Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Fair Tax question.

who's talking here?

Mary C 2
planemom 10
txsweetpotato 1
Justwatching72 6
lilmommy 16
qpc 6
AFWife 1
ZoomZoom 1
lDeal 1
sweet and sassy 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

lilmommy --- 18 years ago -

Am I reading this correctly? Not only, if this were to become effective, will you pay a 30% sales tax on your home so say a 100,000 would now be 130,000 and we will be required to also pay a 30% tax on our mortgage payments as well? This is what I'm reading and it's insane. OMG, how the heck can anyone say this is actually fair? I've learned one thing from the govt. if they say it's fair, you are getting screwed. Please tell me I'm reading this wrong. 

lilmommy --- 18 years ago -

So here is my equation from what I'm reading. Remember if Huckabee gets his way, and I'm reading it correctly we are screwed, blued and tattooed. A home costs 100,000 and we pay another 30% on said home. 30,000 financed into a 30 yr. mortgage at 5.875% is something like another 200 per month. Then say your mortgage is 1200 on that house, you'll pay 30% on that 1200 which is 360 more so basically that 100,000 dollar house is now going to cost you almost 560 a month extra and they want us to believe it's 30%? Hell, I suck at math but not that bad. LOL 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

I don't see the tax on our mortgage payments. Let me keep reading. 

lilmommy --- 18 years ago -

Let me see if I can find it. This is a serious question too. I do see where we will be charged 30% on our purchases and then they'll charge the same tax on credit cards. Hang on. 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

Where are reading that the mortgage payment is also taxed? From I can see is yes you pay the taxes on the cost of the house but that is rolled into your mortgage payment. I don't see anything that says they also add a tax to your mortgage payment. 

lilmommy --- 18 years ago -

* Purchases of new homes * Rent * Interest on credit cards, mortgages and car loans * Doctor bills * Utilities * Gasoline (30 percent in addition to current taxes, which would not be repealed) * Legal fees This is a list of some of the taxed things. It clearly states home purchases and mortgage payments. Maybe I'm reading it wrong? 

Mary C --- 18 years ago -

i may have to find a new house sooner than i think. I don't think huckabee will win though. 

lilmommy --- 18 years ago -

i may have to find a new house sooner than i think. I don't think huckabee will win though. LOL. I am just trying to make sense of it. Will they only tax the mortgage at P&I or the entire payment or what? This is not something people could afford to make a mistake on. LOL 

txsweetpotato --- 18 years ago -

Huckabee is an idiot 

sweet and sassy --- 18 years ago -

Never believe a politician when they talk. 

Mary C --- 18 years ago -

There is nothing "fair" about the tax if you are reading it correctly. Texans would be the only people who could afford a house. Can you imagine buying a house in California and adding a 30% tax to it? 

lilmommy --- 18 years ago -

Huckabee is an idiot Tell us how you really feel. LOL This scares me. Seriously. Doing math from my head tells me that if I purchase a home at 100,000 and have to pay all of that in taxes then I will have given the govt. about 180,000 free tax money over 30 years. I hope I'm not understanding it. 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

In reading from the FairTax website it doesn't show a tax on mortgage interest. You would end up paying taxes on all of those things but you would get to keep your gross pay. No more money going to Social Security, Medicare, or income tax being taken out. You would have more control over how much tax you pay. 

lilmommy --- 18 years ago -

You would have more control over how much tax you pay. To a small point yes. But according to what I'm reading the current taxation on gas will remain effective and we will about another dollar per gallon of gas. So say the average person has a 30 gallon tank and fills up once a week. He will now have to pay 120 for that gas when it was 90 before. That's a price hike of 120 per month. Then you add in the tax on your house, again if my numbers and reading are correct, 560. Then it clearly states you'll pay taxes on your car loans as well. Then for the typical family paying 600 a month for groceries it will increase to 780. 180 more. Then doctor visits will increase by 30%, meds will as well which means one of two things; our premiums will go up or our deductibles and copay. Not to mention everything else but that alone takes up a lot of one person paycheck and with the IRS at least we stand a chance at writing off some things and possibly getting some of that back. 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

Where are you reading this? 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

On the flip side you don't pay any taxes on investment earnings. 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

Also, if you buy a "used" car you don't pay taxes on the car. The person who bought it new paid the tax. 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

I'm finding this on the fairtax.org website. 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

To be honest this could be the best thing since sliced bread and it wouldn't pass. It requires the government to downsize and that would never happen. 

lilmommy --- 18 years ago -

I've read it on many different websites and pretty much collected all of it. Of course, I don't believe one website is going to give all of the clear information. But one of the websites was factcheck.com or something like that. 

lilmommy --- 18 years ago -

To be honest this could be the best thing since sliced bread and it wouldn't pass. It requires the government to downsize and that would never happen. But it also encourages people to not spend which could hurt our economy as well. I'm just trying to figure out how they can tax your home price then tax you on your mortgage payment as well. 

lilmommy --- 18 years ago -

Also, if you buy a "used" car you don't pay taxes on the car. The person who bought it new paid the tax. But... LOL I don't buy used cars. I get better deals now on new. LOL Like I said, if the govt. says fair you can bet your getting screwed somewhere. LOL 

qpc --- 18 years ago -

The actual house bill that has been propsed is on the fairtax.org website. It says that the tax is on any new real property and on services. I cannot find anywhere where it talks about mortgage payments being taxed, and it doesn't fit into the real property or services category. Tuition is one service that is exempt as well as a few others. Also, anytime someone buys something and imports it, it is subject to the same fair tax rate, so that would eliminate people avoiding the tax by buying everything out of the country. I know this was one of your other concerns. I would highly recommend reading the actual proposed house bill. It is quite informative and there is a lot of misinformation out on both sides about this issue. And I agree....it will be hard to pass because people and esp government resist change, even if it is a change in the right direction. 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

I'm just trying to figure out how they can tax your home price then tax you on your mortgage payment as well. I think may be what they are saying is your mortgage interest will be taxed not the principal. Here is what the fairtax website says: Mortgage 

qpc --- 18 years ago -

Thanks planemom...I was looking, ut between the coughing and sneezing I'm doing...I'm pretty useless right now. 

Justwatching72 --- 18 years ago -

I get better deals now on new. Ok I gotta know how you get a better deal on a car that you lose 60% of its value in the first 3 years. 

lilmommy --- 18 years ago -

Ok, but I pose another question. What happens when no one is buying new goods anymore? If they chose to tax me on everything I buy I'd just buy used everything except food and gas of course. So what happens then? I'm sure the answer could easily be explained by raising the fair tax amount, right? Seriously think about how flawed this could be. New cars being purchased at a minimum and new home construction would almost be null and void. A lot of people could be out of work. And another thing that worries me is that you are reading one website that is surely going to promote the tax. I believe it isn't all black and white. But this is why I'm reading and from what I'm reading, I still won't come out ahead by any means. 

Justwatching72 --- 18 years ago -

There will ALWAYS be people that buy new. Manufactures are buying NEW inventory in order to make their products.The uber rich will always buy new cars, etc. And don't forget, any tax ya pay on new items, get refunded to you every month in the form of a disbursement check. also, you will have no taxes taken from your paycheck.what you earn is what you bring home. 

lilmommy --- 18 years ago -

Ok I gotta know how you get a better deal on a car that you lose 60% of its value in the first 3 years. What cars are you buying? LOL I get new cars at a percentage cheaper than it costs the manufacturer to make it. Let's just say my car was almost 26,000 on the lot and I only paid around 14,000 with 0% interest. I am ahead on my vehicle if I were to trade it in today. 

Justwatching72 --- 18 years ago -

I thought ya were just buying it new off the lot. Did not know ya had a 'connection' ;-) 

lilmommy --- 18 years ago -

And don't forget, any tax ya pay on new items, get refunded to you every month in the form of a disbursement check. No, not true. It's called a prebate and it's a set amount. I think I remember reading that for my family it will be a laughable 1100. I spend more than that in a month if you combine everything they are taxing and the increase of 30%. 

Justwatching72 --- 18 years ago -

Let's just say my car was almost 26,000 on the lot and I only paid around 14,000 with 0% interest. Ok, after two or three years the car is worth 10,500. 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

I still won't come out ahead by any means. I don't think anybody will come out ahead we'll just have a much better idea of how much we are being taxed. 

Justwatching72 --- 18 years ago -

No, not true. It's called a prebate and it's a set amount. I think I remember reading that for my family it will be a laughable 1100. I spend more than that in a month if you combine everything they are taxing and the increase of 30%. yes that is exactly what it is...a pre-bate. And with the changes in the tax laws, you would be spending about that amount...its up to you if you choose to buy everything new. 

qpc --- 18 years ago -

Manufactures are buying NEW inventory in order to make their products. That actually won't be taxed under the Fair Tax, but new products are going to be CHEAPER TO PRODUCE because manufacturers don't have to pay payroll taxes and taxes on the production goods (which they do now). The free market will demand that when an item is cheaper to produce, the price will go down. 

lilmommy --- 18 years ago -

Ok, after two or three years the car is worth 10,500. It's been 3 years and my car is at 12,500 trade in and well a few months of payments and it's all mine. LOL 

qpc --- 18 years ago -

No, not true. It's called a prebate and it's a set amount. I think I remember reading that for my family it will be a laughable 1100. I spend more than that in a month if you combine everything they are taxing and the increase of 30%. But you ALSO get the extra money that you would pay in taxes currently. 

lilmommy --- 18 years ago -

.its up to you if you choose to buy everything new. I buy stuff all the time. LOL The free market will demand that when an item is cheaper to produce, the price will go down. Don't see it happening. They will get greedier than they already are. Do you really believe someone like Walmart is going to spend the time and energy to change 1.00 items to .85? I don't think so. I'm asking y'all to think about this. We will be taxed at the same rate as the extremely wealthy. Sure they might buy new but look at Jay Leno, he doesn't buy new. He'll be exempt. The middle class will buy mostly used products and the middle class is what technically dominates our economy. I can see however, how qpc would benefit from the fair tax because your hubby owns a business. From what I'm reading, the rest of us get screwed and are encouraged not to spend which would result in hurting our economy further. 

ZoomZoom --- 18 years ago -

but new products are going to be CHEAPER TO PRODUCE because manufacturers don't have to pay payroll taxes and taxes on the production goods (which they do now). They don't now since most stuff is made overseas either in China or Mexico. The only people who will benefit from this tax are the very rich and the very poor. The middle class gets screwed, as always. 

lilmommy --- 18 years ago -

I have to go clean up a little but I'll be back to try and figure this all out. I'm certain this bill will never pass and I'm thanking God for that but I'm truly trying to understand the logic behind it. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground