increase in total tax collected from the wealthiest 5 percent. This isn't pure theory. Yes it's impossible to measure precisely due to a lot of variables but there is a lot of truth. There's graphs and everything illustrating it. If you go on the link I gave you there is a lot more info. Economists are split on whether the first New Deal helped or just actually prolonged the Great Depression. See for yourself: Production in the Great Depression Unemployment: The New Deal started got rolling in 1933 The recession in 1937 was caused by the government trying to balance its budget before the economy was ready for it. Keynes argued for more deficit spending. After the beginning of WWII at the end of 1939 it is difficult to measure the effect of the New Deal due to war exports. Ahhh but we c,t forget this construction owner also has to pay higher taxes for that 20 million contract how many employees did he not hire to offset the tax? This is all accounted for in the figures in bold and the links. 

AuthorMan --- 17 years ago -

Never mind, that answers it. Read the bold portion, I already addresses this commonly-held and very false belief. Laughable, at best. Keep trying to push this crapola. Thanks for the laughs, but serious economic analysis is not portrayed here. Send it back to the White House for another, maybe more believable version. 

CommonSense --- 17 years ago -

Laughable, at best. Keep trying to push this crapola. Thanks for the laughs, but serious economic analysis is not portrayed here. Fine, feel free to share your "serious economic analysis" as a rebuttal. I look forward to your reply. 

AuthorMan --- 17 years ago -

Keynes: English economist who advocated the use of government monetary and fiscal policy to maintain full employment without inflation (1883-1946). And just when did we have this wonderful mix? 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

I may not know HOW to fix the economy but I sure as hell know how NOT to fix it. You can't spend your way out of debt. The president needs to get a clue! 

Bliz --- 17 years ago -

If you want to increase the GDP, here is one really easy way to do it: 1) use very expensive bombs from our own military to blow up most major cities in the US. 2) Rebuild all the destroyed cities. This will lead to increased need for labor and construction materials. 3) Replace all the bombs used in step one, which will further aid manufacturing and defense companies. The point is, GDP is not necessarily the best way to measure economic progress. 

Bliz --- 17 years ago -

Keynes was quite a guy...here is a quote: "By a continuous process of inflation, governments can confiscate, secretly and unobserved, an important part of the wealth of their citizens. By this method, they not only confiscate, but they confiscate arbitrarily; and while the process impoverishes many, it actually enriches some....The process engages all of the hidden forces of economic law on the side of destruction, and does it in a manner that not one man in a million can diagnose." - John Maynard Keynes Economic Consequences of the Peace, 1920 

donottreadonme --- 17 years ago -

Let talk about debt!  

CommonSense --- 17 years ago -

Keynes: English economist who advocated the use of government monetary and fiscal policy to maintain full employment without inflation (1883-1946). And just when did we have this wonderful mix? You know you can selectively put in little info boxes about him but this entire country became the greatest nation on earth running on his economic principles. He is also the father of macroeconomics, among other things. The world economy is run the way it is thanks to him. This isn't some random guy here, he has shaped our lives more than you will ever know. I may not know HOW to fix the economy but I sure as hell know how NOT to fix it. You can't spend your way out of debt. The president needs to get a clue! You need to get a clue. I just posted proof that that is the exact way to stimulate the economy. Read the bold section in my original post. You can't try to get out of debt in a down economy unless you want to tank it entirely. And who put that debt there? The point is, GDP is not necessarily the best way to measure economic progress. I agree, but the same economic policies which boost the GDP as outlined above also lower unemployment, close the inequality gap, and fight inflation. Keynes predicted the German Hyperinflation and helped prevent the same thing from happening to Britain after World War II by telling them to pay for the war with higher taxes and not deficit spending. Looks like Bush & Co should have taken Economics 101, we'd be much better off. That is an excellent quote on inflation. 

Allimama --- 17 years ago -

I agree that the President's in that graph waaaaayyyyyy overspent what they were supposed to. I heard a guy on Glen Beck the other night who sent a thank you note to the pub party for teaching dems how to REALLY spend. LOL The only problem is that Obama is not on that graph. Wouldn't the latest stimulus dwarf the rest of the spenders? 

AuthorMan --- 17 years ago -

Keynes predicted the German Hyperinflation and helped prevent the same thing from happening to Britain after World War II by telling them to pay for the war with higher taxes and not deficit spending. Looks like Bush & Co should have taken Economics 101, we'd be much better off. Looks like o is the idiot here. In your own quote, what saved Britain after a war was not deficit spending. So what does o do after the expense of the war on terror? The biggest deficit spending spree on record. Make a decision on what is good and be consistent with it. BTW- I student taught micro economics while in grad school in Lamar, 1973-1974. 

AuthorMan --- 17 years ago -

And, to answer your brilliant reply to my list of econuts, I give you: In every so-called capitalist economy, the problems of poverty and boom/bust cycles have deepened as technological and material progress went on. This observation led Karl Marx to theorize that the capitalist economy could not be sustained, that it was only a stage in a larger historical process. Marx thought that industrial workers would become so downtrodden and alienated that they would eventually throw off the control of the capitalists and seize the means of production (land and capital) to create a new form of economy. In the socialist economy that would follow, most economic decisions would not be made for private gain, but in the communal interest of the entire society. This would lead to a "planned economy", in which decisions about production and distribution would be made by the government. By all outward appearances, it seems o is attempting to guide us down this path. 

maverick --- 17 years ago -

Most economist do not agree. Obama and company get failing grades. Source 

Bliz --- 17 years ago -

throw off the control of the capitalists and seize the means of production (land and capital) to create a new form of economy The part left off of this is that not everybody works at once to seize control...only the first movers who also happen to be organized thugs will be successful in seizing control. Then, what you have is not communal property, but tyranny and dictators who run things instead of a failing democratic republic. It does not have to be this way, but if it goes the way Marx suggests, dictatorship is the destination. 

Cicero --- 17 years ago -

The people in office don't want to fix the economy. They want to make certain people rich and the rest of us dependent of the government. 

R.E.B. --- 17 years ago -

How to Fix the Economy? Send Obama, Pelosi and Reid on a four year vacation far, far away. 

Cicero --- 17 years ago -

True Capitalism works if you let it work. The problem is that we have an interest based economy. Interest based economies cannot work in the long term. Everyone eventually ends up working just to make interest payments. 

voice of reason --- 17 years ago -

great post, common sense. 

voice of reason --- 17 years ago -

True Capitalism works if you let it work. The problem is that we have an interest based economy. the true problem is that the human life form contains a huge greed factor. 

Cicero --- 17 years ago -

LMFAO!!! This was the M.O. of the Bush years. Not only did they want to make but a few rich, they actually DID do that!!!!! Stop talking about the "Bush" years. Bush is out of office. Move on with your life and stop living in the past. If I'm not mistaken our CURRENT CONGRESS and OUR CURRENT PRESIDENT just borrowed $800 Billion from our children. I'm sure that in your Commie Fantasy land all of that money is used to "create jobs" and goes directly to the people who "need" it. But in reality that money only further empowers the top players in the game. 

ukchristine --- 17 years ago -

WOW...I never knew what a WONDERFUL President Jummy Carter was during his entire 4 years. I lived through it and though he was the WORST...just goes to show how I and so many more were soooooooooooo wrong. With double diget inflation and mortgages whoda thunk he would end up THE BEST (according to donottreadonme's graph.? And for one year (2000) Bill clinton was better than everybody else by a loooooong way. 

voice of reason --- 17 years ago -

Stop talking about the "Bush" years. Bush is out of office. Move on with your life and stop living in the past. first of all, i can speak of whatever i wish. secondly, as long as i am feeling the impact of the bush years in my day to day life, this makes discussion of him a current event. as for the $800 billion, bush did the same. economic theory and the top economists who advised both presidents all agree on this. 

Cicero --- 17 years ago -

first of all, i can speak of whatever i wish. secondly, as long as i am feeling the impact of the bush years in my day to day life, this makes discussion of him a current event. as for the $800 billion, bush did the same. economic theory and the top economists who advised both presidents all agree on this. see common sense's thread on all this. You can speak whatever you wish but playing the blame game doesn't help anything. How far back do you want to go with this game? 1800's? 1700's? It doesn't start with "Bush". The thread is called "HOW TO FIX THE ECONOMY", not 'Who can we blame our problems on'. You don't know what you're feeling the effects of. You could be feeling the effects of policies implemented by William Taft for all you know. 

AuthorMan --- 17 years ago -

You could be feeling the effects of policies implemented by William Taft for all you know. Or, it could just be gas. :-) 

NoNameNoLastName --- 17 years ago -

Move on with your life and stop living in the past. We can't. Bush's screw ups are still haunting us, and they will for a long time. Great post, commonsense. I find it amazing how conservatives have no concrete data to prove their theories - only Rush yelling at the top of his lungs. 

david --- 17 years ago -

I'm so tired of hearing about rush what about the 51% of dems that wanted bush to fail...hypocrites 

RiteWingKing --- 17 years ago -

DITTO!!!!! Also, Common, I am a student of the Keynesian Multiplier from my education and I thank you for your post to those who are unfamiliar with this economic conceptual!!! So am I and what really scares me is the following statement: "My members are highly skeptical that we can spend our way out of this particular problem," Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell said on Wednesday. Thank the good lord we didn't elect McCain and Mitch is the Minority leader . We would be all standing in the soup lines discussing this while the GOP tried to balance the budget. 

voice of reason --- 17 years ago -

You can speak whatever you wish but playing the blame game doesn't help anything. will you be telling this to all the pubs who bash obama daily because of the stock market and other things that are not within his personal control? 

voice of reason --- 17 years ago -

We would be all standing in the soup lines discussing this while the GOP tried to balance the budget. that's a good one! plus i didn't even know the pubs understood the balanced budget concept since bush was handed one and through it out the window. i'm glad to hear obama has plans to work back towards achieving one in his first term. 

page 1 2 3 4
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

news
politics


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground