Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Is it mean to de-claw a cat?

who's talking here?

Melissa 1
mugglemom 2
Melanie 1
Mary C 1
bbjones 1
Fancy 2
mamadog53 1
likeke27 17
kjones0125 1
movedagain 1
rose8304 1
AuthorMan 1
My2Texans 1
njjk 1
Mygirl01 3
toot 3
Clown Vomit 2
Syrah1214 3
proudmomoftwo 1
Mabbers 2
rkj 1
R.E.B. 1
Gemini~on~the~Run 1
Chelli 3
ghostpost 6
Carole 2
NellieBean 10
Pumpkin 1
Setta 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Syrah1214 --- 18 years ago -

I'm new to this whole cat thing, but am wondering if I were to get a cat who isn't declawed, is it inhumane to have them declawed or is it okay? 

Mary C --- 18 years ago -

We had ours declawed and he lived peacefully inside for almost 20 years. 

Mabbers --- 18 years ago -

It's a necessary evil. 

R.E.B. --- 18 years ago -

I don't think so. It is a lot meaner when you want to kill them for destroying your furniture. I have had two cats declawed and two not declawed. 

Gemini~on~the~Run --- 18 years ago -

If there is no chance in the world the cat will get out, I do not see a problem with it. It is their line of defense and if a cat goes outside w/o claws, it will not make it far. BUT if you have furniture, and the cat has claws, you will need new furniture soon. 

Melissa --- 18 years ago -

No, as long as you don't throw them outside and expect them to defend themselves from other cats afterwards... 

Syrah1214 --- 18 years ago -

How much does it typically cost? 

toot --- 18 years ago -

Is the cat ruining your furniture? 

Chelli --- 18 years ago -

I don't think it is mean to de-claw as long they will never be left outside...both of mine are declawed and they go out for supervised play in the backyard only. I just had my newest kitten done a few months ago and it cost me $160 

Syrah1214 --- 18 years ago -

Is the cat ruining your furniture? I haven't adopted one yet. I was just wondering. I have never had a cat before, and was just wondering about some things that i have heard about through the years. 

rkj --- 18 years ago -

It's a very painful procedure. You can train your indoor cat to use a scratching post. 

ghostpost --- 18 years ago -

I had my first cat declawed. later I read a lot about how painful it was and that it was cruel (I am not saying this is true, but it certainly made me feel guilty). We adopted a little stray a few years ago. I take her to Pets Mart and they trim her claws every month or so for me. She has left our furniture alone. Our cats have been mainly indoors with a little outside time. Good luck with your quest for a kitty. We never intended to have cats--they found us. They have both made wonderful pets and given our family much pleasure. 

Carole --- 18 years ago -

Ok, worked at a vet here and YES, it is cruel and very painful - especially for older cats. Before everyone jumps on me, please read on. All I say is to wait to see if you have an issue with them scratching up your furniture. I have fostered cats for years and had well over 100 in my home for extended periods of time. Also had about 30 of my own (no, not all at once) and only had to declaw 2. If you provide that corregated board type of scratch board, most cats prefer that. If they start destroying things, then of course, it is the better of two evils - get them declawed but then never let them go outside without supervision - and I mean with you right there with them. Is the cat showing any signs of scratching yet? 

Chelli --- 18 years ago -

It can sometimes be painful but they have painmeds for that. I think it is less painful than throwing them outside or euthanizing them for tearing up your furniture. And I did try to train my cats to use a scratching post and I trimmed their claws like every other day but this didn't fix the problem of them tearing up my furniture. I love my kitties dearly and would not have done something that would have scarred them for life. I even tried soft paws and they wouldn't stay on. 

Carole --- 18 years ago -

I guess you were posting that you don't have the cat yet while I was posting my post. I would get the kitty first, then see. Most cats don't need it and you will know they need it before they destroy anything - just watch them and listen for it. Be sure and provide them with the scratching post/board of their choice. And I would get a mature cat - kittens climb everything and leave little pinholes in everything they climb. If you get a mature cat, they are already calmed down and you know what you get. Try AdoptACat or some other foster program that actually has foster homes so they can tell you about their personality already. Or check with Raias mom!! Now that I think of it, she has some she has been trying to place and she can tell you what you need to know about each one's personality!! 

toot --- 18 years ago -

Thanks for post, Carole. I don't think it is humane to declaw, either. My cat is clawed and never scratches the furniture. 

toot --- 18 years ago -

Didn't someone invent caps to put on the cat's claws? 

likeke27 --- 18 years ago -

what about cutting their balls off. is that humane? 

mugglemom --- 18 years ago -

if you have little kids, declaw the cat! yes, it isn't the nicest thing to think about, but i would much rather declaw the cat than deal with a poor scratched up kid. the cats that i have had (as an adult and growing up) were declawed and they were just fine. they even would go out and were fine. we always left the back claws in. just declawed the front. 

proudmomoftwo --- 18 years ago -

Just understand that by declawing them its a lifetime commitment that you keep them indoors. They can no longer climb a tree for protection or fight back.. 

Fancy --- 18 years ago -

Didn't someone invent caps to put on the cat's claws? yes they did. I think declawing is cruel. A cat will get out, and they cannot defend themselves w/o claws. We can train dogs not to bite, you can also train cats not to claw at furniture or kids. 

mugglemom --- 18 years ago -

They can no longer climb a tree for protection or fight back.. i'd have to disagree. i have had MANY declawed cats and they never had any problems climbing trees or jumping the fence. we even had one cat that we adopted that had had all 4 claws declawed. that crazy cat could still get on our roof! 

My2Texans --- 18 years ago -

My indoor cat came declawed and she still thinks she has claws and tries to scratch them on things and she can fight back with just her back claws. She used to go outside alot but would stay in our yard with us, but our momma stray cat fights her so I don't let her out anymore. 

Pumpkin --- 18 years ago -

Didn't someone invent caps to put on the cat's claws Yes, they are called soft claws and we used them on our cat before he went to live with my sister in law. They sell them at Petsmart and they work great! 

mamadog53 --- 18 years ago -

In my opinion, yes, it is cruel to de-claw a cat. It's like having the ends of your fingers chopped off. I'm also against docking dog's tails, cropping ears and de-barking. I've had cats off and on for years and never had a serious problem with clawing on stuff. I value my animals more than my furniture. Try a little kitty discipline before making a final decision. Although I've never asked Dr. Kelly about his views my former vet in Dallas would not declaw cats or debark dogs. Other vets may also have this policy. 

ghostpost --- 18 years ago -

"if you have little kids, declaw the cat!" I don't agree with this. Our little stray that we adopted is the most affectionate and gentle pet you could imagine. She doesn't even scratch or bite when we have friend's children play with her, or carry her around. I have never even seen her "hiss" or attempt to be aggressive even when at the Vets or when a dog came around. We keep her claws trimmed but I think it is also just her gentle personality. I have never been a "cat person" , in fact have always had a fear of them. Sorry to brag so much about her..lol 

Clown Vomit --- 18 years ago -

Only if you use pliers. 

Fancy --- 18 years ago -

I'm also against docking dog's tails, cropping ears and de-barking. Me too. :0( 

Setta --- 18 years ago -

We had my cat, PhoebeSnow declawed thinking she'd never be an outside cat. Years later, she didn't want to stay inside and would run outside every opportunity, so we finally let her be an outside cat. We lived where she could jump up on things away from neighbor dogs, but when we moved was a different story. We had to stay with someone until our closing on our house because our other one sold, and where they lived in Atasc, had fields behind the house where the coyotes would come out at night and to hunt. I am almost certain the coyotes got her and she couldn't climb a tree or jump to grasp the fence to get away from them. I opt for no de-clawing...you just never know and it could save their life to keep them! There are remedies for claws now...tips you can put on there at the vet that stay well, things to cover the corners of your sofa etc...try those first..IMO. 

NellieBean --- 18 years ago -

IMO, yeah.. i think its mean. i understand trimming them or something... but de-clawing them, thats taking away their only defence. 

Mygirl01 --- 18 years ago -

A cat will get out, and they cannot defend themselves w/o claws. If a cat gets out, my cat is inside and declawed and he has NEVER been out of my house except in the pet carrier to go to the vet. Think of this too, with nails and kids... your cat will go to the litter box and cover up their "duties" with cat litter which inevitably will get feces and urine in thier nails...then that cat scratches your child and imbeds that feces or urine into their skin...infection waiting to happen. Docswife...this is a topic that people will never agree on. You have to do what is right for you and your family cat, not what other people think is right for your situation. 

likeke27 --- 18 years ago -

what about cutting their balls off. is that humane?  

likeke27 --- 18 years ago -

...this is a topic that people will never agree on. You have to do what is right for you and your family cat, not what other people think is right for your situation. wow, actually someone with some common sense 

Chelli --- 18 years ago -

Docswife...this is a topic that people will never agree on. You have to do what is right for you and your family cat, not what other people think is right for your situation. I agree 100% with you on that...it is a matter of personal preference and no one will ever agree. 

Mygirl01 --- 18 years ago -

wow, actually someone with some common sense Thank You!! 

NellieBean --- 18 years ago -

Is the cat ruining your furniture? UGH!!! that is SO selfish! why even get a cat? you know the cat is eventually claw it at some point.. you train it.. dont take his claws away! sorry, im a big animal lover. 

NellieBean --- 18 years ago -

Is the cat ruining your furniture? UGH!!! that is SO selfish! why even get a cat? you know the cat is eventually claw it at some point.. you train it.. dont take his claws away! sorry, im a big animal lover. 

likeke27 --- 18 years ago -

what about cutting their balls off. is that humane? funny how no one will answer this!!! 

NellieBean --- 18 years ago -

what about cutting their balls off. is that humane? thats a population issue.. not a defence issue. 

NellieBean --- 18 years ago -

oops! dumb computer 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground