Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

new employee problems

who's talking here?

Bubbles 2
Carla 1
outermaga 2
GCan 1
JDB2 1
Fiona 2
buddercup 1
GHYC 1
txsweetpotato 1
ambergris 2
gking 2
archsbaby 2
jemezchick 11
rose8304 1
proudmomoftwo 2
Cicero 4
*harpo* 1
StephanieM 3
Cindi 2
smiling face's 1
KayCat 2
Carole 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

jemezchick --- 19 years ago -

we hired a new girl, she was asked in the interview if she knew Excel, on her resume the first program that is listed that she knows is Excel, She does NOT know it. She doesn't even know how to set a print area or a margin....ugh! Sorry just a vent. We have a meeting this afternoon to figure out what we want to do, let her go, or send her to an $82 dollar class on her time and money. 

outermaga --- 19 years ago -

or send her to an $82 dollar class on her time and money. Work Source and the Library teaches the Intro Class for free. 

buddercup --- 19 years ago -

you have a pm 

KayCat --- 19 years ago -

Give her the opportunity to take the class - on her dime. Give her a time limit in which to take the course & if she doesn't then let her go. 

jemezchick --- 19 years ago -

I hear what you guys are saying, but she lied on her resume and her interview. This is what bothers me. If she would have said I don't know it but will take a class, that is different. 

GCan --- 19 years ago -

Lying on a resume is not acceptable. If she was given a chance to take the class, she should consider herself very fortunate. The decision the employers must make is whether it is easier to let this go because finding another employee would take more time and effort than sending her to a class. 

Fiona --- 19 years ago -

I would give her the opportunity to take the class or give her a little help with learning. I think some of the best employees are the ones that you teach that way they do not get in their own set ways and look at you like whatever when you ask for it to be done your way. 

*harpo* --- 19 years ago -

I hear what you guys are saying, but she lied on her resume and her interview. This is what bothers me. If she would have said I don't know it but will take a class, that is different. Agree 100%, it would have been alot easier for you to send her off, to the class before she was hired, if she had just told you up front. 

Fiona --- 19 years ago -

I hear what you guys are saying, but she lied on her resume and her interview Yeah I didn't really think of that. 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

You really can't say that she lied. You guys should've tested her during the interview. Some people think that they 'know' a particular type of software just because they use one or two features. The question is, to what level of expertise that person has about the software. Can they write Macros or complex formulas or do they simply know how to enter text into a cell, etc. 

KayCat --- 19 years ago -

She obviously needed the job - a lot of people lie on their resume. Other than lack of knowledge on Excel, how is she doing? Give her a chance! Otherwise you'll have to start interviewing again! Yuck! 

jemezchick --- 19 years ago -

you have a point Cicero. We need someone with high intermediate to excellent excel skills. She has, at best, very beginner. 

jemezchick --- 19 years ago -

a lot of people lie on their resume NOT ME! We use excel through out the whole day, she could get by with no Miscrosoft Word experience but not excel. She seems okay she has been here one week. 

txsweetpotato --- 19 years ago -

Maybe she felt she was familiar with it... or maybe someone else puffed up her resume. Its my experience that its easier to train them once they are hired, than to replace them.... I hate the interviewing most of all. I would definitely call he on it, set a time frame, and let her know you felt she was deceptive on her resume.... Allow her to dig herself a big hole... then offer her an opportunity to become the best employee you have ever had. Your best case scenario... she spends all her days trying to make this up to you. 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

you have a point Cicero. We need someone with high intermediate to excellent excel skills. She has, at best, very beginner. Ouch. I work in the software industry. There are lots of people that claim to 'know' certain products. Usually they don't know as much as we need to. Our company will work with them depending on their other skills (So long as the software in question isn't the main skill that we're looking for). How is she doing at everything else? Does she have the ability to learn what you need her to in a short amount of time? 

ambergris --- 19 years ago -

You really can't say that she lied. You guys should've tested her during the interview. Some people think that they 'know' a particular type of software just because they use one or two features. I agree. She may know some of it but not all of it but didn't know how to put that on her resume. I'd give her the option of paying to take the class or you'll have to let her go as you really need someone who knows it well. 

jemezchick --- 19 years ago -

I have asked her to find a tutorial on excel and work on it at home, then she said she does not have a computer at home...we will see, I do not make the hiring/firing desicion. If I did I would say let her take the class, lets see what the VP says this afternoon. 

jemezchick --- 19 years ago -

Does she have the ability to learn what you need her to in a short amount of time? I wanted to take vacation in Dec, at this point I won't be able to. She has to know excel in order to teach her what she needs. 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

...then she said she does not have a computer at home...we will see, Sounds like she'd better spend some time at the library. Good luck. 

GHYC --- 19 years ago -

If she is trusty worthy and can learn quickly that is worth a lot more than her not knowing a computer program, That can be learned. Good Honest people are hard to find. 

jemezchick --- 19 years ago -

Good Honest people are hard to find. um, she lied on her resume and in the interview. However, she seems nice enough and capable enough, but the lying about a skill that is REQUIRED for a job gets me. 

ambergris --- 19 years ago -

but the lying about a skill that is REQUIRED for a job gets me. honestly at this point I don't think you will ever trust her with anything. You will always be second guessing her so for her sake she would probably be better off moving on to another job. I'd make sure you let her know why she is let go so that she doesn't make the same mistake again. 

Bubbles --- 19 years ago -

Whoops! I have Excel listed on my resume and I don't know how to do print margins or set a print area. I'm just familiar with working "in it". I was told by a recruiter to list any familiarity with any program at all on my resume. 

jemezchick --- 19 years ago -

Bubbles, I bet that is what happened, it makes sense the way you said it. In the interview WE should have clarified the skill level of excel that is needed, she was told that we used it daily, does she know it, not the level. We are to blame for this too. We never do skill tests, background tests, or drug testing, or anything. 

JDB2 --- 19 years ago -

You really can't say that she lied. You guys should've tested her during the interview. BULL$HIT! I have a responsibility to TELL THE TRUTH on my resume. Sure you could dig deaper, but it is ok to expect folks to be truthful...and they should be! 

jemezchick --- 19 years ago -

this is why I bring these issues to KU, you guys have many different suggestions that help make things clearer. Thanks 

Bubbles --- 19 years ago -

oh thank you. You make me feel much better. Because I think if in an interview someone said "I see you have Excel listed -- how familiar are you with it?" I would say "I have used it but not on a daily basis. I know how to set up a spreadsheet and work in it but I'm not familiar with all the details of Excel." 

proudmomoftwo --- 19 years ago -

well if shes a liar then I would not want her working for me.. JMO 

proudmomoftwo --- 19 years ago -

Bubbles you make a good point .. The interviewer could have digged a little deeper.. I guess you cant know what her intention was to mislead you or just figured being familar was enough.. 

jemezchick --- 19 years ago -

The interviewer could have digged a little deeper we have a very low turn over rate here, in the past 6 years, this is the 2nd employee we have had to replace. Our interview skills could be better. 

Cindi --- 19 years ago -

I don't think she should be let go. In past interviews I have always been specific, what I know and to what depth. Whoever did the interview should have asked her what she knows, etc. 

Cindi --- 19 years ago -

Oh, and I don't think she lied at all. I am very sensitive about stuff like this. I was fired last year from a job after 4 yrs due to being out with a sick child, never mind the fact that In my dept there were 3 of us and the other 2 didn't know half of what I did. and my boss said I didn't have anything to worry about. That's Ok though, cuz when I left, EVERYONE heard me leaving. 

StephanieM --- 19 years ago -

You know often those classes are useless. Next time when you hire, you may want to create an exercise with a time limit to see if they can do what you need done. 

Carole --- 19 years ago -

Some people think that they 'know' a particular type of software just because they use one or two features. I agree with this. At one time I thought I knew Access because I had used it for 2 years on a job...then when I tested, I realized just how little I really knew about the software. It may have been an honest mistake on her part. 

StephanieM --- 19 years ago -

I have worked for a couple of different companies, and I have considered myself an expert user, but applications are very company specific. There are a zillion different ways to set something up, and no way is really better than any other. You really need to make sure that you are hiring something that knows what you expect them too. In my job search I took more than one of these exercises to determine if I knew my stuff. 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

BULL$HIT! I have a responsibility to TELL THE TRUTH on my resume. Sure you could dig deaper, but it is ok to expect folks to be truthful...and they should be! It's possible to claim that you know a particular software and feel that you're being honest about it. The question is how well you know it. There are very few people that know Excel to the point where they could pass certification. Look at StephanieM's post before this one. She knows what she's talking about. 

gking --- 19 years ago -

I hear what you guys are saying, but she lied on her resume Bigger folks have fallen, and even been sued for just this sort of thing. Can her. 

gking --- 19 years ago -

It may have been an honest mistake on her part. C'mon....print area? margins? If you can use any software, you should know how to do this. 

outermaga --- 19 years ago -

C'mon....print area? margins? If you can use any software, you should know how to do this. I will have to agree with that statement. I can go into a software that I have never used before and be able to set print margins. 

jemezchick --- 19 years ago -

okay, just got out of the meeting about her. VP is shocked that she did not know excel, being that it is the FIRST software listed under softwares she knows on her resume. Anyway, another meeting on Monday with the other person that is training her on data entry to see if she is catching on. If not, she goes. If she is catching on well, then she stays but then we require that she take an excel class asap, and put her on 60 day probation. At this point my training with her is minimal because she needs to know the data entry first. It is the first step in learning the process as a whole. Everything I teach her is based on the data entered. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground