Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Science vs Intelligent Design - The Dover Decision

who's talking here?

eterry2 2
bbjones 46
Justwatching72 25
CyberSage 1
NoNameNoLastName 7
Shutterman 7.5 + Keygen 4
Superfantastik 7
ChezML 6
Clown Vomit 3
accent_ 12
Mabbers 6
Cicero 10
Lynn 4
CleverName 6
cyber-bullyvictim 1
BluntForceTrauma 1
haroldoftherocks 12
Meteor 1
partyboy 13
KwdIzMyNwHome 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

Intelligent-design discussion shows science's importance By Gerald Ensley TALLAHASSEE DEMOCRAT It can be pointless to go to a pep rally for something you already believe in. It just reinforces how much smarter you are than the other side. But sometimes, hearing others explain why you should believe what you believe helps you understand it better - and reminds you to respect the other side. That's what happened last week at a Florida State University forum, "The Vigil After Dover: Keeping Science and Religion Separate in Schools." It was one of the first public discussions of a December ruling by a federal court in Dover, Pa., that it's illegal to teach "intelligent design" in public-school science classes. Intelligent design is the heir to creationism, and both are the belief that Darwinian evolution is a fiction. The forum was not a debate. It was a discussion of science and religion by six national experts who support the federal court's ruling: an attorney, a theologian, an activist, a scientist, a philosopher and a philosopher/scientist. All were brilliantly articulate. The event drew 400 spectators. Judging from applause and head-nodding, it's safe to say more than two-thirds of us agreed with their every word. We agreed evolution is a fundamental truth of the universe. We agreed improving science education is paramount. We agreed religion is not science and should not be taught as such. But the night's illumination was not the underlining of our values. It was the reminder - warning? - that we must find ways to promote good science without ignoring a belief in God. "Until we evolutionists reach out to understand what motivates people on the other side, we're going to lose," said fiery FSU philosopher Michael Ruse. "And we bloody well deserve to." In the Dover case, 11 parents sued the School Board for requiring science teachers to read a four-paragraph statement to students that called evolution "a theory, not a fact" and urged students to learn more about "intelligent design." In a strongly worded 139-page ruling, a conservative Republican judge, John E. Jones III, said such efforts were illegal. "The overwhelming evidence at trial established that ID is a religious view, a mere re-labeling of creationism, and not a scientific theory," Jones wrote. "Accordingly we find that the secular purposes claimed by the Board amount to a pretext for the Board's real purpose, which was to promote religion in the public-school classroom, in violation of (the U.S. Constitution)." FSU law professor Steve Gey said a pending lawsuit in Georgia may fall in favor of ID - which will leave the score 1-1 and possibly lead to a Supreme Court ruling. On what Gey called the "most politicized Supreme Court in my lifetime," the right to teach intelligent design as science could be upheld. A dozen states are considering allowing science teachers to teach intelligent design - or at least discuss the supposed flaws in evolution. The ID supporters insist: We're just teaching children about the controversy and letting them decide. (One spectator Wednesday muttered: "Are they going to show the flaws in English and let children decide if they should learn the language?") In a 2005 study, Florida was among the 15 states that received a grade of F for their teaching of scientific standards in public schools. The report especially criticized Florida's poor teaching of evolution, calling the state's efforts "superficial" and "disappointing." The report came at a time Florida was preparing to revise its educational standards in all subjects - and Gov. Jeb Bush said he didn't think teaching evolution should be a part of the requirements. The planned revision of Florida standards has been pushed back to 2007 or beyond. Stronger standards are needed, given the abysmal state of science understanding among U.S. citizens. Moderator Deborah Blum, a University of Wisconsin journalism professor, said polls show half of Americans cannot identify how long it takes for the earth to orbit the sun (a year), think humans lived with dinosaurs (never) and think lasers are compressed sound waves (nope, light waves). "The whole debate of science vs. religion is a litmus test for the deep moral, social and political divides we have in this country," Ruse said. "It is more a movement of anti-nationalism, anti-modernism, anti-enlightenment." Yet how can we bridge those divides? Biologist Joseph Travis, dean of the FSU College of Arts and Sciences, said scientists need to become more visible in promoting the importance of science, instead of conceding the public stage to proponents of intelligent design. Travis agreed with activist Eugenie Scott that universities have to produce more and better science teachers. "The students in classrooms today are the citizens of tomorrow," Travis said. "If we send out students who don't know it takes a year to go around the sun, we are doing something wrong." John Haught, a genial and thoughtful Georgetown University theologian, added that seminaries must do a better job of teaching the differences between science and religion - and the ways science might even be a celebration of religion. "A creator who could make things that make themselves (as in evolution) is more amazing than one who is just pulling the strings," Haught said. Yet amid all the boosterism for science was the important caution not to dismiss the role of God in a nation in which nearly 90 percent of the people identify themselves as religious. Haught said those who believe in the supremacy of science must learn to understand "the hierarchy of values" that leads people to find life's meaning and goals in a belief in God. "There is a tendency among the scientific naturalists to leave no room for God," he said. Haught said science vs. religion need not be an either/or proposition: You can believe in evolution and believe in God. "We need to relax and accept there can be many explanations and causes for the universe as we know it," he said. "If we allow room for all levels of explanation, we can have a rich understanding of the world."  

Lynn --- 19 years ago -

Accent what is your understanding of this? 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

Let me be the first to take a stand for my beliefs..I am here because God created heaven and earth. The debate about science vs Intelligent Design isn't about whether He created heaven and earth, it's about the details of just how He did it. The large number of Christians who believe in evolution and that science and the Bible are not in conflict just happen to give God a lot more credit for the system He developed. 

Lynn --- 19 years ago -

So again..how do you feel about it? 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

If some people want religion to be kept out of the schools, then they should want to keep ALL religion out of the schools. That would include the theory of evolution, which is a religion because it is also a belief system. 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

Accent what is your understanding of this? I've kept up with the case, but, for those who haven't, there is a Nova documentary on PBS/KUHF/Broadcast Channel 8 tonight, at 7. I've said a lot on KU, on various threads, that belief in evolution is not in conflict with a belief in God. The debate, really is in the details. At issue in the Dover case was whether science education should be limited to science. I believe that it should be. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

The large number of Christians who believe in evolution and that science and the Bible are not in conflict just happen to give God a lot more credit for the system He developed. Science and the Bible are not in conflict, but the false science of evolution is, because it contradicts what God tells us in the Bible about how He created the universe. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

I've said a lot on KU, on various threads, that belief in evolution is not in conflict with a belief in God. Yes, it is. 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

So again..how do you feel about it? Creationism is not science. Intelligent Design is a version of Creationism and is not science. I believe that science should be taught in the science classroom. 

Lynn --- 19 years ago -

So if a school tried to teach my children about evolution I would have the right to pull my child out..right 

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

I agree, religion should not be taught as science. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Creationism is not science. Sorry, but you are very wrong. Science is the "knowledge or a system of knowledge covering general truths or the operation of general laws especially as obtained and tested through scientific method. Such knowledge or such a system of knowledge is concerned with the physical world and its phenomena." Science is nothing more than man trying to explain the truths and laws of the physical world that God created. 

Lynn --- 19 years ago -

I always thought that any explanation for how the world was created except by God was a mad scientist on an ego trip. 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

So if a school tried to teach my children about evolution I would have the right to pull my child out..right If the school is teaching science, teaching biology, and the subject is how life developed, they need to be teaching evolution, especially if they are a public school. If you don't want your child to be taught the science, even though many scientists believe that evolution is one of the tools that God used, I don't know what the requirements are for your child to get a diploma and enter various colleges if they missed part of the science curriculum. I believe that they should get the science and that you can teach them the Creationism and/or the Intelligent Design. 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

I always thought that any explanation for how the world was created except by God was a mad scientist on an ego trip. Christians who accept the science of evolution believe that it is one of the tools that God used when he was creating. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

The large number of Christians who believe in evolution and that science and the Bible are not in conflict just happen to give God a lot more credit for the system He developed. No, those Christians are calling God a liar because they are not believing in the Word of God. Evolution is at odds with God's account of His Creation. Before the fall of Adam and Eve, the Earth was a perfect paradise in which there was no sin, and as a consequence there was no death. There were no predators, because every animal that was created was a vegetarian, living in perfect harmony with the other creatures of the Earth. The food for man was specified by God: "And God said, Behold, I have given you every herb bearing seed, which is upon the face of all the earth, and every tree, in the which is the fruit of a tree yielding seed; to you it shall be for meat." (Genesis 1:29) The food for animals was specified by God: "And to every beast of the earth, and to every fowl of the air, and to every thing that creepeth upon the earth, wherein there is life, I have given every green herb for meat: and it was so." (Genesis 1:30) Before the fall of mankind, nothing had ever died, not even to provide food for man or animals. All of that changed with the introduction of sin by Eve and then Adam. God had clearly warned them: "But of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, thou shalt not eat of it: for in the day that thou eatest thereof thou shalt surely die." (Genesis 2:17) "But of the fruit of the tree which is in the midst of the garden, God hath said, Ye shall not eat of it,neither shall ye touch it, lest ye die." (Genesis 3:3) Both Adam and Eve originally existed in a world free of sin and death. When Adam sinned, death was introduced into the world: "Wherefore, as by one man sin entered into the world, and death by sin; and so death passed upon all men, for that all have sinned: For until the law sin was in the world: but sin is not imputed when there is no law. Nevertheless death reigned from Adam to Moses, even over them that had not sinned after the similitude of Adam's transgression, who is the figure of him that was to come." (Romans 5:12-14) "For since by man came death, by man came also the resurrection of the dead. For as in Adam all die, even so in Christ shall all be made alive." (1 Corinthians 15:21-22) If a person truly believes in God by faith, then evolution is an impossibility. Why? Proposing that the Creation is only symbolic for undefined eons of time, in an attempt to weave evolution into the creation story, introduces death before Adam and Eve existed, since it proposes that man is the peak of a slow process that took millions of years to evolve from simple forms of life. If death was not introduced by God as the penalty for the sin of Adam and Eve, then the wages of sin is not death. Therefore, God would actually be responsible for creating an imperfect world that had it's origins in death and random evolutionary events BEFORE man ever sinned - and this makes Genesis a lie! Man then did not fall, he evolved as a sinner, being the product of a process of death. Man would therefore bear no guilt at all for sinning against God and introducing death to the world. If man is not responsible for sin and death, then there would be no need to repent and turn to our Savior Jesus Christ. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

If the school is teaching science, teaching biology, and the subject is how life developed, they need to be teaching evolution, especially if they are a public school. Evolution is not science. It is a belief system - a religion. 

CleverName --- 19 years ago -

While the government controlled public schools teaching children a religious belief such as intelligen design is unconstitutional, it is also bad policy. It is a question of competency. Public schools are not competent to wade into to choppy waters of religion in our society. To thrust public school teachers into a religious debate does a disservice to the teacher and threatens the free exercise of our religious beliefs which may be in conflict with a particular school board which controls the public school system in which we are located. Further, when you have a public school teacher paid by the state instructing children on the government approved religious theory, you are establishing a religion. bb, do you really want your children being instructed that they are going to hell if they do not submit to the authority of the bishop of Rome? If you are going to cover the death processes of a cell or organism in biology, why not cover the death of humans and the fates of their souls in biology as well. Likewise, churches are not competent to intrude into the affairs of science. We have a history here. Look at the "controversy" of the Copernican theories of movemant. Galileo's conviction of heresy stood from 1633 to November 4, 1992, about 234 years after the last objections to heliocentrism were no longer given credence by anyone except possibliy the young earth creation guys such as Russell Humphreys, who bbjones loves to cite so much. Of course, most creationist "scientific" apologetics think the young earth creationists are nuts and doing a disservice to the creation debate by destroying creationists credibility. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Christians who accept the science of evolution believe that it is one of the tools that God used when he was creating. Then, they are being deceived because God clearly told us how the universe was created and how long it took and it was not through the hypothesis of Charles Darwin. God clearly said the death entered the world because of Adam, which is the opposite of the evolution hypothesis. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

bb, do you really want your children being instructed that they are going to hell if they do not submit to the authority of the bishop of Rome? You should read what I write. I did not say that children should be taught religion in school. I said that if religion is to be kept out of schools, then the religion of evolution should be kept out of schools also. 

CleverName --- 19 years ago -

bb, do you really want your children being instructed that they are going to hell if they do not submit to the authority of the bishop of Rome? You should read what I write. I did not say that children should be taught religion in school. I said that if religion is to be kept out of schools, then the religion of evolution should be kept out of schools also. Bb, I did read what you wrote. Intelligent design is a religious belief. If you allow that religious belief, what is to prevent a school board in Louisiana to discuss salvation, another religious belief? Where do you draw the line? Furthermore, Are you really saying that physics is a religion? Are Newton, Copernicus, and Einstein heretics doing Satans bidding by preaching laws of movement which we use commercially today to place and keep satelites in orbit to run things like the internet? Is the internet thus a tool of the devil because we are using a "theory" to operate it which goes against your young earth religious belief? 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

Christians who accept the science of evolution believe that it is one of the tools that God used when he was creating. Ditto. 

ChezML --- 19 years ago -

If some people want religion to be kept out of the schools, then they should want to keep ALL religion out of the schools. That would include the theory of evolution, which is a religion because it is also a belief system. Religion, i.e. teaching creationism, has no place in a public school per SCOTUS twenty year ago. EDWARDS, GOVERNOR OF LOUISIANA, ET AL. v. AGUILLARD ET AL. No. 85-1513 SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES 482 U.S. 578; 107 S. Ct. 2573; 1987 U.S. LEXIS 2729; 96 L. Ed. 2d 510; 55 U.S.L.W. 4860 December 10, 1986, Argued June 19, 1987, Decided 

ChezML --- 19 years ago -

So if a school tried to teach my children about evolution I would have the right to pull my child out..right Yes, and you can send them to the religious school of your choice at your expense. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Bb, I did read what you wrote. No CN, apparently you do not read what I write. I did not write ANYTHING about teaching intelligent design in the schools. What I did write was if religion is to be kept out of the schools, then the religion of evolution should be kept out of the schools also. Furthermore, Are you really saying that physics is a religion? No, I did not say that physics is a religion. Where did you come up with that one? I said that evolution is a religion. Physics is not evolution. Evolution is ONLY a belief system, which is the definition of "religion", and not science because evolution cannot be tested by experiment. Some people only BELIEVE evolution to be true. By the way, from a purely secular, scientific viewpoint, intelligent design is an hypothesis just as evolution is an hypothesis. If the "theory" of evolution is to be taught in the schools, then the counter point of the "theory" of intelligent design should be taught also. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Religion, i.e. teaching creationism, has no place in a public school per SCOTUS twenty year ago. Chez, you are wrong again, as usual. Religion is not defined as "teaching creationism". Where do you get your definitions? Do you just make them up? Religion is "a cause, principle, or system of beliefs held to with ardor and faith". There are "religions" that do not believe in nor "teach" creationism. One such religion is the BELIEF that there is no God - atheism. Another is the belief that man was not created by God, but came to be by random chance - evolution. Secondly, the Supreme Court, did not say that "teaching creationism, has no place in a public school". They were reviewing the The Creationism Act that was passed in Louisiana which "forbids the teaching of the theory of evolution in public schools unless accompanied by instruction in "creation science." No school is required to teach evolution or creation science. If either is taught, however, the other must also be taught." The liberal majority affirmed a lower court decision that said the Creationism Act was pushing a religious agenda. The Supreme Court said "The Act violates the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment because it seeks to employ the symbolic and financial support of government to achieve a religious purpose." The Supreme Court DID NOT say "teaching creationism, has no place in a public school". Just more disinformation from Chez. By the way, just because a liberal Supreme Court voted to support an agenda that they believe in, it does not mean that they are correct in their assessment. No school should be required to teach either evolution or creation science. However, if either is taught, the other SHOULD also be taught. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Yes, and you can send them to the religious school of your choice at your expense. That needs to be remedied also. Whether, a family decides to send their children to a private school, religious or secular, or to home school them, that family should not have to pay twice for their child's education. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Christians who accept the science of evolution believe that it is one of the tools that God used when he was creating. I would like everyone who professes to be a Christian to think about what you believe. Do you really BELIEVE, by faith, in Jesus Christ? Do you really BELIEVE in what Jesus Christ taught? If you do BELIEVE, then you would know that the hypothesis of evolution is not true. Even science can not prove through experimentation that the evolution hypothesis is true. So who is Jesus Christ? Jesus Christ is our Creator: "In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. The same was in the beginning with God. All things were made by Him; and without Him was not any thing made that was made. . . . And the Word was made flesh, and dwelt among us, (and we beheld His glory, the glory as of the only begotten of the Father,) full of grace and truth" (John 1:1-3, 14). Jesus, the Word, is the ultimate communication from God and is declared to be the Creator of the universe. "For by Him were all things created, that are in heaven, and that are in earth, visible and invisible, whether they be thrones, or dominions, or principalities, or powers: all things were created by Him, and for Him: And He is before all things, and by Him all things consist" (Colossians 1:16-17). What is Christianity? Christianity is a personal relationship with Jesus Christ based upon His teachings. How does one have a personal relationship with Jesus? You BELIEVE in Him. So the question becomes, "Do you doubt someone that you truly believe in?" Jesus spoke the truth, because He is the truth: "I am the way, the truth and the life" (John 14:6). As a professed Christian, do you doubt that statement? If Jesus told us a lie, then He couldn't be the truth, and, therefore, He could not be the way. If Jesus is not the truth and the way, then why would ANYONE believe in him to be their Savior from the righteous judgment of God? In Matthew 19:4 and Mark 10:6 Jesus said: "From the beginning of the creation God made them male and female." So Jesus is quoted as saying that mankind was created by God "from the beginning of the creation", NOT billions of years later. If the Creator, Jesus Christ, used the evolutionary process, as some professed Christians believe, then it means that He used death and destruction to create man, since evolution requires death and struggle over millions of years before man. However, God's Word in Genesis tells us He did not use death and destruction to create man. Adam and Eve weren't walking on a fossil graveyard in the Garden of Eden, because: "God saw every thing that He had made, and, behold, it was very good" (Genesis 1:31). Anything that God declares as "very good" is measured against His own holiness, for as Jesus said: "There is none good but one, that is, God" (Matthew 19:17; Luke 18:19) Death and violence came as a result of the fall of mankind. It was sin, not evolution, that brought death into the world. The Gospel's salvation message is built on the foundation of who Jesus Christ is, and on what happened back in the Garden of Eden, as recorded in Genesis, and NOT upon the evolution hypothesis. Paul is speaking to Christians in Romans 14:10 and 2 Corinthians 5:10 when he states that we will stand before the judgment seat of Christ. The judgment seat of Christ is not for the judgment of our sin. Rather, it deals with our account of how we faithfully served Him. Jesus teaches this to us in the parable of the Master who returned and His servants had to account for how they had faithfully served him. (Matthew 25:14-30 and Luke 19:12-24). So one day we will stand before Jesus and give an account. What response will you give when He says something like: "You had my written and spoken Word, and the testimony of my life. I declared that I was the Creator. I spoke the truth. Why didn't you believe what I told you in Genesis?" So, if you believe yourself to be a Christian, challenge yourself. Do you really believe who Jesus Christ is? Do you believe that He is the all-knowing, all-powerful Creator of the universe? Do you believe that He is "the way, the truth and the life" who created the universe in six days as HE TOLD US? If you can not believe in THAT Jesus Christ, do you REALLY believe? Can you TRULY believe in Jesus Christ if, by faith, you can not believe EVERYTHING that He has told us? If you can not believe in EVERYTHING that Jesus Christ told us, then how do you choose what part of God's Word is the truth and what part is a lie? It is very sad that some still choose the "tree of knowledge" (Genesis 3:6) rather than the Word of God. (Genesis 2:17). 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

Although the Bible and science are not in conflict, that is not even the issue. The Bible is not and was never intended to be a science text. Promoting the myth that there is some conflict between science and religion doesn't help either. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Promoting the myth that there is some conflict between science and religion doesn't help either. The only people promoting a conflict between science and religion are the ones who promote the false belief that the evolution hypothesis is science. 

Mabbers --- 19 years ago -

I actually watched that show last night accent. Yeah, guess I'm a nerd. Until our cable is restored, I'm reduced to prime time teley. :( 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

I actually watched that show last night accent. What are your thoughts on it, JMABS? Later, I'm off to go paint trees and birds and butterflies and flowers and... 

CyberSage --- 19 years ago -

Okay, let me say this one more time: INTELLIGENT DESIGN DOES NOT AGREE WITH YOUNG EARTH CREATIONISM. INTELLIGENT DESIGN PROVIDES SUPPORT FOR THE BIG BANG THEORY. INTELLIGENT DESIGN DOES AGREE THAT SPECIES EVOLVE. INTELLIGENT DESIGN TEACHES THAT CERTAIN SCIENTIFIC PHENOMENA CANNOT BE EXPLAINED BY PURELY NATURALISTIC, RANDOM DARWINISM. There, I hope that helps set two groups straight: 1) Darwinists who think that ID is an enemy of sound science. 2) Creationists who think that ID is some code word for Young Earth Creationism, and some back door way to get YEC into the public schools. 

Mabbers --- 19 years ago -

What are your thoughts on it, JMABS? I think if one theory is discussed about our creation, all theories should be discussed. Science has to evolve just like our planet, and that means inclusion and postulation. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

2) Creationists who think that ID is some code word for Young Earth Creationism, and some back door way to get YEC into the public schools. So you do not believe that God is an intelligent designer? 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

I think if one theory is discussed about our creation, all theories should be discussed. Science has to evolve just like our planet, and that means inclusion and postulation. Okay, but if the venue is a science class, with extremely limited time to teach, how would you make the judgement as to how much time each of "all theories" gets? Now I'm outa here 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Okay, but if the venue is a science class, with extremely limited time to teach, how would you make the judgement as to how much time each of "all theories" gets? LOL. You did not actually ask that question did you? 

Mabbers --- 19 years ago -

They're theories. I don't remember spending too much time on the theory of evolution anyway. 

eterry2 --- 19 years ago -

"But of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, thou shalt not eat of it: for in the day that thou eatest thereof thou shalt surely die." (Genesis 2:17) "But of the fruit of the tree which is in the midst of the garden, God hath said, Ye shall not eat of it,neither shall ye touch it, lest ye die." (Genesis 3:3) there was no death I'm not saying this to argue, but while reading this a question came to my mind: If there was no death, how was there a word for it? And how would Adam and Eve understand what the word meant? This leads me to wonder how Adam and Eve communicated. Anyone know the origins of language? Genesis uses direct quotes. I wonder how the communication actually worked back then. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

If there was no death, how was there a word for it? God did not have every word that He spoke to Adam and Eve recorded for us. God is righteous and just and would have explained to Adam and Eve what He meant by death when He walked and conversed with Adam and Eve in the Garden. "And they heard the voice of the LORD God walking in the garden in the cool of the day: and Adam and his wife hid themselves from the presence of the LORD God amongst the trees of the garden. And the LORD God called unto Adam, and said unto him, Where art thou?" (Genesis 3:8-9) We don't know what language God gave Adam to use for speech, but he was able to name the animals and communicate with God and Eve. So, from the very beginning, man was intelligent and spoke a language. He wasn't an ignorant caveman who used grunts to communicate with others. 

page 1 2 3 4 5
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...

news
politics
religion


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground