Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

do you think it was to harsh of a punishment for talking in school

who's talking here?

freshhell 3
Sweetie Pie 1
GCan 2
Bows and More Galore 1
buddercup 1
planemom 1
lulajean 1
likeke27 2
MoveIt 2
cowboyswife 2
Pet Lover 1
Shutterman 7.5 + Keygen 1
willow10 1
LAXmom 1
cappyswife 1
Syrah1214 1
Cicero 1
SchoolMom 2
Rachel 1
Lynn 3
curlygirl 1
Caro ♥ 1
jcx2mommy 1
wyfe4lyfe 3
Sue 1
get_the_lead_out! 1
~Shannon~ 10
D'Hat Lady 1
Raia's Mommy 1
catnip 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

~Shannon~ --- 18 years ago -

My son just told me that today in PE they had to get in push up position and stay in that position for 15 minutes for talking and also do sprints all for talking.His arms was shaking bad while doing the push up positions.Do you think it was harsh. He is in 7th grade 

Cicero --- 18 years ago -

Push-ups won't physically damage him. 

Pet Lover --- 18 years ago -

Personally, I couldn't have done that...I would have just layed there...My bad for talking, too. Which school? 

MoveIt --- 18 years ago -

I guess it depends on how often he has been called down for talking. 

cowboyswife --- 18 years ago -

Depends, how many times were they told to be quiet?? 

D'Hat Lady --- 18 years ago -

no, I had to do things like that many times in school... teaches you a tough lesson, but I would prefer that over giving pops any day! 

MoveIt --- 18 years ago -

wow CBW- we must be from the same "stock" LOL 

cowboyswife --- 18 years ago -

LOL, M&M's...Must be...;) 

likeke27 --- 18 years ago -

no 

Bows and More Galore --- 18 years ago -

Nope, not too harsh IMHO. 

Sweetie Pie --- 18 years ago -

No, I don't think it's too harsh. 

Syrah1214 --- 18 years ago -

I hate hearing about stuff where kids are belittled. What if one of the childrens arms couldnt take it and they fell down then got teased or further yelled at? My son has broken his arm twice and there is no way he could do that. I would be upset. 

Rachel --- 18 years ago -

How many times was he asked to stop talking? Did he received warnings? 

~Shannon~ --- 18 years ago -

It was the whole class that was talking so of course the ones that wasn't talking had to get in trouble to. He goes to AMS. 

SchoolMom --- 18 years ago -

not to harsh, sometimes alittle embarrassment is what they need. They want attention by talking but not by having to do push ups, he has to take responsibility for what he did, but I'm biased, I was in the Air Force 

~Shannon~ --- 18 years ago -

How many times was he asked to stop talking? Did he received warnings They were told 3 times to stop.Some did some didn't. Then the coach hollered Shut up then gave a big speech like normal.DS said he was talking at first but then the other times he didn't.I am not going to complain this time but I will next time. He needs to get better control of the kids. They have too many coaches standing around not doing anything. 

SchoolMom --- 18 years ago -

if he is in middle school the kids should be able to control themselves (from talking), unfortunatley sometimes people get punished for other peoples mess ups, guess he learned that. 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

He needs to get better control of the kids. It sounds like he is trying. 

willow10 --- 18 years ago -

No, I don't think it's harsh. 

curlygirl --- 18 years ago -

He needs to get better control of the kids. It sounds like he is trying. I agree with planemom. It is not a bad punishment. It is a logical consequence. 

freshhell --- 18 years ago -

It is funny, but in 7th grade, a physical challenge is the perfect punishment. I taught 7th grade math, and if I had a student who was a real discipline problem, I would send a word to the appropriate coach or PE teacher. It was miraculous! Better by far than calling the parents or sending them to the AP. 

GCan --- 18 years ago -

I don't think it was inappropriate, especially for that age. I'm sure that class was quiet after that. 

~Shannon~ --- 18 years ago -

I told my son maybe I should use that as a punishment here at home when you back talk me. He said no I just want back talk.I also asked him if he was going to talk at all in PE even when it was allowed he said no. 

GCan --- 18 years ago -

SAHM...sounds like your son learned the lesson. Hopefully the other kids in his class did also. P.S. I'm thinking I might use coach's technique on my kid next time he gets out of line! 

freshhell --- 18 years ago -

7th grade is such a hard time, for teachers, parents and kids. I find that as long as I am willing to talk to them about my reasons, they are willing to put up with my rules. 

jcx2mommy --- 18 years ago -

I dont think it was too severe. Far too often, I hear parents complain about teachers not letting them know their child was having problems until it was too late. Teachers have a very difficult job. I have friends that are teachers and they have ALL said the same thing, none of them would ever teach middle school if given a choice. The kids are out of control and disrespectful, and the parents are always looking to blame the teachers. sahm, I'm not saying this is the case with you. But, I am saying that sometimes, teachers have to go out on a limb just to get these kids, particularly middle schoolers - especially the boys, back in line. I spent the day at school with my 7th grade ds a little while back, and I must say, I was appauled by the behavior of most of the kids, particularly the boys. And I saw how difficult it was for the teachers to get across to the few that were trying to learn amidst the chaos. You couldn't pay me enough money to be a middle school teacher. 

~Shannon~ --- 18 years ago -

7th grade is such a hard time, for teachers, parents and kids. Very true. The kids are out of control and disrespectful, and the parents are always looking to blame the teachers. I agree in some cases. My son is not perfect by any means. I know how he acts here at home. He is 12 with a teenagers mouth doesn't make it right. He is learning to control it.Thank God it is only to me and not to any one else. He respects the teachers for teaching him. And helping him. He also sees other kids disrespecting the teachers he has complained about that to me also. 

likeke27 --- 18 years ago -

on some of these post, i see the wussification of america 

Caro ♥ --- 18 years ago -

i would have had to go to the bathroom..lol f-that 

LAXmom --- 18 years ago -

My son came home the other day and started telling me that he (and/or several others) got into trouble for talking - and then he proceeds to tell me how unfair the whole thing was. After he's done ranting, I look at him and say: "here's a tip for you on how to handle that". This is where it gets to be fun for me. He gets all quiet and looks at me, waiting to see what I'm going to say. "Keep your mouth closed, it will solve all your problems". 

lulajean --- 18 years ago -

(opp, sorry I had technical difficulties) My coach considered herself a drill sergeant and had no issues with making us run extra miles for punishment, it hurt like H@ll, but that was the nature of the beast. We knew the rules and the punishments~ sometimes we just did "bad" anyway. lol 

freshhell --- 18 years ago -

If your kid is lucky enough to have a teacher or coach who is willing to command respect on his or her own merit, I say you should support that adult. It is so easy to give up on the challenging kids. Any teacher who can reach your child, among the 150 or so they have every year, that teacher is giving your kid a gift. Ask your son or daughter what that teacher is giving them. It will help your kid figure out their own worth. 

cappyswife --- 18 years ago -

Thank you to all of you who are saying something positive about the teachers position!!! I don't understand why so many parents always have to turn it around to be the teachers fault. "The coach needs to get more control"--ARE YOU KIDDING ME? How about "the kids need to learn to have more respect for the adults" I love the comment from virginiagirl..."keep your mouth closed it will solve your problems" 99.9% of educators do this job b/c they love working with kids. They do not want to "belittle" them as docswife made in her comment. That type of punishment in PE or athletics is common and has been--I am sure many adult men would say they had some type of similar punishment when they were younger and they are just fine today---they probably stopped misbehaving in that coach's class after that. 

Lynn --- 18 years ago -

If my kid come home and told me that she or he was punished at school I would not ask others if I thought the punishment was fair but my child would get more punishment at home..Why is it always the teachers fault that your kids act out at school...Hmmmmmm 

~Shannon~ --- 18 years ago -

..Why is it always the teachers fault that your kids act out at schoo I wasn't making it out to be the coach fault. I was simply asking if this was a harsh punishment.Heck like someone said I might use it myself. Kids are going to get into trouble at school for talking but my kids they know if it continues I will be calling to see what is going on.If it is a class talking or a few of ds friends him included talking.My son has a hard enough time in school and yes he has been bullied by a few teachers. One was even fired over it. At the other school district where we were at,My son has low vision. Teachers have to make sure things are in larged for him to see and give him a hard copy. So yes I know that the teachers work hard and work extra hard for him. He will even say thank you and help them. 

catnip --- 18 years ago -

If he complained about that better hope he never joins the service, LOL, he'll WISH he was back in school again! 

Lynn --- 18 years ago -

There is no way anyone would want to be a teacher now..if you are a female teacher and doing your job that you love you can get in trouble..example..if it's a female teacher and she likes your daughter she must be gay..if she likes your son..she is trying to seduce him..what is this world coming to? Teachers have it rough..cut them some slack. 

~Shannon~ --- 18 years ago -

He just told me not complained. He also said he hopes the boys learned their lesson.He was quite after the first warning.He said that his lesson was not to talk in PE at all.Only if it happened on a day where I was sore. I told him well it just made you push forward. 

~Shannon~ --- 18 years ago -

My step mom has been a teacher for years she taught me in school. She never ran into trouble doing her job.Matter of fact my step sisters are teachers one in High school and one a professor. They have had trouble kids but there is a right way to deal with it. Not saying push up was bad. I was just asking. My dd is a big talker in school. She would always have to walk extra laps. One year the coach would just look at her and she would start walking. He even said He looks forward to PE with my dd seeing if she can hold out on her talking or singing.I didn't take it offensive when he said that. Yes you have to be careful when you are working with any age of kids. 

get_the_lead_out! --- 18 years ago -

no, that discipline isn't too bad for a 7th grader. If he was in football in 7th grade, it would have been a lot more. at least when I was in 7th grade it was 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground