Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Who's to Blame for High Oil and Gas Prices?

who's talking here?

stampin' gal 1
bbjones 3
kjones0125 2
girlsRus 1
jemezchick 1
Puppy again 1
mykidsmom 2
AuthorMan 2
Tyrus 3
NoNameNoLastName 1
gumbeauxgirl 1
Mr Mark 1
accent_ 1
donottreadonme 3
R.E.B. 2
AFWife 2
haroldoftherocks 4
get_the_lead_out! 2
david 1
BFC_Fitness 1
shortfuse 7
IceTea*4*Me 1
~MommyofMonkeys~ 1
SelfDefenseDude 1
wildflower 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Tyrus --- 18 years ago -

by Ben Stein Posted on Friday, March 17, 2006, 12:00AM Executives of the big oil companies have been hauled before the U.S. Senate recently to defend their industry's recent mergers and record profits as American consumers face high oil and gasoline prices. I'm going to defend the big energy companies in this case, since I think they're not the reason for high prices. Before you write me angry e-mails, dear reader, let me first lay down some street credibility. Yes, I'm a gray-haired guy now. But I've spent a lot of time in my life as an antipoverty lawyer in New Haven, Conn., and in Washington, D.C., helping very poor people with their legal woes. I also spent years as a lawyer working on prosecuting false and deceptive advertising. Probably the lion's share of my adult life was spent writing about financial fraud for financial publication Barron's, and I helped put a number of fraudulent entities out of business. I also testified against a number of fraudulent managements in lawsuits, both state and federal, and I still often write about injustice in the boardroom. That being said, I also know how a lynch mob operates. After all, if there's a problem, some cause has to be found. And it's really lovely if the cause can be someone rich and powerful so that we can work off our envy and also take the intoxicating drug of anger. Anger organizes our emotions, lines them up, removes ambiguity, and feels good. Urge to Crack Down So, the mob goes after someone to lynch, even if that person is innocent. After all, as the immortal Bob Dylan sang long ago, "A lot of people have knives and forks, and they don't have nothing on their plates, and they have to cut something." This comes to mind because of the recent actions in the U.S. Senate that attempt to "crack down" on energy companies because the price of oil is so much higher than it used to be and because one large oil concern, Exxon (XOM), is reporting very large profits (after many years of modest earnings). The crackdown takes the form of preventing oil companies from merging or at least making it much harder for them to merge. The idea is that the energy companies have been fixing prices at artificially high levels, and if they merge, they'll just do it more. This idea is apparently backed even by someone as wise as Senator Arlen Specter (Rep.-Pa.), Chairman of the Judiciary Committee and a fellow graduate of Yale Law School. No Conspiracy The only problem with this idea is that it's based on a totally false premise. The energy companies don't set the price of oil or of gasoline. The prices you pay for heating oil or gasoline aren't set in boardrooms in Texas but in trading rooms at commodities markets all over the world. Gas prices aren't set in shadowy conferences in shooting lodges, but in rooms of people shouting or punching computer keys in London, New York, and Tokyo. Oil is a world commodity like tin or copper or rubber or coffee. The price is set by traders anticipating supply and demand. Rumors of war in the Mideast, terrorism against oil platforms in Nigeria, warmer weather in New England, bitter cold in London -- these are what set energy prices. Even the biggest U.S. energy companies are tiny pawns in the game compared with the world market, flotsam and jetsam in the ocean of world oil trading. So, when prices go up or down, it's not a conspiracy. It's panic or confidence in the market. It's just like what happens on the stock markets every trading day -- greed or fear at work, not at the companies being traded but on the exchanges. The oil companies can either lose or gain from this trading. Hobbling the Oil Companies I know this is hard news to digest because who do we hate then? Well, some think we solve the problem by just hating and blaming the innocent -- in this case, the oil companies, dragging them from their beds, and lynching them. So what if they're innocent? Someone's got to pay. The only problem is that if we keep punishing the companies that in good faith give us the energy we need to power our lives at market prices -- which sometimes give them a big profit and sometimes give them a small one -- eventually, they'll go away. Or they won't have the ability to do their jobs as well because of all the restrictions we've put on them. Never mind, some think. A lot of people have knives and forks, and they don't have nothing on their plates, and they have to cut something. 

SelfDefenseDude --- 18 years ago -

According to Schlumberger (www.slb.com) the US gets most of its oil from Mexico, Canada and Venezuela 

AFWife --- 18 years ago -

The only problem with this idea is that it's based on a totally false premise. The energy companies don't set the price of oil or of gasoline. The prices you pay for heating oil or gasoline aren't set in boardrooms in Texas but in trading rooms at commodities markets all over the world. Well said...I'm so tired of hearing boycott oil companies...well sorry, my family works for some of those companies and ya'll really need to find out what you are really so-called "boycotting" 

girlsRus --- 18 years ago -

I know what you mean AFWife, my family works for an oil company and for some reason idiots out there think we get free gas... I WISH!!! We pay the same prices everyone else does! 

BFC_Fitness --- 18 years ago -

Great post and very well presented. 

gumbeauxgirl --- 18 years ago -

Correct me if I'm wrong. The problem I have is that while the oil companies are generating huge profits they aren't investing in new/more refining capabilities. Of course speculation is a huge factor in the price we pay, but there are also times when the price goes up because of refining issues. Our population is increasing, our consumption is increasing... with record profits wouldn't now be the time to invest in increasing our refining capacity? 

donottreadonme --- 18 years ago -

The price is set by traders anticipating supply and demand. The blame is greed, no surprise here. Push prices to help the few and charge the Many. 

kjones0125 --- 18 years ago -

high five to Ben! :) 

shortfuse --- 18 years ago -

Hello Tyrus. How are you? 

kjones0125 --- 18 years ago -

Correct me if I'm wrong. The problem I have is that while the oil companies are generating huge profits they aren't investing in new/more refining capabilities. Hello! Yes, they are spending a lot of their profit on finding new sources of oil etc. The environmental laws are so strict that it's nearly impossible to build any new refineries. Plus, even if a company decides to build a new one, it takes many years (not days or months) to build because of contracts, laws, etc. If a company decided today to build a new refinery, it probably would not come online for at least 10 years. Building a refinery is not a quick fix to the high gas prices. Of course speculation is a huge factor in the price we pay, but there are also times when the price goes up because of refining issues. Yes that is true. If a refinery blows up, or gets knocked out because of a hurricane, then the price goes up. Our population is increasing, our consumption is increasing... with record profits wouldn't now be the time to invest in increasing our refining capacity? See above note about refining and environmental laws. It's faster and less expensive to repair the refineries we have now than to build new ones. I believe I heard or read where some company is building a new refinery somewhere?? (LOL) but it will be years before it's ready to be online. 

R.E.B. --- 18 years ago -

You can blame the environmentalist and the Democrats in Congress who won’t let us drill in Alaska. You could blame China and India for increase competition. You could blame us, the consumers for increasing demand. You could blame those large pick-up trucks and SUV’s I see going 80-90 mph every morning, burning up fuel. If they were going 60-65 mph, they would burn up less fuel. If they would get a lighter vehicle, they would burn up less fuel. And there are probably many more we could blame. If we really want to solve this problem, we would switch over to electric vehicles and use nuclear, solar and wind power plants to generate the electricity. 

donottreadonme --- 18 years ago -

If we really want to solve this problem, we would switch over to electric vehicles and use nuclear, solar and wind power plants to generate the electricity. Give that man a gold star!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 

Mr Mark --- 18 years ago -

After blame is established, the qusestion becomes...What to do about it? 

donottreadonme --- 18 years ago -

Oil should be taken off of the commodities market. It is not a speculative luxury anymore it is a necessity. I completely agree with this. like I said before greed and profit for the few on the backs of the many. What to do about it? Short term - switch from Corn to switch grass. Bio diesel for trucks, 2007 and newer tractors already can use it. Long term what R.E.B said, people can do a lot when they put there minds to it. 

bbjones --- 18 years ago -

The problem I have is that while the oil companies are generating huge profits they aren't investing in new/more refining capabilities. The reason they are not investing in new/more refining capabilities is because environmental regulations, which make it almost impossible to permit any new facilities, and the NIMBY syndrome. 

haroldoftherocks --- 18 years ago -

Yes, hooray for the oil companies, who cares if they're getting sickeningly rich while bleeding the bank accounts of Americans. Yay! I hope they report 20 billion in profit for FQ1 this year. It was only 14 billion this time last year, but that was only the top two companies. I know what you're thinking, decency tells us that in order to alleviate the problem they could cut their margin a little bit and save the economy just a little bit, but hey! theres yachts to buy and mansions to pay for... 

R.E.B. --- 18 years ago -

Short term - switch from Corn to switch grass. Bio diesel for trucks, 2007 and newer tractors already can use it. That would help. Also drilling for oil in Alaska and off the coast of Florida (And hopefully this new oil catch in the northern plains will pan out). It will take us a few years to get off our oil dependency, so we will still need some. 

Tyrus --- 18 years ago -

Yes, hooray for the oil companies, It looks like someone did not read the article. The following is from an article by Christopher Moore. "How much profit does the average oil company make on an average gallon of gas right now? The answer will surprise you — $0.09. How much do you pay in taxes on the average gallon of gas? You probably won’t be surprised by this one — $0.50. So if the oil companies, out of the goodness of their hearts, decided to go non-profit then the cost of an average gallon of gas would drop from $2.92 down to $2.83. You’d save an average of $54 per year. And millions of retirees and pensioners who’s fixed incomes depend on their investments in oil companies would be eating dog food. But we forget that corporations are comprised of individual stockholders when there is an election. Oil company profits don’t look that big anymore, and price gouging doesn’t seem to be the problem. But what about tax gouging? Drop $0.50 from the price and you’re down to $2.42. You just saved an average of $300 per year. So if gouging is going on, then who’s the biggest gouger? ExxonMobil Corp. reported $10 billion in net income in the third quarter, the largest ever by a U.S. energy company. So a back of the envelope estimate would yield a government profit of about $50 billion over the same period. And the government didn’t have to drill for a single barrel of oil! So how can a politician rail against Big Oil profits when their own votes in congress and state legislatures lead to windfall profits for the federal and state treasuries at the expense of yours and my paycheck." 

IceTea*4*Me --- 18 years ago -

Oil Rises Above $118 a Barrel on Supply Concerns By THE ASSOCIATED PRESS Filed at 12:18 p.m. ET NEW YORK (AP) -- Gas and oil prices moved further into record high territory Tuesday, with retail gas reaching a national average of $3.51 for the first time and crude nearing $120 as the dollar fell to a new low against the euro. At the pump, the national average price of a gallon of regular gas rose 0.8 cent Tuesday to $3.511, according to a survey of stations by AAA and the Oil Price Information Service. Prices for diesel -- the fuel used for the transport of most food, industrial and commercial goods -- also rose overnight to a new record of $4.204 a gallon. Gas prices are nearly 66 cents higher than last year, when prices peaked at a then-record of $3.23 in late May, and have prompted many analysts to raise their estimates of where gas is going to go. ''I wouldn't rule out the possibility that we could get to $4,'' said Antoine Halff, an analyst at Newedge USA LLC. Other analysts are less certain. Fred Rozell, retail pricing director at the Oil Price Information Service, thinks gas prices will rise only another 10 cents to 20 cents nationally. That would mean they would peak near $4.15 a gallon in California, where prices are typically highest, and around $3.50 in New Jersey, where they're typically lowest. 

haroldoftherocks --- 18 years ago -

"How much profit does the average oil company make on an average gallon of gas right now? The answer will surprise you — $0.09. Now multiply by that by consumption...3700 gallons per second in the U.S. That's about 290 million in profit per day. I don't feel bad for the poor oil companies, nor do I condone the high tax on gas that's also raping our bank accounts. Honestly one of the worst offenders in this situation is the auto industry for convincing Americans they need huge trucks to drive to the mall. 

get_the_lead_out! --- 18 years ago -

"How much profit does the average oil company make on an average gallon of gas right now? The answer will surprise you ? $0.09. The profit percentage made by oil companies compared to other industries if very small. The total amount is large but the actual percentage is small. Strengthen the dollar and the prices of barrels of oil will come down. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

Bush criticized Clinton for not having an energy policy in place. Aren't you glad that Bush had one? I keep wondering what Cheney discussed with the oil companies during that closed door meeting... 

stampin' gal --- 18 years ago -

Now multiply by that by consumption...3700 gallons per second in the U.S. That's about 290 million in profit per day Ok, but consider this. A major oil company just built a platform in the gulf.......$12 BILLION to build it. Installation was more money, manning it, etc. They started to drill and realized there is a malfunction and THE ENTIRE PLATFORM is now likely going to be useless.....a $12+ BILLION risk and failure, not to mention the years of work. This happens more often than you think. So, yes, they are profitting, but THE RISKS AND OUTLAY of costs are huge as well. just putting another perspective on it. 

bbjones --- 18 years ago -

Now multiply by that by consumption If you use the figures in the article, the oil companies make a profit of 3 percent. I do not see that as outrageous. ALL businesses are in business to make a profit. As for the consumption, the oil companies do not force people to consume more. 

get_the_lead_out! --- 18 years ago -

If you use the figures in the article, the oil companies make a profit of 3 percent. I do not see that as outrageous. ALL businesses are in business to make a profit. We do have a capitalistic economy right? that's a good thing and needs to stay that way. now an outlandish number of taxes on the other hand... 

Puppy again --- 18 years ago -

Fuel, actual gasoline only accounts for about 25% of the profit. Petroleum products are more than just gas, they account for the window tinting I sell, the plastic you drink out of, changing the color of you house (paint), the clothes you wear, yard care, etc. High gas prices are due to many factors, but the truth is, our gas prices are not high. We are a spoiled nation of big cars, fast cars... fuel drinkers. So when the cost goes up, we feel it more than other parts of the world. Personally, higher gas prices have not really affected me. I drive a little slower (which is for the good of everyone I share the road with) and budget my trips a little better. As far as oil production, we, the US, are already the 3rd largest producer. We are just the #1 consumer! 

haroldoftherocks --- 18 years ago -

As for the consumption, the oil companies do not force people to consume more. That's true. Ultimately it is up to the people to decide, do we want them to get richer so we can go shopping four times a week, or do we want to keep our money where it belongs? As for taxes? Its not just the democrats who benefit, its all of the career politicians who give themselves raises and benefits for life. We need term limits, or simply don't vote for incumbents. 

shortfuse --- 18 years ago -

What is wrong with boycotting? Why not stay home and not keep running the streets. If you have to go out do everything at one time. Try going to the store with friends and cut down on oil consumption. Don't run to the store for one thing. Don't drive your kids to and from school. They have school buses. Take vacations closer to home. Keep your vehicle in tip top shape. 

bbjones --- 18 years ago -

What is wrong with boycotting? Isn't what you described conservation? 

shortfuse --- 18 years ago -

What is wrong with boycotting? Isn't what you described conservation? A little of both. I feel if we start to conserve we are also boycotting in a sense. The less you buy the more they lose. 

haroldoftherocks --- 18 years ago -

A little of both. I feel if we start to conserve we are also boycotting in a sense. The less you buy the more they lose. They don't lose when you conserve, they sell the same amount over a longer period of time. A boycott would mean we sacrifice our cars and never buy gas. So these calls for a "one day boycott" doesn't really do anything but get twice as many people to buy gas the next day...no loss for the oil companies. 

shortfuse --- 18 years ago -

A little of both. I feel if we start to conserve we are also boycotting in a sense. The less you buy the more they lose. They don't lose when you conserve, they sell the same amount over a longer period of time. A boycott would mean we sacrifice our cars and never buy gas. So these calls for a "one day boycott" doesn't really do anything but get twice as many people to buy gas the next day...no loss for the oil companies. I am not talking about a one day boycott. I am talking about finding different ways to cut down forever on oil consumption. Not short term. We take things for granted and now it's time to pay the price. We could stay off the roads a lot more. It just takes determination in everyone. 

AFWife --- 18 years ago -

That would help. Also drilling for oil in Alaska and off the coast of Florida (And hopefully this new oil catch in the northern plains will pan out). It will take us a few years to get off our oil dependency, so we will still need some. ANWAR is not what it is made out to be (by enviromentalists) & yes, Floridians can have some rigs off their coast. 

shortfuse --- 18 years ago -

Then people say if we use up our own oil we are hurting ourself. 

~MommyofMonkeys~ --- 18 years ago -

You can blame the environmentalist and the Democrats in Congress who won’t let us drill in Alaska. You could blame China and India for increase competition. You could blame us, the consumers for increasing demand. You could blame those large pick-up trucks and SUV’s I see going 80-90 mph every morning, burning up fuel. If they were going 60-65 mph, they would burn up less fuel. If they would get a lighter vehicle, they would burn up less fuel. And there are probably many more we could blame. If we really want to solve this problem, we would switch over to electric vehicles and use nuclear, solar and wind power plants to generate the electricity. I agree! Well said! 

mykidsmom --- 18 years ago -

I would say that the weak dollar and supply and demand is to blame... 

shortfuse --- 18 years ago -

If we really want to solve this problem, we would switch over to electric vehicles and use nuclear, solar and wind power plants to generate the electricity. I agree! Well said! How long would that take? 

jemezchick --- 18 years ago -

you lost me at "Posted" 

david --- 18 years ago -

"How much profit does the average oil company make on an average gallon of gas right now? The answer will surprise you — $0.09. Man that isnt that much profit but wait the united states uses 9,253,000 gallons a day thats a wopping $832,770 a day $303,961,050 a year profit poor oil companies only making .09 a gallon profit we should let them make more 

shortfuse --- 18 years ago -

"How much profit does the average oil company make on an average gallon of gas right now? The answer will surprise you — $0.09. Man that isnt that much profit but wait the united states uses 9,253,000 gallons a day thats a wopping $832,770 a day $303,961,050 a year profit poor oil companies only making .09 a gallon profit we should let them make more I say we give them a dollar more. Who's with me on this? 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground