Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Evolutionary Idea - Scientists rally in defense of educational integrity

who's talking here?

freshhell 1
bbjones 36
Justwatching72 4
likeke27 10
NoNameNoLastName 10
accent_ 22
Brian 6
d:-] 1
Cicero 6
lemingrebel 15
partyboy 1
ffup 1
SuperFantastic 8
rosebud 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

Jan. 6, 2008, 12:52PM Evolutionary idea Scientists rally to explain and defend the cornerstone of biological study. Houston Chronicle Science education is in danger of collapsing beneath nonscientific teachings, and the nation's biologists, social scientists, pathologists, chemists and others are worried enough to push back. It is high time for these specialists to share what they know. A coalition of 17 science groups, among them the National Academy of Sciences, has just issued a call for their members to engage more in the science education process — including explaining evolution. The coalition warns in this month's issue of the FASEB Journal (the acronym stands for Federation of American Societies for Experimental Biology) that today's muddling of scientific education with unscientific alternatives such as creationism weakens Americans' grasp of the concepts on which science is based. Among the endangered basics: the scientific method, the process of reaching scientific consensus, and telling the difference between scientific and nonscientific explanations of natural events. It is urgent for the nation's top scientists, so aware of ethics and rigor in their own disciplines, to restore science education to the realm of the methodical, the testable and the repeatable. These pathbreakers in lifesaving, life-affirming disciplines need to make clear their work is based on centuries of accumulated facts and test results — not mere "theory" in the vernacular sense. Making that distinction, in fact, is one of the tasks scientists are now undertaking. In a new peer-reviewed journal called "Evolution: Education and Outreach," author T. Ryan Gregory explains once and for all why evolution belongs in science class while creationism and intelligent design do not. "[T]erms relating to the process and products of science itself, such as 'theory' and 'law' are almost diametrically opposite in scientific versus vernacular settings," he writes. "In daily conversation, 'theory' often indicates a lack of supporting evidence." A theory in science, by contrast, "is a well-substantiated explanation of some aspect of the natural world that can incorporate facts, laws, inference and tested hypotheses." In science — unlike in conversation — reaching a theory is the ultimate goal. Creationism may well be worth study, but it lacks the gathered evidence to make it a scientific theory. Yet it's neither the goal nor the interest of most scientists to attack religion. Many are actually strengthened by their own faiths; most Christian denominations have no trouble reconciling spiritual beliefs with appreciation for the gifts of science, including the knowledge that for millions of years new species have evolved from earlier species. Even Isaac Newton, a pioneer in the search for natural causes of natural phenomena, was devout, drawn to religious inquiry as to science. What is not intellectually reconcilable, however, is attacking true science while accepting the benefits it has made possible. Drug-resistant tuberculosis and MRSA are terrifying examples of micro-evolution in action; bird flu transferred from human to human could be the next. Only rigorous use of scientific method — including concepts such as evolution —will help scientists contain these potential pandemics. Denying science students access to these concepts in clear, unadulterated form threatens not just the students, but later generations who will need their expertise. Those bent on denying this access lack foresight. They also lack gratitude. "In an age when people have benefited so greatly from science and reason," notes FASEB editor Gerald Weissmann, "it is ironic that some still reject the tools that have afforded them the privilege to reject them." The scientists who daily battle disease and ease the pain of disaster are now badly needed to show why science class must remain sacred.  

bbjones --- 18 years ago -

Science education is in danger of collapsing beneath nonscientific teachings, and the nation's biologists, social scientists, pathologists, chemists and others are worried enough to push back. That is absolutely correct. Evolution is one of those nonscientific teachings. Among the endangered basics: the scientific method, the process of reaching scientific consensus, and telling the difference between scientific and nonscientific explanations of natural events. The scientific method involves making observations, then making hypotheses based on these observations, and then using experiments to prove or disprove the hypothesis. ANY theory is based on various ideas. If that base is wrong, then the theory is wrong. So let's look at the theory of evolution. It is based upon several foundational principles, but let's look at three of them. 1. Matter comes from nothing. 2. Life spontaneously comes from non-life. 3. One "kind" of animal, plant or organism changes into another "kind" of animal, plant or organism. All three of these are valid, scientific hypothesis made from Darwin's observations which should be proved or disproved by experimental evidence - the scientific method. According to the scientific method, we should have repeatable experiments to prove such things are true. Where are these experiments? If there are no repeatable experiments for these hypotheses, then they are not science. They are interesting ideas, but they are not science. These ideas can be debated ad infinitum, but until there are repeatable experiments for those hypotheses, they ARE NOT science. Drug-resistant tuberculosis and MRSA are terrifying examples of micro-evolution in action; This statement is a very clear indication that the person who wrote this article knows very little about science OR they are purposely trying to mislead people. I know of NO ONE who would say that what is deemed "micro-evolution" or change within a species does not occur. The drug resistant tuberculosis has changed but it is still a bacteria and did not become an amoeba, just as when one type of dog mates with another type of dog, the resultant puppy is not the same genetically as either parent, but IT IS STILL A DOG. 

Brian --- 18 years ago -

McEnroe with a strong forehand. Connors rips a backhand back at him. McEnroe ready to hit again.... 

freshhell --- 18 years ago -

Wonder why I stopped teaching? 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

McEnroe with a strong forehand. Connors rips a backhand back at him. McEnroe ready to hit again.... Brian, if you really call that ripping a backhand, you are no judge of the game, not to mention the disservice to Connors. Fresh, things like this are exactly the reason why people like you, who take education seriously, must remain in the field. Otherwise, the darkness that some would promote would really be allowed to descend. Evil, and ignorance, grow only if we allow them to. 

Brian --- 18 years ago -

not to mention the disservice Connors. Connors was kind of a stubborn old mule, wasn't he? He didn't hit it hard but he hit it with eveything he had. I know the game pretty well. 

bbjones --- 18 years ago -

Otherwise, the darkness that some would promote would really be allowed to descend. Promoting evolution is a darkness. It is promoting the lord of this world. "For the wisdom of this world is foolishness with God. For it is written, He taketh the wise in their own craftiness." (1 Corinthians 3:19) Evil, and ignorance, grow only if we allow them to. Evil and ignorance grow as people reject God's Word. "Take heed, brethren, lest there be in any of you an evil heart of unbelief, in departing from the living God." (Hebrews 3:12) 

bbjones --- 18 years ago -

Brian, if you really call that ripping a backhand, you are no judge of the game, not to mention the disservice to Connors. It is obvious that the poster knows as much about tennis as he does about science - very little. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

He didn't hit it hard but he hit it with eveything he had. I know the game pretty well. It doesn't surprise me at all that you'd know the game, Brian, and that you'd put as much into as you put thought into your posts. Yours is a sane, moderating voice. 

bbjones --- 18 years ago -

Yours is a sane, moderating voice. In a very stark contrast to yours. 

Brian --- 18 years ago -

You two both have good game. Strong volleys, good serves. I hope at the end of the match you can reach over the net, shake hands, and say "good game". Me, I like to pat 'em on the butt and say "good game". 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

Wonder why I stopped teaching? Would you ever start teaching again, Fresh? You see the need. 

bbjones --- 18 years ago -

Would you ever start teaching again, Fresh? You see the need. There is a need for TRUE science to be taught. Someone start by teaching the poster about scientific method. 

bbjones --- 18 years ago -

You two both have good game. Strong volleys, good serves. I hope at the end of the match you can reach over the net, shake hands, and say "good game". Sorry, but this is God's Word against satan's word. I will not ever say good game to anything associated with the lord of this world. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

Me, I like to pat 'em on the butt and say "good game". There are some folks on KU who argue intelligently in support of having Creationism (and/or its Trojan horse, Intelligent Design) in the curriculum, something with which I am in strong disagreement. They have good backgrounds in the sciences and education and believe in dialogue. They haven't posted yet in regards to this editorial, but I welcome their views 

Brian --- 18 years ago -

Give it time. I'm sure both viewpoints will be strenuously argued on this thread by the time it loses steam. By the way, I'm with you on this one. Advantage, McEnroe. 

bbjones --- 18 years ago -

They have good backgrounds in the sciences Of course, compared to me, you have NO background in the sciences, otherwise you would understand scientific method and the concept of repeatable experiments. And you are also wrong about Creationism. Neither evolution nor Creationism should be taught in the schools by science teachers. 

SuperFantastic --- 18 years ago -

undefined 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

There are indications that the world is not as old as we are told. For instance, at the bottom of the world it says made in China, it is also made from a form of plastic rubber which was not around until 1943. SuperFantastic, does this mean that all of those who claim to be 65 or older are lying (as I have suspected), or were their brains imprinted with the belief? How extensive is the cover up? 

SuperFantastic --- 18 years ago -

Who knows I just copied and pasted like my friend BBjones taught me 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

Who knows I just copied and pasted like my friend... taught me Yours usually seem more credible. You must have done some additional study on your own. 

Brian --- 18 years ago -

How extensive is the cover up? The liberal media and the Democratic Congress have covered it up for years. 

bbjones --- 18 years ago -

Yours usually seem more credible. You must have done some additional study on your own. That is funny coming from someone who copies and pastes more than anyone else on this forum, and to top it off, does not understand what he has posted. 

SuperFantastic --- 18 years ago -

Yours usually seem more credible. You must have done some additional study on your own. Well I try not to flex my all knowing abilities on here when it comes to religion, evolution, and creationism. lol 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

The liberal media and the Democratic Congress have covered it up for years. Commie pinko bastards! 

Brian --- 18 years ago -

Fargin' bastages! 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

Fargin' bastages! and probably Yankees and foreigners too 

bbjones --- 18 years ago -

Well I try not to flex my all knowing abilities on here when it comes to religion, evolution, and creationism. Probably because you do not have any knowledge on those subjects. People who know nothing about a subject are the ones that post garbage, thinking that it makes them funny. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

damn, the worms are opening on here too 

SuperFantastic --- 18 years ago -

thinking that it makes them funny. Sorry you cant be as funny as me, lets get together and i'll teach you a couple of things 

bbjones --- 18 years ago -

Sorry you cant be as funny as me, lets get together and i'll teach you a couple of things You are not funny Super, you are just sad. 

SuperFantastic --- 18 years ago -

Not funny to you but i make it a point to be that way 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

Sorry you cant be as funny as me, lets get together and i'll teach you a couple of things Not on THIS thread! Not if I have anything to say about it. When I was labeling the thread, I only did politics, religion, and news. We don't have clearance for humor, or even attempts thereat. I can't afford any more labeling fines. 

SuperFantastic --- 18 years ago -

Cmon bb tell a joke or something 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

Cmon bb tell a joke or something Damn! We definitely don't have clearance for that. I'm going to bed, before things get out of hand. 

SuperFantastic --- 18 years ago -

you better go to bed BB gonna do a little stand up for us tonight lol 

bbjones --- 18 years ago -

Not funny to you but i make it a point to be that way You are not funny to anyone but the people that live in the delusions of this world. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

Okay, after this, I'm going to bed: A scientist, a Creationist, and an Intelligent Designist walked into a bar. The bar tender said... 

bbjones --- 18 years ago -

A scientist, a Creationist, and an Intelligent Designist walked into a bar. The bar tender said... I am glad that you left that evolutionist at the zoo so that he could visit his relatives. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

Actually, SuperFantastic, that wasn't bad. 

page 1 2 3 4
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...

news
politics
religion


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground